10 ms·
The Electric-Bike Conundrum
- ams6110 9y agoI think pedal-assist is fine, but some e-bikes are effectively motorcycles in terms of the speed they can travel. Those are dangerous on bike/pedestrian trails and paths. They should be licensed and taxed and require insurance like motorcycles do, and they should have to use the roads not bike paths or trails.
- tomjen3 9y agoI can see that as an argument, but can we agree to keep the question to one strictly about speeds and safety and not about the relative morals of work?
- avita1 9y agoIn my admittedly anecdotal experience, e-bike riders tend to actually be as safe if not safer on trails and paths. Plenty of traditional bikers are folks who are using bike shares and do things like not wear helmets, ignore road signs, ride two abreast, and swerve without warning. Also a problem are the "pro" bikers (you know, the ones on a racing bike, fully decked out in gear) that tend to ride ~10 mph faster than everyone else and pass aggressively. E-bikers on the other hand, go in a straight line, usually single file, without swerving and seem to follow traffic signs because they have an easier time accelerating and decelerating. Again, just my anecdotal experience -- I ride ~5 miles to/from work in New York.
- Terr_ 9y agoYeah, I imagine e-bikers have fewer incentives to "cheat" traffic rules, it costs them less to obey. I wouldn't be surprised if that overshadows any danger from introducing different travel patterns compared to regular bikes.
- RhysU 9y agoAs a motorcyclist watching food delivery guys in NYC drive electric bikes the wrong way down 1-way streets, amen. Small, underpowered motorcycles don't get special treatment under the moving laws and neither should e-bikes.
- tomjen3 9y ago>But he hadn’t worked to go that fast. I can't explain what I think about that without getting banned on this forum, but that feeling seems to be the center of the article; basically hipsters crying about smart use of technology.
- jff 9y agoI swear there's a pervasive feeling among bicycle and mass transit advocates that if the experience is too convenient, it's not morally right. A bicycle is morally right because it takes effort and gets you to work a bit slower than a car. An e-bike is morally wrong because you don't have to work as hard and you get to work just as fast; you're not sacrificing anything by not taking a car, you're not a hero. Similar reasons behind buses/trains vs. ideas of self-driving electric municipal cars.
- morsch 9y agoYou don't have to involve these kinds of morals do to prefer a practical solution that exists now to a science-fiction concept that doesn't.
- sevensor 9y agoThis is true of any community where the barrier to entry has rapidly eroded. The old-school members who bought their way in with hard work and perseverence (and also usually luck or money) react negatively to recent arrivals who don't understand the community's norms -- which are now suddenly out of date. Meanwhile, the new arrivals often see the old guard as a prickly, up-tight clique. I'm thinking of Endless September, D&D, Anime fandom, model aircraft, music scenes, Old Money versus New Money, Lisp Machine hackers versus Unix folks, Unix folks versus OMGUbuntu... the variations are endless, but they're all the same. And yet, try as I might to be philosophical about it, my gut tells me that people passing me on e-bikes are vile cheaters.
- jessaustin 9y agoAs someone who has killed deer with a bow and arrow (not on a regular basis: it's difficult and I don't always have the time required), I feel the same way about the new rule change that allows people to hunt with crossbows in archery season. I have sympathy for people who can't or won't draw a bow, but I don't see what's wrong with them just hunting during gun season as they always have.
- bamboozled 9y agoJust no, we really need to stop taxing and penalising bike culture worldwide, electric or not. Wanna tax something? How about fossil fuels and combustion engines.
- jff 9y ago> Wanna tax something, try fossil fuels Revolutionary!
- indigo0086 9y ago"concern mom" mentality. All ebike sold in the us have to have a speed limiter, I am limited to 20 miles an hour on a flat road and daily get bypassed by a few mph easy.
- nerdshoe 9y agoOther than your damaged pride, is this a problem?
- Retric 9y ago20+MPH accidents are dangerous on bicycles and they are also more likely to hit pedestrians due to reduced reaction times.
