18 ms·
I've always been more excited about a Moon colony than a Mars one. I mean, compared to Mars, the Moon is ridiculously close. Many of the same benefits Musk se
by tambourine_man 9y ago
I've always been more excited about a Moon colony than a Mars one.
I mean, compared to Mars, the Moon is ridiculously close.
Many of the same benefits Musk seeks (backup for Civilization, excitement) for a fraction of the cost.
Low gravity and atmosphere on a dome would be more complicated, but again, compared to Mars, it's right there.
It would be a more humble and realistic first step, IMO.
- overcast 9y agoYeh seriously, I've always said it as well. Establish a base there first, figure out what works, and what doesn't work. I really think Mars is just too much, too fast. It's way too harsh, and a one way trip. At least we can realistically send help to the moon. I'm guessing the long 28 day(day) cycle is the biggest issue, along with few natural resources.
- QAPereo 9y agoInasmuch as Mars with our current technology offers no back up for civilization, the same can certainly be said for the moon. I would argue over that the moon actually has some benefits Mars lacks, in addition to proximity it has a much lesser gravitational field and therefore a much lower delta V. Moon colony could realistically jumpstart space and vacuum industries beyond LEO, and frankly it would probably give us a chance to test the many technologies we'd eventually need on Mars without having to actually make the trip to Mars. Most of all the moon would be an excellent way station for asteroid mining .
- athenot 9y agoWhen the topic of Backup for Civilization comes up, instead of Wall-E, I tend to think of Elysium, i.e. the backup option is only for the wealthy, leaving the rest in a worse state. https://www.space.com/22287-elysium-space-station-science-nasa.html https://www.space.com/22287-elysium-space-station-science-na...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- QAPereo 9y agoAt this point, no amount of money will save you, we need Earth for food at the very least. That may change, but not soon.
- kbenson 9y ago> the backup option is only for the wealthy, leaving the rest in a worse state. Like most technology, it flows from the rich to the poor eventually as it becomes cheaper. The important part you omitted is that it leaves the rest in a worse relative state. Their absolute state is no worse, and likely better. Arguing against a backup for civilization (or more appropriately, a backup for the species) because it will be used by the rich is like arguing against a cure for cancer because the rich will benefit before anyone else. In the end, a cure existing still drastically increases the chance the poor might be able to make use of it, from zero to some non-zero amount. This is all also ignoring the fact that when it comes to species level propagation and survival, I would rather Hitler and his closest Nazi associates makes it off world sustainably in the event of a species level disaster than nobody. My commitment to making sure Humanity survives is much more than my commitment to ensuring we are a caring and accepting civilization. We can rediscover valuing life, but once we're gone, the chances we are coming back are essentially nil.
- ribosometronome 9y agoWhy is humanity's survival important?
- kbenson 9y agoIt's important for the exact same reason you're able to ask that question. Without humanity, who asks why? Humanity is, to the best of our knowledge, the best and possibly only chance of increasing understanding of the universe. I care about that, as well as about our species generally in what is likely an evolved and chemically reinforced way. At some point that may be less true, and I would care less (but would still care). At a meta level, if you truly don't care about the survival of your species (even if only through the survival of your own relatives and loved ones), you're an evolutionary dead end.
- Obi_Juan_Kenobi 9y agoMars has atmosphere for aerobraking and ISRU possibilities that the moon does not. In many ways, it is much more practical from a spaceflight standpoint. That's not to say that there aren't possibilities for both, but Mars is seen as the preferred choice for a variety of sound reasons.
- keenerd 9y agoThe Martian atmosphere is next to worthless for aerobraking human-scale infrastructure. One of the most significant points in the Moon's favor is the (relative) ease with which a space elevator could be built. It doesn't need unobtainium, current structural materials are strong enough.
- simonh 9y agoSpaceX have run the simulations and while Red Dragon is possible, there's no way they can adapt Dragon to land on the Moon without adding an extra stage. That difference is entirely down to Aerobraking. Even the thin atmosphere of Mars makes a huge difference. Anyone who plays KSP can confirm this for you, especially using the Real Solar System mod, though the same lessson is apparent even in the stock game.
