7 ms·
The first one sounds like an uninsured (maybe unlicensed) driver. This is definitely not the norm. Car accidents are one area where we pretty much don't have to
by mikeash 9y ago
The first one sounds like an uninsured (maybe unlicensed) driver. This is definitely not the norm. Car accidents are one area where we pretty much don't have to worry about lawsuits at all. Your insurance company talks to their insurance company and they work it out.
The second one just sounds like a crazy person. They probably had no intent to sue, and were just trying to stupidly use the threat as leverage for something.
- jacquesm 9y ago(1) https://www.google.nl/search?client=ubuntu&channel=fs&q=whiplash+lawsuit https://www.google.nl/search?client=ubuntu&channel=fs&q=whip... (2) his lawyer did contact us. WW.com has had a number of such threats of lawsuits for all kinds of reasons, exclusively these were by Americans and they were all looking to get money out of us. In business circles this is simply seen as a cost of doing business in the USA, if you are large enough to be visible you will get sued.
- mikeash 9y agoI don't understand what that google link is supposed to demonstrate. Is there something in the results showing that people's insurance doesn't protect them?
- jacquesm 9y agoI don't know what people being insured or not has to do with the fact that people will sue for whiplash claims (even when they don't actually have whiplash) in order to extract some $ from the system, enriching a bunch of lawyers in the process. For all you know the guy was illegally in the United States, it still doesn't matter. In Europe the most likely response to such a minimal accident would be two parties getting out of their car, assessing the damage - if any - filling out a form and getting on with their day after taking some pictures and shaking hands. Nobody would even think of being sued, misfortune in Europe rarely leads to some kind of civil lawsuit here (though, if you're drunk or under the influence of drugs or negligent it is of course very well possible there will be a criminal case brought against you).
- mikeash 9y agoBeing insured is why the most likely response to such a minimal accident in the US is exactly how you describe it in Europe. You don't jump out of your car saying "omg please don't sue me!" You document the damage, exchange info, call the police if necessary (often legally required), and contact your insurance company. They handle the rest. If I rear-ended somebody and later found out they were suing for whiplash, I'd pass the info along to my insurance company and let them worry about it.
- jacquesm 9y ago> they were suing for whiplash The point is - at the risk of becoming boring and repeating myself - that this has nothing to do with being insured or not but with such a suit or claim being brought in the first place. That's an absolute rarity in Europe and a case would have to be pretty severe to get any compensation. In the United States there are plenty of people who see wrong or harm (imaginary or real) done to them as a potential payday, whether through the courts or through an insurance company is immaterial.
- mikeash 9y agoAnd my point is that a person who reacts to a minor crash by begging you not to sue him is not even remotely representative of how things work here. You described "the most likely response" in Europe, as if it was somehow different in the US. It's not.
- jacquesm 9y agoSo, are you or are you not in agreement that monetary compensation after accidents (or crimes) is more likely to occur in the United States than in Europe regardless of the mechanism of getting such compensation (through the courts or through an insurance company)?
- mikeash 9y agoI don't know, but it probably is as you say. I just dispute that a weirdo begging you not to sue him over a minor crash supports the idea.
- jack9 9y ago> The second one just sounds like a crazy person. There are lots of crazy people, and gaming the courts is way many of them make a living, or garner attention, or just give themselves something to do when they are otherwise put together. I've been 3rd party to multiple frivolous suits in california. It's shocking to see the amount of work put into lost causes, but people still show up and fight speeding tickets too...so that's just the USA.
- jacquesm 9y agoI suspect one of the key differences that enables this is that in the United States lawyers can take cases on a contingency basis. There are other (some European countries too) places where this is possible but in the United States it seems to be much more common, especially in such cases where outcome is a long shot but the pay-off is large. If you know for sure that you will lose money (and possibly a substantial amount) for bringing a frivolous lawsuit that works as a deterrent. Of course it isn't perfect and may result in some cases that do have merit also not being brought.