4 ms·
For example, in Filecoin you earn tokens by lending your unused hard drive space. In summary, tokens coordinate efforts in the network and motivate responsible
by AndrewKemendo 9y ago
For example, in Filecoin you earn tokens by lending your unused hard drive space. In summary, tokens coordinate efforts in the network and motivate responsible participation.
Why not just earn dollars? Theory of pricing arbitrage already takes into account coordination irrespective of the currency. What is the distinct advantage of earning Filecoin tokens over dollars?
Ok so lets just say I bought Filecoin (I didn't). How do I liquidate my position? Do I just need to find a buyer like every other security or can Filecoin buy it back?
In other words, is it currency or a bond?
These ICOs provide a sizable improvement in terms of liquidity. Unlike traditional companies, you can represent the value of your assets in terms of tokens that are liquid and tradeable from day one.
Apparently not, I looked through this filecoin sale file [1] and it has a vesting period for investors! Now don't that beat all? So it's an asset of some kind, it doesn't make clear in what class of asset it is. That looks suuuuper fishy to me but maybe I'm missing something.
When I got into Bitcoin when it first came out I thought it was a great concept, but had no future as a legitimate international currency because of politics. This crypto currency wave takes that into overdrive and I'm not exactly sure where the value is behind it.
Or maybe I'm just totally missing the value here, I would love to see it explained better than this article does.
[1]https://coinlist.co/static/media/Filecoin-Sale-Economics.0ae9a53f.pdf https://coinlist.co/static/media/Filecoin-Sale-Economics.0ae...
- ojr 9y agoI can see the value, it is a peer to peer dropbox that pays you in a token that can be used for speculation and immediate liquidity, think about this to sell a US stock to usd takes 7 business days, to sell a crpytocurrency to usd takes up to 3 business days on coinbase, sometimes same day or you can trade the token and hold in a bitcoin or ether within minutes
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoit is a peer to peer dropbox that pays you in a token that can be used for speculation and immediate liquidity Ok, but dollars can also be used for speculation and immediate liquidity. Why is a corporate run token system better than the cash coming from the US Banking system? I mean practically, not philosophically. sell a US stock to usd takes 7 business days T+3 is usually just 3. So I don't know what second tier brokerage you're using but I can ACH stock liquidation cash from a vanguard account in 3 days.
- erikpukinskis 9y agoThe point of cryptocurrencies is they are robust in the face of malicious action by any individual party. If the United States sank into the Atlantic Ocean, Filecoin would still work exactly as designed everywhere else. If it were built around a USD bank account, a simple change in the terms of service for the bank could shut the service down completely. Who is the account holder? The Filecoin inventors? What happens if someone blackmails them for the account password? What happens if they die? To build Filecoin on USD you'd have to put all your trust in the Filecoin corporation. The point of cryptocurrencies is you don't have to put your trust in any single entity.
- FajitaNachos 9y agoIt only takes the trade date + 3 days to settle a stock trade.
- ojr 9y agoit took me 7 days on the Robinhood app not to settle but get the USD into my bank account
- umanwizard 9y ago> to sell a US stock to usd takes 7 business days On Fidelity or Schwab it takes 3, unless I'm confused
- ojr 9y agoworst case scenario crptocurrency is 3 days, best case is 1 hour, to sell a US stock in the worst case is 7 days, best case is 3
- AgentME 9y ago>Why not just earn dollars? Theory of pricing arbitrage already takes into account coordination irrespective of the currency. What is the distinct advantage of earning Filecoin tokens over dollars? A decentralized trustless blockchain can't interact with dollars.
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoOk, this is an interesting argument. Basically here is how I interpret the logic: 1. Filecoin wants to take advantage of unused storage by distributing data to it 2. To incentive the storage holder, they want to pay them 3. They want to ledger payment to storage holders through blockchain 4. Since you obviously can't do blockchain with dollars, they needed(?) to create their own digital currency What I am getting hung up on, and is the crux of your argument, is why they want to pay through a decentralized trustless blockchain. Why for the average storage holder, would blockchain based digital currency be better than just getting a few cents per MB used. If you said, they are anarchists (the good kind) that want to democratize currency, and are doing it on the back of a useful case, ok that's a great argument and one we can make. However that can't have been the pitch for the 200M they raised.
- beambot 9y agoExisting financial infrastructure isn't very conducive to micropayments...? So rather than trying to hack a solution using existing infrastucture, blockchains (filecoin) provide a tailor-made solution to this problem.
- rficcaglia 9y agoApple (PayPal) would disagree.
- beambot 9y agoThe merchant on a sub-$1.00 transaction would disagree -- after Apple & PayPal extracted their fees (esp. if transaction used CreditCard).
- dharma1 9y ago>Why not just earn dollars? Theory of pricing arbitrage already takes into account coordination irrespective of the currency. What is the distinct advantage of earning Filecoin tokens over dollars? There is no counterparty risk of Filecoin not paying out - since the payment mechanism is embedded in the smart contract that is immutable. >Ok so lets just say I bought Filecoin (I didn't). How do I liquidate my position? Do I just need to find a buyer like every other security or can Filecoin buy it back? You sell it on an exchange for another currency like BTC or USD