8 ms·
> but will the executives involved be held to the same legal standard Yes, they will, but Germany will not extradite them. They already made that clear. And it
by rurban 9y ago
> but will the executives involved be held to the same legal standard
Yes, they will, but Germany will not extradite them. They already made that clear.
And it is very unlikely that the german court system will prosecute them. Haven't heard
anything yet, because this might inflict the politicians who backed this Diesel
emission testing system for decades. They didn't even go to the technical root yet.
Only one made the mistake to go for his holidays to Florida, so he was caught.
- okreallywtf 9y agoWhy will they not, do they fear they will not get a fair trial in the US or will be punished worse than their crimes dictate?
- quakeguy 9y agoIn the land of "rolling coal" (0.0), and no TÜV+AU (0),(1), any sudden punishment of violators from outside reeks of market protection. (0) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Technischer_Überwachungsverein https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Technischer_Überwachungsverein (1) https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abgasuntersuchung https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abgasuntersuchung (non english WP link, basically it means "emission checking") Edit: (0.0) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rolling_coal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rolling_coal
- wl 9y agoThere's a big difference between a few rednecks illegally modifying their personal vehicles and a company selling millions of vehicles that fail emissions standards and trying to cover it up.
- quakeguy 9y agoNot really, both are stupid and should be punished.
- dom0 9y ago> selling millions of vehicles VW sold approximately 475000 affected diesel vehicles in the US (compared to approx. 84.5 million car sales in the same time period).
- ams6110 9y agoThis has always been my problem with the whole case. Yes they violated the law and yes they probably should be some punishment but the real impact was almost nothing, the vehicles would have met the restrictions of only a few years prior, and the limits are almost entirely arbitrary and politically motivated.
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoI agree. If we weren't on a forum filled with mostly people from CA who take for granted things like byzantine HOA rules and intrusive bylaws we'd be questioning why emissions requirements made "screw it, we're cheating on this one" a defensible decision for anyone at VW. You shouldn't have to break the law to be competitive.
- simonh 9y agoHow many other car manufacturers broke the law in this way? We're none of the ones that didn't competitive? What a patently ridiculous argument.
- dom0 9y agoLast time I checked all tested diesel cars displayed anomalies between their supposed emissions and their actual emissions. So at this point: Likely all car makers. And while this hasn't been public knowledge, it is not that surprising, because it has been public knowledge how much the mileage tests are gamed, so it's not surprising that all other tests are gamed as well (and, specifically, using defeat devices is also illegal).
- 9y ago
- dubyah 9y ago"Rolling coal" remains an illegal modification, practiced by scofflaws. TÜVs are not immune to conflicts of interests.[0] And while generally not a separate sticker from annual car registrations, annual or biennial emissions testings are carried out by most states.[1] >any sudden punishment of violators from outside reeks of market protection. Perhaps it's because the EU lacks the authority of the member states to regulate & police emission laws. They started legal proceedings against their member states precisely because of their inaction. "The European Commission on Thursday began the so-called "infringement procedures," calling Germany, Britain, Spain and Luxembourg to account for not imposing the same kind of penalties Volkswagen faced in the United States for using illegal software to mask health-harming emissions."[2] Isn't that market protection as well? [0]: https://www.nytimes.com/2015/10/15/business/international/cozy-relations-complicate-europes-bid-for-new-car-tests.html https://www.nytimes.com/2015/10/15/business/international/co... [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vehicle_inspection_in_the_United_States#Jurisdictions_requiring_periodic_vehicle_emissions_inspections https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vehicle_inspection_in_the_Unit... [2]: http://www.dw.com/en/eu-launches-legal-case-against-germany-six-other-countries-over-vw-scandal/a-36690366 http://www.dw.com/en/eu-launches-legal-case-against-germany-...
- NegativeLatency 9y agoMost states emissions testing requirements are not stringent. Having lived in Washington, Oregon, and California I can say that WA's and OR's tests don't do much.
