10 ms·
This VR cycle is dead
- bananicorn 9y agoI think VR might need something akin to the arcade halls of early video games to get people interested - a place where people can try the tech, but as a much more well-rounded experience, if someone went ahead and created something people actually wanted to try, but maybe couldn't afford, I think there'd be a market for this. Just not yet in the personal consumer market. Not yet.
- iterator5 9y agoWe've got a VR arcade in Ballard. It made me realize I definitely couldn't own one at home due to space limitations, but I like heading to the arcade every now and then. They have padded booths and booze.
- bananicorn 9y agoThat's pretty cool actually - I wonder how well the booze pairs with the VR though.
- aedron 9y agoI went to a VR arcade. It was the best setup for VR I can imagine: Big, spacious clean booths, great hardware, knowledgeable instructors (one per booth) to get you up and running and guide you through the different experiences. I feel like I got the best experience VR has to offer. It was fun for the 30 minutes I tried it, but after that I felt no compulsion to come back and do it again (nor, obviously, to get one for my home). I had my entire family in there, including three young boys, and despite having fun, neither of them have been particularly interested in VR since.
- gfodor 9y agoI mean, none of the existing devices for VR were ever expected to be massive consumer successes. The Android standalone HMDs coming out Q4 this year are going to be the first VR devices I'd personally consider as possibly being appealing to the mass market. My personal criteria for a device one could consider a referendum on VR if it fails in the market: - It needs to be at a price point akin to a tablet computer - It needs to be able to run for more than an hour without overheating - It needs full 6dof head tracking and ideally 6dof controller tracking with motion to photon latency comparable to vive/rift - It needs to be comfortable to wear for an hour for most people - It needs to deliver a graphical experience on par with something like a PS2 or PS3 - It needs to be portable and wireless so it can be passed around and shown off to others easily - Most importantly, it needs to be simple to set up and use. Ie, no external computer, no wires, no mounting of sensors on walls, no need to plug or unplug devices before/after use, etc.
- slimsag 9y agoPersonally I do not think "simple to set up and use" is the most important part there: it's the price. I would love to play around with VR, but I'm not going to shell out $600+ for such a device when I don't know how much software it'll have in the future. At the time of writing this comment, I found out that the Oculus is $400, which is quite a bit better (I thought it was $600-$900 still). But I still don't know what future game/app support looks like for it. My gut says it is in a downward trend, so I won't be buying into it until I see them being more popular among e.g. Youtubers etc.
- kalleboo 9y agoI might even be convinced to shell out $600 for it, but to me the price is actually $600 + a high-end gaming PC, since I like most people these days just have a laptop with mediocre graphics. PlayStation VR looks interesting from that point of view but I haven't really heard good things about it.
- dave7 9y agoPSVR is fantastic. It is not quite to the level of Rift and Vive in some areas (tracking accuracy, mostly). But it's still really good! I will add it is in my opinion superior in some areas too (comfort/design, optics).
- PeterisP 9y agoAgain, that is going to solve itself with no action needed from the VR industry - yesterday's high-end gaming PC is today's budget machine, so within a few years the basic PCs and consoles that everyone has will have the power to run decent VR headsets.
- BoorishBears 9y agoIt's pretty popular, and there are daily reports of new players in the industry approaching VR (Today it's Dave Jones of GTA fame) There's nothing to imply a downward trend, but everything to imply an upward one. At previous price points I could see cost being more of a factor, but at 400$ I'd say anyone not interested is probably not going to be (in PC headsets at least). They can't really get much cheaper than that (one of the Windows ones is 300$). And the next generation is 2 years out so it's not like there's a fear of getting outdated hardware. And to top that the sale at 400$ has driven the number of users up significantly so there's currently a fresh influx of new users to setttle in with. The only thing I see changing is the cost of a VR-ready PC going down, but only if resolutions don't increase at a pace that nullifies cheaper performance
- timavr 9y agoMaybe AI is dead too. It needs to get to the point where I have AI assistant which can feed me with the spoon and solve my relationships problems while doing it.
- danielbln 9y agoEarly adopter here, initial 2012 Oculus Rift Kickstarter backer, I own all the headsets. My excitement has all but died down in regards to the current generation of VR. Mostly, I find the hardware cumbersome and clunky and the games to be too same-y (teleportation galore) or unpolished. The absolute best experience I had in VR was playing Half-Life 2 back in 2013, with terrible resolution and tracking, but it was so immersive I could barely contain myself. Now though, that I'm no longer wowed just by "being there", the act of strapping into VR is so cumbersome, the software is buggy at times, the cable is annoying, the headset is heavy, hot, doesn't work well with glasses etc. However, I'm still as excited for VR as I was in the beginning in regards to the technology. Give me a lighter headset, 100% wireless and great handtracking and finally some long, immersive games (can be ports, that's fine for me) and I'm ready to shell out money again. As it stands today though, my VR hype is on hibernation until the next gen rolls around.
