7 ms·
California lawmakers are proposing a tax on water bills
- dmoy 9y ago$370B/yr - It seems a bit useless to call out the total tax number of all the bills put forth. What percentage of those typically pass? That would be relevant info to actually evaluate that number, without it, it's kind of meaningless. $183B/yr is the number given below for total budget. So what, they're going to triple the state budget in one year? No, that's insane, so why the hell bother pointing that out?
- VeronicaJJ123 9y agoTax everyone to death California !
- gedy 9y ago> "California is the fifth largest economy in the world, with a $183 billion state budget and $125 billion general fund that is intended to fund essential government services such as education, health and public safety. The taxpayers of our state have already provided the necessary funding for our Legislature to solve any challenge that impacts our communities." Sums it up well. I know new challenges come up but California does/should already have a enough money to cover basic infrastructure.
- mrgordon 9y agoInvestment now saves money later in many cases. For example, climate change denying Florida will be halfway under water by the time the people give up on their state government and elect some people who will install pumps, barrier islands, etc. to mitigate the effects. The water is already noticeably higher in coastal areas. Another good example is trains. They cost a ton upfront but they will shape entire communities for generations.
- tomcam 9y ago> Another good example is trains. They cost a ton upfront but they will shape entire communities for generations. In California? Which entire communities? I lived there for 30 years and know of only a few very, very narrow definitions of community for which that is true. A strip in downtown LA and some of the BART constituency. California does not have the density of NYC or Paris. I do not understand how the trains will affect more than .05% or so of the population.
- mixmastamyk 9y agoThe reason it doesn't have that density is because of NIMBYs and train opponents like yourself. But the tide has already turned, measure S and skyrocketing rents show that everything has changed. I see cranes all over the place, trains will follow. The nature of that kind of long-term infrastructure investment won't show itself for ten years.
- tomcam 9y agoPlease speak for yourself. NIMBY doesn't describe me very well. I grew up with trains, love them, and was literally a block away from a busy line. I still miss the horns.
- mixmastamyk 9y agoThen perhaps you'll want to refrain from making anti train construction arguments that are now out of date. We're quite behind because of them.
- FooHentai 9y agoChicken/Egg conundrum. LA's low-density sprawl exists for three (maybe four/five) reasons: Geological (quake shake = low rise makes sense), availability of land, and lack of suitable transport infrastructure. (Possible forth reason is the overall history of the place, maybe we're just at the apex of that time when various disparate towns come together to form the city and we're not quite done with that process yet). I guess there's a tenuous fifth reason which is LA's road infrastructure is at the extreme end of feasibility, including but not limited to the inhabitant's seemingly infinite patience for rush-hour gridlock. If you believe the earthquake risk, land area, and roading are reasons enough that urban intensification has not occurred, then adding (more) rail doesn't really make sense. On the other hand, you could regard lack of rail as being the only thing holding back urban intensification, and the lack of it being the very reason for LA's current sprawl. Providing you don't regard the other factors as hard limiters, of course. So in one school of thought: there's nothing really stopping the rest of LA intensifying in the same way as downtown (and the airport area), other than a lack of suitable transport infrastructure to facilitate it. So assuming intensification is a thing you want, there is the argument to invest and deploy the trains; in a few years you should see a great intensification of the new corridor areas of LA where it previously didn't make sense. Personally, I'm not on board with the idea - The quake hazard alone is reason enough to keep things flat and wide. I might be somewhat conservative in that regard of course - Continually echoing in my mind is that statement from 'the really big one' article a few years back that said 'everything west of Interstate 5 will be toast', as far as how I judge LA's realism on earthquake risk.
- hyperion2010 9y agoOf course they don't bother trying to, you know, lift the giant subsidies on water for agriculture when farmers are still using 10000 year old irrigation practices that result in most of the water evaporating into the air ....
- brownbat 9y agoMore info from WashPo, "Agriculture is 80 percent of water use in California. Why aren’t farmers being forced to cut back?": https://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/govbeat/wp/2015/04/03/agriculture-is-80-percent-of-water-use-in-california-why-arent-farmers-being-forced-to-cut-back/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/govbeat/wp/2015/04/03/a... Lays out some on both sides, but still seems jarring to me that a state that sometimes contends with droughts is fighting to maintain so many water hungry crops. Good discussion here of what might shift if agricultural water had a price, or some kind of pigouvian tax: http://www.takepart.com/article/2015/05/11/cows-not-almonds-are-biggest-water-users/ http://www.takepart.com/article/2015/05/11/cows-not-almonds-... Like rice, that both consumes a lot of water and doesn't even produce that great of returns.
- devmunchies 9y ago> Like rice, that both consumes a lot of water and doesn't even produce that great of returns. More water is used by cows. They drink lots of water, plus the food that they eat requires water. The only thing is that their food was most likely produced in another state.
- boyaka 9y agoThen they pee it out
- dbcurtis 9y agoYes, it always amazes me that we grow rice in a desert. But you might say the same for cotton, but in the case of cotton, long-staple cottons derived from ancient Egyptian cottons make superior cloth because of the longer fibers, but are susceptable to boll rot if it gets rain at the wrong time. It isn't always a simple analysis. If you want to give up growing cotton in California, be prepared for the quality of your shirts to go down. The bottom line is it isn't the farmers who are the ultimate consumers of the water. We all use ag water when we buy food at the grocery store. We eat the water. You can't make an impact on ag water without impacting the consumer also, and that connection needs to be acknowledged. The farmers use the water, but they don't consume the water. We do.
