12 ms·
Companies are supposed to pay taxes so we can have schools, healthcare, basic income etc. When they bid countries or states against each other to get tax breaks
by fulafel 9y ago
Companies are supposed to pay taxes so we can have schools, healthcare, basic income etc. When they bid countries or states against each other to get tax breaks and governments play the game, citizens lose.
Yes, it happens in other cases too, and citizens should also protest against those other cases.
- EpicEng 9y agoBut often they chose to build in a location specifically because of the deals you're talking about. This is big money; citizens lose most (in terms of tax dollars) if apple stays out entirely.
- mikeash 9y agoApple will build it somewhere. The states would be better off banding together and pledging to put a stop to this nonsense.
- quadrangle 9y agoPrecisely. It's a race-to-the-bottom.
- aninhumer 9y agoSure, but that's exactly the argument this article is attempting to refute. It says that tax incentives don't actually factor into company's decisions that much, nor do they correlate well with economic performance.
- fulafel 9y agoIt's a prisoner's dilemma type of situation. The best strategy for all states is to cooperate, making a deal like this is the "defect" option in the prisoner's dilemma. Playing for a single win at the expense of others in one round of the game is near sighted.
- mrgoldenbrown 9y agoThe article specifically rebuts that argument.
- KKKKkkkk1 9y agoA corporation is purely a legal notion. In real life, when you shake down a corporation so that "we" can have nice stuff, you are shaking down that corporation's shareholders, employees, and customers. These folks already paid their fair share of income and sales taxes. And they can also be referred to using a first-person pronoun.
- _delirium 9y agoIn this case, it wouldn't really be in Apple's interest to say we should treat them as just individual people who happen to work together. They're only getting a custom property-tax abatement deal because they're a large and important corporation that's treated differently than regular people are. If a bunch of separate individuals had bought parts of this land and each ran small-scale businesses on it, they'd be paying regular property-tax rates, and no state legislator would be rushing to grant them a special carve-out.
- sangnoir 9y ago> These folks already paid their fair share of income and sales taxes That would only matter had they chosen not to incorporate, once they do (or buy into it), then they should accept the rules, warts and all. As you said, a corporation is a purely legal notion with upsides (limited liability) and downsides (pay the bloody taxes, c'mon)
- acjohnson55 9y agoThere are other forms of business if the taxation issues of being a corporation are undesirable. Most big firms are corporations though because the benefits are worth those costs.
- TheAdamAndChe 9y agoThis implies that large corporations act like normal people, which really isn't the case. The shareholders of publicly traded companies expect exponential growth, and if the managers and owners don't provide that growth, the board of directors kicks them out and replaces them with someone who will drive that growth, regardless of the effect on the workers. When corporations naturally behave sociopathically, it's only natural to treat them differently from normal people. Edit: To those downvoting me, could you please explain why? If I'm interpreting something incorrectly, I would like to know.
- AnthonyMouse 9y agoThere is nothing wrong with states competing with each other. If one state has poor schools then companies won't want to be there because they won't be able to find competent employees. If one state has no government healthcare subsidies then employees there will demand higher wages so they can pay for healthcare. The states that have better schools and more subsidies will have correspondingly higher taxes. The only way that creates a disadvantage is if the tax money is being spent inefficiently, so that the benefits don't outweigh the costs. Or, on the other side, the state is giving more to a company in benefits than the company pays in taxes and the company becomes a parasite. But that is not a race to the bottom because ineffective programs and corporate parasites are bad. Pressure to eliminate them is good and the state that best eliminates them wins, as it should be.
- BLanen 9y agoWillfully naive. You presume that all companies choose the locations that will benefit them in the long-term.
- benlorenzetti 9y agoThis seems like a good presumption, at least for a large capital operations like factories and data centers.
- inb4dangshitban 9y agoI hope you do realise that in eastern EU factories get built, work for a few years, get packed up when the wages/unions rise and moved somewhere else? Almost everything in a factory/datacenter is modular, documented building blocks with super detailed assembly documentation. The buildings themselves are often steel framework and panels that get thrown up in ~months No one puts a price on lost expertise and cost of lower quality such moves incur. All they care for is 0.5% lower wages cost
- Larrikin 9y agoA large corporation like Apple getting a tax cut allows Apple to pay the relocation costs of engineers and other employees. Those sames engineers are putting off children to later or not having them at all. A group that also switches jobs frequently. So long as Apple has some trendy locations people will be happy to work there and the schools won't even be a consideration for most.
- lend000 9y ago> When they bid countries or states against each other I have nothing to say specific to this case, but there is a market for governments (very distorted since options are very practically limited for most people, although corporations have an advantage here), and we should encourage competition in this market, as well as political markets. Competition results in better products. Washington already won me over [partially] due to not having a state income tax and yet having infrastructure comparable to my previous high-tax state, although Seattle is working hard to change that. I think the US being a federation of states that compete at some level (since it's relatively easy to move between states) is a large reason that the country has been so successful.
