15 ms·
I'm one of the people who severely dislikes AMP and I've always wanted to know: why not give me an option to disable it?
by MBCook 9y ago
I'm one of the people who severely dislikes AMP and I've always wanted to know: why not give me an option to disable it?
- jacquesm 9y agoBetter still: why not give you an option to enable it and default to normal.
- ehsankia 9y agoBecause the majority of people enjoy it? And the common user wants fast load and doesn't care about the philosophy of data retention and web ownership?
- mulmen 9y agoHow do you know this? It's equally possible the majority of people just don't care. That doesn't mean they like AMP or would op-in to it given the choice.
- sosborn 9y ago> And the common user wants fast load and doesn't care about the philosophy of data retention and web ownership? While this is most certainly true, it doesn't mean that data retention and web ownership aren't values worth fighting for.
- kavok 9y agoReddit links via Google search results were broken for months on my iPhone because of AMP. How many other users had the same issue and no idea what was going on?
- ehsankia 9y agoThat's reddit's fault and isn't anything inherently wrong with AMP itself. Just because someone uses the technology wrong doesn't mean we should hate on the technology. If I use AngularJS to make a Neo Nazi site, should we all boycott that library?
- golfer 9y agoAt some point you have to realize you're an outlier. The vast majority or users appear to tolerate and/or enjoy AMP just fine.
- jacquesm 9y agoThe fact that the vast majority of users wants something does not make it right any more than letting your kids decide what's for dinner every day is right. At some level what people want in the short term is overruled by the longer term consequences. This whole discussion reminds me of the people ranting against RMS who many years later come to the conclusion that he probably was right all along only by then the horse has bolted. The long term consequences of AMP are to consolidate Google's power and to make Google even more of an intermediary deciding who gets to see what. It's an end run around the kind of openness that is a cornerstone of the web and I care deeply about that openness and will oppose vocally any attempt to hijack the web for fig-leaf reasons. Note how Google is slowly boiling the frog by doing all those things that they said they'd 'never do' and how their 'don't be evil' motto gets trotted out time and again to show us how they are good little web citizens when in fact they ram their unilateral solutions down our throats in the interest of their bottom line while pretending it is all about the 'user experience'. Accidentally gaining control over the content delivery of the pages containing advertising tags of competing ad networks sure must look like a nice and juicy bonus.
- MBCook 9y agoSee… I really don't care about the ideology here. If people want to get in bed with someone who doesn't have their best interest at heart that's their choice. Borders and Toys'R'Us both decided to partner with Amazon for a while. I'm not sure why they thought that was a good idea, but that was their choice. What I care about is the user experience. That's where I'd be happy with an option to simply disable it on my devices. I think it's kind of unfortunate that it's not possible for people to discuss AMP without both issues coming up and confusing things. But that's life.
- MBCook 9y agoI would be VERY interested in some sort of study that shows that the vast majority (or even A majority) of users enjoy AMP. If the majority of users merely tolerate AMP... I wouldn't exactly call that a win for Google.
- cramforce 9y agoI'm personally neutral on it. In general, product managers hate complicating the product experience with settings and engineers hate maintaining multiple code paths for the same feature. We did add the link away from AMP, so that users who cared have a per-link opt out. We know that most users love the experience.
- MBCook 9y agoI understand you don't want to keep 100 billion options around, that makes perfect sense. But haven't you seen the level of vitriol that comes up every time AMP is discussed? This isn't a minor thing, a lot of people REALLY dislike it. I have SERIOUSLY considered switching to a different search engine entirely because of this. The fact that there is now a link to get to the normal page after I've already gotten to the AMP page is not a solution to the issue. As an end-user that feels like I'm complaining that her website is too hard to read because of the noisy background and you're telling me I could just use print preview where the background doesn't show and read it that way. This feature has significantly change the way I use Google for the worse, and in the time since it was first launched it really hasn't gotten any better for me. It's so bad my OS vendor is starting to incorporate workarounds directly into their code. If I Google something how do I open five tabs to go look at? I have to ignore every AMP result because I can't open them in a tab. So would Google deems to be the "best" content is now unavailable to me. I don't have a choice to simply turn it off. Not everyone will. If you read the comments here there are people who do like it. But there are clearly a lot of us who HATE it with a passion because it's made your website so much harder to use. PLEASE give me an option to turn it off.
- ucaetano 9y ago> This isn't a minor thing, a lot of people REALLY dislike it. > But there are clearly a lot of us who HATE it with a passion because it's made your website so much harder to use. You really seem to overestimate the size of HN readership compared to the rest of the internet. It is a minor thing. We are a niche audience living in a bubble. We're not - by far - the typical or target users. Our usage behavior is - mostly - irrelevant to Google. The world has over 3 billion internet users. Let's say that HN has 3M unique monthly users, and that only 10% of those comment, and they are split between liking and hating AMP. That gives you 150k people who hate AMP compared to 3 billion users on the internet. Why would you build and maintain a feature for 0.005% of your users?
- notatoad 9y agoi really like AMP, and i wish google would give people an option to disable it just so we could have a discussion about AMP on HN that wasn't completely taken over by people whining about how AMP is an evil plot to destroy the web because it scrolls funny on iPhones.
- thegayngler 9y agoIm in the camp that also hates AMP with a passion. It feels weird not liking much of what Google has been doing lately but AMP for me gets in the way of me sharing articles with my friends and family. It also gets in the way of me sharing a clip of the text so the people I'm sharing with including myself have the proper link and some context to get them to read further.
- euyyn 9y ago> sharing a clip of the text so the people I'm sharing with including myself have the proper link and some context to get them to read further. How do you achieve this with a non-AMP website? It sounds great.
- akvadrako 9y agoAMP is Google's new closed web, like AOL. So the opt-out is to find alternatives. If you don't have any alternatives, then Google can do whatever they want to you.
- niutech 9y agoThere is another open source alternative called Mobile Instant Pages (MIP) https://www.mipengine.org/ https://www.mipengine.org/