8 ms·
For the uninformed, Formula 1 has been running on supercharged 1600 cc V6 engines since 2014, with 100 kg of gasoline for the whole GP (300 km), 105 kg this yea
by pmontra 9y ago
For the uninformed, Formula 1 has been running on supercharged 1600 cc V6 engines since 2014, with 100 kg of gasoline for the whole GP (300 km), 105 kg this year if I remember correctly (because of larger and heavier tires.) That wouldn't give enough power so there are energy recovery systems from the exhaust and brakes. They get close to 1000 HP when all those power system deploy all the power they can generate.
The driver has still only the accelerator and the brakes pedals to control power so it's critical that the car knows when to recover energy (either when braking or when coasting) and when to go full throttle or deploy partial power, and which percentage. That's where Honda has failed.
- derefr 9y ago> The driver has still only the accelerator and the brakes pedals to control power Is there a reason for that? I always assumed (as someone who doesn't know much about racing) that the inside of F1 cars would resemble a jet-fighter cockpit. They're not required to be stock cars, so why not optimize on HCI efficiency as well as on everything else the sport is about?
- Pulcinella 9y agoThat comment was incorrect. If you look at an F1 steering wheel, there are tons of buttons, switches, and knobs for adjusting engine and energy recover settings.
- philjohn 9y agoExactly - they can change throttle map between a "start" mode (less intense application of power to ensure a smooth getaway without wheelspin) and race mode. They've also got a heap of controls over things like the Diff, DRS (where the rear wing opens up to reduce drag on straights when they're lining up an overtake), and most crucially, engine mode - which tweaks fuel injection rate.
- pmontra 9y agoThey do look like jet planes cockpits. This is something I googled right now with a fairly good explanation https://www.thesun.co.uk/sport/motorsport/3042278/formula-one-steering-wheels-explained/ https://www.thesun.co.uk/sport/motorsport/3042278/formula-on... Some form of controls could be denied by technical or sporting regulations. I didn't read them in the last years. They are at http://www.fia.com/regulation/category/110 http://www.fia.com/regulation/category/110 Regulations are interesting and not too hard to follow.
- quickben 9y agoI believe at some point they were afraid everything will get autopilpted in. That also increases the risk to the drivers lifes. So they decided to cut it out early.
- wastedhours 9y agoAlthough it was primarily brake-bias, watch some onboards of Michael Schumacher from his prime, adjusting car parameters on the steering wheel at almost every point - there are a lot of different settings each driver can make inside that affect it.
- paddy_m 9y agoIn 97/98 McLaren added the fiddle brake which was quickly outlawed. The fiddle brake was a two brake pedal system so the left side and right side of the car could be controlled separately. This allowed for better braking entering into a corner and a slight traction advantage on exiting. I always thought it was fair play since it completely depended on the driver and should never have been banned. https://www.reddit.com/r/formula1/comments/1ux791/an_old_f1_shot_of_mclarens_fiddle_brake_a_second/ https://www.reddit.com/r/formula1/comments/1ux791/an_old_f1_...
- alkonaut 9y agoI wonder if this couldn't be emulated somehow via e.g one pedal and steering angle and/or rear diff measurements to put more braking power to the inner wheel? Then of course, it might be banned as a braking aid similar to ABS. Using any kind of feedback loop for braking effectively makes it a stability system which I assume is not allowed?
- andrewf 9y agoI'm still surprised that "the computer knows where on the track you are, and alters the behavior of the car" is allowed. This is the sport which outlaws ABS because the driver is supposed to do the work, not the car.
- unfunco 9y agoIt sounds as if the computer knows because of throttle though, which is rudimentary, and likely purposefully rudimentary to steer around rules about GPS/track mapping?
- serf 9y ago>This is the sport which outlaws ABS because the driver is supposed to do the work, not the car. That's been a silly distinction to bring up ever since the introduction of automated gearboxes and the end of clutch management.
- lqdc13 9y agoIt's still manual transmission and they don't have traction control or launch control or automatic suspension adjustment. I think they added the boost tech so that cars pass each other more frequently.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- TheCondor 9y agoin 2014 vettel fell off a bit and Christian Horner said it was due to a loss of brake feeling with the new formula. Now most of the tricks are completely secret and it's all about tricks to comply with the regulations but circumvent them and racing drivers have a lot of excuses that aren't to be believed but I could sort of see this. If you want to have more natural braking in some corners and recover less energy and then maybe deploy the energy at more optimal places on the track then this sort of thing makes a little sense, especially if you can make it work. I would think it highly prone to being confused though. It would be interesting to see some data on the differences between this type of algorithm when it works and the Prius algorithm.
- logronoide 9y agoIt's not so simple. The driver has control over how to deploy the power (electric and combustion) in the steering wheel. http://www.thisisf1.com/2016/05/16/explained-2016-f1-steering-wheel http://www.thisisf1.com/2016/05/16/explained-2016-f1-steerin... So engineers and Alonso had to agree beforehand on motor maps and different steering wheel parameters. It's not clear if it's a problem in the software or an issue in the parametrization of the car for that qualy lap.
- bsder 9y agoWhy the gas limitation? That seems odd.
- disordinary 9y agoThe sport aims to be an R&D center for road going technology. So the cars are pretty much hybrids with electric power increasing and the reliance on the petrol motors decreasing.
- bsder 9y agoHuh? I though the whole initial problems was that the hybrids outperformed the petrol versions quite handily. Why would you have to limit gasoline when the system is going to evolve to wipe that out anyway?
- quickben 9y agoI believe they are free to not carry gasoline. The fact they carry it, tells you a lot.