- kromem 9y agoSame for me, though a huge factor in my "re-entry" threshold is resolution. I really do enjoy VR when I get around to playing it, but all I have is presence, but in a world that not particularly beautiful. My favorite VR title is Elite: Dangerous, but while it's absolutely beautiful outside of VR, in VR it's rather....blurry. When in-VR had the detail of out-of-VR, the presence may be more meaningful. (But that'll be a while).
- danielbarla 9y ago> in VR it's rather....blurry I wonder where the issue lies; is 1080×1200 per eye just not high enough (considering the wide FOV)? Or is it the optics? I used to play E:D on somewhat of a potato machine, and it was pretty sharp on a standard monitor, with relatively low resolution.
- Taek 9y agoIt's a lot closer to your face. Your conical vision is seeing like an order of magnitude fewer pixels as when it's looking at the same resolution screen but 18" away.
- foxfired 9y agoVR is very nice, when it's in the booth, and they already set it up, and they have a working game already, and there is only one person a head of me in line, and I can only experience it for a couple minutes because someone else is behind me waiting. Try to play a vr game at home with two other people and one device.
- Yen 9y agoWhen I was a kid, sometimes friends would hang out at someone's house, and one person would play a single-player video game, and the others would watch, comment, offer advice, and generally hang out. Even though it was a single-player experience, with eyes glued on screen, it was "social". More recently, I saw a group of friends set up, with couches outside the tracking area, and watch each other taking turns at Job Simulator, Accounting VR, or Space Pirate trainer. They just had fun watching, socializing, and taking their turn. Panopticon and Keep Talking and Nobody Explodes also offer interesting, asymmetric gameplay.
- retromario 9y agoThis is exactly the sort of 'social' experience we are trying to achieve with our game (http://lateforworkgame.com http://lateforworkgame.com). The VR player controls a giant gorilla and faces off against up to four local friends controlling tanks and planes. I think asymmetric VR games are going to be a big niche within the space. If you like these types of games, there's a big list of them here: https://www.reddit.com/r/Vive/comments/67f9sv/list_of_asymmetrical_local_party_vr_games_vivepc/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Vive/comments/67f9sv/list_of_asymme...
- dcw303 9y agoSince I sense this is the perfect time to offer a half-baked eulogy, let me offer my half-baked theory: I think it was McLuhan who said that each new medium begins by imitating the old. e.g - The first television programs were basically radio broadcasts with an image of a talking head. It took a while for tv to break out and capitalize on the features of the new medium. VR was always going to be measured by gaming. But its well-documented problem was that a very large subsection of games (1st person) have a considerable barf factor for a considerable section of the customer base. So VR may have had great future potential for new avenues in gaming, but it was hamstrung by its weakenesses for existing games. People got too caught up with possibilites to objectively look at how sucky it was right now.
- aaron-lebo 9y agoIt would be like if the first TV programs were barely audible but they had images. VR thus far has been a bit of a step back. Devs have for a long time been under the impression that tech > gameplay (which is dumb when you think about it), and now a lot of devs are under the impression that doing something in VR excuses games not getting the basics right. The fun part is the studios who are used throwing 100 artists at a job pumping out the highest detail models, but that doesn't work so well, so they're either gonna go back to the basics or keep floundering. The best games I've played in VR have been ports, and they're just as enjoyable without VR and you aren't hot and sweaty after 5 minutes.
- Taek 9y agoReally have to complain about 'Out of Ammo' on that one. It had a really great gimmick. It's a tower defense where you can become your towers + units and shoot the enemy with superhero speed and accuracy. That part was really fun. It was also one of the worst tower defense games I've ever played. Enemies coming from all sides, rngs that made certain levels unbeatable if you got unlucky with the tower drops, and wide open areas that meant you couldn't really create bottlenecks. For all the potential it had, they really needed someone better at game design. ----- My biggest issue though is that we haven't seen any long form VR games. Everything decent is more or less like an arcade. One room where you do everything, and you run out of unique stuff to do pretty quickly.
- hnnsj 9y agoIt's pretty sad to me that there's more excitement for Snapchat filters than for VR. Also, I'm getting absolutely fed up with the term "social". People are attention junkies, that's what it is. It's not "social". They're hooked on likes and instant gratification.
- ehnto 9y agoHell if you are a lurker it's not even social, some people just scroll through without ever contributing. The addiction is in the continued novelty of a new headline, comment or post every few moments. Although I can see why once you do begin to invest and contribute you can begin to really solidify the addiction and start to integrate it into your personality and sense of self.
- ajeet_dhaliwal 9y agoI don't think it's sad, VR just doesn't provide a compelling enough experience for many to be excited over it currently. I think for it to work next round, it must have as close to photo realism as possible, it's what we expect when looking around. I do agree with the sentiment about 'social', an internet wide replace-all with 'narcissism' would be great.
