18 ms·
How Women Got Crowded Out of the Computing Revolution
- lsd5you 9y agoI am well aware that the climate is well against this position, but you cannot just dismiss the 'Damore' view out of hand. He is not just 'wrong'. The Damore view is at the very least plausible and tarring a whole industry filled with many thoughtful and introverted (i.e. not messing with others, often taken advantage of themselves) individuals to support some view of gender economics is morally wrong. We now live in a time where we are increasingly told what we should believe. In my view morality shouldn't extend to belief. For one it leaves certain individuals (like myself) out in the cold. Sorry, I cannot be told what to believe. Maybe this is just the current hot topic and many people want to read it, but to me it reads as a form of propaganda (by definition media created to determine what people believe) or at least journalistic activism, and who is this guy (apparently some business journalist) to write authoratively on the subject, based on one fact (the predominance of women in early programming jobs). The fact of the matter is that programming has changed beyond recognition, particularly between 1950 and 1980 or so and that is more than enough to at the very least plausibly explain the change in programmer demographic. Anyone who is in the industry knows these eras cannot be compared (surely?).
- ocfx 9y agoYeah this article felt like clickbait to me. Also Google's reaction to Damore kind of proves at least half of his assertions correct. That many topics are too sacred to discuss critically without being labeled a certain way.
- danharaj 9y agoJames Damore's arguments are only plausible in the weakest sense of the word. The only way someone would find his arguments convincing is if one's priors already favor his conclusion. If one weighs the evidence for social factors against biological factors, the question is how should a critical person weigh one against the other? It turns out if one ignores all the evidence for social factors and squint really hard at the biological ones, one can, I guess, scam oneself into thinking there's a strong argument there.
- Fricken 9y agoBiology and culture are not unrelated, there are very tight feedback loops at play there, the two factors are deeply intertwined. I'd be distrustful of anyone who suggests it's exclusively one or the other.
- sanxiyn 9y agoI found evidencs from CAH(Congenital adrenal hyperplasia) rather convincing, in that it is hard to imagine how that effect is entirely social. Admittedly, this evidence was not presented in Damore's memo, so I guess "The only way someone would find his arguments convincing" may stand, if we strictly restrict to "his arguments", but I think it's more useful to consider the best possible version of his arguments augmented by other people.
- mpweiher 9y agoHis claim was that biological factors "could" explain the gap, at least in part, in that you can't rule out that possibility categorically. I don't recall him claiming that biological factors were the more important factors, never mind the only ones.
- danharaj 9y agoIf you don't consider evidence you are aware of in an argument, it means you don't think that evidence is necessary to consider. He wants his argument to be considered rigorously in which case it is appropriate to make inferences about what he didn't consider as well as what he did. It's a quiet truth that most disagreements between people have a crucial basis in the implicit nature of how we weigh and consider information. A great deal of defense of Damore's arguments are to only consider what is explicitly said and not how it fits into the broader discussion, which is implicit by definition. So Damore can claim he isn't saying that he thinks some female engineers currently at Google are there because the bar has been lowered (explicit) and this is accepted uncritically by some defenders, but it's not hard to draw the inference from his arguments and his policy suggestions that he thinks Google's current practices have a negative impact on the quality of engineers it recruits (implicit). Likewise we are told to evaluate the information he gave (explicit) but not consider why he omitted discussing the mountains of evidence that suggest alternative positions and how his arguments should be evaluated in light of it (implicit). My position is that there is the evidence of negative social feedback is significant enough that companies should experiment with changing their demographic compositions and empirically measuring performance. Because software engineering requires a great diversity of skills, including people skills, empathy and whole-systems thinking, I think it's very plausible that making the gender balance less skewed will lead to more productive teams.