- nerdshoe 9y agoNow we're getting somewhere. Given that these factors are multiplied with automobiles, shouldn't all vehicle speeds be limited so? I am a firm believer that everything should be limited to 30km/h in urban and residential environments where pedestrian and vehicle traffic coexist.
- tetromino_ 9y ago> Given that these factors are multiplied with automobiles Not a given. At speed, cars handle more securely than bicycles; cars have power brakes, ABS, traction control; modern cars often have automatic collision avoidance systems.
- jkaptur 9y ago> “But, I feel there is a clear line between human power and non-human power,” he added. “I think there should be a very simple classification: human-powered or not human-powered. I wonder which side of the line electric shifting (which is legal in cycling race) falls.
- nerdshoe 9y agoNowhere near it. Electronic shifting provides no motive power and is still manually controlled by the rider.
- kazinator 9y agoElectronic shifting provides a reduction in the interruption of motive power, so it is not 100% clear cut. The sport governing bodies that be probably had to chew on this from various angles before making a decision. Fast shifting that doesn't interrupt the flow of power is a big deal. That's why Formula 1 cars do not use "H pattern" stick shifts.
- jonathantm 9y agoElectic shifting is irrelevant here. Does it contribute energy to the propulsion? No. It would be akin to asking if wearing a digital watch rather than an automatic (mechanical) watch makes your bike an electic bike. You can say it aids propulsion, but that's only because it aids managing the gear ratios. It doesn't contribute energy to the the propulsive force of the engine of the bike (the cyclist). Yes, it is involved in the drivetrain, but the engine in the derailleur does not contribute wattage to the turning of the cranks. It's power is applied to a horizontal repositing of the conduit through which the propulsive power is transferred.
- mmariani 9y agoTechnically you're correct. However, practically there is an advantage of electric vs mechanical shifting. Usually mechanical derailleurs misbehave a little when used under load. When in turn electric derailleurs shift just fine. That's one reason why all pro sprinters ride di2, eps or etap.
- habosa 9y agoTake a look at something like the Super 73 Scout: https://www.theverge.com/circuitbreaker/2017/7/12/15958836/super-73-scout-price-ride-range-photos https://www.theverge.com/circuitbreaker/2017/7/12/15958836/s... When I first saw this I thought "hell yeah I am buying on of those right this second". I bike every day in SF and there are tons of hills, I'd love one of these for when I am feeling lazy and want to have some fun. But then I thought about what I'd be like in the bike lane. If someone went by me on one of those I'd be pretty grumpy. They take up more space, they don't have the right acceleration patterns, and the rider is not nearly as engaged with the ride. I think the e-bike is the perfect city vehicle, but not sure where they will fit in between bikes and motorcycles as they evolve.
- masklinn 9y ago> Take a look at something like the Super 73 Scout: https://www.theverge.com/circuitbreaker/2017/7/12/15958836/s.. https://www.theverge.com/circuitbreaker/2017/7/12/15958836/s.... > I think the e-bike is the perfect city vehicle, but not sure where they will fit in between bikes and motorcycles as they evolve. It seems to me that Pedelec (assist-only, low-power, low maximum assist speed) are bicycles, other e-bikes are electric mopeds and motorcycles. The Super73 is a moped: it has functioning pedals but can move solely off of the engine (and the official website calls it a motorbike).
- Fricken 9y agoThe article describes the super 73 as a minimalist ebike. That's not minimalist. This is minimalist: http://www.propellabikes.com/ http://www.propellabikes.com/
- masklinn 9y agoYou're confusing e-bicycle and e-motorbike. The Super 73 is the later.
- Zigurd 9y agoNew York City lowered their speed limit to 25mph. Electric bikes generally don't go over 20mph. The trick is they can consistently travel at 20mphs - a fast pace for an average human pedaling a bike. That is, they perform like a fast cyclist. I doubt electric bikes will be incompatible with NYC bike and car traffic.
