5 ms·
Don't live in a flood plane, leave early when there's even a small chance of getting hit. Or alternatively, legally require flood insurance in at risk areas an
by colechristensen 9y ago
Don't live in a flood plane, leave early when there's even a small chance of getting hit.
Or alternatively, legally require flood insurance in at risk areas and let actuaries price the risk, problem solved.
If the bad half of global warming predictions happen, this sort of thing is going to be common. If people don't have a motivation to mitigate the risk, everyone is going to have to pay for it collectively.
- taurath 9y agoThe people who live in flood planes tend to not be the people who can afford insurance.
- function_seven 9y agoTrue. If the requirement existed the areas were settled, then they wouldn’t be living there. BUT, that’s not the case. So enacting the requirement now, all at once, is probably not the right thing to do. Maybe phase it in? All new construction would require it. Existing residents would get it subsidized for a decade, etc?
- brewdad 9y agoI read that many residents were given subsidized or free flood coverage following Rita. That lasted 3 years and expired almost a decade ago. Few, if any of those policies are still being paid. Still leaves the question of whether we pay for this damage or leave people with nothing. Likely something in between the extremes.
- lostapathy 9y agoThis is pretty simple to solve, actually. Once a property is destroyed, pay out the claim as normal, but stop subsidizing insurance on that property. The people who couldn't afford market rate insurance still get paid for the house they lost, but they have to find a safer place to rebuild.
- Swizec 9y agoThat’s why you legally require it. Then people who can’t afford it can’t live there and move somewhere else. The expected cost also potentially brings down the price of realestate so people can afford insurance by paying less morgage. Really it comes down to acceptable societal risk. If floods are a 1 in 100 years black swan, do we bail them out and don’t require insurance? What if it’s every 20 years? Once in 5 years? At some point we can all agree that maybe it shouldn’t be treated as unexpected and precautions should be required. Just like we require everyone to have car insurance.
- rhizome 9y agoIf floods are a 1 in 100 years black swan, do we bail them out and don’t require insurance? I'm fine with that, but it all depends on what you mean by "bail them out," which feels a bit loaded.
- Swizec 9y agoI mean as in using taxes to pay for recovery instead of property insurance. It’s an important feature of society that we do that for rare catastrophic events. But I think there should be a line that’s somehow tied to the probability of said event happening.
- rhizome 9y ago100 years isn't rare? Yes, using taxes. Taxes aren't just for waging wars.
- thaumasiotes 9y ago100 years is frequent enough that -- if there's no variance in how long passes between occurrences -- it will pretty much always have happened within living memory and society will have an established way of handling it. But an event that happens once in 4-5 generations is still rare.
- 9y ago
- gizmo686 9y ago>leave early when there's even a small chance of getting hit. This doesn't solve the problems associated with large scale evacuations; unless your plan is based on the you leaving, while most of the population stays. >Or alternatively, legally require flood insurance in at risk areas and let actuaries price the risk, problem solved. Flood insurance could guard against the financial damage of a storm, but is useless to address the problems that evacuations are meant to address: human life. Unless your plan is for flood insurance to drive down the population in the region; which might work long term, but we still need to figure out how to handle the situation until then. >If the bad half of global warming predictions happen. This is the bad half of global warming predictions. The only question left is how bad the even worse half will be.'\ >If people don't have a motivation to mitigate the risk, everyone is going to have to pay for it collectively. Why wouldn't people have motivation to fix it? Aid is not going to be enough to compensate for all the damages (not event counting indirect economic damage). Everyone, from individuals, to municipalities, to the state, to the federal government, will come out of this in the red.
- moonka 9y ago>>leave early when there's even a small chance of getting hit. >This doesn't solve the problems associated with large scale evacuations; unless your plan is based on the you leaving, while most of the population stays. There's also the issue of having the means to be able to evacuate. Time off work (without pay for a large part of the population), alternative housing, food, travel expenses, for what may or may not end up being a big storm can be out of reach for many people.
- latch 9y ago> This doesn't solve the problems associated with large scale evacuations; unless your plan is based on the you leaving, while most of the population stays. You don't see how having millions of people evacuate over a period of 48 hours vs 6 makes the problem less severe?
- notatoad 9y ago>Flood insurance could guard against the financial damage of a storm, but is useless to address the problems that evacuations are meant to address It does if legally required - the point isn't to finance the evacuation, it's to make living in a flood plain financially unattractive. It's the "let the market decide" approach to disaster planning, by pricing in the cost of disaster instead of externalizing it to FEMA and the Red Cross.
- InclinedPlane 9y agoVery practical and actionable advice, especially for the working poor working paycheck to paycheck.
- tryingagainbro 9y agolegally require flood insurance in at risk areas and let actuaries price the risk, problem solved. No one will be able to afford it, so it will end up being subsidized by the Govt. Like requiring a 70 year old with cancer to get life insurance after years of treatments.
- arthens 9y ago> Don't live in a flood plane, leave early when there's even a small chance of getting hit. That's assuming that people can afford to leave. I read a quite interesting comment on reddit this morning: https://np.reddit.com/r/pics/comments/6wcpt0/la_vita_bella_nursing_home_in_dickinson_texas/dm87jfk/ https://np.reddit.com/r/pics/comments/6wcpt0/la_vita_bella_n...
- stevenwoo 9y agoThe problem is there is a federal insurance program and it keeps paying out to the same people repeatedly - I put this in another comment but it's 30% repeat payouts. https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2017/08/congress-flood-insurance/535731/ https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2017/08/congres...