4 ms·
Outlawing War? It Actually Worked
- angersock 9y agoNow, it's arguable whether or not in the long term that such a pact was desirable--redrawing borders in the 1800s let Europe sort out a lot of its problems (see also, Prussia).
- tpeo 9y agoGiven that the pact is self-enforced, it would simply be broken when it becomes undesirable.
- colejohnson66 9y agoRedrawing borders after WWI and WWII is a big cause of the conflict in the Middle East if I’m not mistaken
- ars 9y agoIn exchange for no more conquests we got never-ending-wars. Wars that just drag on for years, with no real end possible. This is especially common in the ME. Sometimes countries need to change in order to relive tension. Make that impossible and it's non-stop war.
- astrodust 9y agoAs bad as these wars are, they're trivial compared to the endless misery that Europe inflicted on itself and the world in general for hundreds of years. Multi-generation wars have been the norm ever since there were two civilizations big enough to fight one.
- tnecniv 9y agoProlonged guerrilla war didn't start after 1928. For example, Napoleon nominally conquered Spain and installed his brother, but the Spanish were engaged in a large scale guerrilla war until Napoleon was defeated at Waterloo.
- danarmak 9y agoThe article doesn't even attempt to show a causal connection; it just assumes that because a treaty was signed, and then things changed, the treaty must have caused it. Post hoc, ergo propter hoc. I'd rather point to the massive geopolitical differences that occurred during that time period. The Cold War, decolonization (mostly due to the world wars), the growth of the EU and of the USSR (both of which had no internal wars) all greatly reduced conquests.
- smoll 9y agoThis paragraph makes no sense to me: > First, some context. Before 1928, countries had the legal right to wage war. If one state claimed to be victimized by another, international law permitted it to use force to right the wrong. International law also gave countries the right of conquest, meaning they could benefit from war by keeping its spoils, territory and, in some cases, people. The right of conquest did not depend on whether the conqueror was in the right. As long as it claimed to have been a victim, no matter how flimsy its argument, the conqueror became the new legal sovereign. It’s easy to see how the right to wage war could be, and was, abused. First, it's saying prior to 1928, war was OK if the initiator was victimized or it simply wanted to annex a new place. Then it says the victors needed to make up a "flimsy" pretense of victimization in order to keep its winnings. They used to make up flimsy arguments for why they were doing the right thing before 1928, and still do after 1928 (cf. Russia "protecting" its people in Crimea). What part of the "law" actually changed?
- wahern 9y agoThe part that legitimized territorial acquisition--the right of conquest. Flimsy excuses are still accepted for waging war, but not for acquiring territory. It's an interesting notion. However, I suspect the cause+effect is much murkier. Colonialism had all but ended by 1928. Rising powers like the U.S. never had much interest in territorial acquisition. In fact, my naive understanding of world history is that territorial conquest (distinct from cultural/political/economic conquest) was largely a modern European thing, perhaps a consequence of the Treaty of Westphalia which forced European powers to think of conquest in very black & white terms.
- cperciva 9y agoThe US never had much interest in territorial acquisition? Ever heard of "manifest destiny"?
- microcolonel 9y agoThis whole chain of ideas is ridiculous. Conquest is inherently and naturally legitimate; because you can not enforce laws when the prevailing power doesn't respect them. Sure, it sucks, and yeah there has been a coincidental reduction in wars of conquest after these treaty signings, but one does not make a peanut butter sandwich simply by owning bread and peanut butter. Conquest is down because of a) alliances b) the nuclear deterrent and c) market liberalization, causing an increase in the ability of people to make a living where they are, lessening the relative value of conquest.
- marcoperaza 9y agoThis is so wrong. The real reason why wars of conquest mostly ended after WW2 is that the United States has positioned troops and weapons in all the hot spots. That, and all the major powers now have nukes. This is actually a great example of the bullshit quantitative analysis that is sweeping through academia. That something was signed in 1928, and then that the world experienced extraordinary peace after WW2 (the Pax Americana), is NOT evidence that the former led to the latter.
- holydude 9y agoI totally agree with this. Not many people realize this and will continue to blabber about big bad usa but nukes are not the only thing keeping everyone in check. It is fat uncle Sam doing the job. I fear the day of more assertive China or EU acting retarded.
- jacquesm 9y ago> I fear the day of more assertive China or EU acting retarded. It will take a while before they will overtake the US in this respect though. Vietnam and Korea were not exactly examples of 'keeping everyone in check' or 'fat uncle Sam doing the job'.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- thomasahle 9y agoLots of other reasons, such as the European Coal and Steel Community, which had the purpose "to make war not only unthinkable but materially impossible".
- tensor 9y agoYour counter to "bullshit quantitative analysis" is a pub-level speculative opinion? Frankly, I'll take quantitative analysis, or any analysis, over the flippant opinion approach to understanding.
- e12e 9y agoMore like nation states as a vehicle for occupation and acquisition, exploitation (privatisation) of resources played out its role as corporations and capital interest became more globalised. There's a school of thought that think we're heading towards a "normalisation" of as war as a private enterprise, as before national armies were the norm. Where military power is primarily mercenary, and strategic interest is dictated by private actors. Sean McFate discuss some of this trend in his book "the Modern Mercenary". [ed: One might view the use of force in establishing the keystone xl pipeline against native american interests as a microexample of how this might play out not only in "unlawful regions", but even in peaceful, regulated nations, such as the USA]