35 ms·
Hackers nab $500k as Enigma is compromised weeks before its ICO
- jstanley 9y agoFrom what I can tell, the ICO wasn't hacked as such. The ICO customers were just scammed. Edit: title is better now
- etherti 9y agoThe attackers gained control of the official website, slack channel, Twitter handle and mailing list. That's even worse than what happened to coindash.
- nabla9 9y agoIt's just scam if attackers are insiders.
- quoquoquo 9y agosame password and it's such an easy feat for an insider. Especially when the aim is to get press attention. It's cleverly machiavellian. It accomplishes so much for the ICO founders with little to no recourse.
- jethro_tell 9y agowho says they aren't? Seems like a pretty simple trick.
- barkingcat 9y agoThey were pretty much hacked in every sense of the word. Lost control of website, twitter, etc.
- senatorobama 9y agoSo what, just a couple of years worth of work at Google as a SWE.
- bkolobara 9y agoThe problem is that most people tricked into "investing" in such platforms probably don't make anything like a software engineer at Google. This loss hurts them a lot.
- SirensOfTitan 9y agoEven knowledgeable people can fall victim to attacks like this.
- bkolobara 9y agoYou make it sound like I claimed that people not working at google are less intelligent. My point was that if you are already making good money you are not looking for lottery tickets to buy.
- jaclaz 9y agoBut still there are seemingly a few people that threat dollars as peanuts. The data on the page on Etherscan: https://etherscan.io/address/0x29d7d1dd5b6f9c864d9db560d72a247c178ae86b https://etherscan.io/address/0x29d7d1dd5b6f9c864d9db560d72a2... does provide some insight at a quick analysis. The total sent is (at the 494,170.68/1492=331.214 rate) almost exactly 500,000 US$ (499,821.59) of which, in four operation of 373 Eth each 1492 Eth were withdrawn 494,170.68. Of the 212 total operation 4 are withdrawals, 3 are 0, that makes 205 "IN" operations. The distribution of the amounts of the single operations/deposits is interesting, I quickly put together a few "classes": a. >30,000 2 Total 66,243 US$ b. 20-30,000 3 Total 70,840 US$ c. 10-20,000 6 Total 82,803 US$ d. 5-10,000 14 Total 102,576 US$ e. 2.5-5,000 23 Total 80,125 US$ f. 1-2,500 33 Total 54,225 US$ g. 0-1,000 124 Total 43,010 US$ If the "targeted audience" was around 9,000, roughly 200 or 2.2% fell for the phishing. A handful of people (classes a., b., c., 11 in total, i.e. coincidentally roughly the 0.1%) contributed for almost half the amount 66,243+70,840+82,803=219,886 219,886/500,000=43,98%.
- justadeveloper2 9y agoSmart people are often the easiest to scam because they believe they can't be scammed.
- hathym 9y agoICO is the new ponzi scheme
- pc86 9y agoOnly if you use ponzi scheme (incorrectly) interchangeably with "scam."
- bandrami 9y agoOr correctly, in the sense of "a system that requires constant new investment to achieve payouts"
- SippinLean 9y agoIf you think that's all it takes to satisfy the definition of a Ponzi scheme, you're incorrect. That would even be an oversimplification for a Pyramid scheme. I'm not sure why this has to be corrected for every crypto thread on HN. We get it, someone has to comment on every crypto post "Ponzi scheme," "tulips," or the like (regardless on whether or not such a generic comment is especially relevant to the thread) but simply calling it a "scam" gets the unoriginal point across without making you seem so misinformed.
- bandrami 9y agoEqually, "your side" could save a lot of time by saying "This asset bubble is different" and leaving it at that.
- literallycancer 9y agoKind of like pension systems in most countries?