- cmiles74 9y agoThere is a lot wrong here, but what bothers me right this minute is the idea that computer programming has "changed beyond recognition" between 1950 and 1980 and that is the cause of the gender imbalance we see today. For sure, a lot of progress was made in the field during that time span. But did the work materially change? I don't think that's the case at all, we simply saw huge steps made in the quality of the tooling and the machines; they didn't fundamentally transform into different things. The tools improved a great deal and allowed the same amount of people to accomplish more work in the same amount of time, progress that continues to this day (we can complain about Electron until we're hoarse, but it does make it easier to get an application out on every device and one person could conceivably so just that). This is just more painful gymnastics and contortions trying to find another reason for the gender imbalance when the actual cause is obvious and well documented: one gender is working to keep the other out. Damore's memo is an example of this: entirely lacking in applicable science and with a basis grounded almost entirely in the man's existing biases. Talk to some of the people of another gender currently in the field and just listen to what they are saying. You'll hear about educators with axes to grind, encouraging them to pursue another field. You'll hear about coworkers and employers who suspect their work is not their own. You'll hear about job interviews where no answers are correct. And you'll come to Hacker News and read posts like these, from people in the field, insisting that there is no problem.
- belorn 9y ago> did the work materially change? I don't think that's the case at all How much money was the computer programming industry creating 1950 vs 1980. In the memo, one of the larger points was that men are exceptional pushed/forced/heavy incentivize by society towards high paying jobs. Would you argue that this claim is false?
- cmiles74 9y agoI don't understand where you are going with this... Is your argument that since society seems biased to pay men more money, we should blindly do so? Does that logic apply to race as well as gender? IMHO, Damore was playing to the misplaced belief held by some men that they are innately better then everyone else and that societal biases have played no role in their successes.
- pron 9y ago> but you cannot just dismiss the 'Damore' view out of hand But it is not dismissed out of hand. It is dismissed by serious scholars after significant research. It is Damore who dismisses their well-informed position out of hand by taking out of context some papers whose significance he is not qualified to judge. It is he who rejects scholarship and serious investigation in favor of gut feelings. If Damore's view were as well researched as the prevailing view, then it would merit more careful consideration. But as it stands, he is some lay person who, for his own reasons, decides that the scholars are wrong. Physicists don't debate all the bloggers who misunderstand or take out of context physics papers, so why should social scholars debate some random guy at Google who wrote a rant? After all, the couple of papers he cites are scholarly works. Do you think those works are not debated in the research community? But you can't debate some layperson who clearly did not bother to put any effort into studying the issue (e.g., he does not discuss any other paper that contradicts his political views, and there are many more of those). If you want, there are some venues (like /r/science, /r/AskHistorians and others) where experts discuss research with laypeople, and you're welcome to ask them questions there. The belief that there is any serious scholarship behind Damore's rant that's being silenced by non-experts is the exact opposite of what's really going on.
- deepnotderp 9y agohttp://quillette.com/2017/08/07/google-memo-four-scientists-respond/ http://quillette.com/2017/08/07/google-memo-four-scientists-... http://slatestarcodex.com/2017/08/07/contra-grant-on-exaggerated-differences/ http://slatestarcodex.com/2017/08/07/contra-grant-on-exagger...
- pron 9y agoBoth are conservative publications, which is fine, but: There are certainly some researchers, like those in the first article, who agree with Damore's position, but they are by far the minority; if you're interested in the subject, I suggest you at least read some research written by the majority opinion. The second link is written by a non-expert, and therefore does not constitute a scholarly opinion at all. I occasionally enjoy reading some of Alexander's writing, but he is clearly not a serious social scholar, and his writing suffers from some obvious methodological problems that have been well covered in social scholarship.
- sillysaurus3 9y agoI have always wondered: People often point to graphs showing a massive decline in the percentage of women in CS in the 80's. But has anyone seen a graph of the absolute number, not percentages? If 1 million women were coding, then 100 billion men started coding, those 1M women would still be coders. So there wasn't necessarily a decline. Or maybe there was, and the numbers will reflect that. I am interested in the actual numbers, not graphs or interpretations. But I've never found a data source, so hopefully someone knows of one. The whole debate is interesting because there are at least four separate sides: men who don't believe it exists, men who recognize it as a systemic problem, women who believe it's the most important aspect, and women who wish the debate would go away so they can focus on doing good work instead of on doing good work as a woman. Me, I don't know enough about it. I'm just curious about the numbers over time. And if I have a daughter hopefully I'll think of some crafty way to make programming seem interesting. The one badass female dev I know said she regretted not getting into it from a younger age, so it seems worth fixing.
