8 ms·
Does disabling Wi-Fi prevent my Android phone from sending Wi-Fi frames? [pdf]
- lucb1e 9y ago[pdf] TL;DR: when wifi is off, and the setting whose description reads "allow scanning when wifi is off" is turned off (not all softwares have this toggle available in the WiFi settings, it seems default-on) then it doesn't seem to send frames.
- massel 9y agoTL;DR (from TFA): No. We show that another option, called "Always allow scanning", when activated, makes a device send Wi-Fi frames which can be used to track this device, even if the Wi-Fi switch is off. This option is not clearly described in all Android versions, and sometimes even not deactivatable. Besides, the Google Maps application prompts the user to activate this option.
- ringaroundthetx 9y agoTL;DR: No. Just from the rule of journalism about asking a question in the title.
- tinus_hn 9y agoSleazy. Then again, par for the course for modern Google.
- guelo 9y agoThis is pretty simple and I don't think it's nefarious. Android WiFi is used for two purposes, networking and location. The main WiFi switch toggles the networking function and the main location switch toggles its location fuction as well as other location providers such as GPS and cellular location. If you want the main WiFi toggle to also affect its location function then that's what the "Always allow scanning" setting is for.
- carapace 9y agoI downvoted you for trivializing (or missing) the problem.
- infogulch 9y agoI disagree, gp's is a perfectly valid level headed response. It has been known for quite some time that WiFi is used to make the location service more accurate. Think of it from the typical user's perspective: what would they think if disabling wifi suddenly made maps very innacurate? That sounds like the start of a bug report to me. Everything doesn't have to be some big nefarious plan. Sometimes the sensible defaults for normal users don't align with privacy-conscious users.
- carapace 9y agoSo "normal users" doesn't automatically mean "privacy-conscious users" to you? You also are missing (or trivializing) the problem.
- infogulch 9y agoSerious question: have you met many normal internet users? At risk of being too blunt, "normal" people don't give a shit about privacy. I'm not talking about people that hang out here, or on some irc channel, or pretty much any other tech website. I'm talking about the hundreds of millions of people whose primary internet activities are facebook, google searches, media consumption, and online email, in that order. These people are "normal", by number. Only some of these people are aware of privacy enough to set their facebook profile off of public, and 99% of them never look into any privacy settings past that. If you're privacy-conscious enough to worry about this, you probably don't even have a facebook profile (or at least don't have it installed on your phone), and that by itself puts you squarely outside of normal. Most people don't care. I'm sorry.
- bhhaskin 9y agoThere really needs to be an alternative open source mobile OS. I had really hoped that would be Ubuntu touch, but now that development is moved over to ubports I am not sure wide spread support is going to happen.
- Freak_NL 9y agoI would go even further and say we need a free software mobile OS.
- RankingMember 9y agoAs long as it has a good UI. My experience has been that OSS can be functional, but often comes with a bad UI that turns off users.
- digi_owl 9y agoThe problem is that there is a mismatch of priorities between the device manufactures (and in certain places, carriers) and us consumers.
- gcb0 9y agoit is a bad incentive loop. - people change phones every year or two. - OSS community can't keep up with driver support if they change every 6mo and are never documented, protected with NDA. - big companies writing the OS make the older hardware obsolete on purpose. - this forces people that don't want to change phones every year to do so. Back to step 1.
- voltagex_ 9y ago>- OSS community can't keep up with driver support if they change every 6mo and are never documented, protected with NDA. LineageOS seems to be doing OK (other than the terrible name). > - big companies writing the OS make the older hardware obsolete on purpose. Not writing the OS, writing the drivers and platform support (also known as the Board Support Package). I can't find the article, but at some point there was a "cut-off" for devices like the Nexus 4, largely because Qualcomm didn't provide further updates.
- tuddman 9y agoTo disable that deceptive snooping in 6.0 (Marshmallow): Settings -> Location -> Improve Accuracy -> Toggle Wi-Fi scanning.
- jayess 9y agoAny idea how to do this in 7?