- keenerd 9y agoWe can also look at delta-V charts. Earth to the Moon is like 16.4km/s, Earth to Mars is like 14.3km/s using every available aerobraking opportunity (6.4km/s saved) and assuming 500m/s for the final powered landing. (The Red Dragon plan called for aerobraking from 6km/s to 540m/s and then switching to thrusters.) Is that 2.1km/s really a whole extra stage? Or can it be met by reducing cargo capacity somewhat? Two interesting points about Red Dragon - it wasn't feasible to put parachutes on it so its aerobraking would have been greatly limited. It wouldn't have much surface to use for deceleration in that case. I'm curious just how long it would have spent aerobraking, SpaceX's docs don't seem to mention that. And it was cancelled a few months ago with the intent of designing a "vastly" heavier lander, for which aerobraking will be that much less practical. edit: But I can do a back of the envelope calculation. Decelerating 6500kg from 6km/s to 540m/s is 116G joules. The diameter is 3.6 meters so a molecule of air in from of the Dragon would be displaced (on average) 0.53 meters. Let's assume the atmosphere is a constant density (0.020 kg/m^3). Assume a drag coefficient of 0.05 (and ignoring the lifting body effect) that is around 200kN of force, tapering down to 1.5kN. That is like 3000 km of aerobraking at maximum atmospheric density and should take around 2300 seconds. But that depends a lot on the deorbit profile. I'm going to need a bigger simulation...
- WalterBright 9y agoYou can also rotate the crew on the moon. Can send things to the moon you didn't anticipate. Can send replacement/repair parts. Can't do that for Mars.
- pc86 9y agoOf course you can, it just takes a few orders of magnitude longer.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- frandroid 9y agoIf the one specialist in your mission dies and it takes 8 years to send a new one, that's not called an effective replacement.
- Teever 9y agoHas it ever taken 8 years to send something to the moon?
- ryandrake 9y agoAt least in the US, if we urgently needed to send something to the moon in 8 years, we would not be able to do it. Between politically making it happen, deciding who spends the money on it, choosing a contractor that represents the right disadvantaged special interest group, years of contract negotiation, town hall discussions, environmental impact studies, project management failures, budget overruns, pork barrel carve-outs and jobs programs for various congresspeople's districts, etc. it would take way more than 8 years.
- khedoros1 9y agoDepending on how you count, e.g. May 1961 (Freedom 7 flight) to July 1969 (Apollo 11 flight), yes.
- 9y ago
- nolok 9y agoEspecially since a Moon colony would make building and sending future stuff sooo much easier, a very big part of what we work on now and what costs us money (the big decider, whether we like it or not) is "how do we get that off of Earth and into space". If we could assemble on the Moon first, Mars and beyond would be much easier to reach. And for almost everything that is not launching related (radiation, resources, ...) a Moon colony faces the same difficulties with better recovery possibilities in case of catastophic failure, so it's a better learning ground (I mean, if your food producing bio dome or whatever dies for some reason you probably want to be on the Moon with emergency supply very close rather than out there on Mars). The only downside I see is that a Moon colony would not offer the same quality of "backup for civilization" as Mars would, and it's also a harder sell on the public and politician I think.
- yulaow 9y agoI think the 0-step should be a sort of treaty to decide which set of laws and jurisdiction should have a space colony on the moon. Not easily solvable
- rothbardrand 9y agoIt wouldn't really be relevant. For why, read The Moon is a Harsh Mistress. TLDR: The moon colony will be able to make its own rules and keep earth at bay.
- jfolkins 9y agoOne of my all time favorite books. I like how the power roles between the sexes on the moon are reversed too. The matriarch has all the power because women are scarce and they take on many husbands out of this need. They always hold the cards and culturally everyone accepts this. Also, because the value of women is so high no man ever dares attack one less they be sent out an airlock. It is cultural justice. No trial. A man just knows that if he is seen assaulting a woman, he is dead. The community can't afford to lose a single female. Plus with all the talk of the A.I. Armageddon the book plays right into that discussion.
