5 ms·
I am well aware of my inabilities to tackle this issue properly, so ... I don't write a big document about it and circulate it. Discretion is an issue here too
by CydeWeys 9y ago
I am well aware of my inabilities to tackle this issue properly, so ... I don't write a big document about it and circulate it. Discretion is an issue here too. If you are not capable of addressing an issue in a productive manner, then don't, especially if it's not even related to your job. James was hired as an engineer to work on engineering stuff; he wasn't hired as a sociologist to work on diversity stuff. He made the choice to inject himself into something in an ill-advised manner when he could've instead simply not done so.
- pg_is_a_butt 9y agoright... and i was just hired to pour this Zyklon B down this chimney... why should i question any other aspect of my employment or my employer's actions.
- bluGill 9y agoHe was like it or not thrust into it though by the choices google has made, or appeared to make. When your hiring demographics do not roughly match graduation demographics you are not being honest. There is every appearance that google is discriminating against males in their efforts to search out women. This might be best for google overall, but he is a male which means it is not in his personal favor.
- brianberns 9y ago> When your hiring demographics do not roughly match graduation demographics you are not being honest. Or maybe the graduation demographics are biased and Google is just trying to correct them?
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoHow is Google correcting biased graduation demographics via hiring practices?
- goialoq 9y agoBy paying more recruiting/sourcing attention to subpopulations they regard as unnaturally thinned by discrimination.
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoIf they were thinned out in primary, middle, high school, or in university, how does Google bring those women back with their hiring practices? The premise here did involve "biased graduation demographics", which I assume to mean proper educational credentials for the job.
- brianberns 9y agoThere are still more qualified women making it through university than Google could possibly hire. Google just has to try a bit harder to find them. Example: Men and women are equally qualified by nature, but the graduating class contains 800 qualified men and 200 qualified women due to unfair "thinning". Google needs to hire 200 people, so they hire 100 men (1 out of 8 in the graduating class) and 100 women (1 out of 2 in the graduating class).
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoGoogle isn't the only company hiring women.
- brianberns 9y agoHow is that relevant to the question?
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoGoogle has to compete with all the other companies for the same pool of talent. They can out compete them with more money, but that would raise eye brows after awhile. Something has to give somewhere when supply is constrained. The only real solution to the gender gap involves fixing the talent pipeline and then waiting N years for the talent to start coming through. Everything else is just a stop gap that is bound to create distortions. It would be different if there was lots of talent that just couldn't get jobs because of overt discrimination (e.g. as is the case with ageism), but the gender gap is not that easy of a problem.
- jjjasfdj88 9y agoLots of folks seem to think merit, which I'd define as "ability to be successful in a role" is based solely on one metric: their ability to assemble more widgets than the next person. Through human history a pretty obvious pattern that isn't the case appears very obvious to me. Humans rely heavily on the feels to promote and lift up ideas and the people attached to them. There's been study after study in neuroscience and psychology concluding that we don't come to our final decision based solely on available facts. Pre-conceived conclusions rule our decision making in day-to-day life. It's something all these "smart" males raging over this crap would do well to consider. No one really gives a crap that you did well on Google's hiring exam. You're still a disposable cog. You're good at computers. STFU and learn about all the other things out there. Cause just being good at that isn't good enough anymore. It probably never was, and the whole tilt towards males was riding on cultural rails. Humans are not machines. Something that is lost on our culture. Certain voices were warning us about this very scenario of being solely concerned with social statuses: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marx%27s_theory_of_alienation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marx%27s_theory_of_alienation EDIT: Piling on https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15020683 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15020683
- novembermike 9y agoTo be fair, from his perspective it appears he was trying to discuss discrimination taking place against him. I'd think long and hard before I told a woman to shut up if they were talking about the same. There's actually a reasonable argument that his document is protected speech and Google violated federal employment law by firing him.