4 ms·
Economically speaking, finding a more effective to regrow hair in bald men would probably be a lot more profitable than finding a cheap cure for any number of d
by kiba 16y ago
Economically speaking, finding a more effective to regrow hair in bald men would probably be a lot more profitable than finding a cheap cure for any number of diseases ravaging Africa. Doesn't mean it's more important.
In the long run, there are far more values in curing ravaging diseases in Africa than there are values in curing bald hair men, at least to me.(Less disease ravaging means more time for educations, which might mean economic growth, which might mean bigger markets) For a corporation, it might make more sense to cure bald men instead of people in Africa. But it doesn't make sense for a charity organization to cure bald men instead of people in Africa because of their different aim.
Private research doesn't have to be profit...err money driven, but it can be done for err..noble reasons.
What to prevent billionaire from spending money on non...errr..profit research. Indeed, you would expect millionaires and billionaires to donate money to causes that seriously affect their life, whether it is themselves or a love one.
So what if it is viewed in economic lights? You're only looking at it in one perspective, which is how to make a lot of money. What you did forget is the true motivations why humans pursue money, like being able to live longer, have fun, being curious, have sex, etc.
- abstractbill 16y agoWhat['s] to prevent billionaire from spending money on non...errr..profit research... Nothing, of course. But I would rather not rely on the generosity of billionaires to cure the diseases that ravage Africa.
- gaius 16y agoInstead you would "rely" on a politician taxing his voters. Which he will be doing because his notion of "profit" is not measured in dollars but in votes. At least the billionaire's motives are transparent. Here in England we are cutting budgets left, right and centre after the last government nearly bankrupted us. The foreign aid budget is ringfenced. The LibCons have come under a lot of flak for this - but they would have if they'd cut it too - it's simple maths at the end of the day. Remember - the money has to come from somewhere.
- vog 16y agoInstead you would "rely" on a politician taxing his voters. Which he will be doing because his notion of "profit" is not measured in dollars but in votes. In other words, the politician invests taxes where "we" want them to. So the proper question is not whether some politician wants to help poor nations, but whether we want to help them. And that's quite a fair question, which is of a much higher quality than the question whether some individual (billionaire) wants to help them. (After all, taxes are our money and politicians are "just" managing it for us.)
- gaius 16y agoWell, no, not really. This is another aspect of the last government's spending patterns: they measured "success" or "progress" in terms of how much they spent, not the end result. Jo(e) Voter can be told spending a billion on aid is good; he perhaps doesn't see that half of that goes to well-paid quango employees back home, and the other half into a dictator's Swiss bank account. The Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation, on the other hand, is completely focussed on outcomes.
- kiba 16y agoIf it is so important to help poor nations, why don't people just vote with their money instead of having to vote in pandering politicians who will nonetheless squander the money? I mean, at worst, only 51% will get their money spent on things they thought are great noble causes.(Let just assume that every Noble Cause is important) That's not taking into consideration on weather the politicians are managing it wisely.
- vog 16y ago> why don't people just vote with their money It would be really great if that was possible. However, we can't simply buy "$1 worth of helping poor nations" in the way we buy products in the supermarket. And that's why we can't "vote" with our money. (The appearance of micro payments might change that, though.) So we have to trust some organization with the money, and that leads to exactly the same issues of trust. However, the government is under greater pressure and control than most other organizations. Or, at least they should, in a democracy. So trusting them with the money is not worse than trusting any other help organization with the money - except, of course, when you know the people of the help organization personally. But most people don't have such connections.
- kiba 16y agoDo you make yourself to send money to cure diseases that ravage Africa? If it is so moral, than it's worth doing by itself, right?
- AlisdairO 16y agoAbsolutely. If I'm honest, though, despite my ideals being that I want a significant proportion of my money to go to charity, actually forcing myself to part with it directly is a real challenge (particularly thanks to the procrastination that I, like so many people, exhibit in such situations). Personally, I find the level of abstraction provided by the government to be helpful: I'm much more able to say that I want the government to spend money in certain areas, even if it means raising my taxes, than I am able to just hand money to a cause. I'm a much more rational spender of money I've already given to the government than I am of my own. I think the same holds for most people, to be honest.
- kiba 16y agoI'm a much more rational spender of money I've already given to the government than I am of my own. I think the same holds for most people, to be honest. Frankly, I find charity to be much more meaningful when I give it out of my free will, rather than making the government do it for me. Rather, government spending defeat the point of charity.
- AlisdairO 16y agoI don't agree that the point of charity is the warm fuzzies that I get when I give - it's a means to an end (improving the lot of others) which is more effectively accomplished,in my and many others' case, through the government handling it.
- kiba 16y agoI don't agree that the point of charity is the warm fuzzies that I get when I give - it's a means to an end (improving the lot of others) For me, the merits of charity is also about their voluntary nature in addition to the "warm fuzziness feeling". On the other hand, I suspect that our disagreement is in respect to both utilitarian merits and moral/ethical philosophy.
- maxharris 16y agoI think doing something for profit - purely for your own good - is the most noble thing you can do. (When I say for your own good, I mean what's for your own good long-term. Cheating, stealing, lying, etc., is ruled out, because that's not in anyone's self-interest, long-term.)
- contextfree 16y agoCongratulations, you are a sociopath.
- maxharris 16y agoI said: "When I say for your own good, I mean what's for your own good long-term. Cheating, stealing, lying, etc., is ruled out, because that's not in anyone's self-interest, long-term." How does this endorse a lack of moral conscience or antisocial behavior? On what grounds do you judge your morality as better than mine? At the very least, do you think that you have to think about morality rationally, as I do?
- abstractbill 16y agoThe most noble? Really? So, for example, running a casino is more noble than volunteering for Doctors Without Borders?
- kiba 16y agoAltruism, by itself doesn't mean much of anything. I could give 10 bucks to a poor man and than that poor man proceed to squander it. I could have given money to the wrong people(who I thought was nice), who then proceed to buy capitals for criminal activities such as murdering individuals. Of course, it's easy to sneer at the wal-mart or Henry Ford people of the world. However, remember that they have made it much easier to help people by increasing productivity. An engineer who built a safe water supply system has saved more people than most doctors in the world. A sanitation company has saved lives by preventing the accumulation of trash and by disposing it safely. All of which are occupations that are unseen to the public eyes. Doctors, we can see. Doctors who work on charity, we can see. But what we can't see is those profiteers who nonetheless help people but are in the background.