- pm90 9y agoMany societies have historically been matriarchal. It just happened that Christianity, Islam (maybe Judaism? not sure...) were patriarchal and societies that embraces these religions came to dominate most of the other society/ peoples. I do hope the future will be more "centrist", neither patriarchal nor matriarchal.
- bluGill 9y agoThe American west was once very lopsided as well, males became cowboys and the women rarely traveled west. In one generation the few women out west had equal numbers of both gender kids and now that history is not important to the culture. The book is interesting, but it was written for a society that doesn't exist. Women and men will not be as lopsided in a colony. The first few ships might be mostly male construction workers, but after that expect to see a much closer balance.
- munificent 9y agoPeople way underestimate how far away Mars is. To give you a sense of scale, the settlers of Jamestown came from London. As the crow flies, that's about 3,790 miles. If we treat that as equivalent to settling on Mars, then for them to settle on "the moon" would have been a mere 26 miles from London. Perhaps Canvey Island on the River Thames. If we can't manage settlements that close, we really aren't ready yet for the long voyage across the sea.
- andars 9y agoIn terms of distance, sure. In terms of delta-v, the budget for the moon is upwards of 50% that for Mars. EDIT: The 50% figure is from memory, and upon further reflection is probably not quite right, so take it with a grain of salt. I just wanted to point out that distance is not the only relevant metric.
- zamalek 9y agoIt makes much more sense to use the moon as a stepping rock. At least my KSP experience has taught me that :)
- rory096 9y ago>The 50% figure is from memory, and upon further reflection is probably not quite right, so take it with a grain of salt. You're actually underestimating. Mars has an atmosphere, so spacecraft can use aerobraking to significantly reduce the delta-v required to get there. The moon has no such benefit — propulsion is required all the way to the surface. The advantage of the moon, of course, is that it's not limited to transfer windows every two years. If there's an emergency or resupply is needed (or you just want to expand the mission), another lander can be sent at any time. (With some restrictions, like hitting your desired landing spot and making sure the sun wasn't in the Apollo crews' eyes at landing. But regardless, no longer than 28 days between windows.)
- adekok 9y agoMars is effectively a vacuum (for people purposes) anyways, just like the moon. And both are bone-dry, which means lots of static charges when you go outside. The main difference is that Mars has sufficient weather that the dust is roundish, whereas the moon dust is composed of extremely sharp shards. IMHO, if we can't make a go of it on the moon, we have no business going to Mars.
- quotha 9y agoYou know there is water on both right?
- hutzlibu 9y agojust like there is water in the most arid deserts on earth ... and still they are a jungle compared to moon and mars. So I think, boone-dry is a quite correct description ...
- bhnmmhmd 9y agoAlthough the Moon is much closer and "right there" for us, it's subject to numerous meteoric incidents, some of which are disastrous enough to wipe out any settlement we set up there. Moreover, only half of the Moon sees the light of the Sun. This fact alone reduces available surface for settlements to only half of the Moon. While the Moon could be a temporary backup plan, in the long-term, you're going to need to terraform a planet and make a suitable atmosphere, both of which are not possible to do to the Moon. Edit: Thanks to the commentators below who mentioned that while the Moon is tidally locked to the Earth, most of its surface does indeed receive light from the Sun. Only one question though: If that is true, then why do they call it "the dark side of the Moon"? (Honest question)
- omellet 9y agoIt's tidally locked, so you couldn't you put the settlement on the Earth-facing side and not have to worry as much about meteors?
- antaviana 9y agoWell, it's like holding a shield of a radius of only 6,371 km with an arm of 384,400 km long. Or to put it in human terms, like holding a shield of 1.25 cm of radius with your arm of 75 cm. It will not protect you really very much.
- holtalanm 9y agoI was thinking the same thing. Earth will shield the moon on the Earth-side, mostly.