- magpi3 9y agoBy law in the U.S. electric bikes cannot provide assistance over 20mph. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electric_bicycle_laws#Federal_Laws_and_Regulations_Pertaining_to_the_Sale_of_Electric_Bicycles https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electric_bicycle_laws#Federal_...
- baccredited 9y agoHow many pedestrians and bikers have been injured and/or killed by electric bikers? How does that compare to cars and trucks? Wouldn't that information be helpful in thinking through whether there is any problem at all here?
- loeg 9y agoThe population of ebike riders is tiny but growing rapidly. It seems like that might make it difficult to measure relative injury rates accurately.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- eggs_and_avo 9y ago5,000+ pedestrians killed by vehicles in 2015. But let's start worrying about e-bikes!
- Chardok 9y agoIts a conundrum right now, for sure, but I am all for getting more people on bikes, electric or not. The main issue with e-bikes in the bike lane is obviously the speed and pacing are not going to match your average bicycle commuter. The same effect would result from a professional cyclist carving through the streets at speeds no one could match. I think the issue would solve itself as they become more popular. If they can hit speeds of 20-40MPH, then they should be using a full car lane, and can benefit from each other's presence. Professional and highly trained amateur cyclists do this already.
- loeg 9y agoPower on demand vs pedal assist. I think pedal assist bikes are ok in the bike lanes, but power on demand bikes (meaning, bikes that have an explicit throttle control mechanism) are essentially electric scooters.
- Fricken 9y agoI'm plenty capable of going dangerously fast on a regular bike but if I'm in a congested bike lane or passing pedestrians on a multi-use trail I slow down. I don't see how having a motor would suddenly cause common sense to fly out the window. And of course, when riding in traffic, keeping pace with the cars is better and not everyone has the fitness to pull it off.
- hedora 9y agoThe main problem I've seen is that they have a different acceleration curve than a road bike -- they take off from a dead stop faster than a road bike, but for some reason most top out a few mph lower than a slow road bike (15-18mph?). The result is that they rudely pass all the bikes at each stop light, repeatedly forcing the bikes to pass them in car lanes once everyone gets back up to speed.
- mastermindxs 9y agoSame problem with scooters in cities where they cut the lane to go up to the traffic light and then they accelerate up to 30mph and the cars soon have to pass them.
- hathawsh 9y agoPerhaps what bothers the author about e-bikes is that using a bike safely on streets requires hard-won skills, and riders who start out on an e-bike might get hurt before they acquire those skills. The faster the bike, the greater the probable damage. Just this morning, as I was biking to work, a car came within an inch or so of hitting me, but I was moving slowly enough to avoid a collision. On an e-bike the story might have been very different.
- horsawlarway 9y agoThere is absolutely some truth to this. Just like learning to drive, learning to bike takes some time and effort. In the US it's considerably worse because our bike infrastructure is downright terrible in most cities. I was biking in Amsterdam a year ago, and holy shit the difference is night and day (even with the shitty delivery guys doing 40mph on their gas scooters in the bike lanes). Just putting up temporary bike lanes in some cities increased bike rides by 800% (http://usa.streetsblog.org/2017/06/28/macon-georgia-striped-a-good-network-of-temporary-bike-lanes-and-cycling-soared/ http://usa.streetsblog.org/2017/06/28/macon-georgia-striped-...). There's a huge and mostly hidden demand for this. People don't think about it, but when it's offered they take advantage.
- wiredfool 9y agoWas just in semi-rural Germany (villages every km or two, farmer's fields between, so not urban commuting) and I'd say half of the bikes I passed were electric assist. There weren't actually that many cyclists, considering the infrastructure available. Many bike/ped only paths near the roads, and many roads that are farmworker/ped/bike only, so no cars (but those tended to be significantly hilly, like 1k feet of climbing/10 miles). But for the most part, the people on the electric assist bikes were older, a distinct population from the ones out for a spin. They were also pretty mellow in terms of speed -- faster than the kiddos but I'd pass them pretty handily on my road bike. It's my impression that the electric bikes there definitely expand the cycling population, and don't detract from it at all. (ymmv, n=small and all that)
- jahnu 9y agoYeah, was in Lindau and Bregenz, Austria last weekend. E-bikes are a big thing with elderly people (or those who live up the big hills)
- _nalply 9y agoSame here in Switzerland. Even I upgraded my tandem with the trailer for the kids because if nobody but me is pedaling it was too much effort for me. And now, when I am fetching the kids from daycare, it's a joy. By the way I consciously decided on a slower version (25km/h or 15 miles per hour max.).