- klondike_ 9y agoI'm guessing this doesn't apply to the many companies who take groundwater practically for free and then bottle and sell it. Regular consumers shouldn't be punished for the misuse of water by companies and farmers.
- labster 9y agoNope. Modifying pre-1914 water rights in California would constitute a taking, and the state government would have to reimburse that. As for the sweetheart deals that Nestlé gets from the federal government, that's another matter entirely.
- tempodox 9y agoRegular consumers don't finance election campaigns.
- matt_wulfeck 9y agoHonestly why? We have one of the highest tax burdens in the entire USA. We already pay more for water and more for electricity than almost anywhere else.
- damnfine 9y agoIf you were paying for even half your impact on the land, most people would be taxed out of California. Why? You use it, you need to pay for it.
- jonathankoren 9y agoWhy? Because of the initiative process. Budgeting in California needlessly complicated and hamstrung due to the people of California. Prop 13 famously underfunds schools and the like. Also, Prop 98 (which is notoriously complex) hamstrings the budget process so that about half of the budget must be spent on education, which in effect can make everything that's not for K-14 twice as expensive. When I ascend to the throne, I'd make the legislature unicameral (really, what's the point of a state Senate anyway?) and eliminate the initiative process.
- ScottBurson 9y agoI wouldn't eliminate the initiative process entirely, but there definitely needs to be a higher vote threshold for laws the legislature can't modify.
- trapperkeeper74 9y agoAll these taxes to pay for: - $1+ B Side-deals to raise the gas tax $50+ B. - $10+ B Mass-incarceration. - $80+ B High-Speed Monorail boondoggle orders of magnitude more expensive than Hyperloop.
- jonathankoren 9y ago1) It's not a monorail. It's normal high speed rail system that's been successful deployed the world over. 2) Hyperloop doesn't exist.
- true_religion 9y agoAlso, monorails have been successfully deployed around the world. They've been available since the early 20th century. It isn't fantastical technology to use one gigantic rail instead of two smaller rails.
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoThere are, as of yet, no high speed monorails that I'm aware of.
- jonathankoren 9y ago30 kilometers. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shanghai_Maglev_Train https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shanghai_Maglev_Train Then they apparently scrapped the idea of extending it beyond the airport.
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoIs a maglev really a monorail? I've taken it to pudong airport before. It isn't very practical, because of the transfer a taxi is still faster.
- jonathankoren 9y ago
- l3m0ndr0p 9y agoThis sounds like they are going to sell the water management, water rights to a for-profit company, once the taxes are in place. Guaranteed income & increases for years to come. It's sad that most of our resources of necessity are in the hands of for-profit companies.
- nine_k 9y agoWhen they are not, you have a real risk of the tragedy of commons.
- chewbacha 9y agoPublic drinking water helps the poor, taxing it would hurt them. Correct? The wealthy drink bottles artisanal water anyhow. I like the idea of a safe drinking water commission, but perhaps we fund it with taxes on chemical waste, mining, and fossil fuels. Things that contaminate the drinking water. That way the tax itself helps improve the water safety. This seems as misguided as when we added a sales tax to help homelessness.
- sethammons 9y agoI read through the bill. There is a lot of talk on what fees they are imposing and on who. There is not much on what the money will be used for aside from mapping at risk water for contamination. A blurb about infrastructure consulting and potential help. Very light on details. And a section on how farms that discharge a lot of nitrates will be in compliance as long as they pay their fees within 90 days. Sounds like a charge of $1 per month to residents to have a new program around that can raise the fees later to keep the program around. I did not catch much of anything in the text about actually helping communities with unhealthy water.
- rayiner 9y agoAdditional taxes on water are sorely needed for safety as well as environmental reasons: https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2015/03/finding-the-right-price-for-water/388246 https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2015/03/finding.... On average, water rates in the US are about half of what they are in say France. In many cases, not only are rates too low to discourage inefficient water use, they’re too low to even adequately maintain the water/sewer infrastructure: http://www.asce.org/water_and_wastewater_report/ http://www.asce.org/water_and_wastewater_report/
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoDoes that apply to California though? It has some of the highest water rates in the country.
- cobookman 9y agowhy not raise the price of water...vs adding a tax?
- whyenot 9y agoThere is something a little intellectually lazy about taking an editorial from a republican representative in the OC Register and then treating it and commenting on it as if it is a news article that is not implicitly biased. Many news articles have been published on this bill. Here is one that the Mercury News did. http://www.mercurynews.com/2017/08/23/first-ever-tax-on-california-drinking-water-proposed-for-contaminated-groundwater-clean-up/ http://www.mercurynews.com/2017/08/23/first-ever-tax-on-cali...
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoThere's an old adage about hammers, a lack of other available tools and nail. Now replace hammer with taxes... They're tripping over a $20 to pick up a quarter by taxing consumers. As others have mentioned consumers aren't the problem.
- unlmtd1 9y agoDictators are proposing more dictatorship.