- LogicalBorg 9y agoThis may be what you're looking for: https://nces.ed.gov/programs/digest/d12/tables/dt12_349.asp https://nces.ed.gov/programs/digest/d12/tables/dt12_349.asp According to that table, women's bachelor's degrees in computer science: * were low in the 1970's, about 15% average * were higher in the 1980's, about 35% average * declined in the 1990's to about 25-30% * steadily declined from 27 to 17% in the 2000's
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- sillysaurus3 9y agoThank you. Perfect. Now I feel like we're in a position to have a productive debate. For example, there was a sharp decline in the rate of bachelor's degrees for women, but not master's degrees. Those remained nearly the same, then declined at the same rate as men's. It's interesting to see the actual numbers because it clearly shows there is/was a problem. Now, how best to solve it? One issue with quotas is that the rate of women graduates can't necessarily keep up. It seems like we could use an influx of new students (in addition to the current efforts).
- b6 9y agoSuch bunk. I spent thousands of hours fighting with computers due to obsession, certainly not because I had some notion that it was important or that it would be considered a good occupation 20 years in the future. I was practically living a double life as a computer bodybuilder, despite the reaction society gave me about it. When I look back over how I got good at computers and programming, I see no reason women could not have done the same thing. Yet most didn't. Why they didn't, I don't know. Sexism could probably stop a woman from being in construction, but not so much programming. Let's stop with these persecution myths.
- danharaj 9y agoThere's a strong correlation between women entering a field and it having low prestige, and men entering a field and it having higher prestige. Guess which field of ours was considered busywork for women to do until men realized it was going to transform society as we know it.
- utnick 9y agoWhen do you think programming began to have high prestige? I didn't think programming in the 80s or 90s was a particularly prestigous or high status job, salaries back then kind of reflect that too
- cmiles74 9y agoIt was pretty prestigious in the 90's and seems to remain so today. At parties where I'm required to mix with other adults from varying backgrounds (i.e. a child's birthday party), they are almost universally impressed that I am in software development. As a child, people did seem impressed (in the 80's) that my father was a developer and we were one of the few families in town that had a proper computer (not an Atari 2600 or an Intellivison).
- someguydave 9y agoI don't think it is a prestigious job today. When was the last time you remember a movie starring a computer programmer? How often do you hear the phrase "We better consult the computer programmers before we make this important decision"? How many novels center on the daily procedures of computer programming?
- innocentoldguy 9y agoPerhaps, but even if the article is correct, and male programmers in the 1960s did intentionally crowd out women, doesn't that demonstrate what Damore posited when he said women are less assertive and less aggressive, in general? It seems disingenuous for the author of the article to declare Damore "wrong," when studies back up what Damore said, and this article itself suggests those tendencies to be accurate, at least to some degree.
- k__ 9y agoI don't understand this whole thing. Until recent years all developers I met were socially awkward men, me included. These are not the kind of people I would attribute any power to "crowd out" anyone. To me it seemed that they started doing computer stuff, because no one, including women, wanted to have anything to do with them. The "cool", way more aggressive, kids wanted to do sales, law, finance, management and stuff. Computers were new and complicated, a unsafe bet for people who were so good included into society.
- delhanty 9y ago>Until recent years all developers I met were socially awkward men, me included. +1 - that's how I remember it too! I asked the following 12 days ago [0]: >One thing I'd like to ask the women in this forum: >If you'd grown up back in the day before tech was cool and techies were (generally) just nerds with no money, would you have still been interested in tech? >... I didn't get any replies though ... [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14956137 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14956137
- purpleostrich 9y agoI just replied. We exist. In my case, I did not get exposed to programming or computers until I was 24 yrs. old, though chance employment.
