5 ms·
I'm not a libertarian anymore, but I still don't really buy into this criticism, for a few reasons. Taxes are a legal obligation. If taxes aren't high enough,
by philwelch 9y ago
I'm not a libertarian anymore, but I still don't really buy into this criticism, for a few reasons.
Taxes are a legal obligation. If taxes aren't high enough, it's the government's job to fix that. Paying more taxes than you are legally obligated to pay is a disservice to shareholders, which in the case of a YC company includes almost all of your investors and employees.
Corporate taxes in particular are economically inefficient. Corporations are just straw men. Any money that a corporation earns is either paid out as dividends (at which point it's taxable as individual income) or reinvested into growing the company (at which point it turns into things like "salary", which is taxable as individual income).
The US in particular has exceptionally high corporate tax rates--among the highest in the developed world. And if you're going to choose a tax to avoid paying, US federal corporate tax is pretty much an ideal choice. Very little of that money goes to things like schools (which are paid for on the local and state level) or Medicare (which is paid for with payroll taxes). The biggest chunk of it pays for the US military, and a huge chunk of US military spending is pork for defense contractors.
In other words, US federal corporate taxes are largely a mechanism to redistribute money from corporations like Dropbox towards corporations like Blackwater and Lockheed Martin. And you think it's nice and decent of Dropbox to play along with this scheme?
- Retric 9y agoNameplate tax rate is basically meaningless. US effective corporate tax rate after deductions is lower than the OECD average. Though by how much is up for debate. PS: You can debate various points, but it's only 11% of total federal tax revenue.
- gnicholas 9y agoYou're correct that the nominal rate is much higher than the effective rate for most US corporations. This is especially true for tech companies, which have R&D tax credits and are able to shift much of their income offshore because their profits are based largely on intangibles (which can be moved by signing some contracts, as opposed to factories or restaurants, which are geographically fixed).
- adventured 9y agoThe US effective corporate tax rate is not lower than the OECD average in fact. The most authoritative, recent report on the matter by the CBO: https://www.cbo.gov/sites/default/files/115th-congress-2017-2018/reports/52419-internationaltaxratecomp.pdf https://www.cbo.gov/sites/default/files/115th-congress-2017-... It clearly makes the case that the US is non-competitive with other G20 nations on the corporate tax rate. The US average corporate income tax rate for 2012, was 29%. In Canada it was 16%; Brazil 22%; China 19%; UK 10%; Germany 14.5%; Australia 17%; South Korea 20%; France 20%. How much more non-competitive can the US get exactly? And when it comes to the OECD, the US is once again far from competitive: "The most recent estimate comes from the World Bank and International Finance Commission, which put the United States’ effective rate for 2014 at 27.9 percent. That’s second-highest behind New Zealand among OECD countries and 15th-highest among the 189 countries measured." http://www.politifact.com/punditfact/statements/2014/sep/09/eric-bolling/does-us-have-highest-corporate-tax-rate-free-world/ http://www.politifact.com/punditfact/statements/2014/sep/09/...
- Retric 9y agoSanity check, What is total US corporate profit before taxes per year? And what's 27.9 percent of that. Or from GAO: http://www.gao.gov/assets/660/654957.pdf http://www.gao.gov/assets/660/654957.pdf "For tax year 2010 (the most recent information available), profitable U.S. corporations that filed a Schedule M-3 paid U.S. federal income taxes amounting to about 13 percent of the pretax worldwide income that they reported in their financial statements" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Repatriation_tax_holiday https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Repatriation_tax_holiday dropped actual tax rate to 5.25% in 2004. Companies are more than happy to wait for the next one. PS: Also of note a lot of overseas profit is anything as it's easy to pretend US operations only break even by shifting around costs on paper.
- valuearb 9y agoYou are mixing tax deferral with tax rates, there are few meaningful deductions in the US corporate tax code, it tries to match actual profits to your tax obligation. But the US tax code only taxes corporations doing business in the US. Apple's international subsidiaries net tens of billions in profits every year, after paying substantial taxes in their home countries. Those aren't taxable in the US until they are returned to the US. Since Apple would owe over 42% in income taxes to the state of California and the US government if they moved them, they keep them in Ireland instead. Which means they can't be paid as dividends to Apple shareholders. The day Apple repatriates those profits they'll pay the full US corporate tax rate, which is currently one of the highest corporate tax rates in the free world. Then they'll pay the remainder as dividends, which will be taxed again at the shareholder level, for a total effective tax rate on those profits of over 50%. And that tax rate is not progressive, the little old grandma with apple stock in her savings pays the same rate as a billionaire. The fact that it's only 11% of US income tax receipts is a great argument for abolishing corporate income taxes entirely. We can replace some of it by taxing dividends and capital gains at personal income rates (as long as capital gains are indexed to inflation). But the trillions of dollars in capital trapped overseas that will return to the US will more than fill the gap. And making the US a far more attractive place to invest, increasing our productivity and GDP growth. All of that will generate even more tax revenue. People who think the corporate tax rate is fine or that corporations should pay even more are like a medieval tax collector complaining to the king that a farmer hasn't paid enough taxes. The king says, didn't they give us a third of their corn crop this year? Yes, says the tax collector, but they've saved a huge amount of seed-corn in their barn for next years planting, we should take a third of that too!
- Retric 9y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Repatriation_tax_holiday https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Repatriation_tax_holiday "In 2004, the United States Congress enacted such a tax holiday for U.S. multinational companies in the American Jobs Creation Act of 2004 (AJCA)) section 965, allowing them to repatriate foreign profits to the United States at a 5.25% tax rate" 5.25% is a long way from 35%.
