8 ms·
How Do We Solve America’s Oversupply of Bread?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- DoctorNick 9y agoThe Conquest of Bread
- fnovd 9y agoIs this a problem that needs solving? >What if independent bakeries baked only what they thought they could sell and no more? Then they would lose money, period.
- ianai 9y agoWrong question. Right question: how can we get people to make quality bread instead of the trans fatty/overly salty stuff flooding the shelves?
- davewongillies 9y agoAtleast in the US I'd just like it to be not so hard to find bread without sugar added it. Why do I have to resort to eating sour dough all the time just to do that?
- tomohawk 9y agoAt the major grocer in our area, there's only 1 brand that isn't sweetened. It's a traditional pita bread. If I had to guess, this represents .5% of the bread sold there.
- QAPereo 9y agoEducation. It's not quick or pretty, but education is the key.
- fenwick67 9y agoSalt is not bad for you
- uoaei 9y agoToo much of anything can be bad for you.
- votepaunchy 9y agoToo little of anything can be bad for you. By definition.
- tnorthcutt 9y agoArsenic? Cyanide? Mercury?
- Retra 9y agoThey're being pedantic (probably to highlight the complete lack of useful information provided by the post they responded to.) "Too little" means "not enough" and "not enough" is not enough by definition. There's no such thing as "not enough" of those things because none is enough.
- stale2002 9y agoAnd furthermore, the vast majority of people in the USA are not having too little salt. The vast majority of them have way way too much salt in their diet, therefore it is perfectly honest to say that high sodium content in food in the USA is "bad for you", because we live in a context where too much salt is the problem, and not too little.
- KhanMahGretsch 9y agoNot only is it not bad for you, it's essential for a healthy diet. It appears to me that refined-corn and sugar are the two worst culprits for poor nutrition. Edit: Eater always cracks me up with their alarmist headlines and fascination with shoe-horning identity politics into articles. Not to be taken seriously IMO.
- Broken_Hippo 9y agoSubsidize correctly. I'd suggest first and foremost subsidizing healthier flours and seeds/nuts destined for breadmaking. We'll probably need some tax breaks or other sorts of incentives so that mills can scale the product correctly. One of the advantages of using the more refined flours (the all-purpose flour you can buy anywhere) is large-scale production. And then add a tax to either the more refined flours (which is likely to make sweet baked goods go up in price as well) or simply tax the more unhealthy white bread and buns so they aren't nearly as affordable. Edit: I'll mention that some salt is actually good for bread making, as it balances out the yeast. I'm not sure if this is such a problem on an industrial scale since they can control variables much better than the home cook. In addition, it tastes weird without salt. but it doesn't take all that much to satisfy the physical and taste requirements. Furthermore, I'll advocate for a bit of fat in the bread, though it should come from healthy sources. This helps bread not go stale so quickly, and I'm actually more concerned about unnecessary preservatives. Finally, an afterthought: We should make sure to make the healthy bread convenient and available, even in a food desert.
- davewongillies 9y agoAdding to this, desubsidize corn to the point where it no longer makes sense to add HFCS to regular bread that isn't meant to be a dessert.
- Broken_Hippo 9y agoI have mixed feelings on this - mostly, if we do such a thing, we'll need to replace it with something. I think corn farmers really wouldn't have an issue planting sugar beets instead, so long as the various corn sugars (Including but not limited to HFCS) aren't a byproduct of another process. Without some sort of safety net for farmers, it could really hurt some folks, mostly because I'm assuming different harvesting attachments are used for the two crops and what side industries might be hurt (whatever we use corn cobs for, for example). But I simply don't know the answer to this.
- prostoalex 9y ago> I'd suggest first and foremost subsidizing healthier flours and seeds/nuts Huge Pandora's box right there with California nut farmers. Basically, way back a bunch of people bought cheap land and then bought politicians to build the water infrastructure to make that privately owned land commercially viable. Now that water supply is unreliable, there's a movement to force the California taxpayers to boost the nut producers' profits, which some people disagree with.
- rugffgbv 9y agoRight question is how to get people to eat whole grain bread. It has 2x or 3x of vitamins and minerals. http://www.motherearthnews.com/-/media/Images/MEN/Editorial/Special-Projects/Collection-Pages/Whole-Grains-Guide-Recipes-Cooking-Tips-and-Nutrition-Information-for-Healthy-WholeGrain-Foods/Whole-Wheat-Flour-Graph_600X400.jpg?la=en&hash=542CC4B565B9D50C88C891D3AB190409EB491435 http://www.motherearthnews.com/-/media/Images/MEN/Editorial/...
- ianai 9y agoI wonder if it's a leavening thing. What I like most about French, for instance, is the lightness.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- mattnewport 9y agoHow do we solve America's oversupply of people writing articles without a basic understanding of economics?
- yequalsx 9y agoSome things have negative externalities that ought to dealt with. Market forces are such that these negative externalities sometimes exist and so just resorting to, "This is what the market demands" is not sufficient and is bad policy.
- repsilat 9y agoBeing able to give free bread to hungry people at the end of the day is a positive externality. I'm sure there are negative ones too (wasted water from farming excess wheat being one) but bakers pay for that, and if they're not cutting down it's because maintaining a sufficient inventory is worth more.
- yequalsx 9y agoSure but the person I responded to made was making a point about basic economics and, at least to my reading of the comment, seemed to be of the opinion of let the market decide. Sometimes the market decision is not a good one.
