8 ms·
Google says it will ban neo-Nazi site after domain name switch
- to_bpr 9y agoOutrage-driven censorship isn't anything new, unfortunately. While I respect Google's rights to host whatever it wants as a private business, I can't help but feel these actions merely serve to prove certain groups right and embolden, or entrench, divisions even further.
- willstrafach 9y agoMost folks would still vehemently object if this was done on the basis of political party or similar, and would not seriously consider "but you wre fine when they had issues with white supremisists and Nazis!" to be a credible argument. The slippery slope concern does not seem like it would apply much here.
- pravda 9y agoCensorship! It's the American way!
- dragonwriter 9y agoThat's literally true; private censorship is exactly what the freedom of speech and press in the first amendment protect: that every private party is generally free to choose what speech it will relay.
- thrill 9y agoSo ... no "bake that cake" for you?
- flunhat 9y agoWe've been through this debate before - businesses can't discriminate against anyone who is in a protected class. Otherwise, they can pick and choose. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protected_class https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protected_class
- thrill 9y agoSo these guys are claiming their (hateful) message is about their race. Are they justified in claiming their protected class is not being recognized in this business decision by Godaddy, et alia.
- flunhat 9y agoGoogle isn't discriminating on the basis of race. It's not saying "These people cannot host their domain with our service because of their skin color". That would be illegal, but that's not what they're doing, obviously.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> Are they justified in claiming their protected class is not being recognized in this business decision by Godaddy, et alia. They are certainly free to lay out their evidence that it is race and not advocacy of violence that motivated the actions, either to make that case in the court of public opinion or one of law (race-based discrimination in public accommodation is generally illegal). From the publicly available evidence, that explanation doesn't seem the most likely one, though.
- dragonwriter 9y agoPublic accommodation anti-discrimination laws are a thorny area where they address things which can be viewed as expressive/speech acts for exactly this reason, sure. But, the appropriateness of such laws and how they interact with First Amendment freedoms is somewhat irrelevant to this case, in the absence of a statute that would be applicable.
- cperciva 9y agoevery private party is generally free to choose what speech it will relay This is generally true, but not always; in particular, companies with monopolistic power forfeit some of their autonomy. I'm sure that wouldn't apply in this case, but it might kick in if Google banned this website from its search results, for example.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ape4 9y agoFreedom of Speech says this jerks should be able to have a domain. Business sense says its dumb to host this group.
- lightbyte 9y ago>Freedom of Speech says this jerks should be able to have a domain. No it does not, the government is not the entity they are dealing with.
- cgag 9y agobecause we have to do this every time: Either the principle is important and you support it or you don't. If you actually believe in freedom of speech you don't get to celebrate censorship by corporate entities because the constitution didn't forbid it.
- srinivgp 9y agoEquivocation. "the principle" points at different principles for different people. There are differences in which types of organizations we might wish to forbid from interfering with speech. It is absolutely coherent to believe in a principle which celebrates censorship by corporate entities but not by governmental entities.
- dragonwriter 9y agoI believe that the right of private parties to be free from having speech compelled or repressed by the State is an important principal which means (except where it runs up against other important principals) permitting private censorship is important for the same reason as prohibiting public censorship.
- tenaciousDaniel 9y agoAs much as this conversation gets played out, I still find it really interesting. On one hand, there is a difference between free speech as a legal term, and the free speech principles that undergird it. You can argue that Google should abide by free speech principles in allowing open discourse, regardless of the legal requirement to do so. On the other hand, a fundamental component of free speech (expression in this case) principles is the right to free association. Google therefore should exercise its own judgement in selecting those with whom they do associate, and resist external demands to associate with someone they would rather not. I believe that Google should feel free, both legally and socially, to act according to their conscience as a company. However, I believe that their conscience, as a massively powerful part of online communication, should be to remain neutral towards any legal communication that takes place on their platform. I think that's a more effective moral stance than the one they are taking.
- Cozumel 9y agoGoogle - blocking Nazi sites today, blocking your political party of choice tomorrow. This is why namecoin and .bit domains are so great, it's basically registering your domain on the blockchain so it can't be censored.
- Daishiman 9y agoThis a garbage, slipper-slope argument. It is clear and indubitable that the people in question host hate speech. There's nothing controversial about it.
- myrandomcomment 9y agoYes they host hate speech. What is your point. They have the right to speak even if their views are poison and stupid. That is the point. This speech would have been perfectly fine in the 50s & 60s. The sites that would get banned by your logic would be the anti-rascism ones as that did not follow the popular sentiment. All speech should be protected even if it is abhorrent and stupid.
- flunhat 9y agoIn the United States, you only have a right to free speech in the public space - the government cannot punish you for it. But not in the private space, with a few clear legal exceptions. I think a source of confusion in this thread is a lack of understanding over this public-private division, which has existed for hundreds of years now. It's nothing new, and it's certainly not illegal.