- bandrami 9y agoLargely, which is why we keep reminding people they are social insurance programs, not investments. The state has guns, and can mandate the continued investment
- crypt1d 9y agoThis might as well be a scam created by the CEO himself. I mean, who in this 'crypto world' would be stupid enough to use the same, previously compromised, password on all his accounts? P.S. there was a story on reddit (can't find it now unfortunately) about how the attackers tried to deposit the money to Bittrex but luckily someone alerted them and the exchange froze the account. So there is still some hope that funds will be returned.
- mhluongo 9y agoWhy would he do that when he'd make more on the actual token sale?
- otheotheothe 9y agogetting 500k from a stupid hack or 30mio without...ur theory doesnt make any sense.
- tstyle 9y agoThe profit from the token sale goes into a foundation setup to oversee the project, not the founding team's pocket.
- koolba 9y ago> The profit from the token sale goes into a foundation setup to oversee the project ... [truncated] ... that is controlled by the founders and could presumably be used for whatever they'd like. The usual approach is to create two companies. One a shell to own the ICO itself, and the second a tech services company that does development for the shell corp. So it ends up something like: "We definitely need the expertise of ICO founder Mr. X. Let's hire his consulting company to update the CSS on our web page at $1,000/hour..."
- sillysaurus3 9y agoThis is the main reason the traditional VC model works so well. You can't get rich unless the VC's make money.
- jmilloy 9y agoCan we get the title fixed? The editorialized title is misleading/inaccurate. (edit: Thanks, it's fixed now.)
- joosters 9y agoIn what way? The company's website, email lists and other property was compromised and investors lost 500k, seems pretty clear to me.
- ndespres 9y agoWell, it seems unfair to say "investors lost 500k" if they weren't really investing in the ICO so much as taking the bait on a phishing email, which is what it sounds like happened. If a hacker took control of their domain and Slack, and socially engineered people into sending funds into the hackers' personal accounts (which is what it sounds like has happened), Enigma never really had the funds to lose in the first place themselves.
- joosters 9y agoThe title merely states that hackers stole $500,000. It does not say they stole it from Enigma. They stole it from people trying to invest in it - hence "investors lost 500k" seems perfectly apt.
- jmilloy 9y agoOriginal title was something like "Enigma's ICO hacked, $500,000 stolen. CEO reused password. No 2FA." For one, my understanding is that the Enigma's "website, email lists and other property" was compromised, not it's "ICO". Second, the $500,000 was scammed out of users/investors rather than directly stolen in the "hack". I think for crypto-coins this is an important distinction.
- joosters 9y agoIt just sped up the inevitable losses from another scammy ICO. In this case, the hackers made the process more efficient.
- ghostbrainalpha 9y agoYes, but its not how much money you lose that matters, it is how much fun you have while losing the money that matters. These hackers robbed the customers of a valuable roller coaster life experience. Sincerely, Las Vegas Gaming Commission Marketing Manager
- mycosis 9y agowe need to put a hold on all cryptocurrency startups until we figure out what the hell is going on
- SirensOfTitan 9y agoAs with most things security, people tend to be the weakest link in the chain. This type of issue could be solved in a lot of ways. I think a solution wherein: 1. ICOs use a standard 'escrow' contract wherein ether and coin get held by the contract for 7 days or so before either party can withdraw the opposite pair (where either can back out). 2. Building some standard 'ether address' widget that verifies the type of contract an address is. A user-wallet would usually be a warning sign.
- jstanley 9y agoThat wouldn't solve this problem. Did you read the article? The ICO investors were tricked.
- mhluongo 9y agoThe user wallet vs contract distinction might help, but that means tooling and education.
- SirensOfTitan 9y agoAnd how wouldn't it solve the problem? (1) would act as a more safe instrument for sending money to addresses you don't regularly interact with, (2) would attempt to make the address type much more apparent to the user so they don't send to addresses they aren't familiar with.
- jstanley 9y agoJust because you invent a special type of escrow contract that makes it harder to steal money doesn't mean an attacker would use it... he would just instruct users to send money to his own contract and bypass all of the protections you've invented.
