6 ms·
> A lot of expats here complain about the stamp system, but when they get their bank to use their signature instead, they complain that the bank actually verifi
by ekianjo 9y ago
> A lot of expats here complain about the stamp system, but when they get their bank to use their signature instead, they complain that the bank actually verifies the signature, and I've heard stories of people refilling out the same form 3 times just to get their signature to match the one on file!
This happened to me several times. That's because they use a machine to verify differences in signatures and as long as the machines do not OK the operation you have to retry. It's retarded, because that verification is made for stamps and not signatures and therefore it probably is not trained properly for the subtles differences in signatures from one to the next.
And the stamp system in Japan is retarded anyway, because it's super easy to reproduce one's stamp if you have a paper with that imprint lying around. It's not like the stamp is precise at the nanometer level or something.
> how useful are signatures going to be?
I dont even know why we need signatures honestly - at the bank you should be able to present your national ID or passport and that should be sufficient. And nobody writes checks anymore anyway.
- tajen 9y agoMeanwhile, Estonia has a digital certificate on the chipset of their ID card for all their citizen... https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Estonian_ID_card https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Estonian_ID_card
- aikinai 9y agoJapan has this too now, but it's pretty new and not required so not everyone has one yet. If you do have it, you can use it to print super official documents at the convenience store and pay your taxes online (if you get a chip reader for your computer).* *I know in the US you can pay taxes online with just some personal info for verification, but for some reason Japan is super serious about verifying online financial transactions. https://www.kojinbango-card.go.jp/en/kojinbango/index.html https://www.kojinbango-card.go.jp/en/kojinbango/index.html
- marak830 9y agoOh I didn't hear about this. Thanks for the link!
- ivanhoe 9y agoI never understood why official institutions are so concerned about verifications when you're the one giving them money? And they all do this, the same thing is here where I live. I understand the need for a positive identification when you're buying something, but for paying taxes? What, someone will go around and pay other people's taxes? And even so, why the government cares, as long as it's paid?
- kalleboo 9y agoIt's not actually for paying taxes, it's for filing taxes. If someone filed a fraudulent tax report in your name you could be liable ("I made zero dollars last year!"). Actually paying the taxes can be done in cash anonymously at a post office bank teller (or at a convenience store for municipal taxes)
- kobeya 9y ago> I dont even know why we need signatures honestly - at the bank you should be able to present your national ID or passport and that should be sufficient Because those don't exist in the US. We don't have national IDs and not everyone is eligible for a passport.
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoPassports are really expensive in the UK too, are they affordable in USA?
- throwaway049 9y agoA UK passport costs £72.50 and is valid for 10 years. For someone taking one budget package holiday per year it represents about 2 percent of the cost. This seems inexpensive to me.
- kobeya 9y agoAffordability is not the point. Not everyone is _allowed_ a passport. You can't get a passport if, for example, you have outstanding criminal charges that you are awaiting trial for on bail. Should that prevent you from being able to get or use a bank account? You might need that to be able to pay a lawyer.
- slapshot 9y ago>It's retarded >is retarded It's 2017. This type of ableist language should not be socially acceptable anymore, anymore than calling something the n-word as an adjective. Differing abilities should not be an insult.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- OtterCoder 9y agoIt's 2017, you should be mature enough to shrug off language like this, and distinguish between slang and formal meaning. Differing ability always becomes an insult, and if you knew anything about the march of language, you'd know that this is a treadmill you cannot catch up with. It's not language I use or agree with, but my opinion isn't going to change something that turns out to be fundamental to how people communicate. You need to learn how to live and let live.
- maccard 9y agoThe UK had no national ID card, and people certainly do write cheques (although I wish they'd stop)