15 ms·
A Thorium-Salt Reactor Has Fired Up for the First Time in Four Decades
- genzoman 9y agovery excited about this tech, but i think it will be regulated to death.
- tossandturn 9y agoYou are aware of the current U.S. President and the current EPA Administrator, right?
- davrosthedalek 9y agoNot so sure about that. Might risk these billions of coal jobs he created...
- PaulHoule 9y agoAlso those two do not believe in global warming. (One thing nuclear does not cause) It make take a long time for thorium reactors to come online but it is hard to believe anybody is going to fund the construction of a new large LWR anywhere outside China.
- moonbug 9y agoHinkley C
- roceasta 9y agoGreat that thorium is progressing. I predict the debate about global warming will disappear once we have new power sources in place. Those who denied global warming will suddenly acknowledge it; those who berated the deniers will move on to other issues.
- warmwaffles 9y agoYou have way too much hope for the internet to not shit post.
- mschuster91 9y ago> (One thing nuclear does not cause) However, two problems remain: 1) where to get the raw material? African mines are not exactly known for adhering to human or environmental rights, also African mines, by nature of being in Africa, don't create American jobs. Same is valid for the other major sources of nuclear fuel, all of which aren't the USA. 2) where to dump all the nuclear waste? I mean, people have debated to put in the most long-living and nasty stuff into special reactors to get it split up to less harmful stuff, but to my knowledge this has never been realized - and NIMBYs are highly afraid of a rad-waste dump near their houses, across the world. Also, no one has shown how to build something that can last over ten thousands of years while still protecting the rad waste.
- PaulHoule 9y agoThe use of thorium in the MSR is perhaps 30x more fuel efficient than the current light water reactor. Large amounts of thorium have been buried in the desert by the U.S. government. Also, sufficient deposits exist in the U.S. to support centuries of use. As for nuclear waste, the real reason why the problem appears intractable is that nuclear waste is not waste. The LWR gets only 2% or so of the energy in uranium, the same fuel could be reprocessed and used in fast breeder reactors to release the other 98%. In fact, it is the presence of plutonium and other actinides in spent fuel that requires environmental isolation beyond 500 years or so. If we use those actinides as fuel, they do not need to be buried, and if we do that, the volume of waste is vastly reduced along with the half-life. The fast breeder/reprocessing route has not been commercialized as of yet for a number of reasons. Probably the most discussed is that plutonium, neptunium and other actinides useful for nuclear weaponry could be nicked from the reprocessing plant. The thorium MSR is an alternate path to a breeder, aka a "thermal breeder". In the case of the MSR, the reprocessing is done online or nearline to the reactor. It is also possible to do thermal breeding with thorium with a modified version of the light water reactor. Reprocessing that is a bitch though... The most immediate problem facing the industry is an inability to say "it is going to take X years and Y dollars to build a reactor" and then finish it somewhere near on schedule and on budget. Being over 10% would be no scandal, but it is still looking more like 10x than 10%.
- 9y ago
- WillPostForFood 9y ago“We will begin to revive and expand our nuclear energy sector, which I’m so happy about, which produces clean, renewable and emissions-free energy,” Trump said. https://www.nei.org/News-Media/News/News-Archives/2017/Trump-Puts-Nuclear-First-on-America-s-Energy-Agend https://www.nei.org/News-Media/News/News-Archives/2017/Trump...
- FireBeyond 9y ago“We’ve already eliminated a devastating, anti-coal regulation, but that was just the beginning,” he said. “My administration is putting an end to the war on coal, going to have clean coal, really clean coal.” “We will produce American coal to power American industry.”
- WillPostForFood 9y agoIn the speech now known as the "energy dominance" speech, Trump promoted fracking, nuclear, offshore drilling, and coal (including exporting coal).
- pizza 9y agoah yes the renewable nuclear
- WillPostForFood 9y agoBackstory on the debate: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_power_proposed_as_renewable_energy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_power_proposed_as_rene... Regardless, renewable is a less important concept than clean (how do you renew the sun which is a big nuclear reaction?).
