12 ms·
“We do not put a premium on being good mariners,” Hoffman said. “We put a premium on being good inspection takers and admin weenies.” This is a problem acr
by Jtsummers 9y ago
“We do not put a premium on being good mariners,” Hoffman
said. “We put a premium on being good inspection takers
and admin weenies.”
This is a problem across the DoD, not just the Navy. I've seen it first hand in both military and civilian sides of the USAF. It's comparable to the degradation of the US public schools with extensive testing. The tests that start as attempts to evaluate and quantify effectiveness become the goals themselves, rather than measures of the true goals.
- mrexroad 9y agoGoodheart's Law [1]: "When a measure becomes a target, it ceases to be a good measure." [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goodhart%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goodhart%27s_law
- zentiggr 9y agoLet's popularize this amongst the ranks of management, senior administrators and every other supervisor.... and especially the groups that help create the tests and stats and 'merit' systems.
- ashark 9y agoI think it's a consequence of taking away individual judgement and becoming, it seems, terrified of letting a person make a decision, because sometimes they're bad at it, or have biases, or whatever. Organizations are afraid of individuals deciding things, and individuals are eager to push their decisions onto a "process" or "policy" because if they actually make a decision and anything goes wrong—whether or not the decision was a good one given the information they had—they're toast, fired if they're lucky, publicly demonized and blackballed and fined and jailed if they're not. The individual cost of a decision that is bad—even if it's only bad in hindsight—is too often way out of proportion to the harm it caused, so why risk it? I don't know why it's happening, but it sure explains a lot of things across much of US society. Politics, business, education, parenting. I wouldn't be surprised if it's part of what's behind the frightening US "cost disease" phenomenon from the Slate Star Codex post that was discussed here a few months back.
- stinkytaco 9y agoI'm only speculating, but I think social media has only exacerbated this problem. Now every screw-up an employee makes (or a teacher, or an administrator, or whatever) is magnified times ten to everyone on the aggrieved party's Facebook feed. Have a teacher that said something a parent took offense to? An employee who misplaced an item you had ordered? An employee can always fall back on the policy and push the blame to the institution and the institution can say "we'll review our policies". Funny thing is that as a bureaucrat, coming up with policies is my job. It tends to improve overall outcomes and satisfaction, but the same outliers described above are also magnified ten-fold (this policy is stupid because ...).
- ashark 9y agoMy best guess is that it's the result of 20-30 years of never accepting "shit happens, we looked and everything seems basically fine, we're not changing anything" as an answer when something bad happens and someone asks "so what are you doing to make sure this doesn't happen again?"—even when that answer's actually appropriate. The consequences are so bad if you make the do-nothing call and get it wrong (or are just unlucky) that everyone does a whole bunch of stuff to ensure they can say "look at all the things I did!" if lightning strikes twice (or if they were simply wrong and something did need to be done, but it wasn't clear until a pattern emerged) Instead we always freak out and add a bunch of new policies/guidelines, some more mandatory educational videos or classes, and maybe bring down the hammer on some people as well. [EDIT] in fact it may be yet another symptom of post-Nixon-era cynicism. We expect institutions to lie to us about everything (which, to be fair, they often do and often have), so we (rather, the media) dig into any problem expecting criminality and neglect and generally bad behavior (and a great story!), so institutions have to go nuts to make sure it never looks like there's anything there worth reporting as maybe-sort-of-kind-of any of those bad things.
- turbulents 9y agoThe FAA, NTSB, and airlines have made air travel incredibly safe over the years by operating the way you described.
- dak1 9y agoThis is so common one of Murphy's Laws of Combat Operations is: "No combat ready unit has passed inspection. No inspection ready unit has ever passed combat."
- arca_vorago 9y agoA favorite saying for USMC infantry, and much truer than people realize. There is a required balance though, and the best units have officers that know how to walk that tightrope, and listen to and respect their NCO's. A great example of this would be, much fewer uniform inspections, much more combat testing. Less formations 15 mins early by BN CO + 15 mins early for company CO, +15 mins for platoon, +15 mins for squad leader... It's the type of thing that really affects morale which will in turn affects effectiveness.
