6 ms·
Per glindahl's comment from earlier, if we established a space elevator for the moon[1] it would make the delta-v issues moot. Drop off an pick up supplies at t
by ChuckMcM 9y ago
Per glindahl's comment from earlier, if we established a space elevator for the moon[1] it would make the delta-v issues moot. Drop off an pick up supplies at the elevator while swinging by on an continuous Earth/Moon translunar orbit.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lunar_space_elevator https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lunar_space_elevator
- computerex 9y agoThe space elevator even on Earth in GEO is a hopeless, fool's dream.
- nine_k 9y agoOn Earth, it's hard to build due to much higher gravity, higher required orbit, and the atmosphere. Getting much shorter lengths of much less strong fiber to Moon may be more realistic than 20.000 km of super strong carbon fiber to GEO.
- danielbarla 9y agoI'm not too clued up on the topic, but I was under the impression that a lunar elevator would potentially require much longer cables than on Earth (primarily due to the lack of spin of the moon). From the Wikipedia article [1] > There are two points in space where an elevator's docking port could maintain a stable, lunar-synchronous position: the Earth-Moon Lagrange points L1 and L2. L1 is 56,000 km away from the Earth-facing side of the Moon, (at the lunar equator) and L2 is 67,000 km from the center of the Moon's far side, in the exact opposite direction <snip /> > Both of these positions are substantially farther up than the 36,000 km from Earth to geostationary orbit. Furthermore, the weight of the limb of the cable system extending down to the Moon would have to be balanced by the cable extending further up, and the Moon's slow rotation means the upper limb would have to be much longer than for an Earth-based system, or be topped by a much more massive counterweight. To suspend a kilogram of cable or payload just above the surface of the Moon would require 1,000 kg of counterweight, 26,000 km beyond L1. So, we're talking an ~80,000 km one? [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lunar_space_elevator https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lunar_space_elevator
- nine_k 9y agoThis is correct, unlike my assumption of a shorter cable above. OTOH due to lower gravity, the tensile strength required is still much lower. To quote the very article you lonked: > the engineering requirements for constructing a lunar elevator system can be met using currently available materials and technology.
- computerex 9y agoSo what you are saying is that a space elevator is theoretically possible. I think that's step 0 in building something. Being theoretically possible is the most basic prerequisite. Just because something is theoretically possible doesn't mean it's feasible or practical to build in real life. For example, we have known that it's theoretically possible to build vacuume sealed trains, aka the hyperloop, since before the first airplane took flight. And yet whilst you see planes fly everywhere, you don't see any vacuum sealed trains.
- lorenzhs 9y agoA lunar space elevator is feasible with today's materials (just a whole lot of them, way too much for current technology to transport to the moon). Here's a nice talk by Markus Landgraf, a mission planner at ESA, at 33c3: https://media.ccc.de/v/33c3-8407-an_elevator_to_the_moon_and_back https://media.ccc.de/v/33c3-8407-an_elevator_to_the_moon_and...
- computerex 9y agoIt's not just about the tensile strength of the materials. The dynamics of a lunar elevator necessitates and extraordinary amount of weight to be used as a counterweight nevermind the length of the cables themselves. Just because something ticks the checkbox of being theoretically possible doesn't mean it's practical or feasible to build. Maybe in a few hundred years we'll have the means to build something on that scale. It still takes $10k to put 1kg in LEO, imagine the cost of transferring to the Lagrange points.
- lorenzhs 9y agoSure, the amount of materials needed exceeds what current technology can get even into LEO by several orders of magnitude. Nobody's proposing to actually build a lunar space elevator. All I'm saying is that a super-advanced civilisation could theoretically build one from the materials available to us today, which is not true for a space elevator from the Earth's surface.
- stcredzero 9y agoif we established a space elevator for the moon Wouldn't you get the same benefit from a Mass Driver, since the moon is a vacuum body?
- ChuckMcM 9y agoA mass driver doesn't let you land cargo. But as a way to get raw material off the Moon it is an excellent solution.
- tveita 9y agoYou could run the mass driver in reverse for landing, but you'd have to aim well.
- adrianN 9y agoThat would be an amazing feat with the risk of destroying an extremely expensive piece of equipment.
- stcredzero 9y agoIs it any more amazing than doing an orbital rendezvous?
- adrianN 9y agoYou brake before getting close to whatever you want to rendevous with. You couldn't brake if you wanted to hit the nozzle of your mass driver to use it for braking.
- stcredzero 9y agoYou brake before getting close to whatever you want to rendevous with. This makes me question whether you actually understand how orbital rendezvous works. How about as an exercise, you explain why I would say this. Otherwise, I think the resulting conversation would be tiresome and not worth my time.
- aptwebapps 9y agoThere would still be some delta-v. Anyone have a handle on how much? I'm too lazy to look up the data and do the math.
- persimmon_b 9y agoTranslunar injection needs about 10.8 km/s, Earth's escape velocity is 11.2 km/s.
- aptwebapps 9y agoI mean to hook up with the elevator.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoFirst, I've neither done the requisite orbital mechanics calculations nor have I simulated this. But with that caveat, this is how I imagine it would work. Assuming your tug is in the translunar orbit (going in a figure 8 around the Moon and Earth with the intersection being the Earth-Moon L1 point. And assuming the tug is significantly more massive than your cargo. As you cross the L1 point you can use a mass driver on the tug to 'shoot' the cargo out behind you which would decelerate it to a low delta-v relative to the elevator base (and slightly boost the tug on its way) and when you came around the other side you hook the cargo through a loop like the old mail planes did [1] and pulling it away (which would impart a small deceleration on the tug as it headed back to earth). Depending on masses and how closely you could match things, the amount of delta-v you would need for the tug to keep its orbit true should be very manageable. [1] https://postalmuseum.si.edu/collections/object-spotlight/skyhooking-container.html https://postalmuseum.si.edu/collections/object-spotlight/sky...
- Dylan16807 9y agohttp://i.imgur.com/SqdzxzF.png http://i.imgur.com/SqdzxzF.png You might save 2km/s if you can use an elevator on the moon. Which is not a lot compared to a space elevator on Earth, but it would definitely be useful. That could be half your delta-v budget if you're going between the moon's surface and an orbit around Earth/Mars/Venus.