13 ms·
The Daily Stormer, Online Speech, and Internet Registrars
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoI've been really uncomfortable with this whole thing. I get why offensive people get booted out of communities and social networks, but I don't feel like infrastructure/platform providers should be in the business of content moderation. From what I read, it was suggested that it would be hard to even figure out what The Daily Stormer could've done 'wrong' according to Google Domains' Terms of Service.
- AnimalMuppet 9y agoIf I understand correctly, what they did wrong was applaud the lady's death in Charlottesville. Is that against a literal interpretation of Google's TOS? I don't know.
- jackmott 9y agoinciting violence
- 1337biz 9y agoThen it's time to shut down Twitter. I read that somebody is putting up 'Kill Trump' post there.
- danso 9y agoTwitter (ideally) removes those posts/users.
- 1337biz 9y agoWelp, then GoDaddy or Google should email the Daily Stormer to take down the posts they disagree with. What I am trying to say is that it is ridiculous for a domain provider to make editorial suggestions. Just shows how far their tolerance for free speech goes as soon as pressure builds up.
- greglindahl 9y agoThen form your own domain registrar and encourage sites like the Daily Stormer to use it.
- krige 9y agoIn reality Twitter isn't really doing anything noticeable. You can gauge that by the amount of blue checkmark people that post death threats, incitement and doxes daily.
- 1337biz 9y agoSome I think that is similar to Amazon pretending they are fighting product fakes, while hundrets of reviews show otherwise.
- pluma 9y agoIt's in Twitter's best interest not to do this as it drives up all metrics they care about. They may have a fig leaf of diversity but they have also made it very clear they see themselves as an unopinionated platform and don't remove content just because it's upsetting. They only jump into action when not doing so creates enough negative feedback to potentially harm them.
- alanh 9y agoPlease don’t downvote ocdtrekkie just because you disagree with him/her… that’s what replies are for. Downvote comments that don’t add to the conversation. I’m here to say I am uncomfortable with e.g. GoDaddy censoring their users, too. I’m uncomfortable either way. Because I remember when another web host, BlueHost, which happens to be owned by Mormons, decided that it could not in good conscience host (non-pornographic) websites for lesbians, and deleted their accounts without warning. I’m not trying to make a false equivalency, but… should your web host decide whether they approve of your speech? No. OTOH, should companies profit off hate speech or Nazism? No! It's also worth noting that “hate speech” is hard to define! SPLC is the best-known authority here and they have absolutely fucked up and mis-categorized non-hateful religious criticism as “hate speech”. Would you like to see GoDaddy start deleting ex-Muslim bloggers on “hate speech” grounds? Edit 100% not to detract from anything said previously, but it’s valid to say that the line exists at “direct incitement of violence”
- mc32 9y ago>“direct incitement of violence” Doxxing can lead to that no? And there are quite a few quasi-political quasi-religious groups in the US that people outside the groups would consider hateful. Some Baptist, some Islamic, etc. Do we shut those people down? I'm afraid this can go the way of PC speech. First it's really odious stuff, then it's can't say controversial things that might trigger others.
- zimpenfish 9y ago> should your web host decide whether they approve of your speech? Yes. It's the same as any publisher deciding whether they approve of your speech - you have no innate right to a public platform for your speech.
- phil21 9y ago> OTOH, should companies profit off hate speech or Nazism? No! I really hate this point. I was (am) a "webhost" and also happen to be a staunch free speech advocate. My rule when I owned my own company was if I didn't have a court order and the content wasn't blatantly obviously illegal (e.g. child porn or outright specific calls for actionable violence) you stayed on-line and I would vehemently defend that right for you. As expected, as you gain such a reputation you tend to draw some really shitty people. I will tell you that the "problem" customers cost far more than they ever made, and it wasn't even close. These were customers I truly despised, but I would actually be subsidizing their platforms due to those opposed (e.g. ddos attacks, constant support phone calls harassing my staff, fishing expedition warrants that needed to be fought, etc. etc.) intentionally costing me money in an attempt to shut down their speech. I found those actions more contemptible than the content they were opposed to - and much of it truly was vile. This is not a profitable segment of the industry to be in, but I still feel it's an extremely important line to never cross and am saddened by the state of telecommunications as a neutral platform/common carrier today. We've lost so much in less than a generation.