- 9y ago
- ubernostrum 9y agoAny money that a corporation earns is either paid out as dividends (at which point it's taxable as individual income) or reinvested into growing the company Or goes into a giant pile of cash sitting somewhere offshore. How would you feel about a "you haven't paid out that money as a dividend and haven't reinvested it, fork it over now" tax?
- philwelch 9y agoIt's only sitting offshore because of the corporate taxes. "Offshore" just means, "in a country with low or no corporate tax". Often, the offshore money is used as collateral for loans which are then used to reinvest in the company, because the interest is often cheaper than the tax. Eliminate corporate tax and the cash hoarding problem goes away. If it doesn't, then maybe there can be an evidence-based solution to that problem.
- ubernostrum 9y agoYou presented an argument which relied on there being only the two options -- pay out a dividend, or reinvest. There aren't only two options, and zero corporate tax would not change that; a corporation could still choose to sit on a pile of cash if the corporate tax were zero, and it might well make sense to do so as a way for the investors to avoid personal tax on dividends.
- philwelch 9y agoAnd if we removed part of the incentive for them to do that, and they did it less but still more often than we would like, then we would obviously want to solve that problem through a more targeted mechanism than the thing we are currently doing (namely high corporate taxes) which are making the problem worse.
- ubernostrum 9y agoTo be honest this feels like the same thing that's been sold as a miracle cure my entire life. Cut taxes, and if that doesn't work cut them more, then try a tax cut, and if you're still not getting what you hoped for then maybe a tax cut will work, and have you tried cutting taxes? We have decades of evidence that this doesn't work. I used to live in Kansas where the governor made a priority of his "March to Zero" on taxes, as a guaranteed sure-fire can't-fail way to make businesses happy and lead to more investment in business in the state, more businesses relocating there, more jobs, etc. And it was a complete and utter failure. It is now in the process of being repealed by people who were left with no choice other than to admit it failed. It is time for people who advocate this to understand that while it may sound great when deduced theoretically from first principles, it does not work in the real world.
- SomeHacker44 9y agoCorporate dividends are actually taxed twice. Once as profit to the corporation, and a second time as "income" to the recipient. Note that these two words are different. (Not applicable to S corps.)
- Retric 9y agoYou assume both the company and the person are in the US, further dividends are not taxed as normal income so you can't say even close to 2x the income tax rate. I there are plenty of cases where even paying both you save money vs taking the same surplus as normal income.
- philwelch 9y agoIf you wanted to do a revenue-neutral reduction or elimination of corporate taxes, you would probably increase the upper-bracket income and capital gains rates to compensate. This would have the added benefit of reducing effective taxes for middle-income dividend recipients (like retirees and middle-class investors) while increasing it for the billionaires that most corporate tax proponents actually want to target. Which, once again, is not Dropbox's problem to solve.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- random_comment 9y ago> Any money that a corporation earns is either paid out as dividends (at which point it's taxable as individual income) or reinvested into growing the company (at which point it turns into things like "salary", which is taxable as individual income). Or things like 'assets' such as property, cash on hand, holdings in other companies, which generally aren't taxed (or aren't taxed as salary/dividends are). Companies which do this for a long time are able to choose the moment (and sometimes the country) at which the assets are transmitted to investors. If they become big enough, they can even bully governments into changing laws to suit them. I suggest you look at Berkshire Hathaway and evaluate this sentence in the context of that company: > Any money that a corporation earns is either paid out as dividends (at which point it's taxable as individual income) or reinvested into growing the company (at which point it turns into things like "salary", which is taxable as individual income).
- valuearb 9y agoYou should look at Berkshire Hathaway and evaluate your post in the context of that company. Let me do it for you. BRK pays Buffett a relatively tiny salary ($100k, another $400k in benefits, probably NetJet flights). It doesn't pay any dividends. Every dollar of after tax profit is reinvested in new businesses. Those businesses pay many people salaries and wages and those people pay many billions in taxes every year. Because of the faster compounding of Berkshires value this policy creates, when shareholders sell shares they are able to pay substantial taxes as well. What does society gain from taking more of those profits and consuming them, instead of allowing them to be invested in supporting more jobs and creating more economic output? Your reference to taxing assets is evidence of how completely lost you are on this topic. If a business owner invests to buy better production equipment (assets) that will increase the productivity of their workers so they can make more things with the same amount of work, it should be taxed for this decision? Or in the case of cash on hand, which is usually retained earnings, i.e. after tax earnings that have been retained by the company for investment purposes. You really think it should be taxed again and again just because the company has it sitting in a bank account? Our tax system is set up to tax profits and gains for very good reasons. Your tax system would be setup to make it expensive and dumb for anyone to invest or run businesses under it. If you don't like US corporations keeping overseas profits overseas, wait till tax codes changes you like force them to just become overseas corporations. The best tax system, for conservatives, progressives, liberals, etc, is one that defers taxation of gains and profits until they are converted into individual income. It's why our retirement plans (401ks, IRAs) don't pay tax until withdrawals. It ensures their values compound far faster and gives far more incentive for people to save. Allowing operating profits to be reinvested tax-free would also allow our GDP to grow much faster, and that will produce more available funds for social programs and spending (important if you are a progressive) and more wealth for citizens (important if you are a conservative).
- dragonwriter 9y ago> Any money that a corporation earns is either paid out as dividends (at which point it's taxable as individual income) or reinvested into growing the company (at which point it turns into things like "salary", which is taxable as individual income). Or, its invested in assets whose utility is enjoyed by some subset of employees/investors and whose acquisition and other costs are deductible business expenses, so its taxed zero times.