4 ms·
Reporter: Google successfully pressured me to take down critical story
- mcguire 9y ago"[In 2011,] Hill was a cub reporter at Forbes, where she covered technology and privacy. At the time, Google was actively promoting Google Plus and was sending representatives to media organizations to encourage them to add "+1" buttons to their sites. Hill was pulled into one of these meetings, where the Google representative suggested that Forbes would be penalized in Google search results if it didn't add +1 buttons to the site. "Hill thought that seemed like a big story, so she contacted Google's PR shop for confirmation. Google essentially confirmed the story, and so Hill ran with it under the headline: "Stick Google Plus Buttons On Your Pages, Or Your Search Traffic Suffers."" ""I was told by my higher-ups at Forbes that Google representatives called them saying that the article was problematic and had to come down. The implication was that it might have consequences for Forbes, a troubling possibility given how much traffic came through Google searches and Google News."" Ugh. Google was reportedly throwing their search traffic weight around.
- deadalus 9y agoThis is why I am scared to criticize Google. It knows who I am and it knows all the other businesses/websites that I own. It might try to damage/demonetize them subversively if it thinks that I am against it or its owners in any way. There will be no way I can prove it. It also shares it data with the US government. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/In-Q-Tel https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/In-Q-Tel https://gizmodo.com/how-google-gives-your-information-to-the-nsa-512840958 https://gizmodo.com/how-google-gives-your-information-to-the...
- e40 9y agoThis is why I am scared to criticize Google You just did, in what followed that comment.
- jklinger410 9y agoTo me this article feels like bandwagoning and hearsay. I am all for the critical attention aimed at Google, but there is simply no teeth to this story at all. Edit: Thanks guys for the criticism about using the word hearsay in this context. I'll never use it that way again, pinky promise.
- javajosh 9y agoDownvoted, because this comment insinuates wrong-doing without any evidence. Think twice before casting meritless aspersions.
- jklinger410 9y agoIt's ironic that you would say that considering that the article itself insinuates wrong-doing without any evidence.
- spunker540 9y ago"Without any evidence"?? I think first-hand accounts of conversations should count for something. I know it's not as good as a recording, but journalists frequently report on verbal answers to their questions.
- saas_sam 9y agoHearsay is a legal term to prevent court cases from proceeding on information gleaned from witnesses who are not present. So, if you refuse to go to court as a witness, your coworker who overheard you talk about the case cannot sit in your place. When someone writes a story about someone else's experience, that's not "hearsay," that's just "journalism." You may not think this story sounds credible, but if so you should come up with a different reason than "this is a story about someone else's experience therefore it's unreliable." And anyway, you can just read the original article written by the person who experienced this, if you want to circumvent the "hearsay" thing: http://gizmodo.com/yes-google-uses-its-power-to-quash-ideas-it-doesn-t-li-1798646437 http://gizmodo.com/yes-google-uses-its-power-to-quash-ideas-...
- lern_too_spel 9y agoThreatening to retaliate against the press is another thing (after the no-poaching agreement) Google should not have copied from Apple.
- Jtsummers 9y agoNot doubting you, but what instances were there of Apple threatening to retaliate against the press? Nothing is coming to mind when I try to recall such incidents and I imagine you have some specific ones you could point to.
- lern_too_spel 9y agohttp://www.zdnet.com/article/apple-prs-dirty-little-secret/ http://www.zdnet.com/article/apple-prs-dirty-little-secret/ https://www.cultofmac.com/255618/how-apples-blacklist-manipulates-the-press/ https://www.cultofmac.com/255618/how-apples-blacklist-manipu...
- Jtsummers 9y agoThanks for the links, I think I'd read the ZDNet article once before.
- smegel 9y ago> Hill thought that seemed like a big story It is a big story still. It sounds illegal.
- zjmbjkyu7877 9y agoShe was there as an employee/representative for Forbes, not an independent journalist. "...Hill was a cub reporter at Forbes..." Forbes agreed to an NDA not to publish information. Information she uncovered working for Forbes. "...Google representative suggested that Forbes would be penalized in Google search results if it didn't add +1 buttons to the site." Suggested how? Like, this is going to be popular, our algorithm may begin to nudge up sites with +1's versus sites without if the network effect of having a +1 is nudging sites up in popularity/visibility? Or "Larry and Sergei will login and change your rankings?" Big difference. Let's not pretend journalists aren't susceptible to misunderstanding technical topics. None of this is a shock! This happens ALL THE DAMN TIME in business. There's a lot of hit pieces being pushed by Google's competitors and those that may be threatened by them. None of this is discussing how Google screws the public in general, but about how it screws Forbes, or might screw liberals and conservative power players, or Amazon. I'm not saying Google is a saint, they're pretty crappy. But look at the messengers here, and the "issues" being raised. Google can't use their investments to run their business their way. The only concern is how it is screwing with other big wigs, however!
- sctb 9y agoYesterday's discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15145176 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15145176
- Sylphine 9y ago"Disclosure: My brother works at Google." We all know who is getting fired today. grabs popcorn Edit: Dupe already! Man do googlers on HN work fast.