4 ms·
In almost all of eg Appalachia, a 35-40 hour per week, $15 per hour online job (doing anything), is a good job for the majority of people versus the alternative
by adventured 9y ago
In almost all of eg Appalachia, a 35-40 hour per week, $15 per hour online job (doing anything), is a good job for the majority of people versus the alternatives available.
There's no question it can make a meaningful difference near-term. The obvious long-term solution is further urbanization or near-urbanization, convincing people to leave those dying regions for greater opportunity.
- rayiner 9y agoWhat are these $15/hour 40 hour a week remote jobs? How many of them are there?
- meric 9y agoCall centres? They have an advantage over foreign call centres operators (more fluent in the language), some companies might pay for it. Also, this idea: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15136091 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15136091
- Mediterraneo10 9y agoThere are now just too many other countries with young people speaking excellent, near-native English thanks to an entire childhood spent with American movies and television. Eastern Europeans or Filipinos can do call center work cheaper than American rural areas.
- matt_s 9y agoCheaper per hour is easy to measure but its hard to measure customer satisfaction. When I call a support line and get "Walter" who is going to help me, I know they are in a different hemisphere and am mostly unsatisfied with talking to them because they are trained with scripts and they talk like robots. If I called and recognized a Kentucky accent, chances are that person is going to be more relatable and personable than "Walter" from 8 timezones away. Mr./Mrs. Kentucky might crack a joke and get me to lighten up a little about why XYZ isn't working. If both calls have the same result, I walk away from talking to Mr./Mrs. a little more satisfied than with "Walter". The same could be said if it was reversed, if someone was calling from the far east and ended up talking with Mr./Mrs. Kentucky it is going to be hard for them to be relatable and personable to someone from the far east.
- Mediterraneo10 9y ago> Mr./Mrs. Kentucky might crack a joke Call centers insist so much on following scripts that I am not sure there would be opportunities to make jokes even if the person was in the same country as you. Also, do you think that Americans want to hear a Kentucky accent? I would rather speak to a foreigner than hear someone with a village accent from my country. Those places have a reputation for low education and low culture, and so it is hard for customers to trust any employee with that accent who claims he can help you. I know that call centers have moved to my country and to the Philippines because English speakers in these countries have a more "neutral" accent.
- adventured 9y agoEverything from support, to sales, to web development, admin, security, etc. I'd list all the telecommuting job sites, but there seems to be a thousand of them now. The US median income is about $37,000 per year ($17-$18 per hour). To get beyond ~$13 to ~$17 per hour doing lower skill telecommuting work, you have to have a resume with something meaningful on it. If you're from Appalachia, it's not difficult to teach yourself any number of skills (from database admin to javascript), go to a local small college to pad your resume with that, get a certification or two if applicable, and then get a job working remote at an entry level tech job that pays considerably better than anything local (few of those jobs exist locally there). A person can go work at a local AT&T or similar store doing sales in an Appalachian town, get some sales experience, and then go apply for a remote sales job making more than they'll get locally. Particularly right now is an ideal time, the US labor market is getting very tight. I grew up in Appalachia and entirely self-taught my way out of it in the mid 1990s. It was a helluva lot more difficult to do back then. And that process is trivial compared to working in a coal mine, and it's a lot less soul destroying than toiling away for a decade earning $10-$15 at a local Walmart.
- rayiner 9y agoNo doubt some people can do that. But the original quote is comparing broadband to the railroads. The railroads (and mining) supported a broad economy with various roles for lots of different kinds of people. I have a hard time believing that broadband is going to have the same effect through remote sales and database admin jobs.
- turk183 9y agoIt sounds great, but it's out of reach for 98% of those people. They mostly don't have the aptitude nor the motivation to work and the kind of work they are able to do is pretty menial service or infrastructure type stuff. I have been to these places, seen it up close and quite personally and while some few will escape and better themselves, the majority aren't going in to knowledge work and that's true everywhere in the US, not just Appalachia. You grew up there but you don't understand the people? I guess we are all optimists.