12 ms·
SanDisk crams 400GB into a microSD card
- ChuckMcM 9y agoOne of the things I was thinking about building was a write once logging system. Even at the high levels of logging that I run on various servers it is only 10s of megabytes per day which this kind of thing could absorb for years. And as a write once system it would never erase (not even have the capability of erasing) allowing for 'walking backwards' in the logs in the event of intrusion or malicious behavior. It would certainly be an interesting mail archive system as well.
- jakobdabo 9y agoFrom 200GB to 400GB in two years, so Moore's law is still rocking. Now I can place all my music files inside my player!
- pmoriarty 9y agoI wonder how their reliability is compared to a traditional spinning platter drive, for the typical workload of a desktop. It would be nice if I could ditch the bulky spinning hard drive (or even SSD drive) and use a microSDXC card. I've tried that before, and while it did work, they quickly (within maybe a month or two) wore out and got errors on them. I can usually get at least 3 or 4 years out of a traditional spinning platter drive.
- Rjevski 9y agoOne of the issues is that the protocol used by an SD card isn't as efficient nor battle-tested as SATA. It might not be much of a problem with relatively low capacities in the handfuls of GBs but could cause problems as you go beyond that.
- frou_dh 9y agoThe M.2 form factor gets you most of the way there. They're significantly smaller than normal HDD/SSD, and can cope with being used hard, unlike mickey mouse SD card stuff.
- pmoriarty 9y agoFor anyone else wondering what the M.2 format actually is and what compatibility issues there are with it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=opwON-7J_wI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=opwON-7J_wI
- sundvor 9y agoI was going to say something about reliability. As impressive as this feat is, and it really boggles the mind, I've had a large number of SanDisk MSDs fail on me before I switched to Samsung. I'm not very likely to switch back.
- unkown-unknowns 9y agoConversely the only Samsung microSD card I ever had failed on me. I've also had some trouble with SanDisk cards from time to time. My general experience is that microSD cards are okay but I'm not at all happy about them. I'm doing a project soon involving a Raspberry Pi. I've used rpi for various things before but the different thins time is that it's going to be installed at the location of a client. I am quite nervous that the microSD card will fail. For my own stuff I can easily write the image to a new card and it doesn't matter. But with a client where they expect the thing I'm making to work it would be painful to have it fail. Is there some ready-made Linux distro for Raspberry Pi that is extremely small in size and which is made to load it whole self into memory and not write back to the SD card at all? It'd be extremely helpful to know about it if any such distro exists. Preferably it should be based on Rasbian just slimmed down and with logging etc removed. That way the kernel itself would be more reliable so that it won't crash randomly for reasons that have otherwise been fixed in Raspbian but which might not be in an independently maintained kernel.
- voltagex_ 9y agoI don't know what your requirements are, but look at making the rootfs read-only if possible. This is how a lot of consumer devices running Linux work. https://hallard.me/raspberry-pi-read-only/ https://hallard.me/raspberry-pi-read-only/
- keenerd 9y agoIf you want reliability, don't get a Pi. Look at the selection of Odroids and use one of their emmc modules.
- carc1n0gen 9y agoNot raspbian based, but tinycore[1] has a raspberry pi boot, the whole O's is loaded in to ram at boot [1]http://distro.ibiblio.org/tinycorelinux/ports.html http://distro.ibiblio.org/tinycorelinux/ports.html
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- leggomylibro 9y agoFlash memory is usually rated to what, order of 100,000 write cycles? But it has much better endurance on reads. If they aren't used as something like a pagefile, they can usually last awhile. But I guess it depends on the use case, and I'm assuming this will be similar to what exists now.
- imtringued 9y agoMaybe if you have an expensive high end enterprise SLC SSD. Consumers use the cheapest SSDs available and that's usually TLC with 5000 or less write cycles and soon we will be on QLC which will only have up to 1000 cycles. The more bits a cell stores and the smaller the manufacturing process the lower the amount of write cycles. 2D NAND hit a scaling brickwall and the only way to scale NAND is now to stack layers on top of each other. Obviously SD cards are even worse than SSDs when it comes to reliability.