- wingerlang 9y agoI don't use Snapchat or VR and even I am more interested in the filters. They are funny and the friction to try it out is literally zero. The tech itself is cool as well.
- addicted 9y agoWhy are Snapchat filters more complicated than what say Photo Booth on the Mac did a decade ago?
- wingerlang 9y agoAren't they? I didn't have a mac a decade ago, and I never really used photo booth since I got one anyway. But I think snapchat has face-altering features as in 3D modifications while photo booth only changed the image itself or maybe identified "head is at x,y" at most. Snapchat can modify your head, make interactive animations and all that jazz. Do note that I never really used snapchat, but these are my impressions from the few times someone pointed it at me.
- slavik81 9y agoI don't really understand why they play up the current state of AR. To me, it seems that AR is a fundamentally harder problem than VR. To do AR right, you need to solve all the problems of VR, then make the headset transparent, make the entire system portable, and give it the ability to understand the world around the user. Pokemon GO is a cited example of the success of AR, but literally all the AR does is render your Pokemon over the camera feed, using the gyro to keep it mostly in the same orientation. It does nothing to make it feel like it's actually in the world. It moves as your perspective moves, and its perceived scale changes wildly. That doesn't even deserve to be called AR. Most players also seem to turn the AR off, too, so it seems weird to attribute success to the concept. It's a gimmick that makes for cool concept videos like the one pictured in the article, but it's not nearly as interesting in reality.
- Raphael 9y agoIt still places the content in geographical locations, requiring you to physically travel. It's a form of augmented reality.
- pls2halp 9y agoI think this is the key. Ingress was a successful AR game, and the geolocation was the only AR, no shoddy camera overlay. I think you can draw a parallel to traditional video games, in that games with a general understanding of maps, and not much small-scale definition(MUDs, Civilisation, even 8-bit platforms with no sub-pixel movement) tended to achieve a greater level of achieved complexity by glossing over small details, in the same way that Ingress/Pokemon Go only placed the locations in a general geographic area.
- ajsalminen 9y agoIf this is enough then Google Maps is the most successful application of AR ever.
- slavik81 9y agoI hadn't thought of that aspect as being AR, but I suppose that's true. It's just very limited. The recent Sword Art Online movie spends quite a bit of time imagining what a world with ubiquitous, sophisticated AR could be like. While obviously unrealistic, that movie felt inspiring.
- make3 9y agothe fact that acceleration = instant nausea makes VR pretty much doomed imho unless there is some magic anti-nausea injection being developed that would come in the mail with the thing. Not saying that games can't be built that don't give nausea, but severely limiting acceleration (including turning) really constrains the design space. Only being able to teleport or stay in place or at constant speed is really poor
- AgentME 9y agoI think a lot of people (consumers and developers) are still stuck in the idea of games requiring a large space of movement. Some games on the Vive like Out of Ammo, Fantastic Contraption, and Xortex (the arcade game in The Lab) are good examples of new gameplay styles that really benefit from the Vive's roomscale VR and aren't hampered by its limitations.
- Animats 9y agoI've been saying for several years that VR was the next 3D TV. I got a lot of hate messages for that. One "thought leader" threatened to ban me from his blog. I wasn't wrong. I've tried most of the VR headsets from Jaron Lanier's original rig to the HTC Vibe. Over that range, the tracking is far better, the resolution is somewhat better, the headset clunkyness is slightly better, and there's still no killer app. It's great for FPS games. Rollercoaster sims are fun once or twice. There are virtual worlds; Second Life and High Fidelity support VR headsets. But virtual worlds never caught on, even though today they could run in a browser. Then what? Augmented reality has potential, but the alignment with the real world has to be very good, it has to work in the real world, not rooms prepped for it, and it has to cost a lot less. Those are technical problems that can be solved. Then you could play Pokemon Go, so there's a killer app ready to roll. Whether the borghead thing will fly socially remains to be seen. Remember the glasshole problem.
- danielbln 9y agoHere comes the "I told you so" crowd. The main difference to 3D TV is that 3D TV barely added anything of value to the customer. VR actually does offer a lot of value, but is bogged down by its current technical limitations. > But virtual worlds never caught on Maybe in its odd-ball Second Life version, but WoW and Minecraft would like a word with that statement.
- aaron-lebo 9y agoVR actually does offer a lot of value, but is bogged down by its current technical limitations. Isn't adoption by consumers a measure of value? Maybe it's not actually that valuable for most people.
- danielbln 9y agoI would say that value is also a function of price and ease-of-use, both of which VR currently sucks at. Still, put a VR headset onto someone and have them compare it to 3D TV, I guarantee that everyone will say that VR is way more impressive, immersive etc. Does that mean that they'll buy it? No, because it's pricey, bulky and cumbersome, but the core value proposition is there and it is bigger than just "here look, fixed angle stereoscopy".
