2 ms·
Coding is translating (encoding) an existing design into an arcane language at a high level of detail. A coder produces source code from a specification in the
by closeparen 9y ago
Coding is translating (encoding) an existing design into an arcane language at a high level of detail. A coder produces source code from a specification in the way that a secretary produces a typed document from a dictaphone tape. Like a secretary, a coder may be expected to have the domain knowledge and judgement to interpolate small details, but should not generally be making decisions.
Understanding business needs and gathering requirements is software analysis. Deciding what components to write to fulfill those requirements is system architecture. Determining the modules, algorithms, and data structures to use within those components is software design. Finally, writing down those algorithms and data structures in a way that satisfies the compiler is coding.
Most of us "software engineers," "software developers," or simply "programmers" wear all of these hats at various points in a project's lifecycle. But to wear the title "coder" is to explicitly mark your position as one with minimal critical thinking, problem solving, or decision-making.
Coding is nowhere near sufficient to create programs that solve complex problems, in the same way that typing is not sufficient to create a novel. If people explicitly designated as coders are making decisions and thinking critically, we should be as concerned as if typesetters were reworking character development.
"Design is not coding, coding is not design" [0].
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Software_design https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Software_design
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoI guess this definition of coding harkens back to the days when secretaries* would encode programs written by mathematicians by punching cards or weaving knots or configuring wires? Because that hasn't existed in a long time, at least since the 70s. Much like typesetter don't exist anymore where designers use programs that allow the, to typeset themselves. * many of these "coders" like future rear admiral Grace Hopper got fed up with this and did something about it, leading to the first compilers and programming languages.
- closeparen 9y agoCoding is one activity within the software development process, and I agree, I don't think those activities have been separated by job title in a long time. Most people do some of everything. Which is why it's so strange that people would suddenly rally around this term, rather than "programmer" or "developer" or "software engineer" which encompass the full range of what they're doing, and instead choose to cheapen it by calling out the least intellectually challenging step. You could argue that source code in a contemporary high-level language is a software design, and compilers/interpreters have grown sophisticated enough to eliminate the need for human grunt work.