- honestoHeminway 9y agoCompetition between governments results in you as product beeing sold for cheap, without rights and recursions against the company and your health beeing cast aside as obsticle. Even the american post-problem lawsuit culture will fail to hold internationals accountable, once the managed to get that part of law as negotiatable into arbitration courts. How somebody can willingly sew on the branch he sits upon- and declare that reasonable- can you expalin this to me?
- Kluny 9y agoIt's discouraged to mention people's spelling/grammar on HN, provided the intended meaning is clear, but in this case the mistakes are obscuring your meaning in a way that's likely to bring downvotes. I'm guessing that you are not a native English speaker, or possibly using someone else's phone, so please accept these notes as constructive encouragement. > recursions Probably meant "repercussions" > beeing being > obsticle obstacle > once the managed to get that part of law as negotiatable into arbitration courts. Not sure of intended meaning, but "the" is probably "they" > negotiatable negotiable > sew saw > expalin explain
- ethbro 9y agoAlso, the writer's name was Ernest Hemingway. He was from Illinois, despite his time in Spain.
- conanbatt 9y agoIts not a bid of countries and states, its a bid of governments. And who wants the government 'to win' ? Not the citizens..
- dpatru 9y ago> Companies are supposed to pay taxes so we can have schools, healthcare, basic income etc. This is just government-enabled theft. Politicians promise people "free" stuff that is extracted by threat of violence from someone else. Companies provide services that their customers choose to pay for. Profitable companies provide services efficiently so that everyone involved (customers, owners, employees) are better off. Their existence is a social good because profitable companies make everyone better off without coercion. They embody peaceful cooperation and civilization. They are not "supposed to pay taxes", except in the mind of politicians who seek to increase their own power and wealth by appealing to the envy and covetousness of their voters. If you want something, make it yourself or get it from others through peaceful cooperation. Do not take it by force from someone else, either personally or through a proxy (government). Edit: I realize that a world without coercion and violence is an ideal that will not be realized, but I think we should be trying to bring it about anyway. This means promoting peaceful exchange (free markets, private companies) and discouraging coercion and theft (government).
- specialist 9y ago"peaceful cooperation" Sounds nice. Are there any real world examples I can study?
- dpatru 9y agoReal world examples of peaceful cooperation are all around you unless you're in prison. Every time someone voluntarily purchases and another sells, that is peaceful cooperation. The alternative would be for one or the other to force the transaction, as happens with taxes, conscription, or robbery.
- specialist 9y agoBelated response. Okay. You have a nice, optimistic, aspirational worldview. I respect that. You and I probably even want the same thing. This article made me think of your reply: The Endless Rules of Burning Man If you love bureaucracy, Black Rock City is the alternative desert utopia for you. https://www.citylab.com/life/2017/08/the-many-rules-of-burning-man/538389/ https://www.citylab.com/life/2017/08/the-many-rules-of-burni... If this self-selected group of hippies can't be "live and let live", then what hope is there for the rest of us?
- alexanderstears 9y agoYou're right to identify tax revenues as the source of funding for local services but there's a strong case to be made for taxing people and not corporations. Corporations don't pay taxes, they simply pass the burden on to customers/employees/shareholders. It would be simpler (and arguably it would allow the market to allocation resources more efficiently) if corporations paid 0 tax and people paid taxes. Consider this: https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2010/10/why-we-should-eliminate-the-corporate-income-tax/65351/ https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2010/10/why-we-... And you're right to point out that companies bid jurisdictions against each other. But many bid winners wouldn't get the facility without a special accommodation. I'm sure Apple chose this town because of the benefits, and this town is better off for it. I'm also sure this town wouldn't have been selected if there weren't any 'wooing' process, so this town is strictly better off. If the town can serve its citizens with fewer tax revenue, then they're doing something right and hopefully they can expand and more people will choose to live there. This helps incentivize communities to operate more efficiently and that's a good thing. IMO the bigger problem is corporate free loaders. All the local walmarts use way more police time than the targets, but Walmart doesn't pay additional fees for the intensive use of police. The simple solution is a corporate tax but that isn't good because it doesn't incentivize more or less use of the police, ideally we'd charge them according to use which is different from a tax and more closely aligned with our preferences (e.g preference for less police work at walmart).
- little_data 9y ago>IMO the bigger problem is corporate free loaders. All the local walmarts use way more police time than the targets, but Walmart doesn't pay additional fees for the intensive use of police. I really have a problem with this statement. It's not like Walmart is trying to gobble up police services. Your statement reflects the Bloomberg article written about this topic, which IMO is a flawed view. The pains that Walmart faces are similar to many other retailers in non-affluent areas.
- alexanderstears 9y agoIf walmart had to pay for police services directly, they might continue with the status quo, or they might take extra steps - like hiring asset protection employees, limiting the hours of the store, making a policy to not pursue shoplifting under $5, etc. I'm not saying the current allocation of police time is right or wrong, I'm just saying that I think it'd be different if Walmart had skin in the game and I think we'd be closer to the right amount of police time at Walmart if Walmart had skin in the game.