5 ms·
Awesome watch. But they are anachronistic, if you'll pardon the pun. Any $0.50 quartz watch keeps better time!
by robertlagrant 9y ago
Awesome watch. But they are anachronistic, if you'll pardon the pun. Any $0.50 quartz watch keeps better time!
- LeoPanthera 9y agoI don't think anyone would buy a watch like this because they wanted to keep accurate time. There are in fact high-end luxury watches that keep unusually accurate time. I own one - an Omega Speedmaster Skywalker X-33. It has a thermocompensated quartz movement (TCXO) and so is accurate to ~10 seconds a year, compared to the ~15 seconds a month of a normal quartz movement.
- sdrothrock 9y agoThe Bulova Accutron is also very accurate, as the name suggests -- around five seconds a year -- and is much less expensive than the Omega. The fact is that most luxury watches are mechanical; the Skywalker X-33 is an oddity in that it's a luxury quartz, which barely exists as a market segment. Mechanical watches are not as accurate, with standard COSC deviation being -4 to +6 seconds... per DAY.
- lb1lf 9y ago-Other luxury watch companies also made forays into quartz back in the day - say, Rolex Oysterquartz for a prime example. I believe Vacheron Constantin also made one at some point. Modern mechanical watches can do significantly better than COSC, by the way - I have owned an Omega Planet Ocean (c.2500C) for a decade now, for the first seven or eight years it ran consistently 0.7 seconds/day fast - so I just adjusted it back a minute or two every time I unscrewed the crown to correct the date. Now it is due for a service soon - but still within a couple of seconds a day.
- sdrothrock 9y agoBack in the day, when quartz seemed like it would take over the world... how many people nowadays know about or want an Oysterquartz? ;) The point I was trying to make is that probably one of the LOWEST selling points of a luxury watch is accuracy -- there are far more accurate, electronic solutions in the watch space. I love mechanical watches, but I hold no illusions as to how they compare to more modern technology as timepieces. :)
- lb1lf 9y agoOh, I want one - an OysterQuartz, that is - primarily to show off to Rolex enthusiasts who thump their chests saying 'Rolex NEVER made a quartz watch!' (As if that is something to be ashamed of; an accurate quartz movement is also impressive in its own right, IM(EE, digital/RF)HO. I do agree 100%, though - much as I love my mechanical watches, if I happen to be in a situation which requires exact knowledge of the current time, I simply look at my HP Z3801A. A mechanical wristwatch serves a different purpose - and in addition being good enough for everyday life, much as vinyl is plenty good enough to have us enjoy music, even if there are more high fidelity-solutions out there. Vinyl has its own intangible advantages; as do mechanical watches.
- dopeboy 9y agoGenuinely curious (after looking up the price tag) - do you think the accuracy justifies the cost?
- LeoPanthera 9y agoThe accuracy is not the only reason I bought it, it's a very capable timepiece, but it surely helps. During the eclipse I used it to get 60 second warnings of the start and end of totality.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- dozzie 9y agoA good fountain pen is anachronistic as well. They (pens and mechanical watches) are not casual goods just to be used, they are luxury goods, even if some of them are quite affordable.
- TheOtherHobbes 9y agoThese are pure Veblen goods, with a nostalgic slant on trivial practical utility, used to display purchasing power in a capitalist economy where purchasing power is considered a proxy for high social status. In fact they're more like cult power objects - what anthropologists call fetish objects, which confer an implied cultural blessing on their owners.
- dsacco 9y agoI own a watch from a brand of comparable quality and complexity expertise as Vacheron Constantin. I don't use it display purchasing power - I almost never actually wear it because I like to wear my Apple Watch most of the time. When I do wear it, I am almost never around anyone who would recognize the brand of the watch. Essentially no one I personally know is aware of how much I paid for the watch, no one has ever commented on the watch specifically, and I do not bring it up in conversation even when I wear it. In other words, I own the watch because I enjoy it for its own sake. It's a beautiful piece of handcrafted machinery. It's not supposed to have superlative practical utility, nor does any serious watch house actually strive for that. These timepieces are a form of art, and whether or not you appreciate them has no bearing on the fact that their manufacturers are under no illusions of their practicality. Don't generalize your perception of the entire industry based on your experience or preconception of a relatively diminutive portion of its consumers. There are people who buy Rolexes because it's a good way to show off money, but there are many other people who honestly buy them because Rolex genuinely manufactures high quality mechanical watches. My experience as a collector is that most people do not buy these to show off. Rationally, a Vacheron Constantin is an inefficient vehicle for doing so - it looks pretty, but virtually no one will recognize it nor even comment on it.
- 21 9y agoA psychologist said that for some people these kind of objects are a modern ethical way of owning a slave - someone dedicates one year of it's life to meticulously create an object that you then buy, essentially being your slave for a year.
- 627467 9y agoOne of the most useful things i've learn in my business degree is how price has no floor or ceiling price when we are talking about non-commdity products
- nradov 9y agoLuxury good pricing also doesn't follow the supply / demand curve. In some cases higher prices actually increase demand because that signals greater quality and exclusivity.
- betolink 9y agoanachronistic depends on what we are looking for, I for example just got my first mechanical watch, I know it's not accurate as a quartz but that's not the point. I'd like to think about it from a nostalgic point of view, from the days when not everything had a computer inside.
- dsacco 9y agoIt's better to think of these sorts of watches as art. You don't own a watch like this because you have no other recourse for accurately telling the time. You own it because you appreciate it, like a Rothko or Pollock, or a Barcelona Chair if you're into that sort of thing too.
- nicky0 9y agoI did like the pun. However I'm going to argue with you. You can pick up a good mechanical Seiko watch with a tried and tested automatic movement for $100. When properly adjusted these can keep good time and do not need batteries. They stay wound simply by wearing them. They have a sweep second hand (not a "tick-tick" 1hz hand like quartz watches). There is no need to change a battery. There is a lot of practical utility in that. In addition watches can be beautiful objects and a pleasure to wear.
- threatofrain 9y agoLady Gaga doesn't wear a meat dress just to stay warm. Just think about the craftsmanship behind the dress. It's art that is elevated, transcended beyond mere mortal concerns of food.