- aidenn0 9y agoThe sun will burn out at a fixed time regardless of how much or little energy we harvest from it. Assuming energy demand growth of 5% per year, we have enough land-based actinates for less than a century of energy usage in fast breeder reactors (if you prefer 2% annual demand growth, it's enough for about 2 centuries). Seawater uranium buys you more time, depending on how you extract it, but hundreds of years and the sun burning out are two very different timelines.
- philipkglass 9y agoBetter explanation here (linked from Technology Review): http://www.thoriumenergyworld.com/news/finally-worlds-first-tmsr-experiment-in-over-40-years-started http://www.thoriumenergyworld.com/news/finally-worlds-first-... More details on the experiment sequence: https://public.ornl.gov/conferences/MSR2016/docs/Presentations/MSR2016-day1-17-Ralph-Hania-The-SALIENT-Fluoride-Fuel-Salt-Irradiations.pdf https://public.ornl.gov/conferences/MSR2016/docs/Presentatio... This is not actually a reactor test because the thorium-bearing salt does not attain criticality. It's a sequence of materials tests using thorium-containing salt mixtures in small crucibles inside the conventionally fueled High Flux Reactor (https://ec.europa.eu/jrc/en/research-facility/high-flux-reactor https://ec.europa.eu/jrc/en/research-facility/high-flux-reac...). The experiments rely on neutrons from the High Flux Reactor to induce nuclear reactions in the thorium-bearing salt mixtures. However, the experiments will be useful in validating materials behavior for possible future molten salt reactors because it combines realistic thermal, chemical, and radiation stresses.
- dang 9y agoOk, we'll change the url to that first link, instead of https://www.technologyreview.com/the-download/608712/a-thorium-salt-reactor-has-fired-up-for-the-first-time-in-four-decades/ https://www.technologyreview.com/the-download/608712/a-thori.... Thanks!
- tfy11aro 9y agoThanks Dang!
- didgeoridoo 9y agoComments like this are why I don't bother getting my tech & science news from anywhere but HN.
- mkbnnh 9y agoEternal Semptember tho. Give it time.
- 9y ago
- tim333 9y agoGlad to see they are resuming research even though there remain problems with it as a commercial technology.
- mdekkers 9y agoeven though there remain problems with it as a commercial technology Such as...?
- tim333 9y agoThere are quite a few issues which this site goes into quite well https://whatisnuclear.com/articles/thorium.html https://whatisnuclear.com/articles/thorium.html Basically you can make reactors using it but it would probably work out more expensive than conventional ones.
- velodrome 9y agoThis technology, if viable, could help solve our current nuclear waste problem. Valuable materials could be recycled (by separation) for additional use. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_reprocessing#Pyroprocessing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_reprocessing#Pyroproce... https://youtu.be/oAVCaUonrbE?t=12m7s https://youtu.be/oAVCaUonrbE?t=12m7s
- NinoScript 9y agoI wasn't expecting to see George Lucas on that video, I kinda got distracted because of him.
- PaulHoule 9y agoI am surprised they are using stainless steel instead of Hastelloy-N http://www.haynesintl.com/alloys/alloy-portfolio_/Corrosion-Resistant-Alloys/hastelloy-n-alloy/principle-features http://www.haynesintl.com/alloys/alloy-portfolio_/Corrosion-... The Hastelloy family of super alloys is basically stainless steel without the steel and was proven in the Oak Ridge MSR experiment.
- igravious 9y agoMaybe because of the short duration of the tests? Longer term they may use more exotic compounds?
- microcolonel 9y agoI suspect it would be comparatively more expensive to build it out of proprietary nickel alloy; especially considering this reactor will not be in service long enough for embrittlement to matter.
