12 ms·
These are property tax abatements. I don't see the big deal. Apple has to pay the property tax equal to the farmland for the next 20 years instead of the much
by colechristensen 9y ago
These are property tax abatements. I don't see the big deal. Apple has to pay the property tax equal to the farmland for the next 20 years instead of the much higher tax on the datacenter property. Who cares? Unless someone is arguing the datacenter is going to use a lot of tax funded city services (police? fire? ... ?), Waukee isn't giving Apple anything. On top of that Apple is pledging to give them $100M for various things. Seems more like instead of paying property taxes, Apple is donating money to the city which will probably get it an income tax deduction. It's a scam I don't really care about.
If you do care about it, maybe you should be complaining much more about all of the corporations that are "Delaware" corporations to avoid state taxes instead of being corporations where they're actually located.
- starfishjenga 9y agoIsn't the Delawarw thing for resolution of legal disputes? I don't think it affects taxes AFAIK.
- ISL 9y agoYep. Most states charge some sort of "foreign corporation tax" that picks up the lost revenue.
- jessriedel 9y agoMore specifically, Delaware has the largest body of settled corporate case law. Legal disputes between corporations incorporated in Delaware are much more predictable.
- kemiller 9y agoYou are right. Delaware corp taxes are pretty typical so they are not saving anything. It's all about the chancery courts which are very efficient.
- JumpCrisscross 9y agoIt sounds sensible for cities and states to consider extending farmland tax breaks to data centers. Both have low infrastructure footprints relative to their land area. Both provide people close by with potential benefits in the form of better service, e.g. fresher fruits and vegetables and faster pings, respectively.
- Clubber 9y agoYes, anyone can use that. If you buy a bunch of property, just plant trees and get the state / city to come out and verify that you are growing trees and your property taxes are 1/10th of what they were. Trees are probably the lowest maintenance crop you can grow, and the property might already have them. We had a family that owned a LOT of land in our city put a few cows on it to save money on property taxes.
- taurath 9y agoEnough trees to call it a farm is expensive as hell.
- Clubber 9y agoI guess it depends on the state. You can get 150 acres of pines planted for probably around $10K where I live. Regional universities will do it. I suspect it's cheaper in Iowa. Also, depending on the state, the entire property doesn't need to be planted, just a portion that probably varies state to state. Here's a Forbes article on it. https://www.forbes.com/sites/ashleaebeling/2012/06/06/farm-like-a-billionaire-harvest-tax-breaks https://www.forbes.com/sites/ashleaebeling/2012/06/06/farm-l...
- euyyn 9y agoThat might explain the cows in the large chunks of land in Fremont CA, near the Costco.
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> We had a family that owned a LOT of land in our city put a few cows on it to save money on property taxes. If you watch videos of early SpaceX engine tests, you'll catch confused cows running around in the background. Texas is good to its farmers. So SpaceX tested its engines on a "farm".
- vacri 9y ago> On top of that Apple is pledging to give them $100M for various things The article points out that the pledge contains the significant words "up to", and is actually only pledging $20M. So, for $20M, they get $20M off their taxes, plus a 20-year tax abatement worth $190M. Where can I, as an individual, sign up for such an awesome deal? I'll happily pay one year's income taxes to avoid the next 20.
- EpicEng 9y ago>Where can I, as an individual, sign up for such an awesome deal? Nowhere, because your tax dollars are a drop in the bucket. Don't pretend like you don't understand the difference between your few grand each year and Apple's tens of millions.
- edabobojr 9y agoDes Moines offers residential tax abatement on new construction and home improvements from renovation, a deal very similar to what Apple is receiving.
- martinald 9y agoThey will use an enormous amount of (renewable) electricity, and which Iowa has subsided significantly.
- colechristensen 9y agoI don't think anyone reasonable would argue with the state's portion of the tax abatement ($20M). 80% off property taxes in year one decreasing steadily to 0 through five years. That's just good economic development. The rest of the tax abatements are _local_ government property taxes. Given the large pledge of funding otherwise, who cares. This is not money that would go to subsidizing energy programs. It would go to doing whatever the local government does, like city maintenance and parts of the police, fire, schools, etc.
- didgeoridoo 9y agoWhat? Being a Delaware corporation doesn't let you avoid any state taxes. This is legally illiterate.
- colechristensen 9y agohttps://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2016/10/dont-blame-delaware/502904/ https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2016/10/dont-bl... >... it’s important to understand how the “Delaware loophole” works: A company sets up a subsidiary in Delaware, and transfers an intangible part of its business there—say, its trademark or naming rights. Then its other locations outside of Delaware pay money to the subsidiary in order to use that trademark. Since intangible assets are not taxed in Delaware, the company doesn’t have to pay taxes on the money that was transferred to the subsidiary. The company can deduct the cost of the royalties on its state returns in other states where it operates, and thus avoid a large share of the state income taxes it would have otherwise owed. It is the laws of states other than Delaware that allow this system to work.
- didgeoridoo 9y agoSetting up a sham subsidiary in Delaware and doing a tricky tax inversion is completely different from "incorporating in Delaware to avoid taxes." YC rightly recommends incorporating in Delaware because the state has a predictable structure of corporate law and courts that are expert in applying it. Implying that incorporation in Delaware is inherently some kind of tax dodge is bordering on slanderous.
- colechristensen 9y agoImplying that not taking advantage of every legal avenue to minimizing tax burden while incorporated in Delaware is exercising your fiduciary duty to your investors is willful ignorance.