- userbinator 9y ago5K~10K was MLC 8 years ago[1], and there's evidence that some cheaper/smaller-geometry flash didn't even make it that far[2] Now, it's more like ~1K for (good) TLC and closer to 100 for QLC. There are no official numbers I can find on TLC/QLC endurance or retention (besides a lot of handwavy and weasel-worded marketing saying it's "good enough"), but the degradation is exponential with the number of bits, not multiplicative, so one can make an educated guess. [1] http://www.farnell.com/datasheets/1382714.pdf http://www.farnell.com/datasheets/1382714.pdf note date, and see page 3. [2] http://pdf.dzsc.com/88888/2008422102742719.pdf http://pdf.dzsc.com/88888/2008422102742719.pdf also note date, and look at 3rd item in the revision history
- wtallis 9y agoToshiba says their upcoming 3D QLC NAND will be good for about 1k P/E cycles. But like most recent P/E ratings, that's almost certainly given under the assumption that you're using LDPC error correction or something equally robust, so you can't compare directly to the ratings for older SLC NAND.
- 9y ago
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Koshkin 9y agoThis modern uSD tech is astonishing, beyond any science fiction. I no longer pay attention to the transistor sizes or the CPU clock rates, but the advances in the data storage technology look amazing to me.
- mansilladev 9y agoSame here. Clearly, it's the work of the devil.
- hs86 9y agoIf we put the economic part aside, what kind of storage density could we reach with these in a 4U case? I mean something like a custom build Backblaze Storage Pod [1] but for microSD cards. [1] https://www.backuppods.com/ https://www.backuppods.com/
- agumonkey 9y agohmm... an array of µsd in RAID
- samstave 9y agoWe should call it a Beowolf
- hinkley 9y agoFound the old guy
- samstave 9y agoActually imagining a machine with an array of micro SD slots inside filled with a bunch of these (mini version of the bblaze pod mentioned above, but in your laptop -- that would be really interesting. A small SSD for the main OS - then a ton of space RAIDed on these.
- reaperducer 9y agoThis was a common thing in the early days of OSX and Macs that had lots of USB ports. People would gather up all their miscellaneous flash storage devices (CF, USB, MS, etc...) and mount them all at once. OSX had a function in Disk Utility that would take all those pieces of disparate memory and turn them into a single logical disk. It was a nice way to make use of leftover old tech instead of throwing it in the garbage.
- jandrese 9y agoPower and cooling requirements would likely prevent you from achieving absolutely insane density I think. Plus, you would go broke trying to fill the thing with $250 cards. You could use smaller cards, but then you have the nightmare of trying to find a stable supplier that doesn't have a ton of fakes in their supply chain. Even then, your competition is 10TB HDDs, and you need 25 cards + card readers + cooling to match one drive. Performance is better, but probably not enough to justify the expense.
- samstave 9y agodo you have any idea how many microSD cards I have lost in my life... I am less worried about reliability and more about "oh crap I lost another one" - but with 400GB - thats the risk of losing a lot of data.
- jandrese 9y agoIMHO, the most likely use case outside of people who shoot a lot of RAW photos is for people building appliances out of stuff like Raspberry Pis that needs a lot of storage. Things like MAME cabinets, DVRs, security systems, and the like. The $250 price point on these is obviously a barrier for now, but it should come down reasonably quickly if history is any guide.
- bhauer 9y agoAs with previous capacities, another use case is to have your entire music library available in your phone. I use one of the previous 200 GB uSD cards with my whole music library. It's nice to have everything available everywhere I go. Now even those with >200 but <400 GB of music are able to do the same.
- rsync 9y ago"another use case is to have your entire music library available in your phone." Unfortunately, almost all phones continue to support microSD cards "up to 32 GB". Some will (reportedly) work with 64 GB cards, but if I understand correctly, others need hacks/tweaks to access >32 GB cards ...
