8 ms·
A ship that flips 90 degrees for precise scientific measurements
- ge96 9y agoHmm Makes me think like why would they design a hovering rocket crane to lower a Rover autonomously on another planet. There is a reason/it worked, and with this ship hmm, like is that the only solution? You could have floating bouys that have either neumatic or electromagnetic suspension stabilized... But then again the scale/weight of this thing... I guess the design makes sense as far as being able to operate in shallow waters then go out and do it's thing.
- Gracana 9y agoThey say this thing is stable in 30 foot seas. 300 feet of the ship is underwater. I don't think you could match that with buoys.
- maxerickson 9y agoIn the vertical configuration it is described as a buoy: https://scripps.ucsd.edu/ships/flip https://scripps.ucsd.edu/ships/flip
- jdmichal 9y agoLikely because it can't move under its own power. It's akin to a barge when horizontal and akin to a buoy when vertical.
- b_emery 9y agoTechnically it becomes a type of buoy known as a spar buoy: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spar_buoy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spar_buoy The surface wave motion decreases with depth, so having so much mass deep under water makes for a very stable platform.
- ge96 9y agoYeah 300 feet is a lot of ballast I imagine.
- rtkwe 9y agoAt this scale it'd be hard to have a system that was as quiet as this passive stabilization. It's stable up to 30 foot seas according to the article, it's no easy feat to create a system that can stabilize seas that large for any size platform.
- amelius 9y agoWhy can't they just use a probe of some kind? Or a small submarine released from the ship?
- Gracana 9y agoA small submarine wouldn't fit as many scientists or experiments or sensors, and a probe from a traditional ship wouldn't be stable.
- cr1895 9y agoBecause the instability of a submarine is precisely why this ship was conceived in the first place. From the wiki: "Development started in January 1960 after a conversation between MPL researcher Frederick H. Fisher and MPL Director Fred N. Spiess regarding stability problems that Fisher was encountering when using the submarine USS Baya (SS-318) as a research platform." I'm not clear however why a submarine was too unstable for the research they were doing.
- Declanomous 9y agoWhen I watch things floating in water, objects below the water seem to move back and forth with the movement of the water, as if the object and the water were the same, but things that are partially in the water, they seem to "ride" the water and shift much more slowly. Based on that, my guess is either surface tension, or the fact that an object that floats on top of a medium is much less dense than one that floats within it. It would probably be a pretty easy to quantify if you had several liquids with known surface tension, so I'm guessing the information is out there already.
- cr1895 9y agoHere's a gif of water particle movement that's happening in an ocean wave (in deep water; it gets weirder if it's shallow). http://funnel.sfsu.edu/courses/gm309/images/Owave.gif http://funnel.sfsu.edu/courses/gm309/images/Owave.gif Essentially, motion starts with wind. Energy propagates downwards into the water column resulting in the circular orbitals (you see this if you float in the (deep) ocean and you bob up and down in a circle but you don't really go anywhere). But at a certain point, no more energy propagates downward; so your submarine if its deep enough (tens of meters) will not feel a thing from what's happening on the surface. This is also what the FLIP takes advantage of; the base of its deep spar hull lies so far below the surface that it has nothing forcing it to move up and down. This is why it's stable in big waves, and why I'm confused how a submarine is too unstable.
- gerbilly 9y ago>As research budgets shrink, and fewer people go into oceanographic research, it’s hard to say what is on the horizon for FLIP. Why is it that budgets everywhere from businesses public/private to government to scientific research are always shrinking? It's like it's the invariant of our age: well you know, budgets are shrinking...
- monsieurbanana 9y agoMaybe growing budgets don't make the headlines, or newly created budgets don't enter in the "growing" category.
- KekDemaga 9y agoI learned recently that often when it is said that "budgets are shrinking" it actually means the purposed year over year increase has been cut and in terms of total dollars it continues to increase or stay the same. Not sure if this is the case here but something to look out for.
- RugnirViking 9y agoBut due to inflation if it didn't increase the budget would have less value. At least this is the understanding I have usually been given.
- bluGill 9y agoA budget can still be "cut" while growing against inflation though. They also refer to a cut compared to projections, and the projections are usually to increase the budget faster than inflation.
- RugnirViking 9y agoWhile I am sure that dishonest reporting does go on in some cases, a possible explanation for that phenomenon is that many services have to scale the budget not only by inflation but also by population. For example, the health service might have a fixed cost per person and so their overall budget growth could be inflation+population growth
- jacquesm 9y agoThe stresses on that hull when it is at the 45 degree point during a flip must be immense.
- cr1895 9y agoHmmm...I'm not so sure they are exceptional. The upper section is rather light; no heavy machinery like an engine, no heavy tanks like fuel oil. They'd likely only flip during favorable sea conditions so the accelerations are kept to a minimum. And once the spar bit is submerged some meters the influence of surface waves will be reduced. Edit: the bending stresses when its being towed horizontally could be quite large too...in long-wavelength swell you'd have either the center more bouyant than the ends or the ends more buoyant than the center. Once you flip it it's supported by bouyancy and filled ballast water.
- maxerickson 9y agoI linked the Scripps website in a couple other comments, the technical diagrams of the ship show "concrete ballast" in the upper section. I would guess to reduce roll when it is horizontal.
- GrumpyNl 9y agoEvery once in a while you see footage of technology that really amazes you, this is one of them.
- JDT 9y agoI would have designed the crew quarters on a kind of gimbal so that they are always upright. Make better use of the space and no need to put everything away (thinking of the soap dispenser on the basin) when changing orientation.
