2 ms·
While this post deals with interesting ideas and issues, the writing wanders and leaves out enough detail to make the final product unsatisfying. The author cl
by joe_the_user 16y ago
While this post deals with interesting ideas and issues, the writing wanders and leaves out enough detail to make the final product unsatisfying.
The author claims people believe items have essences for cognitive and evolutionary reasons. Fair enough claim but I see no real evidence even after following the links. The Zen story is nice but somewhat tangential to the original claim.
Indeed scanning the links, I gradually get the impression the entire blog involves a stream of appealing ideas lacking details and coherence. The whole exercise seems "not even wrong" but like a wandering between interesting, related but "mushy" ideas, something of a poster-boy for the bad kind of web-generated fuzzy thinking.
One example of a paragraph that in a link that bothered me in it's level of non-communication: "I learned this lesson when I was an intern at a software company in Silicon Valley. I was debating with my boss about what kind of copy should go on our new site, MaviShare.com. This was in the days before data-driven decision making became universally embedded in start-up culture (the correct answer to the debate is really “who cares? Try it and see, and let the results speak for themselves”). Anyway, he asked his MBA girlfriend (now wife), and she said, “People like steps.” It’s a lesson I took to heart." (What "copy" - "ad copy"? The "copy utility". Anyway, the reader simply never discovers where the "steps" come in, in either meaning of "copy", and I found this incompletely expressed idea psychically bothersome enough to complain here. What's the lesson? What?? It's not in the earlier or later paragraphs either). See http://www.zacharyburt.com/2010/06/why-games-are-fun-the-psychology-explanation/ http://www.zacharyburt.com/2010/06/why-games-are-fun-the-psy...
- zackattack 16y agoI hear you about the confusion there. It's really just shoddy writing. One of my weaknesses as a writer, one that I just recently became explicitly aware of, is that when I write, I do it after stacking lots of "schemas": I understand A because of B, and understand B because of C, but many of my audience might only understand C, and I talk about A without first meeting them at C, graduating to B, and then stacking A. (In case you're interested, I'm planning on writing a cohesive post about this phenomenon soon). Many of my claims are scientifically backed but I simply do not care enough to go through and cite them; I would like to but it's not a good use of my time at this point. If you are curious about a specific claim I am always happy to point you in the right direction of the research. Other claims are admittedly speculation and I almost always denote them as such. There is a storied history of philosophers engaging in thought experiments so dismissing my actions as part of some NEW pseudoscience born through the web is erroneous. Likely many of the things I discussed (such as the precise nature of memory encoding, storage, and recall) will not be unraveled in our time. But you may be pleased to know though that I have discussed several of these articles with academics and would've hesitated to publish if I'd got strong dissent. P.S. The lesson is "Actions to achieve our goals are explicit, and prepackaged so we can directly execute on them." The text copy I was referring to was steps for the user to take. Thanks for the feedback.