- Daishiman 9y agoNo, not really. Who the hell thinks that "all speech should be protected"? You're oversimplifying a complex issue into a soundbyte that is not and has never been real. Nobody defends hate speech.
- myrandomcomment 9y agoNo I am not. It is really that simple. People can say and think whatever stupid thing they want. As soon as you put limits on what people can say it becomes a slippery slope (Hey let's ban talking about Abortion - you do not think that would happen given enough control to that camp?). The only way to be safe it just to allow people to say what they want (with in the limits of "fire in a theater" or liable) and deal with it. You do not have to like it. Feel free to argue and protest against it. That is your right because what comes out of your mouth is just a protected as something that comes out of the dumbass alt-right people. I am not afraid of what they say. I challenge the facts and truth of it but it is their right to be stupid. Only education and good people standing up for what is just and correct removes the sources of hate speech. Banning it is just something that allows people to feel good without solving the source of the issue in the first place.
- stupidstupid1 9y agoSilencing opinions is great as long as its opinions I disagree with.
- nemo44x 9y agoThe Website is only doing this for publicity. They knew Google would ban them immediately and they can use that as a cry of oppression to their members and aspiring members and young people who buy into this and are looking for a cause to identify with. And after all this a lot more people know about them than before. Streisand effect in action.
- Clubber 9y agoPerhaps, but Google's short sightedness will probably make them (Stormwhatever) stronger. I mean who knew Google liked to sensor unfavorable views? A lot of people do now.
- nemo44x 9y agoMy fear is it will be easier for organizations like this Website to radicalize otherwise moderate people. It isn't hard to sell the argument that "first they (liberal minded people) wanted to take away your second amendment right. Now they want to take your first! We are the protectors of the Constitution!". Banning them is futile (someone on Earth will host them) and makes them more subversive, taboo, and attractive to certain people.
- Clubber 9y ago>"first they (liberal minded people) wanted to take away your second amendment right. Now they want to take your first! We are the protectors of the Constitution!". I'm sure that is absolutely what is happening, and they kind of have a point. Google leans liberal, they just got a ton of bad press for firing that guy, and they just blocked Stormwhatever from their DNS servers after GoDaddy just did (who I assume is also liberalish). Like I said, shortsighted. Not to mention when people start thinking of Google as a monopoly, they don't want a bunch of references to a banstick coming up in public discourse.
- croon 9y agoRespect, humanity and kindness isn't political, liberal or otherwise. If anyone buys into that bullshit it's on them, not Google or Godaddy.
- lucisferre 9y agoOn a related note, Anonymous has apparently hacked them. https://www.dailystormer.com/hacked-anonymous-now-in-control-of-daily-stormer/ https://www.dailystormer.com/hacked-anonymous-now-in-control...
- myrandomcomment 9y agoPart of the reason we served was to allow people we disagree with have the right to freedom of speech no matter how stupid their views are. Banning hate speech (no matter how abhorrent) is a slippery slope.
- to_bpr 9y agoGoogle, Facebook, Twitter etc. have a pretty beefy track record in very selective censorship. Why would you expect anything else from them?
- ggggtez 9y agoFreedom of speech only applies to government entities.
- problems 9y agoLegally speaking in the US, yes. But freedom of speech arguably holds value as a concept outside of its strict legal definition.
- CydeWeys 9y agoPrivate companies are allowed to choose who they want to do business with. To give you an example, pornography is legal, and the government can't jail you for making or distributing it, but it's also within Facebook's rights to decide that they don't want it on their platform. Freedom of speech has to do with freedom from government censorship and prosecution; you can't force random private entities to help spread your speech.
- steveeq1 9y agoYet the government can force private entities to sell a cake to a homosexual couple? The laws seem arbitrary to me.
- ceejayoz 9y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protected_class https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protected_class edit: The cake case was due to state laws, though. > No federal law requires businesses to serve all customers without regard to their sexual orientation, but 21 states have “public accommodations” laws that prohibit discrimination against gays and lesbians. - http://www.latimes.com/politics/la-na-pol-court-gays-religion-20170626-story.html http://www.latimes.com/politics/la-na-pol-court-gays-religio...
- Overtonwindow 9y agoI really don't like this. I don't support nazi's and racists but I do support the free expression of speech. The mob mentality is pushing Google and GoDaddy towards censorship. Where will it end? Why don't they revoke the domain of 4Chan? What's next, Wikileaks? Unless the website is breaking the law I say leave them alone.
- sctb 9y agoPrevious discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15010981 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15010981
- Overtonwindow 9y agoWhere's the EFF now? Unless it is breaking the law, censorship of any kind is wrong in my book. As distasteful and atrocious as they are, I don't care if you're nazi's or nambla, free expression on the internet, of all places, should be guaranteed. I hope they find a domain that stands up to the mob.
- squarefoot 9y agoThat's a reason for yelling censorship served on a golden tray. Well done, Google. Bravo!