- ryanlol 9y ago>From what I read, it was suggested that it would be hard to even figure out what The Daily Stormer could've done 'wrong' according to Google Domains' Terms of Service. The Daily Stormer is a very small customer that probably only pays google $5 per year, but brings negative media attention that'll cost significantly more than $5 per year. It's obvious what they're doing wrong, they're not paying Google enough money for it to be worth keeping them as a client. If you're costing a business money you really can't expect to remain their customer for long.
- alanh 9y agoDisturbingly, you would seem to be saying that any registrar business should cut off any customer that causes them any problems whatsoever. What if I’m hosting a pro-LGBT blog for Russians and the Russian government starts filing complaints with my registrar? Your argument is that this is a fine time for me to be cut adrift.
- ryanlol 9y agoIt's an unfortunate reality, but luckily there are providers who specialize in ensuring delivery even for such troublesome content. Fact is that if you're getting a bunch of complaints (or, really any at all) you're a very special kind of a customer who needs a specialist service provider. Check out https://njal.la https://njal.la for example, they charge a bit more but they won't shut you down right away.
- Houshalter 9y agoBut if you don't set a precedent for removing "troublesome content" they won't bother to attack it. Once a precedent is set that you can get websites removed from the internet by pestering the registrars, lots of people will come out of the woodwork to try that.
- ryanlol 9y ago>Once a precedent is set that you can get websites removed from the internet by pestering the registrars, lots of people will come out of the woodwork to try that. Uh, this precedent has been set a very long time ago. People have been doing this for ages, I've seen multiple IRC networks have to change their domains because of false abuse reports sent to their registrars. I've personally had several domains taken down by registrars because of utterly ridiculous legal threats.
- FussyZeus 9y agoThe problem is that these kinds of content based bans/service boots/kicks/what have you are all based on human emotion and responses to the given content. It's easy to create a policy to address something like file-sharing, for example; it's a website distributing content it doesn't have the rights to distribute. So take that down, easy. Next we have a website promoting porn. Well, some people have objections to porn, in fact quite a lot do, but a lot also don't. So we'll be alright with that, just make sure kids don't look at it. But then you find a rape video on the porn site. Well that's obviously illegal, clearly this is footage of a heinous crime. Delete it! Well wait, no it turns out that actress was paid and signed a document saying she was participating of her own free will. I guess that's fine then, even though it would be offensive to many there really isn't anything wrong with it. But then you find out that the video was scraped from another website's paid section... And on and on it goes. There are infinite different directions this sort of thing can go, where content that's offensive and horrible can still technically be perfectly fine to host. Ultimately this is the sort of thing that's going to be incredibly hard to get machines to figure out properly, mostly because in our century-ish of "rating" media for audiences and appropriateness, we still haven't even figured it out ourselves. And that phrasing implies there's one given moral set, which is also of course not true; even what passes as "safe for TV" between Europe and the USA is quite a large gap. Ultimately I think this is something that needs to be handled on a case by case basis by the individual hosts. I refuse to believe the Daily Stormer and disgusting websites like it will have a hard time finding someone willing to host their content. There are plenty of hosts that look the other way, and failing that sort of thing, you can always build your own server too. Sadly that's the downside to the democratization of the Internet.
- sigmar 9y ago>If we ask these small companies to take on content removal obligations, we should not expect nuanced decision-making or robust appeal processes. We should expect legal and important sites from across the political spectrum to go down because someone complained about them. This is a ridiculous statement. Domain registrars are already required (by ICANN) to receive, investigate, and respond to abuse complaints.
- ruleabidinguser 9y agoWas that the only point of theirs that held any sway with you?
- sigmar 9y agoI was just pointing out that specific statement. I've got thoughts, but no specific perspective on the rest of the article. It definitely raises interesting questions.
- SirLJ 9y agoFirst they came for the Socialists, and I did not speak out— Because I was not a Socialist. Then they came for the Trade Unionists, and I did not speak out— Because I was not a Trade Unionist. Then they came for the Jews, and I did not speak out— Because I was not a Jew. Then they came for me—and there was no one left to speak for me.
- intortus 9y agoThen we took away their easy access to propagandize hate and they stopped coming for us.