- naturalgradient 9y agoThis is an aspect that has always been bugging me as well. There is this implied notion that for men, it was ok or even encouraged to be nerdy and spend all their spare time in front of a screen. In my experience, committing to this lifestyle meant being socially crowded out. Some people were unpopular to begin with and sort of found refuge in the computer world out of necessity, some of us accepted being unpopular/uncool because we did not care. One possible explanation, but potentially an offensive one, and only based on personal experience: fewer women were willing to make this sacrifice, at least in school. Interestingly, this was not because boys would be unwelcoming but because other women would judge them harshly for stepping out. On a related anecdote, I frequently observed girls in school downplaying their math abilities in front of their friends - not because men judged them, but because they did not want to stand out in front of their friends. I suppose the interesting question is why they felt this way, and I would not wager to answer it. I just think the theory 'men are not letting women into tech' simply does not hold up in the formative school years. Only very recently (since the social network movie) there has been this glorification of tech in combination with the startup lifestyle.
- camperman 9y agoThe _very first sentence_ is a misrepresentation of Damore's memo. "Why aren’t there more female software developers in Silicon Valley? James Damore, the Google engineer fired for criticizing the company's diversity program, believes that it’s all about “innate dispositional differences” that leave women trailing men." "Innate dispositional differences" is a _quote_ from a paper he cites, Why Can’t a Man Be More Like a Woman? Sex Differences in Big Five Personality Traits Across 55 Cultures, a 2008 paper from the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology. Damore introduces the quote with the phrase "research suggests." The computing revolution is dominated by men because men have no problem at all spending thousands of hours tinkering with something just for its own sake. The real world confirms this.
- PeachPlum 9y agoOne of the stars of comptuing, Grace Hopper, rarely mentions her sex. She talks of inspiring young people, her talks are technical. I think we are too quick to get wrapped up in identity politics.
- Klockan 9y ago> They found some predictable ones: a love of solving puzzles, for example. But the only “striking characteristic” that defined successful male programmers was “their disinterest in people.” A subsequent study -- one that was overlooked in subsequent years -- found this to be true of female programmers as well. Isn't this trait much more prevalent among males though? Could explain why we saw women flock to more social fields when the barriers were removed.
- RealityNow 9y agoEven if the author's premise that women were "crowded out" of programming 40 years ago is true, that does not imply that “innate dispositional differences” between sexes don't influence one's tendency towards pursuing certain fields. The author suggests that the current stereotypical portrait of a geeky socially awkward neckbearded male engineer was socially engineered, causing a self-fulfilling prophecy. That's idiotic conspiracy nonsense. Geeky reclusive men tend to pursue computer programming because dealing with a machine doesn't involve dealing with a human, not due to society's marketing of computer engineers as geeks. The author is clearly not a computer programmer (professor of history apparently), nor someone capable of basic logic. If you're going to cash in on the diversity scandal for views, at least make a coherent argument. (Also this post is a dupe, I submitted the same post before this and this is a copy and paste of my comment on the original thread)
- tnone 9y agoLuckily programming or computing hasn't changed at all since the 50s and 60s, so we can effortlessly assume that what people said about it then still applies perfectly to today's distributed, abstract, always-on landscape. Even more, we can use the view from the 50s and 60s, a time which was not sexist at all, to explain why today is more sexist than ever. Women outnumber men in colleges. Women have an easier time getting jobs. Single, childless women outearn men in that category. Women just aren't choosing STEM. And apparently the solution is to tell them loudly how horrible the people they'd get to work with are. Who are some bizarre amalgam of a Goldman Sachs elevator and the cast of Big Bang Theory. Which you can effortlessly get a flood of coverage about, even though you're supposedly oppressed and are fighting the status quo. Go away old media, go away tech feminists, go away white knights. If people stopped seeing women as victims, you'd lose your meal ticket, your power fetish and your moral superiority.