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoLike the central bureaucracy in Futurama?
- kartan 9y agoThe name of the ship is FLIP: FLoating Instrument Platform. Nice acronym work is done there.
- J-dawg 9y agoI thought the photo of the two basins at 90 degrees to each other was a nice example that it sometimes makes sense to violate the DRY principle. Someone must have looked at installing a gimballed basin, realised how complicated the custom-made gimbal and plumbing would have to be, and thought "screw it, let's just order a second basin". Also, someone really needs to put a lid on that soap container!
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoYou're over thinking it. It only needs to move +/-45 in one plane. Weld a hinge to the wall above the sink. Suspend the sink from the hinge. The radius can be determined by how much flex hose you want to purchase for the drain and supply lines. The same should work for toilets and showers. Run all your drain piping toward the corner of the ship that's always under water. Install these on your showers. http://d2ydh70d4b5xgv.cloudfront.net/images/2/7/shower-head-caddy-bath-room-tub-organizer-shelf-steel-shampoo-rack-soap-holder-3d2be0c62103f46a8ec5c51f04717659.jpg http://d2ydh70d4b5xgv.cloudfront.net/images/2/7/shower-head-... You might want to let things move more than +/-45 or install pins to lock stuff. Taking a crap in rough seas could get weird when you and the toilet can stay level as the ship moves but only in one direction. It all comes down to weight vs tolerance for squeaks and rattles. Maintenance should be in the same ballpark. Greasing hinges and more flexible plumbing/wiring/infrastructure to worry about is probably not much worse than twice as much everything.
- jdmichal 9y agoHonestly, I would have just towed it out empty, flipped it vertical, then loaded people on. That way, only one orientation needs to be supported at all.
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoThat's what they wanted to do initially but since everyone wanted to be on the flipped ship when it was flipped they refitted it to house people. At that point you may as well find a way cram them in when it's horizontal rather than incur the cost of bringing them out and back on a separate ship.
- sandworm101 9y agoSimilar approach, but private sector and far bigger. 911 operators get calls whenever these ships operate in view of the public. http://www.telegraph.co.uk/men/the-filter/virals/10583550/How-a-timber-barge-unloads-its-cargo.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/men/the-filter/virals/10583550/Ho...
- troisx 9y agoI saw the FLIP when I was sailing one time. If I hadn't previously read about it I probably would have called the coast guard because it looked like a ship going down.
- sandworm101 9y agoAlso the sea king helos. When they do water landings everyone panics.
- amingilani 9y agoThe article didn't address it so I'll just ask: why? Why do you need to build a flipping (no pun intended) ship? Couldn't they have just as easily built a tall floating rig that could be dragged by the same tugboat? Why do they even need to change to boat form? Can't they tug it when it's vertical? Drilling platforms are stable floating structures aren't they? They consist of a stable floating upper platform.
- ryanmarsh 9y agoBecause the oil industry was already having these built. It was probably just easier and cheaper to buy one "off the shelf" so to speak rather than have a custom ship designed for this purpose. Drilling platforms are large and not designed to regularly circumnavigate the oceans. They float but they're shitty boats.
- maxerickson 9y agoIt's a one off designed to measure sound waves and bearing at the same time. https://scripps.ucsd.edu/ships/flip/history https://scripps.ucsd.edu/ships/flip/history
- cr1895 9y agoNot in the 60s, as far as I'm aware. Same principles but widespread use of spars and semi-subs came later.
- Retric 9y agoYou can tow a ship a lot faster than you can move a drilling platform. But, basically this is a drilling platform. Going horizontal vastly reduces drag, but it's not really designed to be used as a ship.
- masklinn 9y ago> Couldn't they have just as easily built a tall floating rig that could be dragged by the same tugboat? Why do they even need to change to boat form? Can't they tug it when it's vertical? Gigantic drag, low stability, and inability to enter ports and harbours when you have a 100ft draft. > Drilling platforms are stable floating structures aren't they? They consist of a stable floating upper platform. "Truss and spars" platforms usually have the truss floated on its side and the modules mounted on top of it once it's been floated and ballasted in place. Semi-subs can be tugged into place but that requires big tugs (multiple ~20khp units) and is very, very slow, to attain the speeds at which you can tow RP FLIP (7~10kt) you need a heavy lift ship. These are not the kind of expenses oceanography can usually afford. Not to mention the semi-sub itself would be significantly more expensive than RP FLIP was, a semi-sub is more than half a billion, FLIP's original cost was about half a million.
- PanMan 9y agoStrange that they don't flip the small boat that's hanging to the side: outboard engines (especially if they are 4 stroke) don't like being not upright. Seems it would be fairly easy to hang it so it could swing?
- ChuckMcM 9y agoI have always enjoyed articles on this research platform. I imagined at one time that it would make for an interesting tourist site if you could put an observation "dome" at what would become the bottom and viewing galleries along the length. Then tow your tour out somewhere, flip, and let people move up and down looking at various levels of sea life. At the time, an older engineer pointed out that if you didn't fill the bottom with sea water it didn't flip. So really the tourists would all have to wear scuba gear anyway :-). Which crushed my young dreams of a Captain Nemo style encounter in the tidewaters of the great barrier reef.
- pavel_lishin 9y agoYou don't have to fill the entire bottom with sea water - you could leave a (presumably pressurized, which is a bummer) empty bubble at the bottom.
- mLuby 9y agoFLIP is the most Kerbal ship we have right now.
- SquareBalls 9y agoI wonder how many times someone called the coast guard when the ship starts flipping.