- sitkack 9y agoThis "hack" by VW should have been caught in weeks by the EPA. It was detected simply by driving the car around with a sensor in the tailpipe. And yes, when emissions testing switched to relying on the OBD codes, all was lost. Even I thought about hacking the ECU to report "all good"
- valuearb 9y agoThis intentional evasion of emissions standards couldn't have been caught by the EPA test process. That should be changed (which will open other doors for other ways to game the tests) but it doesn't have anything to do with VW's willful violation of the law.
- hueving 9y agoDid you even read the article about rolling coal? It's illegal in the US.
- DominikPeters 9y agoIf they are German citizens, then the German constitution prevents the state from extraditing them (to a non-EU country). https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/gg/art_16.html https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/gg/art_16.html
- vinay427 9y agoIt's strange to me that many countries sign "bilateral" extradition treaties with Germany or other countries with similar policies such as Brazil.
- leipert 9y agoWell. Is there any case where any western country did extradite their own citizen for non-spionage, non-military, non-war and non-capital crime? I hope not. I certainly do not approve of the scam and deception VW did (and possibly other automobile manufacturers?), but I think I do not approve extraditing citizens of your own country for some non-capital crime. Or even some capital crimes for that matter. I (and most of the other Germans and EU citizens [1]) oppose death penalties. So extraditing someone to the US, which could result in death penalty if someone committed a murder, would be a really big ethical and/or diplomatic issue. [1]: http://www.eidhr.eu/highlights/death-penalty http://www.eidhr.eu/highlights/death-penalty
- jburgess777 9y agoThere are several examples where the US has successfully extradited people from the UK on charges related to financial crimes: https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2016/nov/09/british-trader-pleads-guilty-to-wire-after-us-extradition https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2016/nov/09/british-trad... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NatWest_Three https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NatWest_Three The US doesn't always gets what it wants, for example with Gary McKinnon: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-19957138 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-19957138
- leipert 9y ago
- leipert 9y agoMaybe because the Volkswagen AG employs 0.6 million people worldwide, 220 thousand of them in Germany?
- rurban 9y agoIf the Volkswagen AG would be the only culprit. So far it looks like Audi persuaded Bosch to add the cheat detection code into it's ECU used in almost every Diesel car, and consequently almost every car was using it. The scandal is much bigger than VW.
- interfixus 9y agoHonestly, US penal standards are so out of whack with those of the rest of at least the "western" world, that no country ought ever consider extradition as an option.
- Tomte 9y agoOur constitution forbids extradition of citizens to foreign countries. There's an exception for other member states of the European Union, but that's it.
- rurban 9y agoBecause they knew it upfront. The whole Diesel testing system was rigged to eliminate costly end machine testing as done in the US, which historically led to costly cheating on the roll by the US manifacturers. They paid experts passing those tests which were paid as much as a Formula 1 driver. So the Europeans improved that to reproducible test cases, and much cheaper, only with the engine. So when the problem with the overly large AdBlue tanks came up, the Europeans knew they can cheat that away, because legally they thought they can get away with it. The engine test passed legally, and there was no legal framework to protect actual sold cars from emitting too much NOx. This is of course entirely the fault of the politicians, which were of course lobbied into that, and didn't ask much. That's why VW insisted all the time that they acted legally in Europe. In the US of course not, because in the US the big three always had the advantage of special drivers to pass the emission tests. So they still don't fear any legal woes in Europe. So the strategy is to keep calm, and protect the rest of the industry, the politicians, the workers, change the ECU's, and either add bigger tanks or change AdBlue more often. It's insane to ask for 2 years AdBlue storage anyway. 6 months if enough. And the good engines can pass the new EURO 6 limits, because their injection system is highly optimized. Those engines are miles better and more effective than a normal otto, which enables them to actually use the crap diesel oil. Problematic are only the overly large engines or the cheap ones.
- ythn 9y ago> And it is very unlikely that the german court system will prosecute them. Germany is cool that its citizens conducted international fraud at a scale the world has never seen?
- quakeguy 9y agoAnd the US is cool with "rolling coal" because....
