5 ms·
Honestly I'd be more worried about nation states having access to the information held on Facebook and Google than I would private corporations.
by hnlmorg 9y ago
Honestly I'd be more worried about nation states having access to the information held on Facebook and Google than I would private corporations.
- mozumder 9y agoIt's a perfectly fine situation for nation-states to have access to such data, because nation-states already have access to everything inside Facebook and Google. In the US, you only need a warrant to access anything inside those companies.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- hna99 9y agoIndeed but at least with a warrant all access is documented on public record. Which has got to be better than already having access to all that data in private. Plus private companies can (and sometimes do) challenge a warrant.
- lucb1e 9y agoNobody said anything about a nation state (in this subthread). Just non-profit and tightly regulated.
- Asdfbla 9y agoThey can force Facebook etc. to hand over the data anyway, so it does not seem like much would change in terms of the threat posed by governments.
- hnlmorg 9y agoTrue, but I'd rather that process happen publically rather than in secret (as would be the default if the Facebook and Google were nationalised). Not that I'm implying there isn't already secret requests for data (if PRISM is to be believed) but at least with the aforementioned being privately owned there is some chance that unlawful / unjust requests for information can be challenged.
- majewsky 9y ago> I'd rather that process happen publically rather than in secret (as would be the default if the Facebook and Google were nationalised). You're making it appear as through National Security Letters were public, which they very much are not.
- hnlmorg 9y agoIt only appears I'm making that conclusion when you selectively quote small passages from my comment. The very next sentence that follows the portion you quoted starts off by saying: > "Not that I'm implying there isn't already secret requests for data" I appreciate that you consider it worth reiterating the point about national security since I had only glossed over it. But I don't appreciate you manipulating my comment to suggest that I was ignoring that point entirely when I quite clearly did raise it.
- 659087 9y agoI doubt any forcing is involved. These companies are willing participants in government surveillance.
- amelius 9y agoThat's why we need universities and government agencies to work on federated protocols, just like they did with email in the old days.
- hnlmorg 9y agoThe SMTP equivalent for Facebook and Google is HTTP which is a federated protocol. With email anyone can store the content on a centralised server in any format they want. Be that inside an open source RDBMS like MySQL or PostgreSQL, or a flat text file like Postfix defaults, or a proprietary format like Microsoft Exchange does. And the same is true for the services that Facebook and Google offer. The issue here isn't federated protocols (though that is something we could benefit from in other domains) but rather the dependance on a centralised archives in the cloud. Most people simply don't care or even aren't aware of self hosting solutions. And those that are aware often choose cloud solutions because it's cheaper and/or less hassle than self-hosting. Federated protocols doesn't fix this (just look at how hard it is to set up a mail server compared to running Google Mail). Plus in the case of Facebook you have network effects where a social network is only as good as the size of the member base.
- amelius 9y agoYes, I agree that content silos are a problem. But with IPFS, [1], (which is a federated protocol) you can "host" a HTML file or video or any content without any difficulty yourself. I'm not sure if it would be suitable for the functionality in Facebook though (sharing stuff with friends only), sending messages, so that's part of the reason why we need more research. The network effect of Facebook can be mitigated by introducing laws that open up competition, like the telecommunications acts, which opened up the market for telephony. [1] https://ipfs.io/ https://ipfs.io/
- hnlmorg 9y agoYou could host HTML files et al without any difficulty long before IPFS came along. There are plenty of easy to use web hosts out there aimed at the layman for more than 2 decades. I mean that literally as I have none-IT friends that had sites up on Geocities (and it's equivalent) back in the 90s. However as much as we could argue the differences between IPFS and the plethora of other hosted solutions all day and night, but ultimately it would be a moot argument because as cool as IPFS is - and I do think it's a genuinely interesting platform - it is still only a platform for serving static content. So it's definitely not suitable for Facebook-like functionality. In that regard IPFS is more akin to Amazon S3 than it is Facebook. > The network effect of Facebook can be mitigated by introducing laws that open up competition, like the telecommunications acts, which opened up the market for telephony. While I can't see that happening - or at least not inside my professional life time - it is an interesting point. We've seen monopolies split up before and while Facebook is a long way from being a monopoly it would be interesting to see which line they needed to cross before the government stepped in.