- brandonhsiao 9y agoI like how it takes them six paragraphs to say "VR is underperforming." I really need to learn how to speedread...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- michaelbuckbee 9y agoThree things: 1. The experience itself is there and "real" in a way it hasn't been before. The issues seem to be those of the hardware being too big, expensive and wired. All things that are rapidly being improved on in general computing and crucially not just niche VR (for example the awesome display advances driven by mobile phones are pulled into VR headsets). 2. We're definitely still in the "figuring things out" on the software side. An absolutely fascinating video is this walkthrough of all the UX attempts that a developer tried for getting guns to work and feel good in VR. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iYrkXK3V2ik&feature=youtu.be https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iYrkXK3V2ik&feature=youtu.be And everything with VR is this way - there's a half dozen different movement methods with different quirks that people are trying, there's tons of optimization and framerate and interactions attempts. Heck even the controllers are seeing a rapid evolution (stick like the HTC Vive -> Oculus Touch -> Knuckle Controllers).
- wbillingsley 9y agoThere seems to be a trade-off between immersion and casual-ness of the game, and I'm not sure people are that dedicated to immersion to want to trade-it off long-term: - Wanting to slouch on the couch without it affecting your gameplay - Wanting to pick up your cup of tea or soda in slow moments in the game - Wanting to hear & see if other members of the family have got home - Not wanting to look like an idiot with a thing on your head making strange in-game movements - Feeling antisocial because as you only have one head-set others in the room can't see what you're doing (making it feel antisocial to go into that world) We're pretty good at getting "immersed" in things without VR, so I wonder if the immersion gains just aren't worth the social & convenience costs (as well as the real costs) to most people. A little like even if GOT was on at the local IMAX, the vast majority of people would probably still watch it on their smaller screens at home. Maybe even on their tiny phones and iPads...
- danielbln 9y agoOT, but I would LOVE to see GoT in IMAX, especially the current season.
- jamesrcole 9y agoI agree those are issues. It think most of them can be addressed in time.
- DiThi 9y ago> - Wanting to slouch on the couch without it affecting your gameplay You can easily play some games sitting, but still you can't do no exercise. That's a plus: a friend I played frequently with has lost more weight playing than with any other method. (for most people exercising isn't useful for losing weight but it has many benefits for the brain) > - Wanting to pick up your cup of tea or soda in slow moments in the game I've done that. With a bottle or a cup with a straw. The vive camera makes it easy. > - Wanting to hear & see if other members of the family have got home It depends on which headset are you using and how much noise people makes coming home. I usually do hear them. > - Not wanting to look like an idiot with a thing on your head making strange in-game movements > - Feeling antisocial because as you only have one head-set others in the room can't see what you're doing (making it feel antisocial to go into that world) People _can_ see what are you doing with a correctly positioned screen. In any case those problems are temporary and sounds easy to solve. I'm not very social myself but I want to make a SteamVR "intercommunicator" to talk with people IRL without losing immersion (or maybe even making it more immersive).
- mgc99 9y agoI read a novel published about 20 years ago (1999), that "predicted" how VR would take over the world. It starts with the VR headsets of today that you wear over your face with poor graphics and that don't seem very realistic. Then came better ones with eye tracking which replaced keyboards and mouse with eye tracking. Then electrodes which would directly interface with our brains to replace our sense of hearing and vision. Then wireless electrodes so you dont have to wear a helmet but are in VR/AR the moment you step into a room with a computer. Then slowly a Matrix like world where people are plugged into VR from their birth and have no idea there is a physical world or something beyond VR. Pretty interesting.
- amitt 9y agoI run a VR/AR-focused VC firm (Presence Capital). We've done 30+ investments in this space, so you can say that we believe in the long-term potential of VR. Even given that, we're bearish on how quickly there will be a profitable/sustainable VR consumer business and have advised most of our portfolio companies targeting consumers to keep burn low. That being said, this article and most of the comments here are taking a singular worldview: consumer-focused VR for a western market. VR is a tool, not an industry. Context on use is required to assess traction. VR for B2B or enterprises can make money today and doesn't require mass-consumer adoption. If you make someone 10x more effective at their job (tools for sales people: OssoVR) or onboard employees faster (training: STRIVR), you can overcome the cost and rough edges on the hardware and have an ROI to justify the cost of the system. Walmart, for example, recently announced they are using VR to power their training centers. https://techcrunch.com/2017/05/31/walmart-is-bringing-vr-instruction-to-all-of-its-u-s-training-centers/ https://techcrunch.com/2017/05/31/walmart-is-bringing-vr-ins... We're actively investing in VR for training companies and I recently did an overview of what separates out the best companies in this space: https://www.forbes.com/sites/forbestechcouncil/2017/08/24/tips-on-how-to-get-your-vr-simulation-project-funded/#39044a575ed0 https://www.forbes.com/sites/forbestechcouncil/2017/08/24/ti... In Asia (and increasingly in the west), VR-arcades are going to be how most consumers first experience high-end PC VR. Culturally, people there are already used to going to internet cafe's to use computers by the hour and seek out 3rd spaces. VR-by-the-hour rooms fit this mold. Additionally, the short length of most VR experiences makes it easy to have a 15-20 minute session and not be disappointed by the lack of content. IMAX is starting to open multiple VR centers and the word within the industry is that the VR Zones opened by Namco in Tokyo are currently profitable. More info on this here: https://medium.com/@amitt/vr-will-be-huge-in-china-41de0c758.. https://medium.com/@amitt/vr-will-be-huge-in-china-41de0c758.... (disclosure: we're investors in STRIVR and OssoVR)
- rapsey 9y ago> VR for B2B or enterprises can make money today and doesn't require mass-consumer adoption. I would have thought AR google glass type devices would have been more versatile and popular than full VR for enterprise. No?
