2 ms·
It Seems like some sort of Neilson Ratings System would be more representative than basing it purely on sales. Or lower the bulk threshold to one. Meaning a si
by briandear 9y ago
It Seems like some sort of Neilson Ratings System would be more representative than basing it purely on sales.
Or lower the bulk threshold to one. Meaning a single sale of a title “counts” while >1 sales in a transaction counts as 1.
Buying 5 copies of one book doesn’t mean it’s being sold (or willingly read by) to 5 distinct people. So it’s popularity is really just “1” because only one person actually bought it.
That would be much harder to game since they would have to have a lot of single transactions to move the needle. Buying 29 at a time ought not count as 29 sales even though it technically IS 29 sales. But the intent of the Bestseller list is to determine popularity, not necessarily “units moved” otherwise, why disqualify bulk sales? Those ARE sales right? But the NY Times does have a bulk purchase flag which means the list isn’t about volume, but about perceived popularity.
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoOur pastor bought our whole (small) congregation a particular book to read a little while back, it seems equally to fail to report that as a sale of 1; just as much as registering the publisher buying their own book a hundred (thousand, ...) times. ... Cue a book buying app that reimburses the first n people to buy a book and scan the sales receipt in order to provide "genuine" sales for skewing popularity lists.
- mcphage 9y ago> Or lower the bulk threshold to one. Meaning a single sale of a title “counts” while >1 sales in a transaction counts as 1. Not knowing their data, it could be that they settled on 30 because reducing the number below that didn't change the results, and was more effort (ie, expensive) to tabulate.