7 ms·
> As for Robert Baruch's purchase of the chip, he contacted the eBay seller who gave him a refund. The seller explained that the chip must have been damaged in
by pavel_lishin 9y ago
> As for Robert Baruch's purchase of the chip, he contacted the eBay seller who gave him a refund. The seller explained that the chip must have been damaged in shipping!
I think at that point, you report them to Ebay for fraud, don't you? Or is that just spitting in the ocean?
- djsumdog 9y agoIt was more likely some salvager cleaning out a warehouse of old crap. Maybe they were printed in the same Fab and a whole batch of these got mislabeled? Maybe someone intentionally relabeled them years ago back when they were worth more?
- pavel_lishin 9y agoI'd argue that if you don't know what you're selling, you're still committing fraud.
- cat199 9y agoSo pretty much every grocery/convenince store, pharmacy, or any other retailer that relies on upstream supply chains is fraudulent because they have to rely on externally verified sources of trust and don't "know" what they are selling?
- rocky1138 9y agoHave you ever heard of 'mens rea' [0]? Essentially, I'd agree only if it could be proven that they knew the goods were shady but had a "don't ask, don't tell" policy and only used the ignorance as a shield to give them plausible deniability. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mens_rea https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mens_rea
- noonespecial 9y agoIf that were the case, I'd care very much about a mislabeled/counterfeit good and thank the buyer very much for letting me know, as well as immediately giving that refund. Claiming that it was "damaged in shipping" is the shadiest part of the whole deal. It pretty much guarantees the intentional fraud of the seller.
- exelius 9y agoI dunno about that -- for it to be intentional fraud, it would require the seller to know something. He probably knows next to nothing about electronics and just looked prices up in a catalog for a bunch of inventory he got really cheap somewhere. Have you ever seen the show "Storage Wars"? It's really dumb, but basically people go bid on abandoned storage lockers. I assume everything on that show gets sold on eBay. The people on the show are not exactly the best and brightest...
- lb1lf 9y ago-Or, in my experience just as likely - your complaint isn't read, or at the very least not being comprehended - just registered as a complaint, standard answer sent off (damaged in shipping) and refund issued. I have four (4!) copies of a Raymond Chandler paperback; a major online retailer named after a ditto river had it listed as a hardcover edition; I receive my first paperback, get in touch stating I ordered a hardcover, got a paperback, please advise. They told me to keep the defective item, new being shipped immediately, very sorry &c. 2nd paperback arrive, I tell them again that what I ordered was a hardcover; very sorry, keep it, correct item coming soon. 3rd paperback arrive; I beg them to just check their inventory; book must have been wrongly classified. "Very sorry. Keep it, we'll send you a new one." I gave up. 4th book arrived. Anyone interested in a nice copy of "Killer in the rain"? Two copies? Pleeease?
- joveian 9y agoI recently discovered this as well. It turns out that on ebay, "30 day money back guarantee" means "seller is not required to read messages and buyer may not leave feedback that points out that they don't". So as shady as the response seems, I agree with you that this equally likely.
- alasdair_ 9y agoThe worst thing about the "guarantee" is when they send you an item with expensive shipping (bulky/ heavy) that is completely wrong or incorrect. Then ebay demands that the buyer needs to pay for return shipping, despite doing nothing wrong. I don't want to pay $30+ on shipping to return an item that was incorrectly sent to me.
- otterpro 9y agoWhether it was intentional or not, my fear is that the seller will simply re-list the item and try to sell it again to the next "victim". It should be reported, no matter how minute, so that more Ebay and sellers become aware of the problem. I'm so tired of seeing fake SD Cards, fake CPU, fake laptop battery, fake toys, etc. that I've lost trust on things being sold on Ebay.
- jxramos 9y agoits funny, but I remember someone giving me the tip that they try to buy from low volume sellers. It's sort of this weird inverse trust thing, the more volume a seller pushes the more untrustworthy they smell. I've found that with my low seller count my stuff has often sold pretty quick. Scary to think about fake batteries and any other obscure products that can't have its internals inspected.
- paulmd 9y agoThere are some sellers who specialize in legitimate batteries sourced from the official supply chain but they are few and far between. Anyone who wants an easy startup: it's literally impossible to find high-quality aftermarket laptop batteries, the market is swamped with shitty Chinese knockoffs that die in a couple months (or sooner). The battery cells themselves are usually the part that dies, it's pretty straightforward to refurbish the battery by replacing the cells. But right now there is just no place to buy decent-quality replacement packs, it's OEM direct from the supplier or cheap chinese junk, nothing in between. I have no idea why SterlingTek or Wasabi Power or some of the other companies that fill this niche for camera batteries haven't jumped into these other markets, but they haven't, and the niche remains unfilled.
- bloaf 9y agoDo you have any experience with Nickel–iron batteries from Chinese companies? They seem like the kind of tech where a "cheap knockoff" might be good enough because they're A) not that fancy and B) durable as heck.