- SirLJ 9y agoAnd then google came for you...
- lstroud 9y agoFree speech is not a sometime thing. Just ask 1926 Germany.
- MartinCron 9y agoVery good analogy, it was extremely difficult to find good web hosting in 1926 Germany.
- pluma 9y agoWhat exactly are you referring to that happened in 1926 in Germany? Maybe you're thinking of 1930 or 1933?
- ryanlol 9y agoThis article neglects to mention that anyone can relatively easily become a domain registrar. It seems strange that someone would expect a registrar to defend them for the couple of dollars per year you generally pay.
- parenthephobia 9y ago> Anyone can relatively easily become a domain registrar. Relatively easily? It isn't exactly a cheap venture: e.g. $4k+ per year to become an ICANN registrar. I think people shouldn't have to pay that much to exercise their free speech. > It seems strange that someone would expect a registrar to defend them for the couple of dollars per year you generally pay. I think that unless a registrar is legally compelled to unregister your domain name, they shouldn't take it upon themselves to unregister your domain name just because other people are offended by what you put on the web server that your domain name resolves to.
- ryanlol 9y ago>Relatively easily? It isn't exactly a cheap venture: e.g. $4k+ per year to become an ICANN registrar. I'd say that's relatively easy yeah, perhaps a bit much for individuals but in the end not everyone needs to be a registrar. This is still accessible enough that rather small groups of people can set up a domain registrar to serve their own needs. >I think that unless a registrar is legally compelled to unregister your domain name, they shouldn't take it upon themselves to unregister your domain name just because other people are offended by what you put on the web server that your domain name resolves to.  Oh, absolutely. And that's not what's happening here, registrars are simply forcing Daily Stormer to transfer elsewhere. They're not just deleting the domain.
- GenericsMotors 9y ago> This article neglects to mention that anyone can relatively easily become a domain registrar. Remember this suggestion when registrars start taking this kind of action against sites on the other end of the political horseshoe, and don't complain. You can be your own registrar, after all...
- Animats 9y ago"breitbart.com" has GoDaddy as a registrar, and Cloudflare as a cache provider. Should they be cut off?
- foxylad 9y agoA registrar or caching provider withdrawing service to a customer is essentially sending a message, and from that perspective the action should be covered by free speech. So I would argue that yes, if GoDaddy or Cloudflare were offended by Breitbart, they should be able to cut them off. Note that in this case, the provider would not be infringing on the customer's free speech, because there are myriad other providers they can use.
- peoplewindow 9y agoOr not .... the Daily Stormer is now (see comment above) stuck with Tor, which practically nobody uses. That's a victory for those who wish to suppress the Daily Stormer's speech.
- dogma1138 9y agoIf they were "sending a message" to a BLM or an LGBT group would you still support their rights to do so? If the internet existed in the 1950's and the apparent (at least as a public face goes) vox populi would favor and crave for both self and institutionalized censorship as much as they do now the civil rights movement would've been dead in it's tracks. It seems that people are busy yelling Nazi's Nazi's rather than having an actual good look at history. When ever ideas are being silenced much much worse things tend to follow.
- zkms 9y agoI wonder when this "lawfare" (really more like TOSfare) on registrars, hosting providers, CDNs, payment processors, and fundraising sites (like patreon) will escalate into the use of censorship-resistant/distributed alternatives (like bitcoin, or onion services or whatever) among people with extremist political views (of any flavour).
- 1337biz 9y agoNot even a TOSfare. It's just a plain old hate mob.
- jim-jim-jim 9y agoIt does tickle me slightly to see people with generally progressive sentiments become flaming supporters of private property and free enterprise over the issue of objectionable political content, smugly pointing out that free speech doesn't apply to businesses and more likely than not linking to that stupid xkcd comic--as though the debate being held over "free speech" were strictly a legal one. I don't know. Defending Nazis isn't the hill I'm going to die on, but I'm very wary of the "let woke tech corporations root out hate" approach. ToS violations are very malleable things and can be leveraged against other controversial viewpoints as well. There's a communist youtuber who has had his material taken down multiple times for making a silly song about the shooting of Tsar Nicholas II. Making light of a 100 year-old regicide is hate speech in Google's eyes. Reddit has likewise targeted very neutral and scholarly attempts to document jihadist media. Free speech is not compatible with free markets.