- Tiktaalik 9y agoElectric bikes may end up setting back progress in getting people to switch to cycling as a main form of transportation. One of the most significant deterrents to cycling has been the danger involved with being mixed in with automobiles that are easily able to injure and kill a cyclist. The biggest gains in increasing bicycle use has been by creating bike lanes for all ages and abilities that are completely separated from traffic with physical barriers. These are safe spaces for bicycle users and all people can feel comfortable riding on them, whether they're young and fit, elderly or if they're riding with their young child that is just learning. With the advent of fast moving electric bicycles, suddenly these all ages and abilities bike lanes may not be such safe spaces any more and this could discourage people from cycling. People may not want to take their young child out cycling if there are food couriers zooming by at speeds that a normal bicycle wouldn't be capable of.
- _ph_ 9y agoIt is actually quite the contrary. Electric bikes should bring bikes back as full members of the public traffic. Yes, some people are terrified to drive amongst cars. But the so called bike paths are the actual death traps, as most of them have dangerous encounters with the car traffic where it is the most difficult to spot bicyclists, that is at crossings. A large amount of the bicycle deaths are caused by trucks turning right across the bike path, killing a bicyclist. Furthermore, at least in Germany, they are not in a shape for comfortable riding. The only ones enjoying bike paths are unexperienced and untrained bicyclists, who ride a long at little more than walking speed. Any reasonably seasoned bicyclists easily bikes at 20-30 kph in the flats, so by far exceed the safe bike path speeds. Electric bikes give this speed to anyone, who might be older, or is commuting and does not seek the sporty challenge. This requires proper bike traffic handling by the authorities.
- jnty 9y agoThis is a disingenuous argument - cars are "full members of the public traffic" and are regularly involved in minor and major collisions with each other. Drivers are rarely killed or seriously injured in these collisions, whereas it's almost impossible for a cyclist to escape these collisions without an injury. "Some people are terrified" because injury and death is a very real possibility in traffic. The primary issue with road safety is not the speed of cycling but the presence of motor vehicles. The only adequate mitigation is to make them go very slowly to reduce the energy of collision (on side streets) or eliminate them (on well-designed, segregated bike paths). The fact that Germany is not very good at segregation does not invalidate the concept - just look at the Netherlands for an example of what can be achieved.
- indigo0086 9y agoNatural progression of the trend I'm seeing in the comments Step 1: Peaceful citizen buys an ebike to make commute easier. (person is elderly, permanent injury, has steep climb daily, other reasons that are their own) Step 2: Rider Wears helmet, slows on oncoming traffic, stops at lights, and is generally a perfectly fine rider like many bike riders Step 3: Concerned mom-type notices faster bikes with engines in lane and complains Step 4: Law passed, Rider is now doing something illegal Step 5: Ticket/Jail/Confiscated bike despite no evidence or numbers that rider was a danger to himself or others any more than cyclists This is literally every law that affects peaceful citizens.
- Noos 9y agoA problem is that if the bicycle goes above 20mph, it is a scooter and would fall under motorcycling laws. That means licensing and insurance. Generally under 20 miles or so it is considered a moped and is treated differently. Also no offense, but going 20 mph in a bike lane or worse a sidewalk would be very bad. An ebike is not a bike, but a moped under the classic definition, a bicycle with pedals and a engine to provide supplemental power. It's just not a gas moped.
