4 ms·
Doesn't make them wrong. I find the idea of crypto currency, especially bitcoin, very interesting. I just have a very hard time seeing how it's actually usefu
by MBCook 9y ago
Doesn't make them wrong.
I find the idea of crypto currency, especially bitcoin, very interesting. I just have a very hard time seeing how it's actually useful. It can't handle very many transactions per minute. And the thing that supposed to make it so great is that no one controls it. But if bitcoin becomes really important then people will want to control a lot of the mining power. Pretty soon you end up with a group of miners (or even a single miner) having enough power to influence things leaving you pretty close to someone being in charge of the thing.
It's such a fascinating idea. But in less there was someway to limit mining so people couldn't throw additional power at it I'm not sure it's useful.
As an example, you could use a block chain to enforce a ledger between a couple of different companies but you'd have to have some sort of contract it said everyone was only allowed to use one of device X for mining. That way everyone would be equal and you could easily check it because the blocks should be minded roughly evenly.
But when miners can buy additional mining capacity, and they get rewarded for doing that with more money, how does this not end up with a winner takes all situation?
- solotronics 9y agowhy is it useful? you can store and instantly send any arbitrary amount of money anywhere on the planet and it is the hardest (impossible?) for a government to steal it from you
- harryh 9y agohttps://xkcd.com/538/ https://xkcd.com/538/
- nosuchthing 9y agoCorrection: you can store and send any arbitrary amount of database entries and wait for several minutes while your transaction is processed
- MBCook 9y agoI can send money around the world with it. You can too. Will it hold up when 10 million people want to do that per day? 100 million? Half 1 billion? I know it can work at niche scales (relative to total global financial transactions) but can it actually be scaled up to be a real player? Even if the block size was massively larger, say 100 MB, would enough transactions be able to be broadcasted around fast enough to be able to be collected in giant blocks to keep up with demand? As to hardest/impossible for a government to steal from you: this is the mining pool problem. What if China decided to do something about all of the mining pools they have in their country and try and manipulate bitcoin? What if in addition to the pools that they could get/force to cooperate they added a bunch more miners with government computers? What if the US government just decided to throw computer power at trying to make the dominant hashrate mining pool? I'm guessing there are number of governments in the world it would be capable of doing that TODAY. They could certainly do it if they cooperated. Even if they can't take over they could throw enough uncertainty into the process to cause the price to crash. If they all competed against each other we could end up in a situation where even know if theoretically no one controls bit coin realistically it's controlled by a bunch of giant governments and no one else is capable of competing. Oops, that sort of like the current banking system. Like I said it's a fascinating idea, but I don't think it works at planet scale or if people can independently buy additional hashing capacity. It seems like it would have to have some sort of agreement to limit everyone to be roughly equal for it to work out almost anywhere. I'd love to see history prove me wrong. I don't remember seening a solution to the problems that worry me yet. If they exist I'm not smart enough to think of them. We'll see what happens.
- sillysaurus3 9y agoI think it can. People hate on the lightning network proposal, but I've read it and it seems like there's no reason it wouldn't work. BTC would then be used as a finalizing ledger, not for day to day transactions.
- prostoalex 9y agoYou're sending integers. To do anything useful you'd need to convert those integers to actual fiat money, and to do that you either go through a government-licensed conversion channel such as an exchange, or a third party willing to assume the conversion risk that usually comes wih high fees or highly unfavorable exchange rate.
- fooker 9y ago>instantly This makes me think you haven't ever transferred bitcoins.
- rampage101 9y agoIt shows up as unconfirmed usually in a few seconds, meaning it's in the mempool and ready to be added to the blockchain. If you trust the sender it's enough... but on average you are right that it's about 10 minutes to get the transaction included in the block. With Ethereum they are mining blocks about every 10 or 20 seconds.
- solotronics 9y agoI have many times. Bank transfers can take hours or days but BTC shows up instantly and is proven permanently immutable after a few blocks (20-40 minutes)
- drizzzler 9y ago>I just have a very hard time seeing how it's actually useful Why is it so hard to see? Whenever you send money somewhere electronically, a middleman takes a cut. With Bitcoin there is no middleman. It's that easy.
- tunetine 9y agoIt's actually less useful. You already have banks doing the exact same thing for free, while insuring your money, you don't get hit 3% for transferring it into the bank, and there's interest accrued, not wildly shifting value where you might lose half in a few hours.
- tradersam 9y ago> You already have banks doing the exact same thing for free, while insuring your money, you don't get hit 3% for transferring it into the bank, and there's interest accrued So much wrong with this statement. First, not many banks in the U.S. do "the exact same thing for free", actually almost none do. Most ACH transfers take 1-5 days, instead of ~10 minutes with Bitcoin or ~15 seconds with Ethereum. Yes, I know about Zelle, but not all banks support that, and clearXchange isn't always same day, even. Second, some services like Coinbase[1] insure your holdings, even while in crypto. Third, almost all services that use ACH, like GDAX (Coinbase), Gemini, etc. don't do a 3% transfer fee through ACH, it's actually free. But it's next business day, like most ACH, where as crypto would've been an hour at most. Lastly, some countries, like oh I don't know, Japan[2], have negative interest rates, so your money shrinks by the day instead of growing. [1]:https://support.coinbase.com/customer/portal/articles/1662379-how-is-coinbase-insured- https://support.coinbase.com/customer/portal/articles/166237... [2]:https://www.nytimes.com/2016/09/21/business/international/japan-boj-negative-interest-rates.html https://www.nytimes.com/2016/09/21/business/international/ja...
- MBCook 9y agoJust for the record on September 15 most ACH transactions are supposed to start taking a day instead of the multiple days we have now.
- srge 9y agoBeing right or wrong is not time independent. Someone saying it's crazy to buy virtual coins for $1 in 2009 was clearly wrong.