- hencq 9y agoThey address that right? > The idea is to stick to standard materials wherever possible and therefore the tubes are made of ordinary stainless steel. The suitability of steel remains to be determined. Corrosion may be a problem, and it is not yet know if it can be controlled by managing the salt chemistry. The high temperatures in MSRs might also be problematic, even if the pressure inside the system is low. And > For SALIENT-02, a different material mixture will be used that contains beryllium, forming a mixture also known as FliBe. Further experiments will focus more on the interaction between the salt and the containment materials. Corrosion resistance is very important for those materials: they should be mechanically strong, and able to resist chemical corrosion and intense radiation. This corrosion resistance will be the next focus of the experiments with tests for 316 stainless steel, Hastelloy, the nickel alloy that ORNL used in the 1960s, and TZM – a titanium/zirconium/molybdenum alloy. Molybdenum has the potential to neutronically be much more attractive but there is no history of testing it at these temperatures.
- topspin 9y agoOak Ridge MSRE found unexpected cracking throughout the reactor anywhere Hastelloy came into contact with the salt fuel. Experiments produced various means of reducing the cracking, but it is not exactly true to characterize this system as "proven." In 1977 Oak Ridge concluded [1]: Controlling the oxidation potential of the salt coupled with the presence of chromium ions in the salt appears to be an effective means of limiting tellurium embrittlement of Hastelloy N. However, further studies are needed to assess the effects of longer exposure times and to measure the interaction parameters for chromium and tellurium under varying salt oxidation potentials. We know that without very precise control of the salt fuel chemistry Hastalloy N. will become brittle. It's an open question what happens with longer exposure. And that is where it was left by MSRE. [1] http://moltensalt.org.s3-website-us-east-1.amazonaws.com/references/static/downloads/pdf/ORNL-TM-6002.pdf http://moltensalt.org.s3-website-us-east-1.amazonaws.com/ref...
- zython 9y agoI was under the impression that thorium-salt reactors have been tried in the past and not deemed "worth" from security and profitability point of view. What has changed about that ?
- igravious 9y agoI thought it was the other way around in fact. That they don't produce nuke-weapon-ready material meant that this avenue was not profitable from a security perspective. I may be recalling this incorrectly and I haven't re-checked but I think that's correct?
- philipkglass 9y agoNo, that is incorrect, though it has often been repeated by less technically informed advocates of the thorium fuel cycle. The vast majority of the world's commercial nuclear reactors are light-water-moderated pressurized water reactors or boiling water reactors (PWR and BWR respectively). The actual military origins of these light water reactors is that they were originally researched for submarine and ship propulsion for the US Navy: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Light-water_reactor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Light-water_reactor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pressurized_water_reactor#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pressurized_water_reactor#Hist... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boiling_water_reactor#Evolution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boiling_water_reactor#Evolutio... The United States and other nuclear weapons states never produced their weapons plutonium from light water reactors. Weapons grade plutonium has typically been produced from uranium in dedicated plutonium-production reactors moderated with heavy water or graphite. (The United States once had a single reactor that also produced commercial electricity along with weapons plutonium, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/N-Reactor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/N-Reactor, but it wasn't a light water reactor either.) Since uranium fueled light water reactors weren't used to make plutonium for weapons in the first place, the thorium-myth claim that commercial power reactors stuck with uranium so as to make weapons material is ridiculous. The military's early sponsorship of light water reactors for naval propulsion did give uranium-fueled LWRs a significant historical path dependency advantage. I speculate that thorium advocates who continue to repeat the myth about how uranium LWRs became dominant do so because it makes the dominant technology's dominance sound more sinister, hence thorium sound more attractive by contrast.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoA couple of comments; First it is really awesome to see actual research experiments being done on the materials. This is a critical first step in understanding the underlying complexity of the problems and as the article points out it is really helpful to have a regulatory agency that is open to trying new things. The second is this isn't a 'Thorium-Salt Reactor' it is 'parts that would go into parts that would make up such a reactor if the experiments indicate they will work.' A much less clickbaitey headline but such is 21st century journalism.
- xaldir 9y agoThe second is very important, there is still a lot of research and engineering to have: * a (ideally several) functioning research reactor * an industrial prototype * and finally a fully functional commercial plant It's a step in the right direction, but the road is very long.