- gcb0 9y agogoogle surreptitiously moved it to the ellipsis menu. on android 7 and 7.1: settings > location > three vertical dots on the top right > scanning. And on this screen disable wifi and bluetooth scanning. And, you would think that would disable wifi/bt scanning, right? wrong! on the previous screen (settings>location), you also have to click on "mode". And then select "Device only". If you select "high accuracy" or "battery saving", it will ignore the wifi off on the ellipsis menu and still use it! And there is more! ...still on the location screens, scroll down. Past the "recent location requests" and see a section called "Location services". It might very well include a "Qualcomm izat accelerated location". What it does? well, nobody knows! does it enable wifi from sleep mode on the chip? it might. it might not. again, who knows?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- dingo_bat 9y agoSame steps.
- matt_wulfeck 9y agoYes but now every app you open is going to pester you about enabling wifi, including google maps, which will ask you every time you open it.
- lucb1e 9y agoI've never seen that, but then I'm running an ancient version of Cyanogenmod (based on Android 4.4.4) that might not be obnoxious yet in this regard.
- shocks 9y agoTitle needs a pdf tag.
- matt_wulfeck 9y agoYet another reason for privacy-conscious individuals to switch to iOS and a newer iPhone. I hate the walled-gardens as much as the next person, but Apple's stance on privacy and security is unparalleled in today's ecosystem.
- Forbo 9y agoAny indication this is still the behavior in Android 7.0 and beyond? What about in Pixel phones? The one first-party Google device used in the study was a Nexus S running 4.4.
- SadWebDeveloper 9y ago>= 7.0 improved on these and its not longer aggressively looking for beacons, it uses a passive approach.
- YouKnowBetter 9y agoDon't be so sure your $CURRENT iPhone does not do that. I am watching a screen right now where I see the probes from iPhones fly by (# tshark -i wlan0 subtype probereq). Seems less then other devices but still they're there.
- michaelt 9y agoOne of my frustrations with Android is the fact Google Maps constantly bugs me to enable "Google's Location Service". Even if I've asked for something as simple as centering the map on my GPS location. I must have answered 'no' to that prompt a hundred times by now. My phone has GPS, which is privacy-preserving and more accurate when outdoors - which is any time I'm navigating, as I don't need maps indoors. So "Google's Location Service" is useless to me. I don't understand why Google has made it so difficult to avoid sharing my location "anonymously" with them.
- stephenr 9y agoBecause everything they do is funded by selling ads that target people based on a heap of different factors, one of which is location. Honestly I wonder how anyone in tech doesnt know why google offers "free" services and pushes people towards their own non-private "solutions"
- hollander 9y agoYeah but they have my location by GPS, and still they need the Wifi-location service as well. Why?!?!?
- losteric 9y agoThey don't need it, but they'll keep asking in hopes that you'll click "yes" (by accident?)
- SCHiM 9y agoAfter which the option disappears deep inside some obscure setting, is conserved across multiple major updates, and synced across devices on all platforms. ;)
- wlesieutre 9y agoI used to be on Android and I eventually clicked yes out of annoyance.
- stephengillie 9y agoAndroid phones respond to ping when in airplane mode. I have a speech bot that pings my phone (find IP by ARP) and it speaks randomly on successful ping. Sometimes, at night, I put my phone in airplane mode, and sometimes my bot still speaks.
- a_t48 9y agoAt least in iOS-land, you can be in airplane mode and still have wifi.
- briankelly 9y agoSame with Android.
- tajen 9y agoWifi isn't forbidden on planes?
- Johnny555 9y agoAirlines are pushing people to use Wifi on planes by installing Wifi based entertainment systems that display content on user devices (the airlines like it because they save weight and money by not needing seat-back displays). Cellular transmissions are still technically prohibited, but I bet many people don't know how to turn on Wifi while in "airplane mode", so they don't use airplane mode. Here's one such system: https://www.united.com/web/en-US/content/travel/inflight/entertainment/personal-device-entertainment.aspx https://www.united.com/web/en-US/content/travel/inflight/ent...
- kogepathic 9y ago> Cellular transmissions are still technically prohibited In the US. Internationally they are permitted and several airlines offer GSM service in flight. [0] [0] http://www.telegraph.co.uk/travel/news/Which-airlines-allow-in-flight-mobile-use/ http://www.telegraph.co.uk/travel/news/Which-airlines-allow-...