- SirensOfTitan 9y agoWhen did I mention an attacker should use this? How does that argument make sense at all? Legitimate ICOs should take on use of these widgets and contracts, educating users in the process to only send to particular contracts. This requires a great deal of improved hygiene for ICO providers and education for consumers, but there’s no easy foot forward here.
- raesene6 9y agoThis looks like another in a series of ICOs which are not being handled with appropriate security controls. When people are planning on taking in millions of dollars of investment in an easily traded, easily stolen, digital currency, they've got to expect attention from relatively well funded/motivated attackers. Unfortunately many of the founders of these ICOs don't seem to be that well setup in this regard as some of the disclosed hacks, including this one, aren't exactly advanced.
- tdb7893 9y agoI wish that passwords like this stopped being the main form of authentication. I guess I'm not sure what's a better way (I like the physical object + pin of my credit card but that's probably not practical for all Web authentication) but it seems pretty obvious that passwords are broken in their current form unless you use a password manager, which can be a hassle
- laumars 9y agoThis is where two factor authentication comes into play. Then you can have something you know (eg password) and something you own (eg phone). I quite like using Google Authenticator for my 2FA.
- tectec 9y agoThere are also problems with that: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15068567 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15068567
- luke3butler 9y agoThat's not Authy/Google Authenticator. That's social engineering their way into getting a persons text messages for SMS 2FA.
- chatmasta 9y agoIf you can compromise the iCloud account of an iOS user (pretty sure iOS 2fa is only SMS based), then you can install google authenticator on your own device. I'm sure it's more complicated than that in reality, but if you have SMS access, you only need to find one weak link in the chain including iCloud/google, email provider, app provider, etc.
- 15155 9y ago> install google authenticator on your own device. You sure can, but will you then have the requisite TOTP secrets?
- richardknop 9y agoAnother ICO, another scam. I am not sure I feel bad for people who are gullible enough to send their hard earned money to these "companies". They have one PDF whitepaper and a generic Wordpress template website with some buzzwords, based in Cayman islands or some other tax haven for money laundering. And expecting to get rich from that.
- wott 9y agoI am unconvinced that hard earned money is 'invested' in those companies. The target demographic is not hard working class.
- TAForObvReasons 9y agoCNBC has been talking about Bitcoin, Ethereum, Ethereum Lite and a slew of recent ICOs in the last month or so. Whether those viewers count as "hard working class" is up for debate
- justadeveloper2 9y agoWe're still in the "attract as many rubes as possible phase" which is always followed by the "slam the trap shut phase"
- vadym909 9y agoand Fortune is starting a dedicated column to crypto related news called Ledger http://fortune.com/2017/08/22/ledger-blockchain-fintech/ http://fortune.com/2017/08/22/ledger-blockchain-fintech/
- arkitaip 9y agoYou would be surprised. People know nothing about Bitcoin but have a friend, uncle or acquaintance who has dropped a few thousands in BTC and raves about the price going from 580 usd to 4000 usd in just a year. People lose their minds and they won't even have shitty tulips to show for it.
- anovikov 9y agoAs a Russian proverb goes, "a thief stolen a thief's hat"
- PeachPlum 9y agoThat's an interesting concept but I can't find anything about it. I found this : http://kv-journal.su/content/vor-u-vora-ukral http://kv-journal.su/content/vor-u-vora-ukral "the thief stole from the thief" I can't find anything hat related, though I wish I could
- notdang 9y agoTe most used variant is : Вор у вора дубинку украл http://slovarick.ru/211/ http://slovarick.ru/211/ However later is more popular what the grandparent wrote: Вор у вора шапку украл
- Grue3 9y agoThe hat version is probably a result of synthesis with another saying: "the thief's hat is burning" (на воре шапка горит).