- tanilama 9y agoAlways not a fan of VR. The biggest issue here: Why do I need them. The media and some evangelists are selling VR like it is THE new interface for everything and anything, but they cannot really even convince people with their own demo out of the scope of some basic gaming and prototyping. The whole headset too big and uncomfortable point is true, but it comes next at failing to sell the technology to the mess with a legit reason. Yes it is cooler and more immersive, but does this advantage outweigh that much that I should ditch my smartphone and embrace the hype? I am afraid this would come to AI as well, while the media is fear-mongering over human being taken over by terminators-like robots, people out there might just not feel there is a need of democratization of AI at all.
- Stratoscope 9y ago> Millions of Americans donned a wacky-looking headset to get a glimpse of a different reality this week. No, not a virtual reality headset — these people were looking up at the sky through protective goggles to witness a total eclipse of the sun which cut a shadowy swathe across middle America. Oh my. I'm sure you know the old saying: when you read a news report about something you happen to be an expert in, you'll likely find that they got it very wrong. And then you'll wonder what else they get wrong. I'm an eclipse veteran, and I certainly hope millions of people did not wear protective goggles to witness the total eclipse. Because they wouldn't have seen a thing. You need eye protection for any partial eclipse, including the partial phases before and after totality. But not during totality. The solar corona is only about as bright as a full moon, and "eclipse glasses" would block it out completely. Water under the bridge now, at least until the next total eclipse! But when a writer leads off a news piece with something so far from the mark, why should I believe anything they write? Maybe I'm being overly judgmental. After all, the eclipse comment was supposed to be just a clever lead-in for the article. But it was so wrong I just didn't have the patience to read the rest of the piece.
- et1337 9y agoYou discredited the article because it said people used protective glasses to watch the eclipse? I'm not an "eclipse veteran", I don't know anything about it, but my feed was nothing but eclipse glasses for three whole days. I would say people wore glasses.
- Stratoscope 9y agoTouché. ;-) Yes, I did dismiss the article after that first paragraph, and as I mentioned probably unfairly on my part. Sorry, it was just a real peeve of mine in the weeks leading up to this eclipse to see so much misinformation spread by the news media. It was the same thing that happened in the 1979 eclipse that I got to see in all its glory. It was really sad to see so many people denied that experience because of unjustified fear, when it's possible to view a total eclipse in complete safety as I did. And the same thing happened again this year. This astronomer's experience in 1979 was all too typical: http://www.wrcbtv.com/story/35055369/i-was-robbed-of-my-eclipse-experience-dont-let-that-happen-to-you http://www.wrcbtv.com/story/35055369/i-was-robbed-of-my-ecli... OK, enough of my eclipse gripes. Just explaining why this put me off from the rest of the article. By way of contrast, if that opening paragraph had mentioned that all the people who used eclipse glasses during totality missed the whole thing because of misinformation and fear, now that would have caught my attention and led me to believe that the author might have some good insights in other areas too. Y'all can get back to VR now... :-)
- RandomInteger4 9y agoAfter injuring the muscles in my back and shoulders, the only thing I've wanted VR for wasn't even the VR itself, but just an HMD for computing while laying down. It's hard to imagine how difficult it is just to sit or stand at a desk till you injure the muscles that keep everything upright. The next step ideally would be a keyboard that comes with special gloves, or a pair of finger tip RFIDs or blutooths, one for each hand, that can be detected by some sensor on the keyboard, which can be used to calculate finger position in relation to the keyboard and display a virtual version of that on the bottom of the screen. These couple of peripherals shouldn't be too expensive to implement and bring to market I imagine. Touch typing is great and all, and I don't really look at the keyboard while typing directly, but for some odd reason, just seeing my hands barely in the bottom of my vision box makes all the difference in my ability to type accurately. I turn the lights off and I can't type for shit. Maybe it has to do with re-orienting my hands to the keyboard. As I type this I notice every once in a while after pausing that I briefly look down at the keyboard and then back up. Anyways, that was a small tangent, but VR should really focus on certain accessibility aspects going forward.