- SadWebDeveloper 9y agoIf you are concerned about this "privacy issue" you should try Smarter Wi-Fi Manager from Kismet Wireless: https://www.kismetwireless.net/android-swm/ https://www.kismetwireless.net/android-swm/ But in newer versions of Android (afaicr > 7.0) is no longer using an aggressive approach (visible to other devices), it just passively collect frames (https://plus.google.com/+mikekershaw/posts/DmpQ2no5bEk https://plus.google.com/+mikekershaw/posts/DmpQ2no5bEk) so it's no longer an a privacy issue to have this option on those versions, still would recommend SWM to increase security.
- ljcn 9y agoInteresting, but requires location to be on, which is also a battery drain and privacy issue. (I have location on only when needed.) I wonder which is better - WiFi always on and location off, or location on and WiFi sometimes off?
- SadWebDeveloper 9y agoafaik SWM doesn't require location (gps) it uses your cellphone towers as the mechanism to find out if you are near those towers were you usually have wifi. But speaking on your questions... Location On, Wifi Off offers better security IMHO, specially in the case your phone gets stolen/lost you may at least use that information find it or at least report to the authorities it's location the trade-off is that google/nsa et al will always know your location but unless you are Snowden or paranoid, you probably wont mind. Also in the latest version (at least on the Beta afaik) you can activate Wifi Scanning, which uses the passive/aggresive mechanism mentioned on the article to find out if you are near the AP and turn on your wifi.
- edwhitesell 9y agoMy Android 7 phone still sends WiFi probes anytime I wake the screen. Even though the power saving features are disabled such that it remains connected while the screen is off. There's a lot Android could do better in this area.
- 9y ago
- mirimir 9y agoPeople concerned about such matters use devices with cellular and WiFi radio nuked. With separate devices for cellular and WiFi radio. Connected using shielded wires. Edit: OK, people greatly concerned do that. I don't even use the damn things. But I know what it takes to secure them. Edit: I note that none of my VM hosts have integrated cellular and WiFi radios. And I seriously doubt that devices used in high-security commercial, government and military roles have such things. Maybe not even integrated Ethernet. Also, devices with modular cellular and WiFi radios could be produced in the consumer sector. Maybe they'd cost more, and only sell in niche markets, but it's doable.
- jitix 9y agoA bit tangential but here's another reason to disable wifi: even if you don't join a wifi network your phone can be tracked via the packets that it sends out to find wifi networks. That can be used is triangulate people's location within closed spaces like department stores. Source: I work at a company where we sell this tech to department stores and such. We are still not allowed to join that data with our shadow profiles of the users but that might happen in the future. I've become extremely privacy oriented ever since I started working here and saw how creepily companies track users.
- trendia 9y agoDoes this data really provide a monetary benefit to companies?
- losteric 9y agoOf course. eg it can be used to measure how people are influenced by a clothing display, what brands/seasons they're looking for, the effectiveness of different "Sale!" signs, which products are dead inventory wasting floorspace, etc On the other hand, personally I would immediately stop shopping at stores that spied on customers like that.
- jitix 9y agoThe devices are quite inconspicuous and the company has other competitors doing similar things so I stopped having my wifi and Bluetooth on except I know I want to use them. But there's tech being developed that can use cell signals as well but as I understand it's more difficult to read those packets.
- killnine 9y agoF Droid wifi police
- nxc18 9y agoPSA: Google stores your precise location, tied to your account, for every moment of every day. In about 1.5 years of using android regularly I generated 700,000 data points. I understand Google maps on iOS participates in this. Go to takeout.Google.com to see what's in your personal dossier.
- teddyfrozevelt 9y agoYou can also go to maps.google.com/timeline for a better visual.
- pjc50 9y agoFortunately you can skip this one by never signing in to Google maps, although you then lose the benefits of history. Just checked and my location timeline is blank after several years of this.
- pbhjpbhj 9y ago>my location timeline is blank // The one they show you is, at least. /cynic
- breakingcups 9y agoYou can opt-out of this data collection in your Google account.
- type0 9y agoYeah, opt-out from being visible to you, at least that is the feeling for many users and I guess it all depends on how cynical or optimistic you are about Google.
- stephengillie 9y agoGoogle has started asking me to confirm if I really were at the location they detected, sometimes days or a week later. "Were you at Magnussen Park from 6pm to 8pm last Thursday?" It's as though Google is conducting a criminal investigation and I am a suspect.