- kirualex 9y agoHow to make quick money in 2017: - Create a startup in the blockchain world - Make an ICO to raise money - Get "hacked" - ... - Profit!
- ritarong 9y agoIt's amazing that this has happened multiple times before and yet people have not learned to be more careful. Greed and FOMO.
- ringaroundthetx 9y agoThe attack vectors are getting more sophisticated, but it is also a different standard applied to cryptocurrencies: Fraud in legacy payment networks is hundreds of millions per year, with an occasional outlier of 80 billion, the only difference is that it isn't international news every single time. $500,000 thefts are happening every single day in fiat currencies, in person, banks, over electronic networks like ACH/checks, Wire, SWIFT, IBAN etc. Square Inc's annual report cites a couple huge thefts they have had to deal with which have and could materially affect their business of creating merchant tools. They lost like $5 million in one swipe and its just buried in a boring annual report. $500k in one crypto OPSEC issue and you question the entire concept? Cmon thats mentally disingenuous You'll just have to keep that in mind if you want to have any kind of objective view of this reality containing cryptocurrencies
- OscarTheGrinch 9y agoInitial Clown Outwitting
- 659087 9y agoThat's a bit unfair to clowns. The term "investor" in relation to ICOs could be replaced with the term "mark", and the whole thing would be a lot more accurate.
- nickbauman 9y agoCryptocurrency is probably doomed because the makers of cryptocurrencies have a fundamental conceptual disconnect with money: what it is, why it works and what it represents. Money only works when you have a powerful state actor enforcing the legality of the transaction. When you try to escape that, you get at best a parallel system that still goes back to the state for help in keeping functioning or a system prone to failure, fraud and speculation. To whit yet another one of these incidents.
- autokad 9y agomaybe, but this particular incident was more along the lines of phishing and little to do with the cryptocurrency itself
- japhy__ryder 9y agoWell Bitcoin has been doomed since 2011, so I guess if you just keep saying that, it will eventually be true. Until then, it looks like it'll be around for a while.
- option 9y agobitcoin is probably doomed in US because it is taxed as asset and isn't considered a "money" by the IRS. Hence to actually legally use it as a money is a huge pain tax-wise (imagine having to calculate holding periods and capital gains each time you buy a coffee) But US isn't entire world.
- CyberDildonics 9y agoPeople keep saying this, but it just isn't true. All you have to do is match transactions with price. It can be done automatically.
- option 9y agoA lot of things "can be done". And what is not true? Bitcoin IS considered an asset by the IRS
- che_shirecat 9y agoHow to make money in ethereum, from high to low risk: 1. Dump the leftovers of your bi-weekly software engineering paycheck into buying ETH, BTC, or whichever altcoin is popular this week. It went up 5000% in the past, it's got to keep growing right? 2. Participate in an ICO and stock up on whatever platform token they're hawking. It's more profitable if you get in early due to some presale mechanism (hopefully here you aren't sending your hard-earned digital currency to a hacker's wallet). Sell these tokens about 4-5 days after the sale closes, before the hype dies down and the bagholders realize they're holding sand. 3. Even more profitable is kicking off your own ICO. Go through the checklist - fancy HTML5 theme that you can buy off of Themeforest and edit the HTML a bit for the landing page, create a Slack channel/Twitter account/subreddit, write a "whitepaper" that is easy enough for the shmucks you're targeting to understand, yet replete with enough pseudo-academic crypto jargon and irrelevant/unnecessary mathematical symbols to get the shmucks nodding their heads and pretending to understand how this particular algorithm/equation based on the "turing-complete ethereum blockchain" will "change the world" or "bank the unbanked" or, more importantly to them, appreciate 500x in value. Don't forget listing the members of your team and advisors, ideally with as much credential signalling as you can - "MIT," "Stanford," "Comp Sci Phd," "McKinsey," all work here, fake it till you make it and make sure you list Vitalik Buterin on your list of advisors just for that extra bit of technical legitimacy. Use centuries-old sales tactics to pitch your ICO - butter up your target audience's sense of superiority by emphasizing exclusivity - they're the only clever ones, they're the genius computer nerds who understand the 1000x potential of your algorithm, they're the ones that are breaking free of the shackles of regulated securities. Create a sense of urgency with a ticking timer on your landing page, a 24-hour window to buy your monopoly money, a subtle/not-so-subtle hint that the earlier you get in, the more you'll make. 4. You could always just put on your black hat and rob these extremely soft targets blind. The simpler the method, it seems, the better. Plus, there's absolutely no risk of ever being held accountable - that's the beauty of anonymous cryptocurrency!