- christophilus 9y agoThat seems to make sense, but if you look at the moon from Earth, you see an awful lot of craters...
- jgh 9y ago> Moreover, only half of the Moon sees the light of the Sun. I'm no astronomer but the moon is tidally locked to the earth and not the sun, which means that the moon should have sunrises/sunsets...
- needcheapbw 9y agoAgree with all of that, been saying it for years. Even people who aren't into the whole space exploration thing do agree that the Moon would be much better for the foreseeable future.
- gens 9y agoThe biggest problem is getting into orbit. https://api.media.ccc.de/v/31c3_-_6180_-_en_-_saal_2_-_201412271830_-_rocket_science_how_hard_can_it_be_-_david_madlener https://api.media.ccc.de/v/31c3_-_6180_-_en_-_saal_2_-_20141... Around 19'th minute. Then again, Mars is far so it would take some time to get there. Then again again, most of the ships wouldn't have to have people aboard. Edit: It helps that Mars has an atmosphere of sorts.
- perseusprime11 9y agoSo, why is Elon Musk not excited about Moon?
- boznz 9y agoAs an amateur Musk watcher I actually think he will be interested in the moon or more likely some sort of permanent space station as I think he's only now realizing how difficult mars would be as a first goal (also he's very good at surprises)
- Nimitz14 9y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=plTRdGF-ycs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=plTRdGF-ycs
- tambourine_man 9y agoI have to admit I was initially put off by the guy's voice and hair, but it's a thrilling talk. When he says the real science is on Mars, though, I'd raise the challenge and say it's on Europa, Enceladus, Io, Ganymede and Callisto. I mean hot oceans protected from radiation through tick ice. What else do you need? We may find fossil and even bacterial life on Mars (and that would possibly be the greatest human discovery yet), but I bet we can find a thriving ecosystem full of complex multicelular life on one of those Moons.
- woranl 9y agoI rather have Civilization backup in Mars. If the Earth goes, the Moon wouldn't be in a very good shape. Just like I wouldn't go hide in the kitchen, while the living room is burning down.
- hnlmorg 9y agoThis is one of the biggest points people miss when talking about civilization back ups. I tend to think of it in IT terms: the moon is like an offline but onsite backup. It will protect you from most internal cockups where as Mars is more like an offsite backup which will protect you should your building (Earth) get taken out
- andyfal12 9y agoMeteor impacts and supervolcanoes seem to be the near-term worst case scenarios, neither which change the state of living on the moon. I don't know that the metaphor of them being under the same roof works.
- hnlmorg 9y agoI know the risks are astronomical (literally), but anything significant enough to alter Earth's mass would also alter the moons orbit. I just think if we are talking about an extraterrestrial base for the sake of "backing up" the human race then it is prudent to pick a location that isn't in any way dependant on the master copy. However I appreciate other concerns also take priority as well (cost, practicality, etc) but if the topic were strictly just about backing up humanity then my ideal candidates would be Mars plus some location outside of our solar system. But I'm venturing well into the realm of sci-fi now.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- pcmaffey 9y agoWhat's the point of a backup though if you can't restore?
- ugh123 9y agoCloseness aside, the gravity on mars complicates a lot of things from landing to taking off - which currently dictates that this is a one-way trip. A moon base is much simpler in both scenarios and return trips are achievable (has already been done FORTY YEARS AGO).
- thescriptkiddie 9y agoI'm all for building Lunar outposts, but colonization is not really practial. Luna simply doesn't have the natural resources to sustain a civilization. Yes there is water in the regolith, but nowhere near as much as on Mars. And critically, Carbon, Nitrogen, Phosphorus, and Sulfur are only present in trace amounts. Nearly all of the elements essential to life will have to be imported, either from Earth, from Mars, or from asteroid miners. I'd love to visit, but nobody is going live there permanently any time soon.
- boznz 9y ago"Carbon, Nitrogen, Phosphorus, and Sulfur are only present in trace amounts" Is this because we havent found them yet, an educated guess or the moon somehow gets rid of these?