- KGIII 9y agoOff-topic: Let me get an Oorah. On-topic: I noticed the tendency towards formality when dealing with many, many municipalities. This is, in and of itself, inefficient in many areas. Example: A hole opened up in my schedule and I can fit your meeting in sooner. By the time I got a response, that hole was long since gone. Worse, I left that hole open in hopes that they'd respond sooner. They will say that you should have let them know, but you left a half-dozen messages with their secretary. Lesson learned: Get to know the secretarial staff. I'm not going to suggest you bribe them, but I understand if you do.
- arca_vorago 9y agoCompromise: You get an 'errr', cause I'm salty. Always makes friends with the doc, supply, and admin. Usually through booze and not being an ass.
- KGIII 9y agoMy default reply would get voted down, a lot. I don't care. My verbiage is intentional. We all salty, Marine. We all salty. It took me years before I could leave my rack without ensuring it was squared away. It took years before I could invite the missus to touch me while I slept. Eight years is what I served. Worse, it was in two pieces and separated by time at MIT. Yeah, I was a smart Marine. Don't laugh, I can drive a broom like it is nobodies business. Anyhow, I won't tell you I understand. I will tell you that I can relate. As for the karma, I ain't never scared. But, you're right. Always be nice to the folks who decide your life. Strangely, that's frequently not the person who projects power. However, I speak to the choir. Hopefully someone else will pick up on this. Otherwise, I ain't never scared. Karma was meant for burning.
- ThrustVectoring 9y agoYour culture is what you actually reward and punish, not the abstract ideals that you talk about.
- robotresearcher 9y agoThere's a great aphorism with similar meaning: People do what you inspect, not what you expect. edit: Wikiquote attributes to Louis V. Gerstner, Jr. (IBM) but earlier instances can be found (see comments below). Lovely bit of language.
- dctoedt 9y agoThat's an old nuclear-Navy saying from at least as early as the 1970s: You get what you INspect, not what you EXpect.
- robotresearcher 9y agoEarliest citation I could find is a management book from 1962: http://www.barrypopik.com/index.php/new_york_city/entry/you_can_expect_what_you_inspect_management_adage http://www.barrypopik.com/index.php/new_york_city/entry/you_...
- 33W 9y agoI believe in Dan Carlin's recent Hardcore History, The Destroyer of Worlds* he talks about the changes in military commands and micromanagement that have occurred with advances in telecommunications. He compared the discretion given to commanders in the American West vs. Civil War battlefields. The more realtime the communications, the more that higher commands interjected in lower level decisions. With advances in telecommunications, we shift decision-making up the chain of command, leaving subordinates to manage inspections and admin-weenieness. *I can't find a transcript to verify, and as much as I'd like to re-listen to the 6 hour episode, I just can't at the moment. It also could have a Harvard Business Review episode, after reading this: http://www.leadingageoregon.org/assets/docs/Other-resources/2016/4_%20leadership%20lessons%20from%20the%20battle%20of%20gettysburg.pdf http://www.leadingageoregon.org/assets/docs/Other-resources/...
- yhager 9y agoI don't remember this from the "Destroyer of worlds", but hey, 6 hours, it might have been there somewhere and I just missed it. BTW - it's not the recent one anymore, there's a new one. Yay!
- knz 9y agoThe new one ("Celtic Holocaust") is about the Roman conquest of the Celtic people. Definitely worth a listen if you're into history/Carlin podcasts. Personally I'm hoping for a "Common Sense" podcast by him sometime soon !
- 33W 9y agoI saw that when I looked for a transcript (a recent, not the recent I guess). I'm two months behind in my podcast feed, so I'll catch up to the next one eventually!
- arethuza 9y agoIn the Battle of France in WW2 some German commanders (pretty sure it was either Rommel or Guderian) would regularly have radio "problems" isolating them from their HQs when they found tactical opportunities they wanted to exploit.
- r00fus 9y agoWhat was that quote? If you measure success by testing, then you will get results that improve performance against the test at the detriment of all else? Sometimes (often) involving cheating where existential considerations for organizations or leadership is involved.