- arkitaip 9y agoturning your comment into a 10-week pdf course as we speak, just gonna pick a theme over ath theme forest brb
- paultopia 9y agoOMG. People, PLEASE STOP WITH THE RANDOM NEW CRYPTOCURRENCIES.
- japhy__ryder 9y agoI hear that MattDamonCoin is huge in China. Buckle up, Paul.
- asidiali 9y ago...OMG actually dipped and is a good buy right now...
- loopdoend 9y agoYes, this is actually a thing: https://coinmarketcap.com/assets/omisego/ https://coinmarketcap.com/assets/omisego/
- option 9y agoThe ICO concept is fundamentally solid and is more efficient then traditional funding sources. What currently lack is the implementation. Both technological and legal frameworks need lots of work, but I bet it'll happen
- the_stc 9y agoReally? I hope we will enter a post-ICO era of fundraising. Tokens simply do not make sense in most cases, nor do new chains. In my startup, we're issuing Token-Shares (Blockchain Bearer Shares) that pay dividends[1]. I think something like this will be the future. Let people actually own and share in the profits of the enterprise. The share prices can still 10x or more, so there is still a benefit to early investors. Plus focusing on actual business fundamentals. 1: If you want more blockchainy tech, the dividends get paid into the smart contract owning the shares, automatically.
- trhway 9y agofirst time i can't get whether it is sarcasm or not.
- the_stc 9y agoAbsolutely not sarcasm. Why would ICOs giving out tokens with no equity be superior to a tokens that have equity and receive dividends?
- vkou 9y agoIf you sell equity, and will pay dividends, why not just do an IPO? The SEC will treat you as a security anyways.
- the_stc 9y agoWe're doing a blockchain IPO because the subject we deal with has significant legal issues in most countries (details in profile). We're operating as an extrajurisdictional company to get around these issues, with an anonymous founding and executive team.
- tlrobinson 9y agoI'm not sure I buy the premise that every service needs its own coin. Surely in most cases it would be better to just use the most widely used, most stable coin? If the concept of cryptocurrency is going to survive I think there needs to be one or two clear winners to eventually bring some stability to their value. Of course, not issuing your own coin doesn't leave as much opportunity to get rich quick off a bit of hype.
- ringaroundthetx 9y ago> I'm not sure I buy the premise that every service needs its own coin. Surely in most cases it would be better to just use the most widely used, most stable coin? The team cannot finance itself without selling a new token These projects don't use equity and there is nothing that will make the equity more valuable as there. There are lots of things that will make their token be more valuable as it is a new commodity.
- pavel_lishin 9y agoOne thing I don't understand about ICOs is - what do the companies promise their coins to be worth? That is, if I have a Coin from your brand new endeavour - what can I, hypothetically, exchange it for? Do I get a vote in how your company is run? Can I give it back to you in exchange for a product or service later down the line? Or is it just a geegaw for me to put on a shelf, like a printout of a Patreon receipt?
- kazagistar 9y agoGenerally, it'd the second. The coin is supposed to be a preorder, and it's value is thus the value of the service later.
