11 ms·
The reasons HMS Queen Elizabeth has two ‘islands’
- hackcasual 9y agoThe US uses nuclear power for it's Nimitz and Ford class carriers, so there is no need for extensive exhaust.
- akhatri_aus 9y agoThese ships can't use the Suez canal which can be problematic
- blackguardx 9y agoThe primary size constraint of US ships is the Panama canal.
- astrodust 9y agoThe US solution to this problem is to build a ridiculous number of carriers so there's coverage on both sides.
- gozur88 9y agoIt's only ridiculous if you assume we'll never lose one (or more) in a real shooting war. That's not an assumption US planners are prepared to make.
- jabl 9y agoWith a $1 trillion military budget the US can lose half of them and still have more left than the rest of the world combined.. :-/
- astrodust 9y agoIt's ridiculous because most countries have one or two at most and the US has eleven. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_aircraft_carriers_in_service https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_aircraft_carriers_in_s...
- anthonybsd 9y agoYes, but it gets even more ridiculous once you consider the fact that the last 60 years have been relatively peaceful for Naval warfare. During WW2 the U.S. had well over 100 aircraft carriers on active duty.
- sailfast 9y agoConsidering the cold war relatively peaceful at sea is interesting, firstly. Secondly, I would argue that the reason the seas have been free from "major conflict" over the last 60 years is in no small measure due to the preponderance of naval power wielded by the United States and Russia. If odds had not been overwhelming, do you think there would have been less conflict, or more?
- metaphorm 9y agothese ships can't use the Suez canal in peace-time under the currently negotiated treaties. if they really truly must go through the canal, who's gonna stop them?
- isostatic 9y agoEgypt could scuttle a ship or two if they wanted - at both ends, trapping the fleet inside. Seems to me that canals make rather sitting targets for warships, at war time at least.
- djrogers 9y agoA carrier battle group is more than powerful enough to control both ends of the canal for the duration of the trip, and I seriously doubt that Egypt (or any other country) would want to cripple an economic engine as large as a canal unless they were directly involved in the war in question.
- gaius 9y agoReally? Multiple carrier groups, plus ground contingents from the Army and Marines, plus the Air Force are unable to "control" Iraq or Afghanistan...
- StudyAnimal 9y agoI am no military genius, but Iraq and Afghanistan sound larger, more complex, and not as commandable by sea as a typical canal.
- gaius 9y agoPerhaps you are unaware of the events of 1956 when the combined forces of Britain and France failed to hold the Suez Canal?
- 9y ago
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoThe way a carrier group works you shouldn't be cramming it all into a canal.
- dctoedt 9y agoThe new Suez canal has been transited by at least one U.S. nuclear-powered carrier, the USS Theodore Roosevelt [0]. [0] Speeded-up video of the transit: https://sploid.gizmodo.com/cool-video-of-a-us-aircraft-carrier-crossing-the-new-su-1723907545 https://sploid.gizmodo.com/cool-video-of-a-us-aircraft-carri...
- Shivetya 9y agoturn of the century, think 1900-1910 ships, suffered severely from lack of development in boiler technology. Four, five, and even six, in a row could be found. One or two even had parallel rows. For many ships, mostly battleships, which went under modernization programs after WW1 the most common noticeable change was reduction in the number of funnels as boiler count was halved or reduced by two thirds. It wasn't uncommon to take a battleship or even a cruiser apart as it was still cheaper to do let alone easier to get the budget for. with regards to this new carrier it probably was a good idea to not go nuclear when your experience with it at this scale is not sufficient plus just the inherent costs of doing that. one would think the age of CVs has passed similar to how the age of BBs passed even prior to WW2 but naval commands are very loathe to acknowledge a shift in tactics until half their fleet is sunk
- 21 9y agoThe title is highly confusing. I believed that it was about the Queen (person) owning two physical (land) islands. But HMS Queen Elizabeth is a ship and the islands are the two towering structures on it.
- dionidium 9y agoThe HMS portion makes it clear that we're talking about a boat https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Her_Majesty%27s_Ship https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Her_Majesty%27s_Ship
- astrodust 9y agoIt doesn't make it clear unless you know what that means. "HM" is understood to mean Her Majesty, but the "S" could mean anything to those not familiar with the abbreviation.
- detritus 9y agoIn that case, take the time to check what the abbreviation is? Headlines are inherently not exhaustive in their explanation, that's kind of the point.
- astrodust 9y agoWhat's CSIS? NFB? OHIP? These are all acronyms that are geographically localized, and arguably HMS, like NHS and OBE is one of those as well.
- 21 9y agoI'm in London and it was not clear at all, considering how pretty much anything here is HM.
- johneth 9y agoI think you might be an outlier in this case. 'HMS' is pretty widely known to mean 'ship' (in the UK, at least).
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoWith twice as many towers the enlisted personnel on Royal Navy carriers will have twice as many people pissed off at them when there's a minor slip up.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- twic 9y ago> The captain has a day cabin just behind the bridge for use at sea but as is usual on a carrier, his spacious main cabin is down aft with the other officer accommodation. There is a small lift that allows him to quickly get up or down from the bridge to the operations room which is situated seven decks below. > The Commander Air, “Wings” gets a day cabin in the aft island but does not have his own lift, like the Captain up forward. I know there's a perfectly good practical reason for the Commander Air not having a lift, but i do love the idea that we British are still playing silly little status games even at sea!
- gozur88 9y agoStatus can be conferred in lieu of extra pay :) In all seriousness, symbols of status are important in the military, and not just to stroke the top guy's ego. They reinforce the notion of hierarchy, which is something without which you lose battles you might have won. Besides, if there's any people who know how to prepare for and execute surface warfare, it's you British. Clearly you've done something right over the years.
- sgt101 9y agoThe reason is very simple : after the Falklands war the Royal Navy adopted a design rule which states that all surface ships must have two islands. You can see it in the 45, 23 and 26. My guess is that this is because of the fires which took Sheffield out of combat, the initial damage from the Exocet warhead was substantial, but what killed Sheffield and Coventry was the fire afterwards. The investigations afterwards showed that a split superstructure would have allowed continued operation including withdrawal from the combat space and low allocation of rescue resources. I think/guess that this would have been critical should aggressor forces been slightly more substantial; it would have been very easy to get into a situation where the capability to manage the rescue and recovery of struck ships would have been lost, and this would have led to a substantial escalation in casualties and probable collapse of the fighting capability of the formation - hence to a strategic opportunity for aggressor forces.
- junto 9y agoIs anyone else disturbed by the fact with all that money spent on this, they choose this horrendous decor for the chairs styling? http://www.savetheroyalnavy.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/08/HMS-Ark-Royal-Bridge.jpg http://www.savetheroyalnavy.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/08/H...
- zimpenfish 9y agoThat screams "competition winner".