8 ms·
This is how I feel about boxing vs MMA. Boxing gloves are huge and massively padded, meaning you take hit after hit after hit, bouncing your brain around like
by komali2 9y ago
This is how I feel about boxing vs MMA.
Boxing gloves are huge and massively padded, meaning you take hit after hit after hit, bouncing your brain around like a ball. MMA gloves are only padded enough to maybe prevent you from breaking your knuckles, and maybe prevent your knuckles from breaking someone's jaw. If you threw the kind of punches people throw in boxing with MMA gloves on, you'd wreck your hands.
That one is safer than the other has been discussed before:
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/mixed-martial-arts-safer-than-boxing-study_us_563ce23be4b0411d3070c8d6 http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/mixed-martial-arts-safer...
https://www.nytimes.com/2015/11/20/science/which-is-more-dangerous-mma-or-boxing.html?mcubz=1 https://www.nytimes.com/2015/11/20/science/which-is-more-dan...
- jklinger410 9y agoEvery knockout is a concussion, and likely brain damage. It may be relatively safer than Boxing but you can't keep striking and knockouts and think it's too much better.
- kasey_junk 9y agoThe issue with those studies is that they don't really account for more modern views about brain injuries. We know that boxers suffer "serious" head trauma more frequently but lots of modern research suggests small repeated head trauma is as dangerous. Incidents of cte for instance in soccer maybe accounted for by heading drills. Which is why talks about concussions isn't enough. I'd still expect MMA to be safer in this regard than boxing but there is enough head banging events in things like gaurd practice that don't occur during normal boxing practice that I wouldn't be shocked to learn MMA has as serious a problem with CTE as boxing.
- scott_s 9y ago> If you threw the kind of punches people throw in boxing with MMA gloves on, you'd wreck your hands. MMA fighters often wreck their hands during fights. They are in no way pulling their punches; they throw as hard as they can, just as boxers do. I find it plausible that MMA fights tend to end with less concussions and serious head trauma than boxing. But I doubt it's significantly safer. That ignores training, where fighters spend much more time, and still receive many, many sub-concussive hits. I have trained BJJ for over 13 years. During that time, I have also trained MMA. I have helped training partners for MMA matches. I have cornered training partners for MMA matches. I follow professional MMA. But I am finding myself more and more unable to justify even paying attention to it because of the evidence that even repeated sub-concussive hits cause brain damage.
- agumonkey 9y agoWell the irony is that boxing gloves were introduced because hands are so fragile compared to skull that fights would be too short. It wasn't a noble reason.
- baldfat 9y agoI boxed a little and worked out and hit a heavy bag for years. I never would punch someone because I'm not that kind of man and secondly I would more then likely break my hand.
- agumonkey 9y agoIf I was a trained boxer I'd be way more worried about killing someone accidentally, with or without a broken hand.
- girvo 9y agoIn Australia, trained fighters who get into fights at bars for whatever reason have been charged with "weapons" charges, as their body is considered one (as opposed to the untrained person they're fighting)
- agumonkey 9y agoIn France I think it's similar. Martial Arts, boxing .. if you pass a certain level you're liable in case of serious injuries.
- protomyth 9y agoJoe Rogan feels that MMA would be safer if the participants did not wear gloves https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u-SY0F6Kkg0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u-SY0F6Kkg0
- athenot 9y agoOf course, that's for classic boxing. I train muay thai and you're also liable to get a shin/knee/ankle/elbow from your opponent, and there's zero padding there. However, as someone else commented, there are some crucial differences with football: - there's no injury unless it's an actual fight. Sparring is intentionally toned down, because the sport is not about the power but agility and speed. Those can be practiced with minimal danger (of course there are always exceptions and accidents); - there's the benefit of transparency. Hits may be heavier but are fewer and much farther apart than the repeated hits in football which may go unnoticed.
- stevenwoo 9y agoI could be mistaken but I thought a few concussions was enough to cause brain damage, once you get to three there's a marked increase in permanent, measureable damage in most people, if one is under 25, it doesn't take as much.
- jaggederest 9y agoAny concussion is by definition a brain injury. Any brain injury is, by definition, damage to the brain. And we know that brain damage has an uncertain prognosis - it may or may not ever heal in any meaningful way, and might even get worse over time. People handwaving around how much worse it gets under x or y circumstance just don't like the way the math adds up: brain injury is cumulative and progressive regardless of severity, age, repetition, or any other factor.
- scott_s 9y agoRepeated sub-concussive hits cause brain damage. That's the important point from all of the recent studies: it's not just the concussions, but all of the hits people take to the head. You're still at significant risk when sparring.
- baldfat 9y agoBoxers have much stronger punches and would break their hands. Boxers end their careers by punching someone without their gloves. It has happened many times in the past. MMA punch much lighter because it is a different style and skill set.
- philwelch 9y agoThere is no way that MMA is safer than boxing in terms of traumatic brain injury, aside from the ability to win a match by submission rather than knockout. After a boxing knockout (which almost always results in concussion), the boxers are immediately separated. After an MMA knockout, the winning fighter is invariably allowed to jump on the loser and continue pummeling him in the face a few times. This is, incidentally, the worst possible thing that can happen after a traumatic brain injury.
- scott_s 9y agoI don't think MMA is safer than boxing (as I explained in a sibling comment), but this aspect is interesting. Yes, MMA fighters often get subsequent hits. Which is bad. But, in boxing, when you get knocked down but not out, you get a standing count. Then you take more punishment. But if that was an MMA fight, there's a good chance the downed fighter would be pounced on, and the fight quickly ended. Both are bad, but it's hard to say which is worse.