- ringaroundthetx 9y agothey are for a product or service, the limited issuances of the token gives them a speculative market based on future demand and future supply. the team and organization gets funded, the buyers are liquid, nobody makes ridiculous decisions counter to their dreams hoping for "an exit", because everyone already has one. we don't have consumer or investor protections here yet so sure it is ripe for abuse, so far people are content with that, and we also haven't needed it
- EGreg 9y agoQuestion: in light of the SEC decision regarding the DAO, is there any way to do an ICO that doesn't run the risk of later the whole company being shut down for not registering securities? Like maybe opening the company in Crypto Valley, Zug? Is there a way to do a public offering of tokens? Or does it necessitate all the same reporting that a publicly listed company has? Could still be worth it! Because the investors control even less of your board than in Snapchat IPO.
- sillysaurus3 9y agoYes: Do an ICO like a kickstarter. It's not illegal. The tokens just need to not be financial instruments. You can say "Buy my tokens to fund my project."
- EGreg 9y agoWait, what? Can lawyers please weigh in on this? There are the Howey test on the Federal level, and then there is also the Risk Capital Test in several states. Precedent can very easily go towards the direction that people have a reasonable expectation of the tokens going up in value, making them securities in the eyes of at least the Risk Capital Test. In fact club memberships became securities under this test! http://www.theselc.org/which_states_apply_the_risk_capital_test_when_deciding_what_is_a_security http://www.theselc.org/which_states_apply_the_risk_capital_t...
- ringaroundthetx 9y agoMany people buy Nike shoes to go up in value. Nike Inc. purposefully limits the quantity. Are Nike shoes therefore securities? It is an open ended question and yes where we are in this country a future court could rope something like that in too before Congress gets around to forcing regulatory clarity. Tokens can be products. It is what you sell them for and how you sell them and how you interact with that market, and how others interact with that market, that determines if something is a security. But is isn't a single one of those factors in isolation that makes it a security.
- 9y ago
- throw2016 9y agoIts appears crypto currencies have escaped the technical domain and have landed plum into nigerian scam territory. The crypto currency ecosystem has become toxic and irrational propped up by ignorance, desperation and blind greed I wonder what arguments will be made to third world countries at the next climate change summit when a large number of our population seem to be squandering electricity without pause in the hope of riches. The only way any crypto takes off in the world we live in is if some powerful vested interest sees some use for it, at which point all the speculators having spent the better part of the past decade pushing fantasy narratives about freedom etc will sell out every single tall claim made for a dime. Those who do not understand history and in this case economies are condemned to repeat it, and badly.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- wickedlogic 9y agoUser machine, not blockchain, security will continue to be the biggest risk in all these systems. With gold for example, stealing the physical assets takes effort, resources, time, equipment, etc. With digital assets, that is not the case... and our current level of system security is not adequate in the slightest. It is a challenge we are still largely ignoring today, but crypto currencies will require it be fixed, or better-risk-managed at any rate. (not advocating gold over digital, but people continue to hand wave the actual risks)
- jacquesm 9y agoAh, the good old 'the hacker did it' story. Never fails. I suspect a pretty large fraction of the 'hacker did it' cases are inside jobs.
- JohnKacz 9y agoSorry for the uneducated question here, but I've wondered how those who steal crypto-currency "launder?" their ill-gotten coin. More specifically, how do they not get caught since the blockchain records everything? Take it out really quickly? Move little bits around to obscure ownership in some kind of shell game? Am I just totally off-base with my understanding?
- Pfiffer 9y agoYou're not far off, I think it's usually done through a mixer: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bitcoin_mixer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bitcoin_mixer
- asddddd 9y agoThat works, but you can also just deposit to an exchange/service, withdraw on another chain (i.e. btc -> eth) and repeat this a few times. Unless there's a large target on your back, even doing this once will effectively destroy any paper trail - especially if it's an offshore exchange that uses subpoenas for toilet paper (most of them?).
- evbots 9y agonot necessary to launder if you steal something like zcash or monero.
