6 ms·
>all launchers in Plasma have text search over name and description, so they're good there // I find this a bit lacking, for example there's a lot more apps li
by pbhjpbhj 9y ago
>all launchers in Plasma have text search over name and description, so they're good there //
I find this a bit lacking, for example there's a lot more apps listed under "audio" than "sound" yet for menu purposes, particularly discoverability, they should be treated as synonyms; one can't be expected to remember the precise adjective/noun used in an app description.
The thing I'd most like for the plasma menu is just to be able to alter it's size, corner drag hasn't existed in KDE menu for a long time now. I do a config file fix, which gets overwritten every update.
- toyg 9y ago> "audio" than "sound" yet for menu purposes, particularly discoverability, they should be treated as synonyms The answer for that has been staring us in the face since the 80s: good icons. I shouldn't have to navigate words, I should be able to navigate concepts and intuitions through icons that work at subliminal level. But good icons require good icon designers, which are few and far between; they require icon designer to work closely and in harmony with UI designers and developers, which is challenging; and they require a shared body of iconographic culture that is often impossible to achieve (e.g. a "rescue" concept could use a red cross in Europe / Americas / Australia, but it would have to be different in other continents).
- majewsky 9y agoThat brings you to the mess that is mobile app launchers. The problem is not whether the cue is visual or textual, the problem is that were cannot all agree on how to categorise thousands of apps in a way that is useful to all of us.
- toyg 9y ago> the mess that is mobile app launchers In the big picture, we've only been trying to do mobile launchers for about 10 years. 10 years after C, we were still very far from getting Python; it doesn't mean we should have stopped trying to make better high-level languages. I still think a purely-icon-based approach, possibly augmented with optional search, is the best option. IMHO Apple got it almost right with desktop Launchpad. Yeah, it takes the whole screen, but the human mind is single-task oriented - while you are launching an app you are not trying to also type out a document exactly at the same time, fullscreen is fine as long as it's dealt with it quickly enough to reduce the overall interruption to a minimum. Where launchpad fails is in having groups shown as a collection of miniaturized icons with associated (small) text, which is hard to grasp at a glance. It would be better if I could associate an icon to the group, maybe having it automatically suggested when you create the group. > the problem is that were cannot all agree on how to categorise thousands of apps I partially agree, but realistically speaking we've been failing to solve the taxonomy problem with documents for 50 years and we're still nowhere near having a solution (folders, tags, views, colors, whatever - someone will always disagree). I don't think we can (or should) wait for that to change before we can attack this problem.
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoIMO tags with filters is better than trying to create an applications hierarchy, particularly if you only place one link for each app in that hierarchy. Tags for function, and major alternatives are probably needed if you want a high degree of discoverability.
- majewsky 9y agoThis should work in Plasma app launchers. (If not, file a bug.) A .desktop file (which, among other things, registers apps with these launchers) has a GenericName field for precisely this purpose. For example, Name=Firefox GenericName=Web browser A possible source of error might be that the application developer did not enter a GenericName (or one that is not helpful, like "KDE clone of $gnome_app").
- digi_owl 9y agoUgh. That gets me thinking about how Gnome seems to play games with this. Take File Roller for example. Their git repository is names thus, the tar-balls are names thus, even the resulting binary is named thus. But the desktop file insists on calling it Archive Manager.
- majewsky 9y agoHaven't checked, but that's probably the GenericName. The question is what the launcher displays.
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoMy point is more that the approach (this isn't a good example, but i think it shows the problem) of having a single generic name is insufficient. Perhaps someone coming from another OS types "explorer" when looking for a browser, "zip" when looking for an archiver.
- digi_owl 9y agodesktop files as an idea seems fine, but as usual with Freedesktop stuff it seems to have wandered off into its own world of bike shedding.