- dando 9y ago>Also no offense, but going 20 mph in a bike lane or worse a sidewalk would be very bad. How? 20mph for a road bike is slower than what trained cyclists do
- loeg 9y agoSane cyclists don't ride 20 on the sidewalk. Too many obstacles and too much risk. Any alley/driveway is potentially a blind corner with a car backing out. Pedestrians never move predictably. Etc, etc. Bike lanes are hit or miss. I'd ride over 20 in a protected lane, but not next to a line of parked cars (door zone).
- indigo0086 9y agoThen why does practically 90% of non-motorized bikes pass me on a flat road. Also prove the anger that actually has been caused by bikes compared to road bikes and I'll maybe consider it. It's really reactionary and would be silly nosy neighbor legislation.
- eggs_and_avo 9y agoHere's a conundrum: Cars kill ~30,000 people per year in the USA. Vehicle emissions cause ~58,000 premature deaths. That's a problem. Not bicycles, not E-bikes, not bike sharing programs, not motorcycles, not skateboards, not rollerblades – Cars!
- summer_steven 9y ago> Here's a conundrum: Cars kill ~30,000 people per year in the USA. Vehicle emissions cause ~58,000 premature deaths. That's a problem. Not bicycles, not E-bikes, not bike sharing programs, not motorcycles, not skateboards, not rollerblades – Cars! Let's also consider how many lives that fuel-based transportion saves. How many people would die of starvation if you outlawed internal combustion engines? How much would clothes cost? Food? I'll remind you electric engines cannot easily transport 1000-tons of goods across a transcontinental railroad.
- eggs_and_avo 9y agoListen to yourself. Edit: Nobody is suggesting that cars be made illegal. But pretending (yes, pretending) that bicycles, even e-bikes, are a threat to the safety of pedestrians is not supported by any facts or statistics. It seems disingenuous to ignore the elephant in the room: Drunk driving accounts for approximately half of all pedestrian fatalities in the US. When talking about pedestrian safety, it's ridiculous to devote resources to activities that don't comprise any significant portion of pedestrian deaths. Talking about bicycles as a real problem for pedestrian safety is nothing but an emotional circle-jerk.
- acomjean 9y agoI looked into getting one. It would increase my commute range if I move (I ride about 4miles to and from work daily). It would also make me a little less sweaty on those hot summer mornings. They are fun, you feel very strong riding them. Most have various levels of assist. They are heavy and making them a good workout with the assist off. I do feel you would get scowls from other riders, though they are a little discreet (pedal assist means you look like pedaling), you do notice when people ride by such little effort.
- bryanlarsen 9y agoOne windy day I asked an e-biker if he wouldn't mind breaking the wind for me on my commute. He agreed, and obligingly slowed down for me a couple times when he dropped me. Ever since I've been much more charitable towards these "cheaters".
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- dalanmiller 9y agoA few critical problems in the US that you don't see as much in Europe (especially DACH + NE where bike culture / support is fantastic): * is a clear respect for the fact you're in a 4,000 lbs vehicle and I'm on a bike. If you hit me, I die. Drivers in CH stop and wait meters away for bikers to pass the intersection. People in America ain't got time for that I guess. * Great intra-suburban bike lines that can support multiple commute speed bikers on electric assist or not. (Try riding from any south bay city to any other non-adjacent south bay city) * General conditioning to driving culture. You gotta get somewhere, you hop in your whip. Walking or other forms of transportation are looked down upon.
- titanomachy 9y agoCH = Switzerland? Definitely found it a safe place to bike, or to drive for that matter. Also I guess DACH is Germany, Austria, Switzerland. Never seen that abbreviation before, but then I live in North America.
- anotherboffin 9y agoCH = Switzerland indeed (from "Confoederatio Helvetica"). About DACH, I think your interpretation is correct, but I had never seen it either.