- EternalData 9y agoThere's a boom and a bust cycle when it comes to new technologies -- doubtless blockchain will have to go through the buzzsaw just like the early commercial Internet did in the early 2000s.
- vkou 9y agoThe commercial internet brought an unprecedented increase in the speed of communication. Blockchains... Bring a secure, distributed ledger. That's nice, but this isn't Amazon replacing the Sears catalog.
- dmtzz 9y agowhat does nab mean?
- djhworld 9y agoEnigma is building a decentralized, open, secure data marketplace that will change how data is shared, aggregated and monetized to maximize collaboration. Catalyst is our first product and the first application running on our Enigma protocol. Powered by our financial data marketplace, Catalyst empowers users to share and curate data and build profitable, data-driven investment strategies. So much said that explains so little.
- tzz 9y agoThere are a lot of scams on the web, but you don't blame the HTTP protocol. There are a lot of email scams, but you don't blame SMTP. Sad to see the dominant view of this community is against any type of cryptocurrency.
- psyc 9y agoI don't think HN is remotely opposed to "cryptocurrency", but at the same time it's abundantly clear IMO that what's happening at this moment is a full-bore speculative mania.
- Steeeve 9y agoIf you're an NBA player, you spread the word about gold digger scams. If you're midlevel management you spread the word about timeshare scams. If you're a retiree, you spread the word about tech support scams. If you are a techie, you spread the word about blockchain investment scams because we're the target market for those scams. Scammers do their best to associate themselves with our communities because positive discussion at a place like hackernews is seen as "well, all those smart techies trust it..."
- ascendantlogic 9y agoThis is getting a lot of traction because anything related to crypto evokes really strong responses here, but this was a phishing attack. The fact it happened in the crypto space is largely secondary. People get phished and get tricked into handing out bank account and credit card details all the time. It's not even newsworthy unless it happens on a large scale. This is only newsworthy because of the fact that it's crypto so people equate this with some sort of deficiency with the technology and/or ecosystem. That's not the case.
- surrey-fringe 9y agoExcuse me, but Bitcoin is ENCRYPTED and SECRET
- ascendantlogic 9y agoit was encrypted and it was secret. They tricked people into giving them money. The currency is the only variable here. I do understand you're being sarcastic, though.
- drngdds 9y agoDo the victims ever get their money back after these cryptocurrency hacks/scams? I know crypto transactions are irreversible by nature, but do the coins ever get seized by law enforcement and returned to their owner? If not, that seems like a major problem. (I know they got around the DAO hack, but that's a unique case.)
- ringaroundthetx 9y agoNo, one thing that has been a partial remedy is that the token sale creators give the new token to the people that sent money to the wrong address anyway. It isn't really dilution to the founders so its easy to remedy. Case in point, Enigma was trying to raise $50,000,000 which they haven't even initiated yet. This was only going to result in 50% of the tokens in the hands of the public. So buyers would have new tokens and trade that amongst themselves and other people, Enigma would have $50m a lot of that for the founders, and Enigma would also have the other Enigma tokens which would also be valued at $50m which they could use for rewards or selling into the market in the future, all depends on how the market grows. The hackers get their $500k bug bounty and would have to have equally as bad OPSEC to get caught. The deterrents aren't really there right now, it isn't necessarily a problem, I don't really think the state is necessary here and I wouldn't want them to use my pooled resources on this given the cost of their investigations.
- CryptoPunk 9y agoHackerNews gets an unrepresentative picture of the token market. The only stories that get to the frontpage are the ones concerning hacks. But that's not the whole picture. There are a huge number of token sales happening, and the vast majority are not being hacked. This is certainly newsworthy but it needs to be put into the context of how many token sales occur.
- whipoodle 9y agoOK, but there are a lot of these. I get that it's not all of them, but the ratio has got to be terrible.
- NicenJehr 9y ago> 3. Weekly password rotation, and daily rotation in the week leading to the token sale this seems useless