- errantblaze 9y agoI didn't realize this was an issue. Does this include flagship phones or is it mostly lower- and mid-range? From experience, the Galaxy S7 supports at least 128GB (a quick search returns a 256GB max). S6 didn't support microSD, S5 supports 128GB, S4 supports 64GB, S3 supports 64GB.
- SAI_Peregrinus 9y agosdxc has been in the spec since 2010. Anything that supports over 32GB (sdxc) can support up to 2TB with no hardware changes. I still have an S4 and use a 128GB card, but I've got a custom ROM. Most of the "up to" values for support are simply the biggest card that was available when the device was released, not the biggest the device can read. That's almost always going to be 2TB, the maximum that exFAT can support.
- cmurf 9y agoOn reliability, I've got a much smaller 32GB Samsung EVO microSDXC in an adapter in an Intel NUC formatted Btrfs being used as rootfs for Fedora Server, for 6 months with zero errors of any kind including regular scrubbing. I think the latest iterations of these cards (at least brand name anyway) are a lot more reliable than SD cards of yore. Those were meant pretty much strictly as a FAT32/exFAT camera card that you only write to, read off all files from, then reformat to reuse; and were not really meant as a random access device, organizing files, deleting individual files, modifying them, like what an OS would do. I do highly recommend running f3 tests on whatever you buy, f3write followed by f3read, to check for fake flash. There's a lot of fake flash out there.
- nickcw 9y agoIf you like testing your media then you'll probably enjoy: https://github.com/ncw/stressdisk https://github.com/ncw/stressdisk my project to test media. I test all my flash / hard disks with it and have sent plenty back over the years which failed!
- lisper 9y agoMy first day working at Google back in 2000 they had just inked an exclusive deal with a hard drive manufacturer for their brand new high-capacity 40 GB drives. They had a 4U rack stuffed full of 25 of them, and everyone was standing around oohing and ahing and saying, "Wow, that's a TERABYTE!" Now the same storage is the size of a thimble.
- 52-6F-62 9y agoAre there archived photos from those days? I think that would be interesting to see
- dopeboy 9y agoIf you get a chance to go to the Google visitor office in Mountain View, they have old racks on display.
- schoen 9y agoSee also http://infolab.stanford.edu/pub/voy/museum/pictures/display/0-4-Google.htm http://infolab.stanford.edu/pub/voy/museum/pictures/display/... which apparently has been moved out of the basement of Gates Hall but is still on display elsewhere at Stanford. http://infolab.stanford.edu/pub/voy/museum/pictures/display/Huang-Google.htm http://infolab.stanford.edu/pub/voy/museum/pictures/display/... (Note that this is from 1996, so it's apparently 40 GB rather than 1 TB.)
- 9y ago
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- th-ai 9y agoIF 'SanDisk made a 4 GB microSD card on July 2006, at first costing $99 (USD)' [1] and in 2017 'SanDisk crams 400GB into a microSD card' (costing $250 USD) THEN In 2028, maybe a 40TB microSD might cost $300? (@10 years of mp4?) And by 2040, 4 PB petabytes? (@1000 years of mp4?) Who's gonna have time to watch all that? So much local client memory is coming. With less network dependency in more local storage, will our apps process memories faster? [1] https://simple.wikipedia.org/wiki/MicroSD#History https://simple.wikipedia.org/wiki/MicroSD#History
- wingworks 9y agoBut as time goes one video etc gets larger, e.g. 1080p to 4K, to 6K to 8K etc. Usually, the extra space we get is used up soon.
- eat_veggies 9y agoThis might be another "64kB of memory should be enough for anybody" prediction, but will we ever need to go past 8K resolutions? Even 4K is crazy high resolution and anything higher feels unnecessary and pointless if our eyes can't see smaller.
- wingworks 9y agoI can see 8K res coming to 27" computer screens, I've got an iMac 5K 27" and there is room for improvement with the pixel density when it comes to video/photo editing. But yeah I don't see it going much higher for displays, maybe for large cinemas. But I'm sure there will be other video/photo technologies coming up that will use large amounts of data. People just haven't invited it yet due to storage constraints.