- kd5bjo 9y agoMy most frustrating commutes (in the US) are when I get unlucky enough to share a two-lane road with a peloton of bicycle commuters. All the cars slow down and move over a lane to pass them, which slows down traffic enough that you get stopped at every traffic light. The bikes lane-split at full speed through the stopped cars and the red signal, which means you're playing hopscotch with them for miles and traveling at half the speed of a normal day. If they bothered to obey the traffic laws, on the other hand, it wouldn't be a big deal -- you slow down, pass the slower vehicle, and move on.
- ubernostrum 9y agois a clear respect for the fact you're in a 4,000 lbs vehicle Completely unrelated, but it's interesting to me how deeply the "4000lb. vehicle" meme seems to have embedded itself. I can find plenty of articles backing it up and talking about how cars are so much heavier now, cars are getting heavier, etc. But I notice a problem: they include SUVs, trucks and "luxury" land-yacht vehicles in that classification as representative of the "average car". Cars intended for broad segments of the market are usually much lighter than this. A Toyota Corolla, for example, weighs 2800lb., the (popular) Ford Fiesta is 2500lb., the Nissan Versa is 2300lb., and even hybrids like the Prius (2500lb.) come in way under the "4000lb." meme. These are still much heavier than bicycles, of course, but it fascinates me how much people have decided that SUVs, trucks and gigantic luxury cars are "average" and built their memes of car weight around that.
- schneems 9y agoI have an electric bike and I love it. It makes places that were "just a bit too far" away without assist perfectly close. It won't replace a car 100% for me (I live in Austin, Tx), but it does cut down my total car trips quite a bit.
- hyperbovine 9y agoAh man as a committed bike commuter in a hilly place I _SOOOOOOOOOO_ identify with the what the author is saying. Something about electric bikes just ... irks me. It's totally irrational because every e-bike is presumably one less car on the road. But the bike lane should be reserved for bikes. And hard work.
- pyoung 9y agoFor what it's worth, as a fellow non-electric bike commuter, plenty of non-electric bike commuters irk me. Whether it's jumping in front of me while I am waiting at a light, only to be significantly slower than me when the light changes. Or passing at speed on the right hand side. Or jamming up a 4-way intersection by blasting through while others are waiting. In general, some people tend to turn into assholes when they are commuting, regardless of what form of transportation they are using. If someone is using an electric bike, and they are being courteous to other road users then there really isn't any problem. And as far as I am concerned, they really aren't that different than the lycra clad strava jockeys that are already racing all over the place, with the exception that electric bike users are probably MORE likely to obey the rules of the road because it is easier for them to get up to speed after stopping.
- whipoodle 9y ago> “If it’s such a good thing, why do we have this resentment?” I asked. Yes, why?
- dsfyu404ed 9y ago> "E-bikes being licensed as motorized vehicles is good. E-bikes being in human-powered infrastructure is no good. . . .” And that's a great way to make sure e-bikes stay unpopular. Most "developed" countries make owning a motorcycles only slightly less expensive than a car (because safety). If it's less convenient and not cheap enough to offset that people won't do it.
- slackstation 9y agoThis is just people complaining loudly and vebosely about something they don't like and trying to make it into a vague moral failing. Electric bikes exist. Bike advocates for years have railed against cars and said the world would be so much better if people biked. Now the electric bike is expanding the world of biking and all of the social benefits of biking still exist with electric bikes and these people don't like it. It's just classic policing of a sub-culture. According to him, you aren't a real cyclist if you aren't pedaling as hard as he is. What he needs to do is get over himself and realize that progress doesn't look like what you want it to look like; that you should learn to accept the world rather than just like a child expect the world to conform to your purist expectations.
