3 ms·
To quote Felix von Leitner (https://blog.fefe.de/?ts=a7666dad https://blog.fefe.de/?ts=a7666dad): > You cannot solve social problems by using technology. And
by mschuster91 9y ago
To quote Felix von Leitner (https://blog.fefe.de/?ts=a7666dad https://blog.fefe.de/?ts=a7666dad):
> You cannot solve social problems by using technology.
And when you do try to do so, it quickly gets nasty. Just look at the #Shadowban scandal on Twitter.
You will need humans in the loop, and they need to be well-trained, in order to actually recognize images such as the famous Vietnam napalm girl, which FB banned for "nudity" until huge public shitstorm, and well-paid and well-"maintained" in psychological terms, given that they will see the nastiest content on the web... everything from child porn over gore to livestreams of rapes and murders.
But, to be honest: this should not be done by the sites themselves - the best solution is an "ombudsman", an independent institution maintained by the state but financed by the social networks. This prevents "overcensoring" (aka that the moderators don't delete too much content that's legit out of the fear they might be hit with costly punishments), and having them mandatory financed by the "big players" prevents them from systematically understaffing or exploiting the workers. Also, they will need to have a proper appeal process: both for content creators whose work has been inappropriately taken down, and for users who believe that the content in question is, in fact, illegitimate.
Also, the sites must be regulated as public utilities given their importance to people's communications. For example, my phone provider is not allowed to terminate me, only if I haven't paid my bills for longer than 3 months - while e.g. Google can terminate my account (and thus, all my emails, all my purchased applications/other content on Play Store) because people abuse the Youtube flagging system and have my account terminated. Same goes for Facebook and Twitter. There needs to be an independent, legal way of forcing them to provide service.
- HarryHirsch 9y agoYou must be from somewhere where they have a functioning government. Here in the US they don't trust the government to be accountable, consequently they farm out its responsibilities to a host of unaccountable private companies.
- marcosdumay 9y agoThat must have been the longest lived and most successful large scale propaganda attempt in the world. There are many countries (not just the US) convinced that unaccountable entities can manage a monopoly with more accountability than their government.
- slededit 9y agoIts more that third party companies can and are replaced over time while the government always remains. Were Facebook and google to go "too far" they could be replaced by other online venues. Replacing the US government would require violent revolution. The democratic system was supposed to solve this problem. However while the man in "charge" comes and goes the bureaucracy has been moving in only one direction.
- mschuster91 9y ago> Replacing the US government would require violent revolution. Not necessarily - what Bannon championed for was, basically, the deconstruction of the state. For example, Trump still hasn't filled hundreds of leadership positions,and a government shutdown isn't unlikely given the disconnect between Trump government and Congress, as well as the Democrats opposition to anything Trump/Rep Congress want to do. It's going to get interesting pretty soon.