4 ms·
There has been a lot of academic interest in doing something like this for Java, generally with a pitch like "If we took all the scary syntax out of it, program
by patio11 16y ago
There has been a lot of academic interest in doing something like this for Java, generally with a pitch like "If we took all the scary syntax out of it, programming would be accessible to $GROUP_OF_INTEREST." My personal opinion is that, with the debatable exception of Microsoft Excel, every project along these lines seems to rediscover "Oh yeah, syntax is rather useful for doing non-trivial work" roughly forty five seconds after the conclusion of their most advanced published tech demo.
- k7d 16y agoExactly.
- abhat 16y agoI doubt it, your statement reflects Ignorance. Have you tested for all $GROUP_OF_INTEREST s ? E.g. Chemical Engineers use flowchart based system to design and test plants which has a set of complex programming language associated with it. There isn't any syntax involved as such and serves the purpose really well. You seem to be living in your own small world.
- abhat 16y agoAlso simulink which is part of matlab package is quite successful. It has an underling syntax, but that hasn't led to complete abandonment of the gui. People dont write set of XML (Yuck!) files describing connections between individual components.
- credo 16y agoTrue, but the goal here is not necessarily "make programming more accessible". The goal is "make it possible to create an app with NO programming knowledge". The ability to create "trivial" apps and then run them on your cell phone can be exciting for many people. I think this will increase the appeal of Android as a consumer device. Of course, a big flood of trivial (tool-created) apps in the Android market may reduce some of that appeal, but overall, this seems like a good move by Google. It will be interesting to see if more people buy Android phones because they can now create and run their own apps on their phones
- WorkerBee 16y agoMaking apps is programming - you can make it more accessible, but "programming" is still a good definition of the activity. Making programs with no programming knowledge sounds about as useful as driving forklift trucks with no forklift-truck-driving-knowledge. There have been visual app generators before, for other platforms. None of them took the world by storm, and mostly were very limited and/or actually quite hard to learn - different from regular programming languages, but still with a learning curve. The devil's in the details, and a good programming language "makes easy things easy and hard things possible". App generators often succeed very well at the "makes easy things easy" part but fail at the "make hard things possible" bit.
- notauser 16y agoPhones are a bit different though. On the Internet, we saw a lot of 'personal home pages' which were basically globally accessible bookmark menus. Those had limited utility because they were public and only available when on-line. By comparison something as 'easy' as Frontpage would be great for making a personal single-purpose app for your phone. It doesn't have to do a great deal to be useful - perhaps it would just show the RSS feed from your school events society. Maybe it would just make a ping sound when you touched the screen, or be a really simple game just for the fun of it. If we are talking about 15 minutes of setup and build time then the apps really don't have to do much, and they only have to be useful to one person to get made. But it makes owning the phone much more interesting to people who are a bit geeky but don't code, which is important for Google. (Compare to the iPhone - where the easiest option is to set up a web server and build a single-purpose web site. That's easy for us but for a 10 year old it's a huge barrier.)
- wonkytonk 16y agoyou dont write an OS in GWBasic, but it sure does makes you interested in CS, rather than just watching some stupid crap on itunes
- rmc 16y agoExcel is one of the most widely used programming environments out there, and it's pretty visual.