- setra 9y agoSlateStarCodex did an in depth cover of this issue at: http://slatestarcodex.com/2017/08/07/contra-grant-on-exaggerated-differences/ http://slatestarcodex.com/2017/08/07/contra-grant-on-exagger...
- lumberjack 9y agoWhen do we start looking at articles like this as misandry? The author is seriously implying there was some sort of conspiracy that all men partook in, with the intent to exclude women from software development. Are you fucking kidding me? This shit has gone too far.
- cmiles74 9y agoThere's no conspiracy, there's only satisfaction with the status quo that leads to those with the upper hand working to preserve the status quo. This dynamic is discussed all the time on this forum.
- peoplewindow 9y agoUgh. So basically when programming was unskilled and considered one step up from being a secretary, women did that and men built the machines themselves. As software became a larger and larger component of the machines, and more and more complex, it became dominated by men. This, we learn, is because men made it more rigorous and scientific as part of some bizarre sexist plot. Or maybe the nature of programming today is pretty different to how it was in the immediate post-war years, and the kinds of jobs women can get changed too.
- cmiles74 9y agoI'd bet that as the field grew, they eventually had a surplus of engineers working on new hardware and a deficit of people working to write new software. Once there were men willing to do the work, they were seen as a better bet than the women already in the field. The same thing happened after WW2, this isn't a new pattern.
- d728ud 9y agoWhy do sites like bloomberg.com publish such ill-researched propaganda? Are they acting on behalf of certain interest groups who want more obedient, fungible and cheaper devs?
- csomar 9y agoWhy is the obsession with this topic? I have never been to the US but is there a problem for a female to be a software developer in the US? Is this problem just in the US? By the way, there are countries where over 50% of CS Students are female.
- botverse 9y agoHow advertising of computers was made had an important accelerating effect towards the exclusion of women from the industry. https://qz.com/911737/silicon-valleys-gender-gap-is-the-result-of-computer-game-marketing-20-years-ago/ https://qz.com/911737/silicon-valleys-gender-gap-is-the-resu...
- botverse 9y agoThanks for the down-vote. More on this, computer were expensive toys, and traditionally boys get more expensive toys than girls. It's quite understandable the marketing decision there. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2005/dec/06/gender.christmas https://www.theguardian.com/world/2005/dec/06/gender.christm...
- rhapsodic 9y agoJust once, I would like to read in one of these articles about an actual non-anonymous woman who could plausibly demonstrate that a.) she had a strong desire to be a software developer, b.) she had developed sufficient skills in a marketable language to be employed as one, and c.) she had made a prolonged effort to find employment as one, and d.) she was unable land a job as a software developer. Instead, it's always about something that a magazine ad said in 1969, or a teacher who told them that woman couldn't be programmers, or the boys in their school computer club ignored, them, etc. etc. And the prescriptions, as usual, are that in order to get more woman into software development, that changes must be imposed on men, not woman. This crap got old a long time ago.
- rhapsodic 9y agoThe parent of this post has been getting about an equal number of upvotes as downvotes.
- deepnotderp 9y agoIt's hilarious that they criticize the stereotype of nerdy outcast male. If you're a girl, 9/10 you will never get flak for being nerdy (yes, exceptions exist, i know, but in my experience), on the other hand, emasculating the male nerd is practically a national pastime. To add to the irony, a surprisingly large proportion of the anti - Damore tweets were criticizing his appearance and/or calling him a virgin.
- deepnotderp 9y agoNotice how they make the claim that males used underhanded tactics to force women out of the software industry, but they never provide a single bit of evidence for that. The entire article is basically about the software industry evolved into more male positions and things like altitude tests and requirements of advanced degrees which are apparently part of some coordinated conspiracy to be sexist against women. I agree that aptitude tests and degrees are stupid , but for totally different reasons. This is just incredible mental gymnastics to push an agenda.