- droopyEyelids 9y agoThere are probably infinite dimensions that can be added to a visually recorded piece of media. What if it had an 8k camera recording in every cardinal direction as well as facing upwards and below for a 'VR' like experience? What if it had 16 of those to page between different perspectives in that scene?
- patrickfl 9y agoThis is getting crazy! One thing I love about the microSD market is it (pretty much) eliminates the need to upgrade your iphone to the 128/256/512 version and pay $xxx extra when you can just keep one of these puppies, and even take it with you to your next upgrade, or swap to Android etc.
- ezequiel-garzon 9y agoI'm lost, as I thought iPhones didn't have SD slots.
- hanklazard 9y agoMaybe a dumb question, but how are you using microSD with your iPhone?
- kevin_thibedeau 9y agoThere are cases with an integrated lightning -> SD adapter.
- tinus_hn 9y agoYou can only use the storage with the app that came with the adapter.
- userbinator 9y agoThis is almost certainly going to be 3 or 4 bits per cell flash, which has exponentially worse retention and endurance than 1 (SLC) or 2 (MLC) bits per cell for only a multiplicative increase in density[1], and requires even more (fragile) algorithms for error correction/avoidance/longevity. I wouldn't be surprised if this "400GB" was actually 512GB (2^39 bytes, or "512 real gigabytes"[2]) of raw capacity, with 112GB of spare area. OK for short-term "transfer" storage, like the camera applications alluded to in the article, but definitely not for long-term archival or maybe even medium-term. Perhaps there should be a separate category for devices like this: "pseudononvolatile".[3] To parallel an old saying: "big, fast, reliable - pick two." [1] The terms "triple-level cell(TLC)/quad-level cell(QLC)" are entirely misleading, since they imply only a multiplicative increase in the actual number of distinct voltage levels in each cell. One wonders if they are deliberately downplaying the associated reliability issues by making it seem multiplicative instead of exponential. These should really be called triple-bit/quad-bit or eight-level/sixteen-level cells. [2] Remember when flash disks had real binary capacities? I have a 64MB USB drive that really contains 131,072 user-accessible 512-byte sectors --- and it's still working, because it's SLC flash. [3] I've worked with NAND flash over the years and noticed something interesting: you can very easily find datasheets for SLC and MLC (2-bit) flash, which give the endurance/retention. But there is very little on TLC (3-bit) flash --- they're almost all NDA'd leaks, which a few years ago were already rare, but seem to have mostly disappeared now --- and basically nothing on QLC/4-bit. Why the secrecy? It makes one wonder if there's something inconvenient about this high-density flash, that they don't want people to know...
- georgespencer 9y ago> To parallel an old saying: "big, fast, reliable - pick two." Small, surely? Edit: I'm dumb. Big storage. Duhhh!
- alister 9y agoBy "big", I assume he means biggest storage, not smallest form factor. By the way, unless there is some technology I don't know about, microSD cards have consistently been the highest density storage devices for many years running.
- kazinator 9y ago> That means it can hold up to 40 hours of full HD video, in case you were wondering. Easily 100 to 200 hours of 1080p material, if we go with a bit rate in the range of 2 to 4 gigabytes per hour.
- _acme 9y agoAs opposed to the microSD card with the most capacity, what is the microSD with the best reliability for use with, e.g., a Raspberry Pi?
- Scene_Cast2 9y agoAnother aspect is the random read & write speed. Typical microSD cards are abysmally slow at those.
- StavrosK 9y agoThe Lexar high endurance. If you want to find SD card reliability info, check websites and videos that do reviews for dashcam SD cards. Their primary focus is on reliability because they need the cards to be able to be written on constantly without failing for a long time.
- adrr 9y agoI run Lexar high endurance in my dashcam had issues with other cards but with the Lexar cards. Its different technology(MLC) so it doesn't have the capacity as other cards but gains in durability. If i remember it stores 2 bits per cell instead of 3.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jballanc 9y agoThis raises the inevitable question: what's the bandwidth of a 747 full of these cards?