6 ms·
There is nothing wrong with states competing with each other. If one state has poor schools then companies won't want to be there because they won't be able to
by AnthonyMouse 9y ago
There is nothing wrong with states competing with each other.
If one state has poor schools then companies won't want to be there because they won't be able to find competent employees. If one state has no government healthcare subsidies then employees there will demand higher wages so they can pay for healthcare.
The states that have better schools and more subsidies will have correspondingly higher taxes. The only way that creates a disadvantage is if the tax money is being spent inefficiently, so that the benefits don't outweigh the costs. Or, on the other side, the state is giving more to a company in benefits than the company pays in taxes and the company becomes a parasite.
But that is not a race to the bottom because ineffective programs and corporate parasites are bad. Pressure to eliminate them is good and the state that best eliminates them wins, as it should be.
- BLanen 9y agoWillfully naive. You presume that all companies choose the locations that will benefit them in the long-term.
- benlorenzetti 9y agoThis seems like a good presumption, at least for a large capital operations like factories and data centers.
- inb4dangshitban 9y agoI hope you do realise that in eastern EU factories get built, work for a few years, get packed up when the wages/unions rise and moved somewhere else? Almost everything in a factory/datacenter is modular, documented building blocks with super detailed assembly documentation. The buildings themselves are often steel framework and panels that get thrown up in ~months No one puts a price on lost expertise and cost of lower quality such moves incur. All they care for is 0.5% lower wages cost
- Larrikin 9y agoA large corporation like Apple getting a tax cut allows Apple to pay the relocation costs of engineers and other employees. Those sames engineers are putting off children to later or not having them at all. A group that also switches jobs frequently. So long as Apple has some trendy locations people will be happy to work there and the schools won't even be a consideration for most.
- TheAdamAndChe 9y ago> Those sames engineers are putting off children to later or not having them at all. A group that also switches jobs frequently. Do we really want to structure our society like this? Do we want to require so much instability for the workers that they can't even start families? I don't. I'm getting really tired of large multinational corporations blatantly controlling our government, our quality of life, and now trying to control our very culture.
- devdas 9y agoJob switching doesn't have much to do with starting families. Well educated people tend to get together with other well educated, career minded people, and children get deferred.
- TheAdamAndChe 9y agoAre you saying you don't think frequent job hopping & moving doesn't strongly affect the choice to deffer starting a family?
- Aaargh20318 9y ago> they can't even start families? You say that like it's a bad thing. Humanity is a plague, we breed uncontrolled and our population keeps growing and growing. There is no need for anyone to start a family, there is no shortage of humans.
- altstar 9y ago
- abalone 9y ago> Pressure to eliminate them is good and the state that best eliminates them wins This is nonsense. By this logic, corporate pressure to eliminate environmental regulations is "good" because they are "ineffective programs". You assume, wrongly, that the benefits of public investment realize themselves within a timeframe that matters to the bottom lines of individual corporations. In reality, markets reward short-term orientation and externalizing costs. Traditionally it has been up to the public sector to take the long-term view. This is true especially in our industry. The majority of very-long-term-oriented investment in high technology that has no immediate ROI prospects comes not from VCs, but rather the U.S. government through agencies like DARPA. Corporate tax avoidance has nothing to do with seeing DARPA as an "ineffective program".
- benlorenzetti 9y agoGrandparent post didn't say anything about timeframe of civic government and even mentioned things like schooling that have a long time frame. Also assertion about DARPA supports a small logical induction, in that the U.S., which spends taxpayer money on DARPA, competes well with other nations.
- AnthonyMouse 9y ago> By this logic, corporate pressure to eliminate environmental regulations is "good" because they are "ineffective programs". Environmental regulations prevent a harm. A dollar value can be attached to the harm, the cost to compensate victims and clean up the damage. If a company is polluting but not providing enough value to compensate for that pollution then they're a parasite and the state does not benefit from avoiding environmental regulations in order to attract them. In practice not polluting is almost always more cost effective than polluting and then cleaning it up afterwards, so states that have environmental regulations will out compete states that allow pollution and then have taxes high enough to recover the cost of pollution from local companies. If that wasn't the case then it wouldn't actually be a problem. Suppose someone invented a way of converting CO2 + H2O + sunlight into hydrocarbons that was so efficient it put all the oil companies out of business. Now everyone is still emitting carbon, and increasing carbon would still cause climate change, but recovering the carbon using that process would be more cost effective than alternatives that don't emit carbon to begin with. Which would make doing that a completely reasonable thing to do. The problem case is when the state is externalizing its costs, e.g. West Virginia burns coal and the pollution spreads to many other states. Those are the cases where national regulations (or international treaties) are necessary. Not because the state is allowing a company to externalize costs, since it has no incentive to do that if the state is the one paying the full cost of that. But instead because the state itself is externalizing costs and that requires some external force to prevent it, equivalent to the need for the state to prevent the company.
- paganel 9y ago> The states that have better schools and more subsidies will have correspondingly higher taxes. The reality contradicts you. The Netherlands and Ireland have some of the best schools in Europe and at the same time they're some of the best tax-heavens for big corporations. Too early in the morning for me to search out for any reasons for why this is the case, I've just presented what the facts currently are.
- MarchHare 9y agoIreland may be where many corporations are registered but is not necessarily where the employees are located. Similar to how many companies are registered in Delaware.
- paganel 9y agoThere are lots of employees over there, at least in IT. I work as a programmer in Eastern Europe and half of the offers I received for working abroad came from companies physically located in Ireland, meaning I would have had to relocate to Ireland had I accepted any of said offers.
- tallanvor 9y agoThe Netherlands and Ireland are also much smaller (geographically speaking) and don't have to have as many small schools as you'll find in the US. Most likely they also don't have to worry about providing school buses for most of their students. European countries also set and collect income taxes centrally, not at a state/county/province/whatever level, and they distribute the funds more fairly so that poorer regions aren't left behind the way they tend to be in the US.
- paganel 9y ago> Most likely they also don't have to worry about providing school buses for most of their students I agree with that, but a company that does business in Romania (my country) but instead pays all of its related taxes in Ireland (as Google does) is causing my country not to provide school buses and the like (that and endemic corruption, but that's another issue). I was regarding the EU as a bigger political-economic union, more like the United States, I'm pretty sure that inside both of Ireland and Netherlands both of their governments are interested in re-distributing the taxes they collect from business-activities carried out all over Europe.