- nate908 9y agoWhat's up with this image caption? "The inside of the Petten test reactor where the thorium salt is being tested is shining due to charged particles traveling faster than the speed of light in water." As I understand it, nothing travels faster than the speed of light. The author is mistaken, right?
- lutorm 9y agoNo, it's correct. The key is the "... in water" part.
- mikeash 9y agoFor details, see: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cherenkov_radiation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cherenkov_radiation
- DanBC 9y agoCherenkov radiation: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cherenkov_radiation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cherenkov_radiation "Speed of light" seems simple, but is a bit more complicated than that.
- xyzzyz 9y agoNothing travels faster than the speed of light in vacuum. Light is slower in other media, such as water, where its speed is only 3/4 of its speed in vacuum. This difference in speed is responsible for the light refraction, for example.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- logfromblammo 9y agoNothing travels faster than the speed of light through vacuum. But the index of refraction of water is 1.33 . So the speed of light through water is much slower than through vacuum. And electrons can travel through water faster than light through water. The effect is similar to a massive object traveling faster than the speed of sound through air. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cherenkov_radiation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cherenkov_radiation Edit: I love that HN is so smart that a dogpile can form from all the people rushing in to explain Cherenkov radiation.
- MentallyRetired 9y agoHow'd you like to be the guy pressing the button for 40 years?
- skybrian 9y agoThis was apparently at the High Flux Reactor in Petten, Netherlands. https://articles.thmsr.nl/petten-has-started-world-s-first-thorium-msr-specific-irradiation-experiments-in-45-years-ff8351fce5d2 https://articles.thmsr.nl/petten-has-started-world-s-first-t...
- bhhaskin 9y agoReally happy to finally see some movement with Thorium. It might not be the magic silver bullet that some people hype it up to be, but it needs to be explored.
- xupybd 9y ago"The inside of the Petten test reactor where the thorium salt is being tested is shining due to charged particles traveling faster than the speed of light in water." What I thought that wasn't possible? Or is this just the speed of light in water, so the particles are still moving slower than the speed of light in a vacuum?
- tomr_stargazer 9y ago> What I thought that wasn't possible? Or is this just the speed of light in water, so the particles are still moving slower than the speed of light in a vacuum? Good question! It's the latter - the shining is due to Cherenkov radiation [0], "electromagnetic radiation emitted when a charged particle (such as an electron) passes through a dielectric medium at a speed greater than the phase velocity of light in that medium." [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cherenkov_radiation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cherenkov_radiation
- jhallenworld 9y agoSo there was a meltdown at a liquid sodium cooled reactor due to a materials problem: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sodium_Reactor_Experiment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sodium_Reactor_Experiment I don't see a pump seal test in this experiment... does anyone know if a solution to the SRE meltdown problem is known at this point? Perhaps the LFT chemistry would not have the issue.
- foxyv 9y agoThis isn't a sodium cooled reactor, in this case the molten salt is the fuel itself, not the coolant. Plus there is probably no sodium involved but instead a fluoridated nuclear fuel such as thorium or uranium. Also this is a sub-critical experiment so pretty much all they have to do is turn it off if it overheats. The best part of a molten salt fueled reactor is that in case of heat runaway the fuel would melt plugs and drain into separate containers. Essentially a meltdown would only require replacement of the plugs and refueling of the reactor to make it operational again.
- dabockster 9y ago> charged particles traveling faster than the speed of light in water What did I just read?
- lumberjack 9y agoSpeed of light in water is slower than speed of light in vacuum
- mgsouth 9y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cherenkov_radiation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cherenkov_radiation The particles are still moving slower than Relativity's limit, the speed of light in a vacuum.
- toufka 9y agoCherenkov Radiation [1]. It's not because the particles are going faster than 300M m/s, but because light in the medium is going less than 300M m/s. The unbreakable "speed of light" is actually, the "speed of light (in a vacuum)". Outside of a vacuum, the light is slowed by the materials it travels through (see prisms, angles of refraction, Snell's Law [2] etc.). But it's still a very special condition when the medium slows light to some large fraction of C, while particles are going faster than that (but still less than C). [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cherenkov_radiation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cherenkov_radiation [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Snell%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Snell%27s_law
- Florin_Andrei 9y agoYup. Whenever you see that blue glow surrounding a reactor core submerged in water, that's the Cherenkov radiation. If the blue glow happens in your own eyeballs, you've probably just witnessed your own death sentence.
