10 ms·
Boring Company to use Tesla’s technology for its tunnel project under LA
- jaclaz 9y agoThe TBM (Tunnel Boring Machine) seems pretty much a "standard" one and in a note on one of the photos it is stated how it has been alredy used (in some project in San Francisco). The title seems to imply that the technology for boring the tunnel is Tesla derived, while it is related to the whatever vehicles that will be used in the tunnel once it will have been bored "traditionally".
- drcross 9y agoWhile the two subject seem to be confused in the article I assume that Tesla tech can be used in both the tunneling and the sleds. Musk's aim was to increase boring speed by two orders of magnitude so presumably they'll find inefficiencies by converting the boring machine to run on electric motors over what I presume to be diesel engines in existing machines.
- stupidcar 9y agoI'd be surprised if they use diesel engines. Seems like dealing with the exhaust in a closed environment like that would add too much risk and complexity.
- jaclaz 9y agoRight, though the issue is not much about risk and complexity, but rather by sheer power needed to push the air in a tunnel. The smaller the tunnel is, the smaller is the size of the ventilation tubes that can be used, and thus you need more power to push the air inside. The amount of air needed by an electric motor is "0", whilst the amount of air needed by a combustion engine is something that needs to be evaluated on a case by case basis, normally the rule of the thumb is 4 cubic meters per minute for each Diesel HP (i.e. with kW's 5.4/KW). And you have to assure anywyay some air to the people, usually 3 cubic meters per person per minute is used. And there is anywyay a limit to the pressure with which you can pump air in, because the "return speed" is usually limited to a maximum of 0.5 m/s (as higher speed may cause the transportation of dust and particles). And then of course the longer the tunnel is the more powerful must the ventilating fans be, we are talking of several hundreds of kW to power these fans.
- Dylan16807 9y agoSo that's enough airflow to make the engine exhaust be half a percent CO2, which is right about at workplace limits. And extreme overkill on the per-person air if everything is mixed together. (If it's not mixed together it makes sense to over-ventilate the humans for comfort.)
- jaclaz 9y agoI am not sure to understand what you mean "not mixed together", the tunnel is a single environment to which you provide air. The method generally used is "positive pressure". I.e. there is a single pipe or duct through which the air is pushed till the excavation front. The air, having no possible way out is forced to go back towards the tunnel opening. Since usually the most activities are near the excavation front there is concentrated the clean air, while the one returning back is "contaminated" by the CO2 and other fumes at the excavation front. The 3 m3/min per person and 4 m3/min per HP are common rules of the thumb to calculate the amount of air, and is in practice a "large" allowance since it is calculated with the maximum possible number of people and with the theoretical power of diesel engines (that never run at 100% throttle), and it has to take into account the said effect of contamination so that people working in the tunnel (not a the the excavation front) still get enough clean air. Moreover it is not a "continuous fine regulation", fans have normally a finite number of speeds, so you are always using the speed (and the number of fans) calculated for the "longest stretch". As an example for the first 200 mt of excavation you have one fan at 1st speed, the next step, switching to 2nd speed is good up to (say) 400 meters, and you switch to 2nd as soon as you get past 200 mt, and so on.
- Dylan16807 9y agoSo yes it's all mixed together from the second the air leaves the duct. Which makes it interesting that the 4 cubic meters per HP is about 10 times the allowance for contamination as the 3 cubic meters per person. Everyone shares the higher contamination level whenever the engines are active.
- 9y ago
- hengheng 9y agoThat seems like the last thing that is keeping us from having more tunnels under our feet.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jaclaz 9y agoRest assured, all existing TBM's are already operated by electric motors. And they need an amount of power that very doubtfully can be delivered by batteries. It is a bit of time that I don't deal with those smallish diameter TBM's, of 14 feet or so but to give you a comparison, a 22 feet one has usually a head (just the head) driven by some 6 x 300 or 350 kW electric motors. In the FAQ of the boring company: https://www.boringcompany.com/faq/ https://www.boringcompany.com/faq/ they mention diesel locomotives, but personally I have only seen electric (battery) locomotives used during TBM excavations. And the plan is to make their TBM's speedier by augmenting the power (to the head), besides optimizing cycles and what not, thus most probably the TBM itself will be powered "traditionally" by cable electricity.