- Yen 9y agoIncidentally, I've noticed this same thing when trying to touch-type with a VR headset on. Even though I consider myself pretty good at touch typing, and even fairly accurate at touch-typing with my eyes closed, it's very difficult to type while in VR. Similarly, when I'm wearing a headset and I need to grab something off my desk quickly, and don't want to take off the headset, it can result in a lot of fumbling around. Interestingly enough, I find it helps to close my eyes, and I actually find things more quickly and accurately. So, even just a bit of video passthrough of the keyboard, or an in-VR visual excuse for why the keyboard & your hands are occluded from view, might be enough to solve touch-typing in VR.
- mncharity 9y agoI too found that I needed to see the keys. But while there are glove startups, and Leap Motion hand tracking can be usable, it's much easier to just see the keyboard. I use camera-passthrough AR on a Vive, with a ducktaped-on camera. The Vive's own camera is too low resolution (it's both fisheye, and bandwidth limited to 6?? x 4?? pixels). Other people have mounted a camera above the keyboard, and inserted only the keyboard image into their otherwise VR environment. Another option is to get an AR HMD. There's Hololens. And a "like Google Cardboard, but for AR" kickstarter? I've not been following the area. I've heard, but not tried, that one can make some use of seeing down past your nose on the Rift. So I've not found keyboard use a problem. But the low angular resolution has been. I get something like 40 lines of readable text without having to move my head. The Rift/Vive panels are low-resolution per eye, and are PenTile (so it's really even less), and you're only able to use the center third or half. That's not much realestate. But, if you're ok with that, you can do RDP... there are youtube videos. I've heard people who commonly work in small terminal windows can be happy. The new Windows VR HMDs (available now as developer versions) are said to be higher resolution, with perhaps poorer optics, but I've not tried them yet. AR HMD's have narrower fields of view, and thus higher angular resolution. So Hololens et al might be an alternative, but I've not tried that. Depending on your constraints, another option might a projector - projecting on a ceiling, wall, or suspended screen.
- sulam 9y agoI spent 5 years building a company in this space in the 90's, and eventually gave up. I know people still in the space, true believers of a sort I could not emulate (having people working for you focuses the mind on actually making money pretty well, at least for me). I stayed out of this cycle because honestly it doesn't look to me like anything significant has changed. Yes, the technology is better, but fundamentally the problem is not the technology, it's the applications and the fact that a significant portion of consumers only spend time in front of a powerful computer at work (and many don't even do that anymore). One more generation of hardware might get us there, if we can somehow keep Moore's law going.
- toast0 9y agoI suspect VR may go away again (although it's lasted longer than i thought it would). When it comes back for the third round, it's more likely to stick. Enough people have been exposed to it this round, that I think there may be compelling content when it comes back. And ten years better hardware would help a lot.
- avaer 9y agoI'm really liking the HN discussion, but this article has the smell of PR submarines. No investigation or new info, just waxing poetic whether the suit is back or dead. Is there any party that would benefit if people believed they should wait five years for VR? EDIT: In case it's not clear, I'm talking about [1] [1] http://www.paulgraham.com/submarine.html http://www.paulgraham.com/submarine.html
- Yen 9y agoMy suspicion is that it's just the author's opinion, and because negativity sells. But I could be wrong. If it is a submarine piece, well, the author does seem particularly sold on the idea of AR vs. VR. Brings up several emotional negatives of VR that AR would be the savior for. The author specifically mentions Pokemon Go, and Snapchat.
- dave7 9y agoMicrosoft?
- Yen 9y agoThe article is long-winded, and a bit patronizing(1), but it seems to generally be saying that "VR is going to drop off in popularity in the near future, and may never become popular again". I don't think this will be the case. A few decades ago, you could experience VR of a similar nature as you can today ... if you happened to have an in with a nearby university research lab, with a setup space with carefully calibrated sensors, hundreds of thousands of dollars of computers, projectors, and other equipment. Now-a-days, you can experience that VR with about $2,000 worth of computer + headset, and about as much setup difficulty as a home theater system. This is _massively_ more accessible than it was. It's certainly not perfect. $2,000 is still a lot of money, and 550 grams is a lot of weight to put on your face. But, even if it's not a smashing consumer success at the moment, the number of developers, artists, and other creatives who have access to the tools of VR development, and the size of the potential audience, are several orders of magnitude larger than they were just a decade ago. And, really, if the biggest complaints about VR headsets are that they're too heavy, too expensive, and they look dorky, then I'd say VR's already won, one way or another. Technology has had this weird habit of getting smaller and cheaper. The hype may cool off, but I don't think there's going to be much slowing of developer behavior or consumer behavior in the near future, and new headset models coming out will just slowly ramp up enthusiasm. (1) but seriously, this author is really really concerned about how un-cool the headset makes you look, as if people staring intently at a movie screen, or play, or classical music concert are that much more photogenic.