- pitaj 9y agoIt is dangerous? Nuclear subs have cherenkov radiation outside the hull which implies they have it inside the hull as well, but you don't hear about sailors getting radiation poisoning all the time.
- SubiculumCode 9y agoAnyone with insight on this I read years ago: http://www.popularmechanics.com/science/energy/a11907/is-the-superfuel-thorium-riskier-than-we-thought-14821644/ http://www.popularmechanics.com/science/energy/a11907/is-the... I worry that that if Thorium reactors become very very common because they are thought to be very safe (e.g. behind your house common, as some have bragged), but they turn out to be dangerous...we will have a real problem.
- hexane360 9y agoI'm not sure if this is a real possibility given our current understanding of nuclear physics and reactor design. We have enough knowledge to fully understand how a reactor like this would function. Past incidents have been caused by design flaws that were known at the time. It's not a matter of lack of knowledge so much as a lack of good management and regulations.
- SubiculumCode 9y agoTo be clear the worry was not about a meltdown, but that Thorium can be used to create Plutonium 233, per the article I cited.
- acidburnNSA 9y agoRight. A Thorium-232 atom that absorbs a neutron becomes Protactinium-233 which decays to Uranium-233, a fissile nuclide like U-235 and Plutonium-239. This is how the controlled chain reactor works but like any fissile material it also has potential weapons uses. Thus, Thorium reactors require safeguards and monitoring just like any other peaceful nuclear reactor.
- jopsen 9y agoI think it's unlikely that we'll want to have people playing with radio active waste in their backyard.. We have decent electricity grids, if reactors become financially viable, first goal will be to power the grid. I don't see any profit margin in decentralizing the grid.
- zmix 9y agoAs far as I know the Chinese are also putting much effort into this type of reactor.
- rosege 9y agoThats what I heard too a couple of years ago - they were putting huge amounts of money into Thorium research - does anyone know how far they are away from something similar?
- ece 9y agoIndia has the most thorium reserves, according to USGS: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Occurrence_of_thorium https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Occurrence_of_thorium And they have had the plans and motivation to build domestic reactors for the past two decades: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/India%27s_three-stage_nuclear_power_programme#Stage_III_.E2.80.93_Thorium_Based_Reactors https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/India%27s_three-stage_nuclear_... NSG membership keeps getting held up by someone or the other and would provide more energy security for India. http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/nuclear-reactor-at-kalpakkam-worlds-envy-indias-pride/articleshow/59407602.cms http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/nuclear-reactor-at-...
- knowThySelfx 9y agoIndia's Thorium rich sands are being mined and exported. Not many people are aware though. Hope it isn't too late. Scandals have throttled many efforts to grow indigenous techs. The ridiculous ISRO spy case is one such example. Cui bono?
- ece 9y agoCui bono indeed. Corruption benefits. I don't think the spy case affected much of anything.
- knowThySelfx 9y agoIt did affect our Cryogenic initiatives. Nambi Narayanan was the main brain behind it. It was a setback from scientific point of view for ISRO. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nambi_Narayanan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nambi_Narayanan Looking at the wiki, it seems likely that outside forces might've been involved in the scandal.
- xorfish 9y agoThorium is so common that it would be profitable to mine Thorium at nearly any place on earth.
- novalis78 9y agoGreat that they are mentioning ThorCon's project in Indonesia. Too bad that they had to leave the US after trying really hard to find a way to build it here.