- randomdata 9y ago> wasted water from farming excess wheat being one As a wheat farmer, I am curious to know what water you think is wasted? Wheat is normally harvested at 14% moisture, so what water content the crop has taken on by harvest is minimal. Otherwise it seems like the rain is going to do what the rain does. What am I missing? Do you mean that the rainwater could have been used to grow some other crop? The primary reason I grow wheat is for plant and soil health reasons in order to sustainably grow the pulses and other legumes that the consumer demands. There is not much money in wheat, but it is hard to argue with the ecosystem benefits that it provides. Crop rotation is a necessity for good farm management.
- nxc18 9y agoIts a 3-step plan: 1. stop subsidizing it. 2. stop buying it. 3. deal with the monumental consequences of step 1. An optional 4th step might be taking some time to understand basic economics. A 5th step would be to address the underlying causes of poverty in our communities, rather than complain that we have too much food to give away. (Note that taking step 1 will probably change the economics of food such that there is much, much less free food floating around)
- Im_back_4_U 9y agoThe real question is why can't we make bread anymore. To much of this crap called "bread" and none of what used to be known as bread. Something is really wrong with the system when competecies that were for eons the norm really can't be done anymore at a cultural scale. Something is wrong in Denmark people, and by Denmark I of course mean America.
- EternalData 9y agoIs it just confined to bread? I feel like subsidies/industrial farming have led to a homogenized diet overall -- to the point where it can be hard I think to confine the definition of oversupply to only one foodstuff.
- klondike_ 9y agoWhy is this a problem? The author points out that excess bread is given away to those in need or used as animal feed.
- iUsedToCode 9y agoSorry, but American bread (at least on West Coast) is really bad. Maybe you can find something edible somewhere, but most of the shops carry only the worst of worst IMO. In Europe (not including UK) the quality is like night and day. I've noticed bread getting worse as it's produced in bigger batches since couple of years, but american stuff is in its own category of bad. I hear that East coast has more european style (of cities, buildings and cuisine), so maybe it's better there. OTH, perhaps just missed all the good bakeries.
- jasonjei 9y agoHave you tried Tartine, Josey Baker, ACME, Craftsman and Wolves, or Arsicault for bread in San Francisco when you were in the west coast? San Francisco is considered one of the best bread cities in the world, especially when it comes to natural starters and sourdough... Bi-Rite Market's bread section has a really nice selection. I'm assuming none of those were to your satisfaction? Some French people have told me that Tartine's baguette is better if not equal to French baguettes, so I'm curious to know why it is so distant to European quality in your perspective.
- noja 9y ago> San Francisco is considered one of the best bread cities in the world... I've never heard this before. By who?
- davewongillies 9y agoThis is seriously not meant to be a snark at all but I've only ever heard it from people in SF.
- jasonjei 9y agoBy Serious Eats[0], founded by former New York Times food editor Ed Levine. Also by the BBC[1]. Arsicault Bakery in SF was named the best bakery in America by Bon Appetit. Tartine Bakery is a James Beard winner. [0] http://www.seriouseats.com/2013/08/taste-test-the-best-sourdough-bread-in-san-fr.html http://www.seriouseats.com/2013/08/taste-test-the-best-sourd... [1] http://www.bbc.com/travel/story/20131121-flour-power-in-san-franciscos-sourdough http://www.bbc.com/travel/story/20131121-flour-power-in-san-...
- analog31 9y agoThere’s also the fact that, except in the most exclusive bakeries, a bare shelf is a no-no. Amusingly, I was in a mountain village in Switzerland for several days. If you got to the bakery too late, you were SOL. You could still go down to the Co-Op and get bread, but it was noticeably inferior.
- Noumenon72 9y agoOne nice thing about the oversupply is that if there ever is some kind of shock to the food supply like Krakatoa or a blight, we have a buffer available by just not wasting as much. Probably more sustainable as backup capacity than some kind of government-funded granaries. Also, I believe white, refined flour is so dangerous to your insulin resistance that it's usually better to throw it away than to eat it.
- spoonie 9y agoHow about supply management of wheat like Canada's dairy board?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- coldtea 9y agoOversupply? America has almost no real bread. Maybe instead solve the overabundance of sugar, mass-produced, full of BS preservatives and artificial flavors BS that passes for bread in the US?
- pasbesoin 9y agoJust read the other day about how this year's U.S. wheat harvest will be the lowest since some year in the teens of the prioir century. Wheat prices are down significantly. And vegetarian protein demand is up. Farmers have been switching to garbanzo beans (chickpeas) and lentils. Sorry, I don't have the link right at hand.
- somecontext 9y agoFor some context if anyone in interested, it appears that before WWII, the peak production of wheat in the United States was in 1915 with ~1 billion bushels/year. The expected production for 2017 is over ~1.7 billion bushels/year. The last time production was even close to the peak pre-WWII level was in 1962. Sources: the absolutely amazing "Crop production historical track records" from the USDA available at http://usda.mannlib.cornell.edu/usda/current/htrcp/htrcp-04-13-2017.pdf http://usda.mannlib.cornell.edu/usda/current/htrcp/htrcp-04-... for historical numbers and https://www.usda.gov/oce/commodity/wasde/latest.pdf https://www.usda.gov/oce/commodity/wasde/latest.pdf for 2017 estimates. It may be interesting to note that the area harvested has gone down by ~40%, but of course the yields have increased -- by a factor of ~2.7.