3 ms·
I think that this professor is correctly relating the recent sexism episode with other critiques of Google, culture, it's place in our society, and previous mon
by ilaksh 9y ago
I think that this professor is correctly relating the recent sexism episode with other critiques of Google, culture, it's place in our society, and previous monopolies. We should take advantage of his perspective. They are all related problems.
In a way, getting down to the uglier sides of the people involved in the organizations with unchecked control over our society is a way to bring the point home that no, we cannot place this much trust in these people.
But whether people are buying that angle or not, listen to the professor when he connects it to the larger problem of technopolies. Really this is just a new variation of the overblown corporate power that has been around forever. These companies like Google, Uber, and Amazon are so powerful they are basically supplanting aspects government in many countries. It's sort of like the giant corporations the cyberpunk authors envisioned, but worse because they don't have competition.
It does seem to basically be working to most people's benefit -- as long as you don't have a business that tried to compete with these companies.
This is just the core problem with both cooperative and competitive approaches to society -- without adequate structural prevention they tend towards over-centralization. If we can realize that this over-trusting relationship is unacceptable, that will motivate structural changes to improve it.
I believe the next big revolution will be mass deployment of truly decentralized, open, easily evolved, and public, platforms that have some similar features to the closed for-profit monopoly technology giant services. This includes things like search indexing and advertisement Google, retail indexing and logistics (Amazon), transportation (Uber), etc. And probably even banking, which is not quite as centralized but has things like PayPal etc.
Because high-tech economies of scale are great, but centralization of control by private companies over the public at large with fixed platforms that don't evolve are not.
- humanrebar 9y ago> ...listen to the professor when he connects it to the larger problem of technopolies... Well, I was already on board with that thesis. I'm not on board with (I assume) the proposed solution, which would be relying on new regulatory powers to resolve the issue. It doesn't help with other corporate oligopolies, so I'll need some convincing that this time it's different.
- ilaksh 9y agoMy own proposal is basically to replace those companies with versioned, modular software or protocols/smart contracts. See my history for the comment I just made prior to this one about Bannon and competition.
- humanrebar 9y agoOn some level that sounds good, but how does that protocol come into existence? Does the government write the protocols? Wouldn't they just design what relevant (i.e., Google, Amazon, et. al.) lobbyists tell them to? Who penalizes companies to aren't compliant with the protocols? What about the data? Data management isn't free and you can have a pristine protocols that are worthless due to garbage data.
- ilaksh 9y agoThe existing government absolutely does not write the protocols. Rather the ecosystem around the protocols (or more accurately maybe something like versioned semantic modules) becomes a new paradigm that supercedes traditional government. How or whether that type of thing comes into existence is obviously extremely challenging and isn't determined. I believe that useful governments will support some structures that enable these types of systems, but must not be allowed to directly control them -- we have too much evidence of how poorly that works out. That will be the remaining utility that allows the existence of traditional government, until these new systems are fully deployed. Yes, data management isn't free, and there are severe challenges related to that. But we have technologies that give us hope that we can find better ways to do data management than just letting Facebook or Google track everything we click on and store them in their own data centers.