- Sukotto 9y agoI think we're making a serious PR mistake calling these "Thorium Reactors" even though the term is accurate. "Reactor" evokes "Nuclear Reactor". For many people, "nuclear reactor" is a deeply loaded term. Likewise "Thorium" (and other words that end in "-ium") sounds dangerously like "plutonium" and "uranium". It doesn't matter how much better/safer this technology is. Don't expect the public to respond positively when we use those words. There's too much knee jerk, "no nukes!" baggage. We should start calling these "salt power stations" or something else accurate, yet non-threatening. Otherwise, IMHO, it will be a steep uphill battle getting public and legislative support for building these things, regardless of their many benefits.
- nnfy 9y agoAt least this way you convince the educated public that you are credible. We should avoid names inspired by what amounts to political correctness, because people who see through the names may distrust us further. However, I do appreciate your point, and I agree that it is a problem. I think the attitude, at least from young white collar professionals, is warming up to nuclear.
- wil421 9y agoNuclear Magnetic Resonance was the original name for the imaging technique we call MRI. Patients were scared so they changed the name.
- acidburnNSA 9y agoGlad to see some thorium-bearing salt being irradiated in a conventionally-fueled test reactor. That's a big step to getting back on the road to fluid-fueled reactors. Here are some reminders for everyone on the technical info about Thorium. First of all, Thorium is found in nature as a single isotope, Th-232, which is fertile like Uranium-238 (not fissile like U-235 or Plutonium-239). This means that you have to irradiate it first (using conventional fuel). Th-232 absorbs a neutron and becomes Protactinium-233, which naturally decays to Uranium-233, a fissile nuclide and good nuclear fuel. This is called breeding. Thorium is unique in that it can breed more fuel than it consumes using slow neutrons, whereas the Uranium-Plutonium breeder cycles require fast neutrons (which in turn require highly radiation-resistant materials, higher fissile inventory, and moderately exotic coolants like sodium metal or high-pressure gas). Any kind of breeder reactor (Th-U or U-Pu) can provide world-scale energy for hundreds of thousands of years using known resources and billions of years using uranium dissolved in seawater (not yet economical). Great, so Thorium can do thermal breeding, so what? Well to actually breed in slow neutrons, you have to continuously remove neutron-absorbing fission products as they're created (lest they spoil the chain reaction), so you really can only do this with fluid fuel. This leads to an interesting reactor design called the Molten Salt Reactor (MSR). Fun facts about this kind of reactor are that it can run at high temperatures (for process heat/thermal efficiency), can run continuously (high capacity factor), is passively safe (can shut down and cool itself without external power or human intervention in accident scenarios), and doesn't require precision fuel fabrication. Downsides are that the radionuclides (including radioactive volatiles) are not contained in little pins and cans like in solid fueled reactors so you get radiation all over your pumps, your heat exchangers, and your reactor vessel. This is a solvable radiological containment issue (use good seals and double-walled vessels) but is a challenge (the MSRE in the 1960s lost almost half of its iodine; no one knows where it went!!) U-Pu fuel can work in MSRs as well, getting those nice safety benefits, but it can't breed unless you have fast neutrons. People on the internet may tell you that Thorium can't be used to make bombs and that it's extremely cheap, etc. These are not necessarily true. You can make bombs with a Th-U fuel cycle (just separate the Pa-233 before it decays), and nuclear system costs are unknown until you build and operate a few. There are reasons to hope it could be cheaper due to simplicity, but there are major additional complexities over traditional plants or other advanced reactors in the chemistry department that add a lot of uncertainty. Fluid fueled reactors are probably ~100x or more safer than traditional water-cooled reactors, on par with sodium-cooled fast reactors and other Gen-IV concepts with passive decay heat removal capabilities.
- unlmtd1 9y agoI have a better idea: horsecarts and sailships.
- tfy11aro 9y agoSupport the exciting development: https://www.patreon.com/bePatron?redirect_uri=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.thoriumenergyworld.com%2Fnews%2Ffinally-worlds-first-tmsr-experiment-in-over-40-years-started&u=5771623&utm_medium=widget https://www.patreon.com/bePatron?redirect_uri=http%3A%2F%2Fw...
- AndreasFling 9y agoI'm already a Thorium Patron, proud to be part of this!