- minikites 9y agoIt tickles me in exactly the same way to see people with generally conservative sentiments becoming flaming supporters of free speech and denouncing censorship over the issue of a non-governmental business making a business decision.
- jim-jim-jim 9y agoI'm a socialist.
- minikites 9y agoI wasn't talking about you personally.
- ue_ 9y agoI am too. What happened to Bat'ko (if this is the Communist you talk about) on Youtube isn't good. But I think there is a clear difference in what he was saying compared to, for example, The Daily Stormer. But it's possible on a matter of principle to be against Nazi speech and applaud when it is removed. Being the victim of suppression of speech designed to liberate people (Socialism) does not mean that you must also be against the suppression of speech designed to advocate genocide and racism (Nazism).
- minikites 9y agoI think this author either misunderstands the issue or is trying to pull a fast one. They start out by reviewing net neutrality and how it affects ISPs: >At the same time, if the people I talk to are geeky enough, they usually support Net Neutrality. They believe that ISPs, as providers of core Internet infrastructure, should not get to be arbiters of content. ISPs should allow the bits to flow equally -- not suppress or favor particular messages or sources. And then leaps into talking about registrars and hosting: >Two of the intermediaries that rejected the Daily Stormer, Go Daddy and Google, were only acting as its domain registrars. They did not host the site, they just made sure that dailystormer.com was associated with the right IP addresses, so users typing the domain and clicking links to it would get there. ISPs should transmit bits neutrally but there's no reason a registrar or hosting service needs to host those bits if they decide not to. There are plenty of registrars and hosting services, market effects will shape behavior. If GoDaddy doesn't want the bad publicity, they should make the decision that suits their business. There are not that many ISPs and it's not their role to police content for exactly the same reason the phone company isn't liable for connecting a call that results in a bomb threat or wire fraud.
- remarkEon 9y agoI used to think it was fairly easy to identify who was/is a "Nazi" or Nazi sympathizers (The Daily Stormer obviously passed the smell test). What I'm concerned about is that the scope of who's included in that group seems to be expanding. Immediately after Chancellorsville plenty of Liberal pundits, on and off Twitter, explicitly stated there was no difference between Republicans and the NRA and Nazis, which is of course a ludicrous statement. But people don't think it's ludicrous anymore. It seems a reasonable expectation at this point that this expansion will continue, because anyone who doesn't sufficiently condemn/signal their agreement with policing speech in this manner might find themselves branded a "Nazi sympathizer". Is this where we're headed? I sincerely hope not, because it's going to lead to a frightening trend of self-censorship. This is a sign of a seriously unhealthy political culture.
- mc32 9y agoAfter the election there was a commentator who attributed Trump's win to "whitelash". If true, I think one could say in the media we're experiencing an aggravated allergy to anything that does not toe the PC-line. No doubt the most of the protestors were white supremacists and sympathizers, but to equate everyone who coincidentally shares anything with them (they vote R, they support NRA) is automatically binned with such groups is just as bad as what the left complains about when people on the right equate people who share some values with extremist-terrorists as equal to being a member in those kinds of groups.
- Red_Tarsius 9y agoThat's exactly were the USA is headed. The vocal minority wants the civil war to happen. They want to affirm their own epic narrative (https://sivers.org/drama https://sivers.org/drama). David defeats Goliath, for the common good. A lot of young people can't get a hold of their identity, so they grab on to their gender, race, being liberal, whatever. They make a virtue out of anything they already are. Then the journalists exploit the collective search for meaning by selling outrage and a scapegoat. Some people need the "nazis": their identity depends on it.
- yannis7 9y ago
- 21 9y agoACLU position on this is also interesting. They actually fought in court for the permit for the rally. "The First Amendment is a critical part of our democracy, and it protects vile, hateful, and ignorant speech. For this reason, the ACLU of Virginia defended the white supremacists’ right to march. But we will not be silent in the face of white supremacy. Those who do stand silent enable it. That includes our president." https://www.aclu.org/news/aclu-statement-charlottesville-violence-and-demonstrations https://www.aclu.org/news/aclu-statement-charlottesville-vio...