- dcw303 9y agoSlightly OT but since posting at this time gets the eyeballs of a few Tokyo folk, I'll ask this: has anyone been to this VR amusement centre in Shinjuku yet? https://vrzone-pic.com/en/ https://vrzone-pic.com/en/
- stuzenz 9y agoNot Shinjuku, but a few months ago I was in Odaiba and had plans to book in for this place on short notice - sadly it was all booked out. https://project-ican.com/en/vr-zone/ https://project-ican.com/en/vr-zone/ Thirdhand, but my friends have told me it is really worth it. Odaiba is known as a popular dating spot - so it isn't hard to believe that they regularly get fully booked out for something new like that.
- allenleein 9y agoHTC is also exploring options that could range from separating its virtual-reality business to a full sale of the company. Smartphone Maker HTC Explores Strategic Options: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-08-24/smartphone-maker-htc-is-said-to-explore-strategic-options https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-08-24/smartphon...
- dawnerd 9y agoEveryone is focused on at home gaming, but the real market for VR is in attractions - mainly theme parks. Six Flags has been able to take really old and new rides and turn them into completely different experiences with essentially just a cell phone. You also have a LOT of haunts popping up that are VR escape rooms. Universal Orlando used it in one of their upcharge experiences during Halloween Horror Nights last year. There are also some fitness programs starting out that use vr as a way to help motivate people who would normally not want to work out. So yes, at home vr never really took off. I don't think anyone honestly believed it would at the current price point/computer requirements.
- flukus 9y ago> Everyone is focused on at home gaming, but the real market for VR is in attractions - mainly theme parks. That's a tiny market that doesn't come close to justifying the current levels of investment though. When billions of dollars are being injected then you need mass market adoption, either home or business.
- dawnerd 9y agoDon't underestimate how large of a market the amusement industry is. > United States: Nearly 30,000 attractions (theme and amusement parks, attractions, water parks, family entertainment centers, zoos, aquariums, science centers, museums, and resorts) produced a total nationwide economic impact of $219 billion in 2011. (The figures there are a couple years outdated. Last few years have seen record numbers.) http://www.iaapa.org/resources/by-park-type/amusement-parks-and-attractions/industry-statistics http://www.iaapa.org/resources/by-park-type/amusement-parks-... The video game industry is barely half that: https://www.cnbc.com/2017/02/15/digital-games-market-to-see-sales-worth-100-billion-this-year-research.html https://www.cnbc.com/2017/02/15/digital-games-market-to-see-... If investors want to keep blowing money trying to force tech into the home, so be it. Ninja edit: Not trying to say you're wrong by any means though. The amount of money being thrown at putting VR into the home is insane and in my opinion just outright stupid. Way better to spend that same money in an industry that's already accepting of the same tech.
- madaxe_again 9y agoI had to abandon Minecraft on a 2D screen after getting motion sickness from just a faux 3D-perspective Does he get motion sickness watching F1 on TV?! I'm inclined to take this article with a big pinch of salt, as regardless of how many truths it touches, there's an undercurrent of hatred. Also seems to pretty much disregard the vive.
- corysama 9y agoWelcome to this VR cycle's Trough of Disillusionment. I'm looking forward to the coming Slope of Enlightenment. VR is not going to immediately obsolete your smartphone, computer monitor, TV and car. But, it is a wonderful new option for a great many things. It's not ready for daily use by hundreds of millions of people today. But, it is getting better pretty fast. Give it time (and a lot more investment). When it is ready, I expect to see a lot of people immersed in new worlds with new interfaces and new opportunities reporting back "Well, yeah I use a VR interface at work. It's OK, I guess. I wish they'd fix this one feature..."
- mdekkers 9y agoA badly written, badly argued, and boringly long article that boils down to "I don't like VR, I lack the imagination to come up with any use-case besides (western) consumer entertainment, so it is useless and therefore dead." No mention of Hololens, which is unfortunate - and shows how poorly researched this verbal diarrhea actually is.
- tigershark 9y agoHololens has nothing to do with VR. It is AR.
- realworldview 9y agoVR: still rubbish. Not rocket science.
- darksim905 9y agoA lot of the complaints I see in the comments center around weight of the headset & resolution. Regarding weight wouldn't it make more sense to have an overhead track installed where you live discrete, that takes the stress off the helmet? http://techblog.steelseries.com/images/ikeahaxx/6.jpg http://techblog.steelseries.com/images/ikeahaxx/6.jpg This person seems to have it mostly correct except the wires still touch their back. It would make sense to me to have nothing touching you so you don't feel encumbered.
- emptyfile 9y agoNot sure how you write a VR article without ever mentioning non-gaming applications. Gaming itself is a niche market. And for AR, mentioning Pokemon GO and Google Glass multiple times without mentioning HoloLens is plain bizzare.
