23 ms·
> The red fitted line has a slope above 60.000 km (say 40,000 miles) of 1% per 50.000 km (30,000 miles). I'm going to bring this up because I think it's both i
by kbenson 9y ago
> The red fitted line has a slope above 60.000 km (say 40,000 miles) of 1% per 50.000 km (30,000 miles).
I'm going to bring this up because I think it's both interesting, and sometimes it comes up on its own and detracts from the conversation with conjecture (and sometimes harsh assumptions) until covered adequately[1] - different countries have different conventions for whether they use a comma or period for a thousands separator, and in those languages if they also speak in English sometimes, they may choose to continue using a period as a thousands separator as is convention in their country, even if the predominant language in their country is not English, and there are circumstances which might make that more common for some people.[2]
In this case, we have what appears to be switching convention when switching unit systems, which is interesting. I'm not sure if it's more or less confusing in the end, but there's not really any standardization of this as far as I know, so it's all good.
1: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14970002 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14970002
2: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14862695 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14862695
- microcolonel 9y agoFrankly it might be a bit confusing to Canadians, here we use the U.S. numeric conventions, but we tend to use a mix of SI and imperial units, and in this case we'd use kilometres for ground distance, with thousands separated by commas. The UK also seems to prefer commas to separate thousands. I'm inoculated against confusion about this because I've done a lot of software and content localization, and have a grasp on the specifics for a lot of different cultures. I think the problem is exacerbated by the underuse of the SI system's prefixes. Why even talk about thousands of kilometres when you can speak in tens of megametres? Added: I figure it's getting to the point where there are too many genuine English locales to keep up. It takes a lot of energy for normal people to retain fluency in dialects and locales like en_US, en_IN, en_CA (thankfully rapidly merging with en_US), en_GB, en_AU, en_JM, en_MY, etc. etc. etc.. all at the same time. Maybe at some point there will be a great and natural convergence.
- photojosh 9y ago> Why even talk about thousands of kilometres when you can speak in tens of megametres? Probably because when you're speaking about them colloquially, you don't say "kilometres" you say "kays". That probably varies by locale too, I'm in en_AU. How is it over your way? I do like the nerdiness in the idea of saying "two megs" instead of "two thousand kays", but it's never going to happen.
- Coincoin 9y ago>I do like the nerdiness in the idea of saying "two megs" instead of "two thousand kays" But they are not the same!!oneoneone. Unless you are in the dog food prefixes camp. Are you?
- photojosh 9y ago2 000 km = 2 Mm? You're not thinking of the mebi-, kibi-, etc debacle, are you?
- Coincoin 9y agoYes. I'm old school, 1K is 1024, 1M is 1024K, 64K is 65536 and I refuse to use kimblebits and such. Ah... screw it: https://www.xkcd.com/394/ https://www.xkcd.com/394/
- photojosh 9y agoI'm with you, but it's a non-issue when it comes to non-computer units, which is what we're discussing here.
- microcolonel 9y agoDecimal prefixes are standard prefixes for SI units.
- sergers 9y agoWestern Canada, we use a short form pronunciation similar "Kay" too (pronounced like just saying the letter "K"). "K" is short form thousands as well written and pronunciated "k". Ex: 20,000 = 20k. But when talking about distance specifying units, you say the thousands and "k" as in short form kilometers. 20,000km is pronounced: "twenty thousand k" or kilometers. But if not specifying the unit, you could say I drove twenty "k", as in "I drove 20 thousand (kilometers)"
- Coincoin 9y agoI'm always surprised that en_CA and fr_CA are so different. We use spaces as separator and comma for the decimal. Also we use the 24h format while the ROC uses 12h. We do use 12h colloquially though. Dates are officially y-M-d but most people use d/M/y. It's funny how in Canada we have some specific remnants of the imperial system. Most people under 50 have no idea what a Fahrenheit is (myself included), except for pool water and oven temperature. Go figure.