- mc32 9y agoThat's an interesting position. And I understand it. It's not easy. But it exposes the discomfort they have with defending the first amendment. It's like saying you support the right to an attorney but since someone is a murderer you hope the State Appointed defense attorney is a lackey or they don't appoint any.
- 21 9y agoI also wondered a long time about why would an attorney defend someone which clearly seems to be a criminal. My understanding of this is that if someone is an obvious criminal, it will be easy to prove in court, so the attorney will not change the outcome.
- abhi3 9y agoOJ Simpson
- pfranz 9y agoJohn Adams volunteered to represent British soldiers accused of killing civilians[1]. He made some good arguments about fairness. Even if they're guilty of crimes, it's still not fair to abuse them, pile on more charges, or take shortcuts when gathering facts. They also still need to be sentenced fairly. For example, if the guy who ran over and killed the woman in Charlottesville didn't get fair representation or trial, both sides could rightfully argue "the system is rigged." [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Adams#Counsel_for_the_British:_Boston_Massacre https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Adams#Counsel_for_the_Bri...
- Red_Tarsius 9y agoThe Daily Stormer read like a parody of the alt-right. But, unlike ISIS videos, it had zero persuasion power. https://web.archive.org/web/20170813051230/http://dailystormer.com/ https://web.archive.org/web/20170813051230/http://dailystorm... If anything, it was a testament to what's wrong with the movement. Leave the website up, for everyone to disprove and make fun of.
- spiderfarmer 9y agoIt's not persuasive to you (and me). But look at how many people are staunch, almost religious, defenders of ridiculous alternative facts. A lot of people believe what they want to believe and will only look for evidence that supports their believes.
- ebola1717 9y agoRight, like literally this weekend, there was a violent mob of people that found this persuasive.
- Freak_NL 9y agoYou might want to enclose a term such as 'alternative facts' in quote marks; without them you legitimize the concept. The use of the adverb 'ridiculous' and the gist of your comment imply that you do not subscribe to the notion of 'alternative facts' yourself.
- spiderfarmer 9y agoLearned something. Thanks.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- JudasGoat 9y agoInfowars has 2 million subscribers on YouTube, so...
- ufmace 9y agoWell this is an interesting situation. I don't mind reading absurdly offensive things that I disagree with, so I went looking for what happened to them. Seems they were rejected a total of 3 times for registrars for their .com domain, and were briefly online via a .wang domain which they claimed to have discovered was superior, but has since been shut down also. They are currently online via a Tor hidden site, and they still seem to have a Twitter feed, for now. They claim to be actively searching for a new .com registrar. They also seem to have been dropped by several other cloud services, including Zoho, Sendgrid, and Discourse. Obligatory disclaimer - open Nazi-ism, every bit as offensive as you think it is. Browse at your own risk to your sanity and browser history. Thought about posting the Tor link, but honestly, you can find it with a couple of Google searches. As someone else here said, I'm not so sure that defending the right of Nazis to speak and publish websites is the hill to die on here. But this does raise the question of who they will go after next. Exactly how offensive or outside of the mainstream do you have to be to get 90% of registrars and cloud services to terminate your services?
- 21 9y agoSo, Amazon is still selling Mein Kampf. Going by the No Platform argument mentioned a lot in this thread, or by the right to choose how to do business, people should be putting pressure on Amazon to stop selling it. https://www.amazon.co.uk/Mein-Kampf-Struggle-Adolf-Hitler-ebook/dp/B01HE5UE04/ https://www.amazon.co.uk/Mein-Kampf-Struggle-Adolf-Hitler-eb...
- SirLJ 9y agoLet's start by burning books we don't like and disagree with...
- ratsmack 9y agoAfter reading this entire thread, I am amazed at the mental gymnastics elicited to defend the silencing of a group or person with distasteful views... I fear for out country.
- Houshalter 9y agoReposting pieces of a comment I made yesterday: Defending freedom necessarily requires defending undesirables. Because undesirables are the people who benefit most from freedom. Think of the history of freedom enabling technologies. Copyright violators are the first people to adopt torrents. Pedophiles are the first people to adopt tor. Hackers and drug dealers are the biggest adopters of bitcoin. Undesirable extremists are going to be the group to benefit the most from the open web. Defending any of these things requires defending their undesirable users. Sure, it starts with the most extreme, least defensible things. Like stormfront. But you really think it will stop there? Where will the line get drawn? What happens when the next red scare happens? Politics is like a pendulum - it goes back and forth. Just a generation ago Communism was the persecuted ideology. People on the far left were blacklisted, silenced, and discriminated against. Was that ok with you? You want it to be 10x worse next time, by establishing a culture with no tolerance of differing opinions? Because that is where we are heading.