- disordinary 9y agoI guess there's two reasons - the first is when they started this process it was before we had full electric vehicles and it wasn't clear what the best technology would be, at the time hybrid vehicles were very popular. The second is that F1 has been carbon neutral for at least two decades with the FIA planting trees to offset the extraordinary amount of pollution that flying the F1 circus around the world generates. Even though reducing fuel does nothing to make F1 greener when you take into account the carbon generated by transportation it is important that the actual show is as green as possible.
- lqdc13 9y agoThis is all PR. In bet now it's way more energy demanding than before just because there are way more people involved. More journalists/media and many more support staff to work on hybrid tech.
- chad_c 9y agoThe engines are turbocharged, not supercharged.
- dingaling 9y agoTechnically the article is correct, turbocharging is a form of supercharging. Supercharger is an overloaded word, it refers both to the principle of forced induction as well as a particular mechanical method of achieving that. Oddly this isn't just a problems with English, German has the same overloading of 'kompressor'. Turbocharging was originally called turbosupercharging when developed by GE.
- seabrookmx 9y agoCorrection: they're turbocharged not supercharged. For those that don't know the difference, a turbocharger is two turbines connected to eachother. One, powered by exhaust gases, spins the other, which forces air into the combustion chamber (the pressure applied is typically called "boost"). More air means more fuel can be injected while maintaining stoichiometric equilibrium. More fuel combusted means more power is produced, given equal waste due to friction etc. A supercharger is very similar, but conceptually more simple. The turbine creating boost is instead connected mechanically to the engine's crankshaft, being driven directly by the engine.
- pietjepuk88 9y agoTo be fair, the turbochargers in contemporary F1 cars are not powered only by exhaust gases. To get rid of the infamous turbo lag, they are electrically assisted. Still not a super charger of course, but the "assisted" part makes them a bit more similar.
- pryelluw 9y agoI tend to think of this system as a sort of twincharger, because the compressor is driven by a turbine and an electric motor. And to nitpick, all turbochargers are superchargers. Their original term was a turbosupercharger. It was later renamed to turbocharger. :)
- lostlogin 9y agoThe poor mans equivalent of this is hooking up a decent computer fan to the battery on a scooter. Force feeding the intake on the poor little thing certainly felt like it doubled the power, but double almost nothing still isn't much. Turboing the lawn mower works great too, but I'm less sure you would want that done.
- GoToRO 9y agoDoes it actually work? I might try it.
- andrepd 9y agoI was under the impression that the MGU was manually controlled by the driver via controls on the cockpit. Also I don't know if that 1000HP figure is correct. AFAIK teams don't disclose power ratings to the public.
- cucuuc 9y agoThe powers are usually estimates, afaik. however they seem to be open secrets
- userbinator 9y agowith 100 kg of gasoline for the whole GP (300 km), 105 kg this year if I remember correctly (because of larger and heavier tires.) Taking gasoline at approximately 0.75kg/L, that's 133.3L for 300km or around 44.4L/100km. That's 5.3MPG in US units. Not very fuel-efficient...
- hm8 9y agoIt might sound like bad fuel efficiency but the engine efficiencies they have managed to achieve are insane. The latest Mercedes and Ferrari engines are able to gain 47% efficiency [1]. Compare that to the road cars which are able to do 25-30% thermal efficiency and Prius which can manage 40%. In my opinion, the fuel efficiency suffers because it's a sport at the end of the day and burning more fuel at a higher rate (limited to 100 kg/hour) gives you more power. [1] https://arstechnica.com/cars/2016/05/turbulent-times-for-formula-1-engines-result-in-unprecedented-efficiency-gains/ https://arstechnica.com/cars/2016/05/turbulent-times-for-for...
- ddeck 9y agoNo it's not, but keep in mind that the cars accelerate at an average of around 1.45g. If it weren't for the inability to transfer all of the power to motion (due to traction loss), they could accelerate from 0 to 100 kph (62 mph) in around 1 second. With the down force provided with increased speed, they actually accelerate faster from 100 to 200 kph (62 to 122 mph) than from 0 to 100 [1]: 0 to 100 km/h (62 mph): 2.4 seconds 0 to 200 km/h (124 mph): 4.4 seconds 0 to 300 km/h (186 mph): 8.4 seconds [1] 2016 Mercedes W07 (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Formula_One_car https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Formula_One_car)
- elorant 9y agoWell they're in par with fuel consumption of supercars. For example, a Lamborghini Aventador has 10 MPG, an Aston Martin V12 Vantage has 12 MPG, a Bentley Continental has 13, a Ferrari 488 GTB has 15,a McLaren 570GT has 16, a Mercedes AMG GT also has 16 as does a Nissan GT-R, and only Porsches get a tad above 20. Considering that none of the above could hold a candle to an F1 car, its fuel consumption doesn't sound too exotic.
- pmontra 9y agoInterestingly Ferrari missed the opportunity to pass Mercedes at a restart after a safety car late in the race [1] because software cut off one electrical motor close to the end of the main straight [2]. That was a common choice to preserve energy for other parts of the track. Still Mercedes has a button on the steering wheel to override the software and keep delivering power from all engines. That might have won the race for them. [1] https://youtu.be/rhmGaCjpoBY?t=4m20s https://youtu.be/rhmGaCjpoBY?t=4m20s (check the speeds and the nice 3-way pass behind the leaders) [2] http://www.motorsportmagazine.com/reports/f1/2017-belgian-grand-prix-report http://www.motorsportmagazine.com/reports/f1/2017-belgian-gr... at section "5) The crucial power de-rate"