5 ms·
Norway tightens IT security to prevent ballot tampering
- saltvedt 9y agoThe machines used to count votes were Windows machines connected to the internet. https://www.nrk.no/norge/teller-opp-stemmer-i-valget-pa-datamaskiner-tilkoblet-internett-1.13660659 https://www.nrk.no/norge/teller-opp-stemmer-i-valget-pa-data...
- marksomnian 9y agoIf this was a joke it wouldn't be funny. Oh wait.
- spaceseaman 9y agoSo when is this gonna blow up for someone? Like are we gonna read about the U.S. power grid being shut down, or an entire state / nation wide election tampering? It's absolutely terrifying how incompetent these folks are. Why is there no one marketing their skills to governments who have actual skills? Why aren't governments hiring employees with actual skills? We used to have the most talented structural, mechanical, and industrial engineers in government positions or as government contractors. Is tech simply too young for that to have happened yet? Or are governments failing to adequately respond to their massive skills' gaps?
- empath75 9y agoIt already did. Look at the last election.
- gruez 9y agoNot obvious enough. Power grid hacked, widespread blackouts = somebody obviously hacked it. Meanwhile, poll numbers slightly off from opinion polls, but enough to sway an election = could he hacks, or could be sampling error. And thanks to the 2 party system, both parties will poll close to 50% it's very easy to hide in the noise.
- paulddraper 9y agoWhat did what last election? I heard rumors of people thinking there could have been problems, but nothing more than rumor came of it.
- maaaats 9y agoTightening it by counting manually, hehe. Was a big deal earlier this week that the keys and stuff for some municipalities were posted online on their web pages. Edit: it was certificates you had to install in the browser to verify that you were in the position to enter the total amount of votes in your municipality. The url for download were unique and random, but got indexed by search engines because they spy on urls you visit. https://www.nrk.no/norge/sensitive-valg-filer-for-tre-kommuner-var-tilgjengelig-for-hele-verden-1.13664601 https://www.nrk.no/norge/sensitive-valg-filer-for-tre-kommun... Edit, hmm, downvoted?
- JetSpiegel 9y agoI don't speak Norwegian, but this claims Edge sends all visited URL to Bing? Microsoft taking a page from Google, how quaint.
- chha 9y agoThere were similar reports earlier this year as well. Autopass, a Norwegian company responsible for most road tolls reported that a bunch of reports became publicly accessible as a result of people using Edge internally, and Evry reported the same regarding a bunch of invoices and other financial information from a client of theirs. (https://www.digi.no/artikler/16-mai-ble-det-full-kriseberedskap-i-evry-etter-datalekkasje-rotarsaken-kan-pavirke-alle-norske-selskaper/383149 https://www.digi.no/artikler/16-mai-ble-det-full-krisebereds...)
- rlkf 9y ago> this claims Edge sends all visited URL to Bing? Yes. So if you instead of attachments of large files in email send an URL such as https://acme.pri/?id=cafe-babe-deadbeeff00d https://acme.pri/?id=cafe-babe-deadbeeff00d, which is not secured by any other method than obscurity, then Edge will submit it to Bing, which indexes it and then the content is available if you can come up with some keywords that match. It is fairly well known in Norway, due to having been in the national news earlier this spring, but I have no reason to think it doesn't apply universally.
- e12e 9y ago
- ingve 9y agoVivaldi browser developer Patricia Aas has done a terrific job bringing awareness to election security issues ahead of the upcoming Norwegian election: https://twitter.com/pati_gallardo/ https://twitter.com/pati_gallardo/ (most links are in Norwegian, but Google translate does a reasonable job).
- erokar 9y agoI agree. She raised this concern as a private citizen and debated it on national tv and radio with the ballot bureaucrats who initally dowplayed the issue. If it hadn't been for her, probably nothing would have been done about it.