- LyndsySimon 9y agoI own a GearVR, and have played with a Vive, Oculus, and PS4 VR. Of those, the only real immersive experience I've had was playing Minecraft on the GearVR. Yes, the resolution is low, but Minecraft is pretty low-resolution to begin with. The key seems to be the lack of wires and freedom of movement. I have a SteelSeries bluetooth controller, and I sat in a swivel chair to play. I agree with the article on the whole - there is no compelling use case for VR as it exists today, or as it will exist in the near future. Higher resolution will make some uses better (e.g. porn), but it's still going to be very limited-use. I can't wait to get my hands on a HoloLens. I think AR is going to be a killer tech, though I don't think it will really hit "mainstream" until direct retinal projection or a similar technology is widely available. It's still not socially acceptable to wear an HMD in public.
- falcolas 9y agoFor years I have been quite negative about VR, the negativity driven by attempting to use current generation VR for applications that it doesn't fit well. However, I have finally come to the conclusion that the current VR setups are an amazingly good fit for two uses: - Space/Driving/Flying Sims - Emulating a room The first is fairly obvious - you're sitting in a chair, looking outwards. You have the visual context of your cockpit to keep you from getting nauseous, and the immersion is out of this world. The last is where things get pretty exciting to me: It's the next evolution of the home theater. You can emulate any theater, any screen size, and include proper sound processing to give a spatial sense to the audio. The possibilities here are pretty damned close to endless. There are other great uses for emulating rooms - such as for architects giving virtual home tours, or giving 3d artists a more natural medium to work with. Yeah, it might be a long hard slog to global adoption, but it can only go up from here.
- Lio 9y ago> Sony’s device is slicker, but underpowered and incapable of even delivering PS4 level graphics let alone surpassing them. Hmm, I've got Resident Evil on my bog standard PS4 and PSVR; it plays its fine. It's a AAA game and seems to contradict the above assertion. It could be better but that's true for all games on all systems.
- exodust 9y agoWithin days of buying an Oculus DK2 back in 2014 and trying a ton of applications, I knew the tech was years away from where it needed to be, so I sold the rift on ebay. After the novelty wears off, you're left with this thing strapped to your head, and it's not comfortable. It's not ergonomic, it's awkward, and a blindfold to actual reality. No doubt the headsets are improved from DK2, but they would need to be a LOT better before I bother trying again. 5 years is wishful thinking. Try 10 to 20 or more for the kind of VR that is like wearing regular sunglasses.
- mcbruiser3 9y agoI have to say, this article comes off as pretty biased. Gauging the future of VR by comparing it to social / mobile gaming adoption is a false comparison and just makes the author look dumb. First of all, the author mainly writes about mobile and social games, so she obviously has no interest in VR and has probably never even tried it. Unfortunately for those on the fence about VR, she's painted an unfair and bleak picture. That's unfortunate for them because they may miss out on something quite fun and interesting. I was a VR skeptic right up until two weeks ago when I tried a friend's DK3 and have since purchased a CV1 during the summer sale event. I was not a gamer beforehand, but the immersion of VR has sucked me in. That fact that you have to move to play is what makes it fun.
- tbcktu 9y agoVR is absolutely perfect for sim racing and I hope it doesn't go away. Even if it just becomes another niche device that sim racers spend way too much money on.
- Daseinen 9y agoI'm building a business in the VR space -- a VR real estate aggregator that's beginning as a VR centered brokerage in NYC. We recently had our beta launch, but I've been working on it, off and on, since late 2015. So, obviously, I think VR has something special to offer. What VR does is incredible, and incredibly valuable. But it has a very limited scope. I've been bearish about VR since the beginning. Even when it's approaching perfection, it's too socially isolating. Lots of things are as socially isolating, but few FEEL so overtly isolating. Moreover, we're accustomed to viewing things from a narrative distance -- a sort of 3rd person impersonal viewpoint. VR is intransigently stuck in 1st person. That's great for certain kinds of video games, and can be great for video once software allows for truly interactive video experiences. But it's still a deeply limited perspective. Think of all the forms of entertainment you've ever used. Now eliminate all those that aren't 1st person. That's what's left for VR. AR will end up covering everything. We love computers, information, virtual socialization, but we also want to feel like we're engaging in those things as an extension of the world we live in on a day to day basis. AR allows an increasingly rich interpenetration of the virtual and the real. It's going to take over completely. But I'm confident that VR will always have a place. It's like a motorcycle to AR's car. For example, VR is unquestionably the future of the home search. Being able to tour through many homes, walk neighborhoods, check out the local bars and restaurants, all without having to travel. That's invaluable. AR just won't cut it for these purposes. And VR will eventually be used extensively for 1st person gaming, a relatively small range of focused media, some art, training, and probably for home-movies (think of going back, 20 years later, to be in the room during your kid's 5th birthday!). So I remove all the magical talk. Then look at the functionality, and I think you'll see that VR's value is tremendous, within a limited domain.