4 ms·
What burden are you talking about exactly? You (along with many others) seem to be conflating the major point of the memo between interests and abilities. Not
by manigandham 9y ago
What burden are you talking about exactly?
You (along with many others) seem to be conflating the major point of the memo between interests and abilities. Not liking something does not mean you're not capable of doing it.
- dguaraglia 9y agoWould you rather hire someone that likes what they do or someone who doesn't? Would you intuitively think that someone who loves their job are going to be more interested in bigger challenges and doing great work, or someone who doesn't care for the job?
- humanrebar 9y ago> Would you rather hire someone that likes what they do or someone who doesn't? I wouldn't assume someone's interest level based on their demographics. I would, you know, talk to them.
- dguaraglia 9y agoSo, you are in favor of outreach programs where you get to talk to more people?
- humanrebar 9y agoSure. I do that already, both formally and informally. Though I've probably been underestimating how career limiting that can be. The Google firing was a really bad move if outreach programs are a good idea.
- dguaraglia 9y agoNot sure I follow why you think the firing had something to do with outreach? You mean they'll be losing out on candidates like Damore?
- humanrebar 9y agoI think people won't feel comfortable sharing freely, which undermines the whole point of it. It won't just affect candidates like Damore. People who don't feel like sharing probably won't feel like getting talked at, so there won't be much listening in the other direction either.
- manigandham 9y agoI optimize for productivity first, that doesn't always equate to someone who likes their job. Regardless, I'm not sure how that's related to my comment - the memo was discussing relative interests in software engineering (and other disciplines), not capabilities of people being able to do code better than others.
- dguaraglia 9y agoBy perpetuating the stereotype that "women are less interested in engineering" and suggesting that your chances of getting a good female candidate are lower, Damore is introducing an unconscious bias against women. After all, "it's likely that she doesn't really like this", "she probably went into engineering because her parents pushed her", "maybe she's great now, but she'll lose interest once anxiety kicks in." Next time your engineers are scheduled to interview someone and they see a female name on the resume, they'll form an opinion (even if slight, and even if overridable by interacting with the person) about who the candidate is. Depending on how tired/stressed/bored they are that day, that opinion will play a smaller or bigger role in what they write down in the candidate report. That bias, by the way, exists today. Trying to justify it on the base of biological differences does nothing to fix it.
- kansface 9y ago> That bias, by the way, exists today. Trying to justify it on the base of biological differences does nothing to fix You presupposed that the bias is why the disparity exists in the first place. Its plausible that we completely fix all biases in the industry and the gender ratio does not change whatsoever, or even gets worse.
- dguaraglia 9y ago> You presupposed that the bias is why the disparity exists in the first place What in my comment tells you that? I made a conscious effort not to bring that up. > Its plausible that we completely fix all biases in the industry and the gender ratio does not change whatsoever, or even gets worse. This argument sounds like the global warming denier argument "What if it's not true? What if we make the world a better place to live for nothing?" It is plausible, but right now we have no way to measure it. We do, on the other hand, know that unconscious bias is affecting prospective female candidates. Why don't we focus on fixing the existing problem first?
- richmarr 9y ago> You (along with many others) seem to be conflating the major point of the memo between interests and abilities Sorry, this is wrong. Direct quote (emphasis added): "I’m simply stating that the distribution of preferences and abilities of men and women differ in part due to biological causes" See Damore's own mirror: https://firedfortruth.com/ https://firedfortruth.com/
- manigandham 9y agoYes, this is a case of context. In that exact quote it states "preferences and abilities" in terms of biological associations. However, biological traits and abilities != career ability. Even more so since these are average indexes with vast overlap between groups.
- richmarr 9y agoOkay, let's try another approach. On what basis do you think that preferences and abilities are two mutually exclusive traits? We know interest is influenced heavily by environment. We also know that ability is influenced by both interest and environment. Carol Dweck's work is a good source for this type of study. It also seems intuitive that ability influences interests, although I'm actually not aware of what studies exist in that area. I don't think you're standing on as solid footing as you think when you're making accusations of others conflating topics.
- manigandham 9y agoThere's another conflation between skill and ability. Lots of people can do lots of things, some are better because they're more interested (leading to more practice, etc). Just because interests and abilities influence each other does not mean they are not exclusive. You can do a lot of things that you probably have never even considered before too.
- tajen 9y agoPlus where is the outrage when newspapers title: "A scientist proves that women can do two activities at the same time" and "What makes women better at management"? Many women believe they're statistically more intelligent than men and less violent, by fate of biology.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]