4 ms·
Under some interpretations of physics there is a finite number of objects in the universe, hence a largest possible cardinality of things that is finite. Even s
by pbhjpbhj 9y ago
Under some interpretations of physics there is a finite number of objects in the universe, hence a largest possible cardinality of things that is finite. Even sets like the number of possible states of the Universe appear to me to be finite, though so large as to be intractable to my imagination.
A conceptual circle and a real circle differ markedly because of the lumpiness of matter, quantisation, uncertainty. Every real circle is an approximation (yay Plato!).
Pi doesn't appear to me to be real, as in writ in matter/energy -- it's a ratio of measurements of an imaginary article, circles don't exist in our experiential 4-space.
Irrational numbers like root-of-2 just fall out of basic maths though, there's not going to be a real line with that measure just as there's no line with a predefined unit measure (ie unless you define that line at that point in time as your unit, but a real line isn't even straight).
I'd be really interested in refutation of this -- it's one of those positions I've held since Uni, at least, but never explored as I've never seen it challenged/supported nor named.
- revelation 9y agoWhat do you mean "refutation"? This is making you look as much of a crank as they are. There is no imaginary requirement to have a direct counterpart in the physical world, in "matter/energy". Infinity, axiom of choice, .. are all tools. We use them because their presence gives us other helpful results. None of it has anything to do with "lumpiness of matter", "matter/energy", "experiental 4-space", "real line".
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoPerhaps I am a "crank". Refutation as in "you overlooked this standard point that undermines your position", like maybe "polarised light describes a perfect circle", or "the gravitational field of a black-hole (when shaved) is a sphere". AFAIK there's nothing truly infinite, nor perfectly geometric, that we can experience in our physical spacetime -- I'd like to hear from those who can show me that's wrong. The world itself isn't axiomatic, if certain theories/systems that are unfalsified show parts of it are infinite/etc. -- despite that just being a model -- that's an interesting result.
- coldtea 9y ago>There is no imaginary requirement to have a direct counterpart in the physical world, in "matter/energy". No, but there's no requirement that the useful/only way to do math is with "platonic" / ideal math objects either.
- wolfi1 9y agosounds like you belong to the pythagoreans[0] [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pythagoreanism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pythagoreanism
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoI'm certainly sympathetic to some Platonic ideas.
- Houshalter 9y agoAs far as we know the universe isn't discrete like a cellular automata. So it's state contains infinite information for starters. I'm not sure what the current theories of physics say, but I don't believe the universe is finite in time or space either. And who knows what new discoveries physics might make in the future and what weird math it might require. There's no a priori reason to expect the universe to be modelled by finitist math. But even if we knew for sure it was, so what? Theorems about real numbers apply perfectly well to finite approximations. You don't gain anything by restricting yourself to finite math, and you lose quite a bit and make a lot of things much harder.
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoCurrent theories AFAIAA are that the universe is finite in all dimensions. If it had finite particles, with finite (quantised) states, with finitely many discernible locations, to be found at finitely many discernible times, then the states overall are finite. Time and space are effectively discretised, Planck scale and time. Even aside from that: for considerations of physical measure we always use something with an explicit size, a wavelength of light say, as our rod which limits our precision.
- gus_massa 9y agoThere may be finite real particles, but there are infinite virtual particles (and some times, the difference between a real and a virtual particle is not too clear). For example, a proton has three real quarks. But the mass of the three quarks is only the 1% of the mass of the proton https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quark#Mass https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quark#Mass the rest is crap, or in more technical terms https://physics.stackexchange.com/a/81284 https://physics.stackexchange.com/a/81284 . When you measure with more energy, you see more and more virtual particles, infinite virtual particles.
- sgregnt 9y agoBut if the energy is finite, soesnt it mean that you can only produce so much virtual particles?
- jpatte 9y agoYou seem to forget that maths and physics are meant to describe reality, not be reality. Any abstract concept (like numbers, forces, shapes, temperatures, energy levels, ...) we use to describe a real thing is different from that thing itself. If you think about it, even 2 isn't "more real" that Pi, because there are no 2 identical things in reality. When we say "a human hand has 5 fingers", we use the abstract concept of "finger" to make that description. It is abstract because each "finger" is actually unique. It's just a handy approximation we use (pun intended) for descriptive goals. Basic maths is not reality. Therefore no, irrational numbers do not "fall out of it". Edit: format
- brians 9y agoTwo is the number of electrons in He, and the number of slots in the lowest orbital. Two appears in nature. Circles appear in the shape of that same s orbital, though, so I don't see how to avoid pi.
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoThere's no such thing as an S-orbital, there a probability distribution where a bounded probability produces an approximate sphere, in any universe with more than two charges that sphere is going to be 'irregular'. The parent argument works here as much as for fingers though, those 2 electrons are identical but their spin differs. All electrons differ in the Standard Model by either spin or location.
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoSo you deny classification of similarity - fingers have structural similarities that allow them to form a class of object/item, this class and it's per-person sub-classes have a reality that to me is not entirely abstract. Even without classification we can create arbitrary groupings of physical objects, those groups have cardinalities. (Unless your materialism denies the existence of more than one thing/substance; philosophy is fun, eh.) I'm for pragmatism in such things however.
- coldtea 9y ago>You seem to forget that maths and physics are meant to describe reality, not be reality. So why describe reality with an ideal and infinities and not based on fixed/arbitrary precision but limited math?