- antonvs 9y agoI doubt you read the full article. It's quite a bit more reasoned than you suggest. The author acknowledges his bias, its source, and even that it's not entirely rational. But he's also exploring how e-bikes change the dynamic of pedestrian vs. bike vs. car traffic in a city, what kinds of pros and cons exist, and whether there are any rational sources of objection to the way e-bikes are currently being used. He acknowledges that e-bikes are fun and useful: "I found the effect narcotic and delightful: on a flat road, I moved faster than I did on a normal bike, with less exertion. [...] Assisted living was so pleasant!" Commiserating with a friend, they conclude that despite their objections, "for all our shared sense that something was wrong with electric bikes, we agreed that, by any rational measure, they are a force for good. [...] The engines are efficient, they reduce congestion [...] Fewer cars, more bikes." However, they did identify at least one issue worth considering: > "if you are not human-powered, you should not be using human-powered infrastructure. You should be in the street. E-bikes being licensed as motorized vehicles is good. E-bikes being in human-powered infrastructure is no good..." Of course it's not quite that simple - e-bikes mingling with cars seems more dangerous than them mingling with human-powered traffic - but it's a point worth considering, for sure. For example, it's much easier to get up to 20 mph on an e-bike than an ordinary bike, and they tend to be quieter, too, so for pedestrians they can be quite terrifying. As the number of e-bikes increases, it's likely to become necessary to address this kind of thing. He also notes the increasing difficulty of distinguishing between human-powered and assisted activity in an increasingly machine-assisted world, acknowledging that the distinction in the quote above is becoming less easy to make. Even if you disagree with his perspective, it ought to be possible to read an article like this and recognize its value, unless you're even more ideologically fixed on a particular perspective than the author is.
- scythe 9y agoI broke my knee three months ago. At that point I went from uninterested to annoyed by the recent wave of attempts to convert roads into bike paths. And this guy -- I hope he breaks his knee.
- guyzero 9y agoNo one parodies Hacker News comments as well as Hacker News commenters. This is a piece about one guy's emotions and feelings about the rise of e-bikes. He's not policing anything. He's not setting government policies. He's lamenting that bicycling, especially in NYC, was once an activity for people who had to physically struggle with it and who got some viceral return from that and now it's just another form of commuting alongside cars, taxis and the subway. He's not telling anyone not to buy an e-bike. He's not saying they don't belong on the road. People have written the same pieces about automatic transmission in cars and all other sorts of automation. Of course e-bikes will continue to grow. But riding one will never be the same as doing it all yourself.
- giggles_giggles 9y agoThe attitude in the article reminds me of a passage from George Orwell's Road to Wigan Pier: "Everyone who has travelled by primitive methods in an undeveloped country knows that the difference between that kind of travel and modern travel in trains, cars, etc., is the difference between life and death. The nomad who walks or rides, with his baggage stowed on a camel or an ox-cart, may suffer every kind of discomfort, but at least he is living while he is travelling; whereas for the passenger in an express train or a luxury liner his journey is an interregnum, a kind of temporary death. And yet so long as the railways exist, one has got to travel by train—or by car or aeroplane. Here am I, forty miles from London. When I want to go up to London why do I not pack my luggage on to a mule and set out on foot, making a two days of it? Because, with the Green Line buses whizzing past me every ten minutes, such a journey would be intolerably irksome. In order that one may enjoy primitive methods of travel, it is necessary that no other method should be available. No human being ever wants to do anything in a more cumbrous way than is necessary." For someone to whom the effort required to be a bicyclist was a badge of honor, an electric bike is the equivalent of that annoying Green Line bus, I would think..
- xg15 9y agoI get your point, but I think it's somewhat ironic we currently have this thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15045531 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15045531 just a few items below the current on on the frontpage.
- Terr_ 9y ago> I began to crave that bump. It was the effect of the assist I wanted; it was the feeling of being assisted. Isn't that qualitatively the enjoyment drivers can get from accelerating in a car?
- sunstone 9y agoI had a Jetson e-bike and it was great. What I found was that it was much more of a replacement for short haul car trips than it was for long haul bike trips. Also, as a rider and a driver, I find e-bikes are fast enough to not be too irritating in regular traffic. The more popular they become the safer they will become to ride in traffic. They just need to get cheaper and rangier.
- throwaway73738 9y agoHere in Tokyo, mamacharis with their 1.1 kids are all electric powered. Real bikes are rare to come by for a city as large as this one.