- guscost 9y ago"When a measure becomes a target, it ceases to be a good measure." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goodhart%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goodhart%27s_law
- smallnamespace 9y ago> The tests that start as attempts to evaluate and quantify effectiveness become the goals themselves, rather than measures of the true goals. I think you need a second factor to make flawed metrics a big problem: increased competition. More competition strongly incentivizes all actors in a complex system to favor optimizing over the currently-measured metrics rather than the true goal. You see this playing out across all parts of society today: academics that chase impact score rather than groundbreaking research, bankers that chase short-term profits to the detriment of actual sound banking, and now we have a Navy that can't do basic seamanship. I think we really need to recognize as a society that if the thing you care about is inherently hard to measure (e.g. science, the overall stability of the financial sector, the ability to fight the next war while still at peacetime), there are no shortcuts, you just need to suck it up and keep trying to measure the real thing rather than only relying on proxies. Throwing more and more effort at optimizing over bad metrics will only lead to long term disaster.
- Shivetya 9y agonot in military, but the joke among colleagues has been that we are very in following our processes, not so good in getting anything done. sadly this is excused because the process was followed and the auditors are happy
- stevenwoo 9y agoJuking the stats ala The Wire, gaming statistics about crime becomes the objective over good police policy or reporting good, valid data on crime. https://www.themarshallproject.org/2015/04/29/david-simon-on-baltimore-s-anguish https://www.themarshallproject.org/2015/04/29/david-simon-on... http://www.motherjones.com/crime-justice/2012/06/fbi-crime-stats-fudged-the-wire-nypd/ http://www.motherjones.com/crime-justice/2012/06/fbi-crime-s...
- dmh2000 9y agosounds like US Army in 1975.
- cgmg 9y agoIs the degradation of US public schools really due to extensive testing?
- tyingq 9y agoI believe the idea is that the entire curriculum is then centered around teaching the test, versus what kids actually need. As to whether that's the primary issue, no idea.
- cgmg 9y agoDo you really think eliminating standardised tests would improve the education system?
- wavefunction 9y agoSchool-funding and even whether a school closes or not is tied to these tests, so there would be some work involved in replacing that aspect of standardized testing in US schools as well.
- KGIII 9y agoThere's an excluded middle, in that statement. De-emphasizing the importance may be an option.
- cgmg 9y agoFair point. Let me rephrase the question: Do you really think reducing standardised tests would improve the education system? If so, what objective evidence can you provide for this belief?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- closeparen 9y agoIf you measure it less, you'll have a weaker argument for how the education system is doing! Your comment is precisely the problem: objective metrics will always support their proponents' arguments for more measurement, while any upsides to a lessened objective grading will be difficult to show because they'll involve subjective assessment or less assessment. Do not confuse the investigator's convenience in accessing a truth value for the truth value itself.
- brightball 9y agoGoodhart's Law, "When a measure becomes a target it ceases to be a good measure."
- trhway 9y ago>“We put a premium on being good inspection takers and admin weenies.” such a shift is natural and necessary in the context of the future warfare being completely robotic/autonomous. People role would be exactly inspection and admin. And as preview of the future - we've just had 2 people driven destroyers lose to the most probably autopiloted a cargo ship and a tanker.
- TheCondor 9y agoI've thought about not saying this, I intend no disrespect to anyone. Are there two militaries now? There is JSOC, with a budget, toys and gear, their pick of everything and they are a smallish, nimble ultra trained force designed to engage these terrorist groups and do special tactical missions, fighting dirty if needed. Then there is the greater navy and army and, respectfully, it is sort of a conservative voter friendly rural jobs program. I'm not saying this about the volunteers that sign up, but national policy. It only makes sense that they'd squeeze every dime from it like everything else. To top it off, there are the private contracting outfits that do stuff too, where does that fit in? The idea that they're supposed to learn on the job is insane, you don't get a lot of second chances on aflight deck, you don't get to make a lot of mistakes on a boat twice.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- closeparen 9y agoThere sort of are two militaries: - One we maintain to prove to our potential adversaries that we maintain it, in order to preserve stalemate. - One we maintain to actually use. I'm going to venture a guess that a well-functioning defensive military is inherently unstable, as anyone who understands how powerful it is will realize that it never actually has to function.
- someguydave 9y ago> well-functioning defensive military is inherently unstable This is why it makes sense to have a purely defensive military work on a reserve and draft basis. You don't really need the defensive military - until you do - in which case you want to magic a really big and reasonably competent one into existence quickly.