- captchaos99 9y agoOr someone else would have done it.... ;-)
- erokar 9y agoOr not ;)
- klondike_ 9y agoComputer voting was a mistake. It has been shown over and over that voting machine security is abysmal. Voting is one of the few things that shouldn't be computerized. It's far easier to swing an election by hacking a few voting machines than to forge thousands of ballots. No matter where you live, do yourself a favor and vote only on paper.
- spaceseaman 9y agoI think it's a great example of our governments' misunderstanding of modern technology and security. Our current governmental computer systems appear extremely fragile[1] and prone to tampering. If governments were actually serious about electronic voting, they need dedicated committees and bureaucratic entities whose sole responsibility is the maintenance and security of these systems. I expect the United State to be absolutely crippled by cyber-warfare in the coming decades. On a state level, our government is simply incapable of recognizing the many vulnerabilities their systems have and compensating for them. While personally I think electronic voting is a trash idea (couldn't we instead still vote via paper, and then read the results via ML? This would give us a "margin of error" of votes, but we would always have the paper ballots to fall back on), I think that tightening IT security is a good thing for governments to do. Especially considering just how poor computer security is for government entities. [1]. Just want to mention I'm not a security guru. This is just my interpretation after visiting many government websites, reading stories, etc
- QAPereo 9y agoThere is always major opposition to anything which would cause many more people to vote, because that would utterly change the current political landscape. The turkeys won't be voting for Thanksgiving.
- jacques_chester 9y ago> couldn't we instead still vote via paper, and then read the results via ML? You just move the single point of failure to an even more difficult-to-prove location.
- 9y ago
- anfractuosity 9y agoOut of interest, with computerised voting do they generally also protect the information of who voted for who? I might be wrong, but I don't think paper ballots have any identifying information on. Edit: Hmm, ballot papers do apparently have a unique ID on, which I hadn't noticed before.
- tyfon 9y agoHere in Norway at least, all voting is on paper ballot. You receive an election card (valgkort) in the mail to bring to the polling station containing all your info. ID is also required. If you forget this card, they can print it out for you. Then you enter the booth containing party lists. You can't "punch" the wrong party as each have their own ballot. You can erase/add/reprioritize names on the party list you choose though. Then you put this ballot into an anonymous envelope. This envelope is then put into another envelope along with your election card. When they count it, they pull out the ballot envelope and the election card, register that you have voted, then someone else will open and count the actual vote. It seems to me to be pretty secure and anonymous.
- andy_ppp 9y agoIn case you haven’t seen this breakdown by Tom Scott about why electronic voting is lunicy, here it is: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=w3_0x6oaDmI https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=w3_0x6oaDmI
- alain_gilbert 9y agoJust a wild thought I had: If you remember the invisible dots that printers add, so the government can track where something was printed. ( https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14501894 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14501894 ) I wonder if some government did/are/could use this technologies to deanonymize voters. For example they would print your SSN on the piece of paper that you are voting on.
- askvictor 9y agoIt might be possible, but quite difficult in practice given that a voter can show up at any time to any number of voting stations.
- alain_gilbert 9y agoIt's been a while I haven't voted. I'm from Canada and currently live abroad. But If I remember well, I had to actually vote at a specific place. The part I don't remember well is if they were giving me a specific sheet of paper, or just take one on the top of a stack. I remember they were looking for my name, and I have a souvenir that they detached the side of the sheet (but this is vague). I guess it was a stack :)
- askvictor 9y agoIn Australia, you can go to any polling station in your electorate, where they find your name in a book of paper (of which there are several copies in each station, and several stations in each electorate), cross it off, and give you a ballot paper from a stack. Presumably they process the names lists after the fact to see if anyone voted twice, though by that point there's no way to get the votes out of the mix.
- askvictor 9y agoReposting what a few 2nd level comments have already said: voting is still done on paper in Norway; the counting if what is being done electronically.
- nkristoffersen 9y agoIsn't blockchain tech perfect for voting?