- zimpenfish 9y ago
- JCzynski 9y ago>But few really oppose the basic predicate of these removals: that private companies can and should be arbiters of permissible speech on their platforms. I am proud to count myself among those few. Social media is the modern public square and must be treated as such.
- onion2k 9y agoYou're interpreting the first amendment as "Congress shall make no law [...] abridging the freedom of speech on the speakers chosen platform." I rather like the idea that the New Yorker rejecting my work could be considered a violation of my rights.
- DarkKomunalec 9y agoDon't confuse the ideal of free speech, with its legal implementation in the 1st Amendment.
- ebola1717 9y agoBut free speech as an ideal is made to protect people from the unique threat posed by state censorship. This may have applications to platforms with influence as widespread as Google or Facebook, but it certainly doesn't apply to most other private entities. Absent such an overwhelming imbalance in power, what most people consider "censorship" is more often than not just counter-speech and holding people accountable for their words and actions.
- Khaine 9y agoWhen the constitution was drafted, there were no companies like facebook or google. The state was the largest and most powerful entity. The first amendment is a product of its times, if it was drafted today it would be different to reflect the massive power that corporations hold over people.
- wutbrodo 9y agoWhy is this canard such a common response in discussions like these? The only explanation I've come up with so far is that the people saying stuff like this are profoundly stupid, and I really hate it when my only explanation of a POV is that facile and self-serving. I don't mean to pick on you in particular but I'm hoping you can explain this to me and try to steelman this common refrain. Free speech as a concept (or a spectrum) exists independently of its codification in our Constitution. It's not something the founders accidentally wrote down and now we're stuck with it: they did it for a reason that some people (myself and the parent comment included) find compelling in contexts other than simply "when the Constitution forces us to". It's fine to disagree with its relevance to specific contexts, but what on earth compels you to think that "The Constitution doesn't force us to!" is a remotely relevant response to "I think free speech is a good idea in this context"?
- libeclipse 9y ago"Abhorrent but legal". An interesting term. I feel that most people miss out the "legal" part of it, though.
- gadders 9y agoReading posts by Milo et al, it seems MailChimp is also stopping service for some people on the Right they don't like.
- nullifidian 9y agoTo me this is not that different from state censorship I experience in Russia. I would argue that the internet is the primary medium for exercizing one's free speech today. The technological change made printed medium outdated. If you are not on the interent, you will not be heard. If the the government decided to configure the crucial internet infrastructure (domain name resolution) in a way that private companies can censor speech(registrars and verisign), then it's effectively a violation of the first amendment. Because what this ammounts to is government saying that the medium of public protesting or sharing printed material is protected, but the medium of electronic communication is not, because we decided to privatize it. It's like saying you can't protest here because we decided to privatize all the public squares and paved roads, their owners don't want to see you, and the fist amendment does not protect you there, you can protest on a dirt road in the forest(TOR etc) where no one sees you. I feel very uneasy about these events, because it's a precedent. Censorship of the interent in Russia began with pedophile histeria in the media to justify the laws, and now it's used to censor opposition supporting media. Considering the changing tastes of upcoming college graduates in the US, in terms of interpretation of what constitues free speech and what doesn't, the political censorship could become intstituionalized in the US through "TOS violations". And through this censorial normalcy could eventually pave way to the end of the current absolutist legal interpretation of the first amendment. Which would be very bad IMO.
- CM30 9y ago> It's like saying you can't protest here because we decided to privatize all the public squares and paved roads, their owners don't want to see you, and the fist amendment does not protect you there, you can protest on a dirt road in the forest(TOR etc) where no one sees you. This is why I've always been skeptical of the whole 'no one owes you a public platform' thing. Because prior to the internet, they kind of did. Public property meant your protest would likely be visible to a large audience, even though those who may disagree with you or wish you'd go away. Even in cases that would probably horrify a large percentage of people on social media sites: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Socialist_Party_of_America_v._Village_of_Skokie https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Socialist_Party_of_Am... In that sense, why you weren't de jure guaranteed an audience, you were de facto guaranteed one because public property was well, public. The internet being all private property means that while the legal basis of free speech isn't under threat, the practical purpose of it is.