- gaius 9y agoIt is not as simple as that e.g. JSOC doesn't have its own ships, limited aviation, etc. It is totally reliant on the "regular" military to support its operations. And of course it gets most of its recruits from there too - AFAIK only the SEALs do direct entry for civilians.
- aaron695 9y ago> The tests that start as attempts to evaluate and quantify effectiveness become the goals themselves, rather than measures of the true goals. Is this a dank meme?
- kevin_thibedeau 9y agoA good admin weenie would have laid down the law and forced the ships in their fleet to step up operational awareness and training. Astonishingly whatever attempt was made to address the problem was useless.
- foxhedgehog 9y agoWhen I worked at DoD, it was explained to me with an analogy of monkeys and ladders. You have a ladder, and at the top is a bunch of bananas. You rope the ladder with electrical tape, so that any monkey who attempts to climb is shocked. Eventually, the monkeys will socialize and prevent each other from climbing the ladder. What's interesting is that this will continue even after you remove the electrical wire.
- jacalata 9y agoSounds like this mythical experiment - http://www.throwcase.com/2014/12/21/that-five-monkeys-and-a-banana-story-is-rubbish/ http://www.throwcase.com/2014/12/21/that-five-monkeys-and-a-...
- martindelemotte 9y agoPartially mythical, there were no bananas and if I remember well there were only two monkeys. [1] [1] https://www.scribd.com/doc/73492989/Stephenson-1966-Cultural-Acquisition-of-a-Specific-Learned-Response-Among-Rhesus-Monkeys https://www.scribd.com/doc/73492989/Stephenson-1966-Cultural...
- analog31 9y agoIn my view, hand-in-hand with measurement is the proliferation of stuff to measure. It occurs to me that at some point in the history of navigation, the skipper was probably the only literate person on the ship, if that. His log, if he kept one, was the only source of data. And you couldn't get his account until he got all the way back to port, assuming he survived. Today, the ship (or business) is a floating, real time data acquisition server. Folks all over the world are analyzing the performance of the ship from every conceivable angle. They are literally gathering and processing more data than the skipper herself can even comprehend.
- fsloth 9y agoI would claim the core problem is an environment than incentivizes people to care more for their careers than for the actual work they are doing. Sounds pretty much like Soviet Union, actually [0]. The chickens have come to roost, indeed. Managerial science driven process oriented organizations and what happened in the soviet countries share the same basic tenent: individuals don't matter. This is a cancer for performance and quality of life. The former should concern all economically minded people and the latter just everyone. It's not a lose-money, gain happiness proposition, it's a gain-money, gain happiness one. The problem is that local optimization (career, prestige) causes the global system to reach an unoptimal state. In computer science we say - greedy algorithms seldom lead to globally optimal solutions[1]. Of course, no one is stopping from developing key-performance indicators for a person being a good person - but this seems really arse-backwards way to approach the problem as being a good person is what most people would prefer to do naturally given a healthy environment to begin with. To slightly misquote Suzuki on his basic idea on how to maintain good character in a group: "Watch, but don't judge. But, do watch". [2]. Ie. make it understood everyone is responsible for their results but don't be an anal retentive accountant while you're at it. [0] http://militera.lib.ru/research/suvorov12/index.html http://militera.lib.ru/research/suvorov12/index.html This is a damn fascinating read. A bit like autobiographic Catch-22. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greedy_algorithm https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greedy_algorithm [2] https://www.amazon.com/Zen-Mind-Beginners-Informal-Meditation/ https://www.amazon.com/Zen-Mind-Beginners-Informal-Meditatio...
- ouid 9y agosounds like the tests are bad.
- m_fayer 9y agoI hate to be so grand but this seems to be a problem across many sectors of the entire western world. Over and over, in many different guises, I hear stories like this one. What characterizes them all is excessive faith in reductionist measurement-driven processes, and then the attendant army of humans-of-stock-photography consultants that inevitably lurks in the vicinity of such processes.
- rospaya 9y agoReminds me of something I read on HN the other day, I'm not sure if it's true but one commenter said he got a driver's license without ever actually demonstrating he can drive. If it's true then it's outrageous that this can happen in the US.
- qrbLPHiKpiux 9y agoEmphasis is put on didactics rather than common sense.