- abalone 9y agoThis is an important and well-written article that succinctly exposes the history and mechanisms of sexism in the industry. How once software became a valued profession a complex of obstacles at the cultural and professional level were put in place to change its composition from primarily women to men. It is also a damning indictment of the HN community. It is clear this post has suffered a campaign of down voting. Every comment that is positive toward the article, even just summarizing its content, has been downvoted. By the time I finished reading it it had disappeared off the front page entirely. Meanwhile, many of the comments merely state anecdotal experiences and armchair theories reinforcing why men end up dominating the field, while entirely ignoring the content of the article. There are clearly some high-karma men aggressively censoring this topic. I hope this article makes it back onto the front page because it's really worth a read by our whole community -- even if you disagree.
- rhapsodic 9y ago> It is also a damning indictment of the HN community. It is clear this post has suffered a campaign of down voting. Every comment that is positive toward the article, even just summarizing its content, has been downvoted. By the time I finished reading it it had disappeared off the front page entirely. I don't know for sure, obviously, but based on the patterns I've casually observed on HN in the past, I suspect this article was flagged not because it promotes a male-blaming POV, but because the anti-male-blaming types seem to be winning the arguments in the comments. And on topics as polarizing as this one, I suspect that every comment, on either side, gets some number of downvotes and upvotes. It's the countering effect of the upvotes that keep them from getting killed. Personally, I upvote a lot more than I downvote, and I routinely upvote posts I disagree with if it appears they were made in good faith and some thought was put into them, but are nonetheless suffering a lot of downvotes.
- booleandilemma 9y ago"More women should be coding" I see an article with some variation of this argument here every week. I’m starting to believe that society has become obsessed with getting more women to open up Visual Studio every morning. But this isn't like recycling, saving the rainforest, stopping ozone depletion or global warming. All of humanity benefits from doing those things. I couldn't care less if the person who develops the next hot phone app is a man or a woman. I don't think any end user cares. Because the fact is it doesn't matter. A Git repository doesn't treat code any differently depending on the gender of the person who pushed it. And yet I see a new article about getting women to code every week. Are women themselves fighting for the right to hit F10 and step through code every day? Is it akin to another woman suffrage movement? I don't think so. In fact, I think the majority of women just don't seem to be interested in coding. It's as if this is someone else’s agenda. An agenda to get more women to code, whether they want to or not. So who’s pushing this agenda? If corporations are pushing it, then the end goal is probably to save money, because that's why corporations will push any agenda.
- riskable 9y ago> Sexist stereotypes are used today to justify not hiring women programmers, [Citation Needed] Only once (recently) have I ever had the chance to interview a woman for a job. She was fine. I gave my approval. We didn't end up hiring her. Why? Because someone else had more of the specific skills we were looking for. She was just unlucky. 5-6 other people were also turned down for the same reason. The guy that was hired just happened to have experience in some of the products we were working with.
- aaimnr 9y agoSlatestarcodex in the article cited here multiple times made a point that men didn't push out women out of other high paying fields like law or medicine. If the theory is right, why did it only happen in IT?
- hokkos 9y agoIt's sad the article starts with the use of the Ada Lovelace trope, she is not widely considered to be the first computer programmer, or maybe on a pop culture way, not in a scholarly way.
- Mz 9y agoIf this is at all accurate, then all it is saying is that programming started as a pink collar ghetto. The article itself indicates it was dominated by women as long as it was considered "glorified clerical work." This is actually really normal stuff, not peculiar to the computer industry. "Serious jobs" tend to get dominated by men. This may be related to "the second shift" -- that women seek jobs that don't take an excess of their energy so they can go home and cook, clean, etc. Men are much more often in a position to say "Woman, get me a beer" and just collapse after giving their all to their job. I don't know a solution. But, I think we aren't going to find one if we don't first recognize that one of the roots of such problems is not that women are predisposed to certain kinds of labor, but that society as a whole expects women to do "women's work" at home and this is rooted in the reality that women can get pregnant, men cannot. A lot of traditional gender roles grow out of that and a lot of societal expectations grow out of that and it wasn't intended to oppress women. It evolved organically as a way for both adults in a household to contribute meaningfully to making ends meet, raising the kids, etc at a time when birth control was not readily available and yadda.