- microcolonel 9y agoDates are a complete mess, yeah. I've seen absolutely every single convention used in Canadian government and business documents. I personally use ISO 8601 wherever it's an option (contracts, personal documents, casual communications) because of how ridiculous all of the other options are.
- jacobush 9y agoAgree about 8601 except that not ALL other options are silly. Writing the day with words is kind of nice in some writing, like "September 1 (Monday), 2017" is not too bad.
- microcolonel 9y agoThe funny thing about the imperial remnants is that for almost all general tasks, Canadians still use pounds for weight (groceries, body mass, vehicle weight), but we don't use ounces. We use feet and inches to measure people, but metres for almost everything else, except nautical speed. Litres for gas in cars, sometimes gallons or pounds instead of litres for gas on boats. Pints for blood and beer, ounces for hard liquor, litres for all other service and retail fluids. People complain about inconsistency and lack of standards in the use of measurements in the U.S, but it is actually much more consistent there. It turns out that decimal units aren't really better for any practical purpose in a typical person's life, and it's certainly worse if you need to know both! Even in the U.S. of course, engineers, mechanics, plumbers and others still have to deal with a mix. Think metric-based and imperial-based bolts, metric v. imperial lumber sizing.
- sergers 9y agoBorn in canada, West coast, lived here still for 30+ years. English as first language, but 2nd/3rd language for immigrant parents. I have very rarely seen space separator for thousand seperate, maybe one some bank drafts. Everyone I know, and I have used the comma seperate. Officially may be a Canadian thing, but not used really
- user5994461 9y agoIt's not just about the thousands separator, the same character is used to separate the decimal part. It's better to use no punctuation at all if you want to internationalize.
- KGIII 9y agoWhen the period is used to separate thousands, the comma is used to separate decimals. Usually... https://docs.oracle.com/cd/E19455-01/806-0169/overview-9/index.html https://docs.oracle.com/cd/E19455-01/806-0169/overview-9/ind...
- microcolonel 9y agoOf course, that page is completely wrong about the large number convention in Canada. Anglo Canada (including government documents) uses the U.S. convention, and at very least uses period for the radix point. The shown convention only applies to Franco Canada, and maybe not even all of Franco Canada.
- KGIII 9y agoI see both in Quebec, so it isn't universal - even there. Meh, it's close enough to demonstrate. I prefer the US method, but that's just due to familiarity.
- kbenson 9y agoActually, if you want to internationalize for the thousands separator, spaces are likely pretty safe as they are preferred by numerous standards bodies, as well as AMA.[1] That also neatly sidesteps any comma/period confusion for the decimal in large enough numbers, since whichever you see, if there's space grouping thousands, it's that one. 1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Decimal_mark#Digit_grouping https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Decimal_mark#Digit_grouping
- wongarsu 9y ago>but there's not really any standardization of this as far as I know There is. Resolution 10 of the 22nd General Conference on Weight and Measures [1] (the body responsible for the SI system) forbids the use of comma ordot as thousands separator. Other institutions like NIST have followed suit, forbidding or at least recommending against it. The recommended approach is to use spaces as thousand separators (or ideally: thin, non-breaking spaces). You are still seeing a lot of people do it wrong because the resolution is from 2003, and these things take decades to overcome entrenched preferences. 1: http://www.bipm.org/utils/en/pdf/Resol22CGPM-EN.pdf http://www.bipm.org/utils/en/pdf/Resol22CGPM-EN.pdf
- stephengillie 9y ago[Comments cannot be deleted once a reply has been made.]
- photojosh 9y agoI'm curious at to when that example would ever be suitable; memory sizes should be grouped in 3s as well. The only one I can think of is phone numbers, e.g. Australia is a 4-3-3 grouping for mobiles. But a space has been the standard delimiter there anyway.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- bigiain 9y agoDashes were "the standard delimiter" for a long time for Australian phone numbers. 451-4153 was my phone number growing up (and yeah, I'm showing my age with a seven digit phone number... A friend of mine was on 99-0066 up until the early or mid '90...)
- photojosh 9y agoFair enough. I grew up overseas, so my local knowledge only kicks in in '99.