8 ms·
It's questionable that it's really much lower cost. The Moon, as a vacuum body, doesn't give the option of aerobraking or atmospheric entry, which dramatically
by Robotbeat 9y ago
It's questionable that it's really much lower cost. The Moon, as a vacuum body, doesn't give the option of aerobraking or atmospheric entry, which dramatically reduces delta-V. You can get a payload to Mars' surface with less propellant than getting it to the Moon's surface. And because atmosphere is everywhere (which includes oxygen in the form of CO2 and also water vapor), propellant is way easier to make, so it's easier to get your ship back.
Transit time is lower, but the currency of space travel is delta-V, and by that measure, Mars is just as close or closer.
I would guess that the Moon still slightly wins as far as transport costs, but the advantage is much smaller than you'd think, and the far greater resources available on Mars (as well as effective immunity to solar particle events and micrometeorites that Mars' atmosphere provides) tilts the situation strongly in favor of Mars for actual settlement. Joy trips may be cheaper to the Moon, however.
- sunflowerfly 9y agoFor me the real advantage of a moon base first is safety. If something goes horribly wrong while we are learning to live on other planets, a return to earth or a rescue mission takes far less time. I am not a space expert though, so perhaps this is wrong?
- escape_goat 9y agoI have head that moon dust is reputed to be a consideration, as it creates a type of environmental problem that would not be as extensive a problem on Mars. My understanding is that, due to a lack of fluid and chemical erosion, it tends to be extremely fine and abrasive, and it clings to everything due to static charge, making it hard to keep out of compartments and machinery. They're both definitely too far for a rescue mission or evacuation that wasn't planned for in advance. In terms of the old eggs/basket metaphor, it becomes a question of whether you want to use half your straw to weave a second basket, just in case the first one breaks, or if you want to use all of the straw to make your one basket as strong, redundant, and well designed as possible.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- boznz 9y agomelt sand it turns into smooth glass, wondering if you couldnt do something similar with a few focused mirrors
- njarboe 9y agoAs NASA has shown in the 30 years, "safety first" does not work as a prime directive, if you want to advance space travel. Musk stated in a recent talk with NASA,"Going to Mars is not for the faint of heart." and "If safety is your top goal, I wouldn't go to Mars." [1] https://youtu.be/Jv5LjA62Uw8?t=3480 https://youtu.be/Jv5LjA62Uw8?t=3480 [2] https://youtu.be/Jv5LjA62Uw8?t=3644 https://youtu.be/Jv5LjA62Uw8?t=3644
- pjmorris 9y ago'Apollo: Race to the Moon' by Murray and Cox described how the Apollo engineers drew their priorities from Kennedy's speech: Man. Moon. Decade, in that order. There's a difference between genuine safety and bureaucratic safety, something NASA has admittedly forgotten.
- passivepinetree 9y agoYour assertion about getting to Mars with less propellant is super interesting. Can you provide a source for me?
- hoorayimhelping 9y agofewer than twenty five seconds of googling: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Delta-v_budget https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Delta-v_budget From LEO to the surface of the moon is 5.9 km/s From LEO to the surface of Mars is 4.1 km/s
- dwringer 9y agoUnless I'm misreading something, both the text and graphic of that page seem to indicate it's 4.1km/s from low Mars orbit to the surface of Mars. I can't find anywhere saying it's 4.1 from LEO.
- Kubuxu 9y agoI get 2.5+0.7+0.6=3.8 to get into Mars Transfer from LEO. If we were to execute perfect aerobraking, the rest would be free. It for sure wouldn't be perfect so some fuel will be needed but not that much. Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Delta-v_budget#Delta-vs_between_Earth.2C_Moon_and_Mars https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Delta-v_budget#Delta-vs_betwee...
- i2shar 9y ago[To put things in perspective] travel time to the Moon is about 3 days, Mars would be about 150 to 300 days (source: Google).
- Tepix 9y agoYou don't have to use the cheapest, but slowest Hohmann transfer orbit to get to your destination. You can also spend more fuel and get there faster.
- Dylan16807 9y agoA bit of searching suggests that a mildly increased delta-v budget can get your half-year trip down to a quarter-year, but beyond that you're looking at ridiculous costs.
- Fej 9y agoMars has the radiation problem while in-transit, which is still unsolved. We have already gone to the Moon. Given that the travel time is relatively short, radiation is far less of a concern. This is why the Moon is attractive. We know how to get there already and it's not too difficult, all things considered. The problem of how to get there and back with humans aboard has already been solved. It's never been done to Mars.
- Mtinie 9y agoWithout a magnetosphere isn't solar radiation a problem, long-term on the Moon?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- hwillis 9y agosolved by piling dirt over the habitat
- flashdance 9y agoFun fact incoming: there is a mini-magnetosphere centered around Mare Crisium on the Moon. http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1029/2009GL041721/abstract;jsessionid=1DCF99B6136DB85166DC63391AE9C980.f03t04 http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1029/2009GL041721/abst... It's only 360km across though...
- dredmorbius 9y agoTMA-1. Erm, CMA-1.
- adrianN 9y agoIMHO the radiation problem is solved by telling the astronauts that a journey to Mars increases their risk of dying of cancer in the next ten years by 30% or whatever the right number is and asking for volunteers. I'm pretty sure you'd find plenty. I would go, for example.
- 9y ago
- ChuckMcM 9y agoPer glindahl's comment from earlier, if we established a space elevator for the moon[1] it would make the delta-v issues moot. Drop off an pick up supplies at the elevator while swinging by on an continuous Earth/Moon translunar orbit. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lunar_space_elevator https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lunar_space_elevator
- computerex 9y agoThe space elevator even on Earth in GEO is a hopeless, fool's dream.
- nine_k 9y agoOn Earth, it's hard to build due to much higher gravity, higher required orbit, and the atmosphere. Getting much shorter lengths of much less strong fiber to Moon may be more realistic than 20.000 km of super strong carbon fiber to GEO.
- danielbarla 9y agoI'm not too clued up on the topic, but I was under the impression that a lunar elevator would potentially require much longer cables than on Earth (primarily due to the lack of spin of the moon). From the Wikipedia article [1] > There are two points in space where an elevator's docking port could maintain a stable, lunar-synchronous position: the Earth-Moon Lagrange points L1 and L2. L1 is 56,000 km away from the Earth-facing side of the Moon, (at the lunar equator) and L2 is 67,000 km from the center of the Moon's far side, in the exact opposite direction <snip /> > Both of these positions are substantially farther up than the 36,000 km from Earth to geostationary orbit. Furthermore, the weight of the limb of the cable system extending down to the Moon would have to be balanced by the cable extending further up, and the Moon's slow rotation means the upper limb would have to be much longer than for an Earth-based system, or be topped by a much more massive counterweight. To suspend a kilogram of cable or payload just above the surface of the Moon would require 1,000 kg of counterweight, 26,000 km beyond L1. So, we're talking an ~80,000 km one? [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lunar_space_elevator https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lunar_space_elevator
- danblick 9y agoAre you assuming travel is one-way? That seems okay for probes and maybe problematic for people. Although the poor slob plan comes to mind: https://books.google.com/books?id=7ejGJaFjLccC&lpg=PA154&ots=_saq_k6kNC&dq=poor%20slob%20moon&pg=PA154#v=onepage&q=poor%20slob%20moon&f=false https://books.google.com/books?id=7ejGJaFjLccC&lpg=PA154&ots...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]