- zimbu668 9y agoIn July 2014, the United States Environmental Protection Agency stated that the practice was illegal, as it violated the Clean Air Act which prohibits the manufacturing, sale, and installation "of a part for a motor vehicle that bypasses, defeats, or renders inoperative any emission control device [and] prohibits anyone from tampering with an emission control device on a motor vehicle by removing it or making it inoperable prior to or after the sale or delivery to the buyer." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rolling_coal#Legality https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rolling_coal#Legality
- icebraining 9y agoI love this bit (not a criticism, just find it amusing): "The bill was introduced by state Assemblyman Tim Eustace after a pickup truck blasted smoke at Eustace's Nissan Leaf while driving on the New Jersey Turnpike."
- johnbrodie 9y agoYou're comparing industry-wide fraud with an illegal practice that individual citizens do? I'd wager that there are easily 100,000 trucks on the road in the US for every one that can "roll coal".
- PhasmaFelis 9y ago...It's not? It's illegal here. It's not often punished just because (a) it's quite rare and (b) most police have better things to do than pulling some guy over and emissions-testing his car over something that looks like a simple engine problem. It's in the news because it's political, but it's not actually common at all.
- joering2 9y agoI must say I'm troubled about recent political situation in Germany.. for so many years they been a real good example in Europe how to lead, despite the fact they start the WW2. But now there is no free speech (you cannot shout Heil Hitler - that might be long prison sentence) and just recently there been article here how Germany court system doesn't believe in freedom of speech. Now this. If there truly won't be any consequences for those involved (or extradited) then I really put Germany next to Russia, Ukraine and Kazakstan, and will make sure all my friends and family avoid it during their travel plans.
- eropple 9y agoGermany has had laws against Nazi symbolism and activity for decades. This isn't new. "Now there is no free speech" is the rewriting of history--and it smells pretty disingenuous. And Reporters Without Borders ranks Germany sixteenth in the world as far as press freedom goes. The United States is forty-third, behind such leading lights as Belize and Burkina Faso. The understanding that is that support of Nazism serves primarily as a declaration of the intent to commit violence, and the state reacting thereto, sure doesn't seem to be a problem.
- icebraining 9y agoIn fact, they've had laws against Nazi symbolism since the US imposed it on them. From an article of the TIME from 1946: To re-educate Germany, the Allies last week adopted a typically Nazi device. The four-power Coordinating Committee decided to reduce to pulp all "undemocratic, militaristic and Nazi" literature, museum and library material, newspapers, films and war memorials. (...) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Denazification#Censorship https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Denazification#Censorship
- simonh 9y agoMaking a few specific Nazi phrases illegal doesn't meant there is 'no free speech'.
- blubb-fish 9y agoAww - come on Winterkorn is already punished enough - his company pension is dire 3100 Euro. [1] [1]:http://www.faz.net/aktuell/wirtschaft/unternehmen/ex-vw-chef-martin-winterkorn-soll-3100-euro-rente-bekommen-14604034.html http://www.faz.net/aktuell/wirtschaft/unternehmen/ex-vw-chef...
- skhro87 9y ago.... a day
- smnscu 9y agoPer day. For reference, that is €1,131,500 or $1,350,000 per year. > You’re in the top 0.007% richest people in the world by income. > That makes you the 428,441st richest person on earth by income. I'm really disappointed with Germany on this one, but it makes sense since VAG were buddy buddies with Merkel & co. since time immemorial (makes sense since it's a powerful force for the economy, still despicable). If you kill a couple of people you go to jail or might even get executed. If you kill 1200+ you get early retired on a comfy stipend. http://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1748-9326/aa5987 http://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1748-9326/aa5987
- madez 9y ago> If you kill a couple of people you go to jail or might even get executed. If you kill 1200+ you get early retired on a comfy stipend. This falsely looks like a good point. Cars kill a lot of people by virtue of accidents. Does that mean cars are a bad thing? You see, just because something inevitably kills people in practice it isn't automatically a bad thing. What you need to balance it with is the good it brings compared to the alternatives. Your point makes a comparison between killing a couple of people for no good and the effect of cars and their exhaust. Your point is bad.