- rxhernandez 9y agoMaybe there are other duties to other groups that are more important than your investors. I can't believe I even have to say that out loud. I can extend your fiduciary duty to uber easily insofar as them doing malicious things so long as the payoff was better than the legal costs. Hell I can extend this to certain evil pharmaceutical entities with little more additional effort. Your logic is either naive or you don't care about your fellow man. If it is the latter, I wish you your just deserts
- fulafel 9y agoCompanies are supposed to pay taxes so we can have schools, healthcare, basic income etc. When they bid countries or states against each other to get tax breaks and governments play the game, citizens lose. Yes, it happens in other cases too, and citizens should also protest against those other cases.
- EpicEng 9y agoBut often they chose to build in a location specifically because of the deals you're talking about. This is big money; citizens lose most (in terms of tax dollars) if apple stays out entirely.
- mikeash 9y agoApple will build it somewhere. The states would be better off banding together and pledging to put a stop to this nonsense.
- quadrangle 9y agoPrecisely. It's a race-to-the-bottom.
- aninhumer 9y agoSure, but that's exactly the argument this article is attempting to refute. It says that tax incentives don't actually factor into company's decisions that much, nor do they correlate well with economic performance.
- fulafel 9y agoIt's a prisoner's dilemma type of situation. The best strategy for all states is to cooperate, making a deal like this is the "defect" option in the prisoner's dilemma. Playing for a single win at the expense of others in one round of the game is near sighted.
- mrgoldenbrown 9y agoThe article specifically rebuts that argument.
- rtpg 9y agowhy is there a different tax for farmland and for datacenters? Because we want datacenters to pay more! I understand making some deals, but this is slightly much. You wouldn't make a deal like "Oh if you open a bank here we'll exempt you from capital requirements".
- colechristensen 9y agoProperty tax is based on the assessed value of the land and what's (permanently) on it. A lot with a house is assessed higher than one that's vacant. A parcel of farmland is assessed quite a lot lower than one with a hundred million dollar data center built on it. The tax abatement says Apple gets to pay the property tax for X years assessed at the value before they build anything.
- ebbv 9y ago> Who cares? The people in Iowa who have to subsidize this and don't have the billions sitting in the bank that Apple does? I can't believe anyone really seriously takes this side of this argument.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- PeterisP 9y agoIt's not really equivalent to subsidizing (which would imply some transfer of value from Iowa to Apple, or selling something below cost) but rather to a discount. Iowa was willing to provide their services at a hefty discount, so Apple chose to "buy" them from Iowa and not another state - but in any case Iowa gets money from Apple (just not the listed rate) and the citizens of Iowa are better off than they would have been if Apple wasn't placing that facility there and thus would pay zero taxes to Iowa.
- ebbv 9y agoAny discount given by the government is subsidizing, dude. That lost tax revenue that Apple gets to keep has to be made up for elsewhere. It's not like when they give Apple this "discount" it goes along with a reduction in spending elsewhere. They're effectively reducing their tax revenue without any offset in costs and the tax payers have to make up that difference.
- PeterisP 9y agoThe point is that without the discount there is no lost tax revenue that needs to be made up by a reduction in spending, because without the discount the facility gets built in another state and Iowa gets no taxes from it. Offering the discount gets an increase in total tax revenue for Iowa and its residents, since it allows it to get something instead of nothing. However, your argument certainly applies in a wider context - from the perspective of all states together it would make sense to not offer the discount and avoid the race to the bottom, but as they're not coordinated and each care about their own interests, then it makes sense for them to "defect" and offer such discounts to ensure that the facility gets built at their site.
- rectang 9y agoExempting wealthy corporations while individuals are squeezed ever tighter... eventually there will be pitchforks and torches.
- Gustomaximus 9y agoAnd maybe there will be autonomous crowd control drone.... And seriously. Going by history, people will suffer plenty before they are willing to become subversive for an economic cause.
- dsfyu404ed 9y ago>If you do care about it, maybe you should be complaining much more about all of the corporations that are "Delaware" corporations to avoid state taxes instead of being corporations where they're actually located. I fully support corporations and individuals who exercise their capacity to do business elsewhere to save money. While competition of this type promotes a race to the bottom it's the good kind of race to the bottom. Government is like an operating system in that it should do it's job as efficiently as possible. Every resource spent doing it's job is one that people society can't use to do what they want to do. If for example the state doesn't want people businesses registering their fleets out of state then they should make the cost of doing so in-state competitive with the cost + hassle of doing it out of state.
- victor106 9y ago"If you do care about it, maybe you should be complaining much more about all of the corporations that are "Delaware" corporations to avoid state taxes instead of being corporations where they're actually located." The corporate tax for Delaware is 8.7%. How can that benefit a company in not paying taxes? I am sure there are other benefits in incorporating in Delaware but does not seem like it has any tax benefits per se.
- cabalamat 9y ago> Apple has to pay the property tax equal to the farmland for the next 20 years instead of the much higher tax on the datacenter property. Who cares? Let's say I have a house or small business. Do I get a property tax abatement? If I don't, Apple shouldn't either. Big corporations should pay their fair share of taxes.
- zdkl 9y agoThe other side of this debate is that as a small business, if you find a municipality willing to deal with you in terms favourable to your business, you'd be a fool not to work with them.
- crb002 9y agoApple paid the City of Waukee a $100m bribe to influence their vote to abate $188m in property tax. The County/State were robbed in broad daylight. Imagine going to your city council, and pitching them a 50% bribe in return for a 71% abatement. You or I would be going to jail.