- 9y ago
- rbcgerard 9y agoJust my two cents but ebay is irretrievably broken (especially if you want to sell something), the only thing it works for is buying small $ items where you're not too put out of it's a fake/fraud...
- maccard 9y agoI'm a semi frequent ebay user. I've Bought and sold a lot of video games over the last few years (normal value of between 10 and 40 pounds per transaction) and I'd tend to agree. I'd never use it for anything more expensive, and definitely not as a seller. As a buyer, I know I'm all but guaranteed a refund from eBay if the seller tries to scam me (which has happened) but as a seller I'm screwed if a buyer decides to scam me. (Which has also happened). Even if the buyer doesn't scam me, by the time I've paid eBay fees and PayPal fees and postage, it's eaten into the small value fairly substantially.
- stevenwoo 9y agoI can remember 10 years ago finding that most bargain cartridge games I bought were counterfeit (getting ones with typos in the name/description on the box art were my awakening) but worked fine. At that point someone might as well get a programmable cartridge and insert one's own memory cards.
- stordoff 9y ago> At that point someone might as well get a programmable cartridge and insert one's own memory cards. I wouldn't be surprised if that's what some of the fake carts are. I ordered an X-in-1 card for DS recently (haven't seen one since the OG GameBoy days and was curious), and it was just a generic DS flashcart with a QA sticker covering the SD slot. Same seller was selling a bunch of single DS games without box and suspiciously cheap, so I wouldn't be surprised if they were essentially the same thing.
- new299 9y agoIn general I've found it's pretty easy to get refunded. And for items like this, the seller is often super-quick to refund. They're just playing a numbers game, and know many/most people wont bother.
- pizza234 9y agoI had two (and "half") fraud experiences, and Ebay didn't care much. One case was a fake flash key, another a scammer trying to "buy" my laptop with fake bank transfer receipts, and the last one a genuine SD card, but destined to the chinese market. In all cases Ebay didn't care much; in the first, I even lost my money. Nowadays, when something similar happens, I just report the item as not arrived; although this is not 100% ethical, for clients it's sadly the safest way. This is in reality part of a much larger issue, where the portals profit from being more lenient, so that they have a larger amount of sellers (and sales) of cheap crap, rather than being more punishing, and losing sales. I definitely advise to report items as not arrived, rather than risking through reporting frauds.
- ryanlol 9y ago>where the portals profit from being more lenient, so that they have a larger amount of sellers (and sales) of cheap crap, rather than being more punishing, and losing sales OTOH being more punishing also incentivizes false reporting by competitors, which isn't at all rare.
- kentt 9y agoEbay does not care about counterfeit items. I bought $300 fake Bose and they did nothing about it. I had the persons address and everything and they were in a neighbouring city to me.
- X86BSD 9y agoIs there another auction site that addresses these issues better? Or is this just the nature of the beast?
- jacquesm 9y agoCatawiki.
- nobodyorother 9y agoAssuming you live in Iowa, you could sell that as a really bad revenge action movie: eBay's Bose Boise Betrayal.
- KerrickStaley 9y agoBoise is not in Iowa.
- sitkack 9y agoIt was poorly done knock-off.
- DrPhish 9y agoNot only is it useless, it can be actively harmful. My wife had her account "suspended" for reporting too many fraudulent cases when she went on a buying spree from Chinese sellers. Normally you lose about a 3rd of the things you buy from China due to: -Non-shipping of items -Loss of items in transit -Counterfeit items -Damaged items -Completely wrong items -Wrong quantity items Turns out she opened too many cases and they "suspended" her account, which is an eBay euphemism for being banned for life. That means that her account that she'd been using since 2000 was dead and gone forever, and she was no longer welcome on the site. I agree with other posters. The eBay of old is effectively dead. You are better off buying things from Amazon or Ali Express 99% of the time. The days of great deals on items are pretty much gone. You can still find some rare and unusual stuff that is worth buying, but the dominance of eBay now means that most things are very close to market rate unless (or even if!) they are counterfeit or some other scam. More like a dollar store than an online auction house.
- monksy 9y agoMuch of the time things from Amazon are actually from Aliexpress.
- tluyben2 9y agoThat is why for a lot of things I prefer Aliexpress: no issues with refunds. The sellers usually even do not care about proof but just refund.
- hvidgaard 9y agoI've bought quite a bit from AliExpress, and the sellers have always send a new item or refunded. It can be annoying to keep track of, but that's what you get for the extremely cheap prices.
- pizza234 9y ago> You are better off buying things from Amazon or Ali Express 99% of the time I wouldn't say that. I buy from both, and it's a matter of know what you're getting into. For example, in eBay, it's much more obvious which the location of the shop is (although, it can be tricked as well). At the same time, the client protection process is somewhat simpler in Amazon.