- stephenboyd 9y agoYelp just paid 20 million dollars for Turnstyle Solutions, which specializes in tracking retail customers with the WiFi signals sent by smartphones, without asking for the phone customer's consent. If you want to opt out, you have to go out of your way to register your device's mac address with them. https://www.wsj.com/articles/what-secrets-your-phone-is-sharing-about-you-1389663783 https://www.wsj.com/articles/what-secrets-your-phone-is-shar... https://techcrunch.com/2017/04/04/yelp-acquires-wi-fi-marketing-company-turnstyle-analytics-for-20-million/ https://techcrunch.com/2017/04/04/yelp-acquires-wi-fi-market...
- abakker 9y agoregistering with the company you want to avoid sure seems like a great way to guarantee privacy. /s
- agumonkey 9y agoThis whole era of data gathering boggles my mind, what kind of fluff do they extract ? and how valuable is it really ? I think it was S. Yegge that said we turned the smartest brains into like-button developpers. :sigh!
- sixothree 9y ago> and how valuable is it really ? at least 20 million dollars
- otto_ortega 9y agoDoes any body knows how to run a passive scan for networks in range from an app, even if the Wi-Fi is OFF? I know this is possible for sure, the app "Wifi Analyzer" does it. As you can see on: https://snag.gy/cfYTmy.jpg https://snag.gy/cfYTmy.jpg The only network related permission this app requests is "Wi-Fi connection information" so I'm wondering how they do it, and if it is possible to do so from a background service. I will like to run scans periodically and show up a notification once a predefined network is in-range.
- r1ch 9y agoThis relates to the setting mentioned in the article, "always allow scanning".
- r1ch 9y agoSomewhat related is positioning your WiFi AP based on passive signal strength monitoring. Both Apple and Google do this to maintain their own private WiFi positioning databases, but there are also public databases with this information too. http://find-wifi.mylnikov.org/ http://find-wifi.mylnikov.org/ is a great example of this - I was very surprised to find a brand new AP I'd installed less than six months ago already in the DB! I wonder how they track it - I certainly don't expect many people to be running their tracking apps. Perhaps there is some reporting SDK that gets bundled with certain free apps? The author of the above page has a WiFi positioning demo app for iPhone and Android that uses those public databases - during my testing it was almost as accurate as GPS (even more so indoors) with instant results.
- Mister_Snuggles 9y agoIf I had to guess, Apple and Google use the GPS on the phones plus the WiFi information to feed back into those databases. It makes sense for them to do this as it helps improve the accuracy of their location services.
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoPresumably they also wardrive (war-fly with directional antennae??) when they're making maps/streetview?
- kej 9y agoNo presumably about it, there was some minor outrage that they were capturing traffic when it first happened: http://www.pcworld.com/article/198667/google_wifi_data_capture_unethical_but_not_illegal.html http://www.pcworld.com/article/198667/google_wifi_data_captu...
- wooptoo 9y agoIt's called wardriving, and there's a huge db available for free at wigle.net
- mirekrusin 9y agoInteresting that simple UI on/off switch requires a scientific paper as proper documentation.
- eighthnate 9y agoThe honest answer is unless you physically disable your wifi antenna, you can't really be sure. The same thing with your laptop web camera or anything physical on your desktop/laptop/smartphone/etc. If you want to be sure that your laptop camera isn't recording you, you have to put electric tape over it, if you want to make sure your mics on your devices aren't recording you then you have to physically block it. http://www.telegraph.co.uk/technology/2016/09/15/put-tape-over-your-webcam-fbi-director-warns/ http://www.telegraph.co.uk/technology/2016/09/15/put-tape-ov... This is a very complicated issue of reliability of kernel/compilers/hardware/etc. We are dependent on these layers telling us what "reality" is. But how reliable is it? And interesting look into "trust". http://wiki.c2.com/?TheKenThompsonHack http://wiki.c2.com/?TheKenThompsonHack
- tony-allan 9y agoThis also occurs on Apple iPhones... http://www.idownloadblog.com/2016/01/21/iphone-ipad-location-services/ http://www.idownloadblog.com/2016/01/21/iphone-ipad-location... http://www.moutfitters.com/blog/iphone-privacy-settings/ http://www.moutfitters.com/blog/iphone-privacy-settings/