- fastball 9y agoIt's because the Moon lacks an atmosphere. CO (and then CO2) form at high temps, so elemental carbon doesn't have much chance to condensate to a "rock" form in regards to non-stellar celestial bodies. These float off into space, no atmosphere to contain them. At the temperatures/pressure of the moon, Nitrogen rapidly boils off and floats away as well. Not sure about Phosphorus and Sulfur, but I'm sure they can be either directly or indirectly related back to the moon's lack of an atmosphere as well.
- simonh 9y agoThe moon was mostly cast off from the Earths upper crust during an impact when earth was still forming. As a result it's mostly composed of lighter materials and lacks heavier metals and elements brought the the surface on Earth due to magma flows in the mantle and vulcanism.
- fastball 9y agoThe moon is a pretty terrible backup for Civilization. A lot of the things (majority) that would eradicate life on earth would also eradicate life on the moon.
- ajmurmann 9y agoSomeone else asked this as well but I haven't seen a good answer: what scenario destroys moon and earth but leaves Mars fine? I can think either of stuff that only impacts earth like meteors, nukes etc on one hand and issues like a supernova or a stray planet coming through the solar system on the other hand.
- Robotbeat 9y agoIt's questionable that it's really much lower cost. The Moon, as a vacuum body, doesn't give the option of aerobraking or atmospheric entry, which dramatically reduces delta-V. You can get a payload to Mars' surface with less propellant than getting it to the Moon's surface. And because atmosphere is everywhere (which includes oxygen in the form of CO2 and also water vapor), propellant is way easier to make, so it's easier to get your ship back. Transit time is lower, but the currency of space travel is delta-V, and by that measure, Mars is just as close or closer. I would guess that the Moon still slightly wins as far as transport costs, but the advantage is much smaller than you'd think, and the far greater resources available on Mars (as well as effective immunity to solar particle events and micrometeorites that Mars' atmosphere provides) tilts the situation strongly in favor of Mars for actual settlement. Joy trips may be cheaper to the Moon, however.
- sunflowerfly 9y agoFor me the real advantage of a moon base first is safety. If something goes horribly wrong while we are learning to live on other planets, a return to earth or a rescue mission takes far less time. I am not a space expert though, so perhaps this is wrong?
- escape_goat 9y agoI have head that moon dust is reputed to be a consideration, as it creates a type of environmental problem that would not be as extensive a problem on Mars. My understanding is that, due to a lack of fluid and chemical erosion, it tends to be extremely fine and abrasive, and it clings to everything due to static charge, making it hard to keep out of compartments and machinery. They're both definitely too far for a rescue mission or evacuation that wasn't planned for in advance. In terms of the old eggs/basket metaphor, it becomes a question of whether you want to use half your straw to weave a second basket, just in case the first one breaks, or if you want to use all of the straw to make your one basket as strong, redundant, and well designed as possible.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jshelly 9y agoI wonder if launching a trip to Mars would also be easier from the moon?
- njarboe 9y agoNo reason that 7 billion humans can't work towards both at the same time. Many technologies (like cheap, reusable heavy-lift rockets) will be useful for both. Bezos seems interested in the Moon and Musk in Mars, but I don't think you would hear either of them saying one place must have a colony before starting to work towards the other. Let a thousand flowers bloom.
- hyperpallium 9y agoAnd it's right bang smack in the habitable/goldilocks zone. Would digging a big valley (no dome), and putting air in it be ridiculously inefficient? Of course you'd lose some over time, but at what rate?
- elsonrodriguez 9y agoThe Moon can be useful as an outpost, like Antartica. In contrast Mars can be made into an actual home for us. Also, as others have pointed, closer/further is a tricky thing when talking about interplanetary travel: http://www.marssociety.org/home/about/faq/#Q12 http://www.marssociety.org/home/about/faq/#Q12 There's at least one colonization plan floating around using what's essentially Apollo-era hardware for getting to Mars for that Delta-v related reason.