- Khaine 9y agoSigh. We went through this 70 years ago with literal nazis, are we going to have to live through it again, this time from the far left? Didn't they learn this poem in school? "First they came for the Socialists, and I did not speak out— Because I was not a Socialist. Then they came for the Trade Unionists, and I did not speak out— Because I was not a Trade Unionist. Then they came for the Jews, and I did not speak out— Because I was not a Jew. Then they came for me—and there was no one left to speak for me." To be clear, I don't agree with what nazi's say, but like voltaire I support their right to be able to say it.
- c0nducktr 9y agoAre you kidding me? That poem is literally about the Nazis, and how you have to fight them before they exterminate you.
- leereeves 9y agoThat poem is indeed literally about the Nazis, but it's a warning about any extremist group that gains power by attacking other extremists, wherever they fall on the political spectrum. The first line, "First they came for the Socialists", is about communists, another despised group who certain politicians in America have targeted to their profit and our lasting shame. The remaining lines are about other groups the Nazis attacked by associating them with communists, in the same way Hollywood was once associated with communists in America. In our hatred for Nazis, let's not forget our basic values the way we once did when McCarthy waved communists in front of us like a matador.
- TheAdamAndChe 9y ago> it's a warning about any extremist group that gains power by attacking other extremists I believe you may have misinterpreted the poem. It's not about preventing "attacks" towards other extremists, it's about _suppressing_ them. It's one thing to argue with someone, fight with them, make your disagreements known, and whatever. That advances the conversation. It's a completely different issue to silence and suppress your enemies. That leads to authoritarianism, whether from the left or the right. In my opinion, it is right of the majority to make their disdain towards the Nazis known. It is right of them to denounce their behavior. I personally don't feel it's right to suppress their ability to express their views, however.
- davidreiss 9y agoIt is insane that we are allowing GoDaddy, Google and tech companies to be arbiters of free speech. As a kid, I used to associate google, yahoo and the whole of internet as a bastion of freedom. It is shocking to me that liberals ( a group I used to identify with until fairly recently ) are the proponents of censorship on the internet and in america. It is shocking to me that google, godaddy and the internet is now synonymous with censorship and propaganda. Not only is censorship giving daily stormer and neo-nazis more sympathy/credibility, companies like google, godaddy and the liberal movement is making a mockery of liberal principles. My first philosophy course in college was with a jewish professor. We were discussing free speech and the rights of neo-nazis/kkk/hate groups to free speech. I clearly remember her saying that protecting the rights of neo-nazis/kkk to free speech is the only way to ensure the rights of speech speech for everyone. Free speech rights exist to protect "offensive" speech - whether it be pornography, atheism or hate speech. What has happened to the tech industry? What has happened to the liberal movement? How did the tech community and the liberal movement get hijacked by anti-free speech and oppressive extremists? If conservatives are pro-censorship and now liberals are pro-censorship, what future is there for individual rights, free speech and the liberal world order?
- doubleshame 9y agoIt is very important to distinguish something like Facebook blocking an account / Medium taking down a blog from a domain registrar refusing to cooperate. You are free to create a room where only some ideologies are allowed, but it's dangerous to play the same game with the ability to create the rooms. First the domain registrars, then networks say that they don't want to peer, and then we end up with a fragmented internet. It is not wise to pretend that an opinion that you do not want just simply does not exist. The extremist in the room who everybody pretends is not there, is eventually going to do more radical things to be noticed. In the echo chamber of extremism, there is now no moderating thought; and the world loses empathy to understand these unpopular perspectives that still exist. "Sunlight is the best disinfectant" "Isolation only promotes extremism"
- khabaal 9y agoAs a person from germany and as many of you might not know, the "daily stormer" is directly connotated to "Der Stürmer" [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Der_St%C3%BCrmer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Der_St%C3%BCrmer]. That newspaper with its very popular antisemitic caricatures was one of the main sources of radicalization in germany.