- Animats 9y agoMusk's aim was to increase boring speed by two orders of magnitude The Boring Company FAQ only says 3x. They also want to do cutting and ring installation simultaneously, rather than alternately. TBMs have already been built which do that. Here's the fastest TBM in current use.[1] Best month, 702 meters. Worst month, zero, when they hit a cavern and had to stop to fill it with gravel and grout before proceeding. Tunneling has surprises like that. That machine has both a hard-rock and a pressure-balance mode. Switching is a big deal, with lots of cutter changing. One place Tesla might make progress is at the back end of the TBM. There's a huge amount of activity in back. Behind the TBM, there's usually a narrow gauge railroad track, and two tracks if there's room. Dirt cars are brought forward, filled with dirt, and sent back out. Ring segment cars bring ring segments forward. Work cars bring workers, tools, and spare parts. Track cars bring more track sections, to be laid behind the TBM. The TBM has machinery for laying track, loading and unloading cars, and moving cars from one track to the other. What if all those work cars were self-driving battery-powered vehicles? Get rid of all the tracks, use self-driving vehicles with 4-wheel steering, and have them position themselves exactly where they're needed. Dirt cars stop under the output conveyor, fill, and leave. Segment cars maneuver into position to where the segment assembly arm (a big robot arm) can remove the segments. No more track section cars. You'd need vehicles which run well on the bottom of a round tube without being centered, so they can pass each other. That could eliminate about half the gear at the back end of the TBM. [1] http://www.therobbinscompany.com/news/2017/07/10/mexicocitybreakthrough/ http://www.therobbinscompany.com/news/2017/07/10/mexicocityb...
- frik 9y agoYes, the video mentions the machine is a used one, formerly used in SF. They mention it wasn't altered at all to keep the certificates but they try to learn and in future may improve it. The Tesla reference is about a vehicle that would autonomous drive in the tunnel, it will not resemble a Tesla car but feature a cabin and use some components like battery/etc.
- Joeri 9y agoTesla started out by converting an existing lead acid electric car to lithium ion. It's smart to try to understand and optimize the already existing thing before you redesign it from scratch.
- agumonkey 9y agoThey didn't start from a clean slate ?
- tsuraan 9y agoThe tesla roadster started with a Lotus Elise body and frame. The S was the first tesla that was entirely their design (AFAIK). EDIT: actually, from looking at [0], Tesla says it was based on licensed Lotus tech, but most definitely not an electrified Elise. TIL. [0] - https://www.tesla.com/blog/lotus-position https://www.tesla.com/blog/lotus-position
- agumonkey 9y agoHa, I never knew that
- Joeri 9y agoThey originally got venture capital by shopping around an existing handmade electric car, the AC Propulsion tzero. https://evannex.com/blogs/news/75692101-from-tzero-to-model-s-how-ac-propulsion-was-a-catalyst-for-tesla-motors https://evannex.com/blogs/news/75692101-from-tzero-to-model-...
- agumonkey 9y agowow amazing, I never read about anything involving musk prior Tesla incorporation.
- acdjuiamadfn 9y agoCan anybody comment on how technology transfer between two firms works where one firm is say 80% musk + a + b and the other, say, 40% musk + x + y + z ? Both firms are technically separate, right? I suppose x,y,z would mind if Musk just took the tech to Boring company. And a,b would mind if he chose Tesla (if it were not the best)? Or are people flexible in this regard? In the initial stages?
- Heliosmaster 9y agoWhat about a contract signed between two parties (Tesla, TBC) in which TBC acquires some of Tesla's technology for a symbolic price? Would that have any problem?
- Tuna-Fish 9y agoOther Tesla shareholders could well have a problem with this, up to the point of suing Tesla management for it. Tesla management has a duty to make the deal with terms that are as beneficial to Tesla as possible, and if they breach that duty, the shareholders can sue them for the loss. For the initial projects, it's possible that Tesla will license tech to TBC for a nominal price, because they can justify it as expanding the market -- if TBC is initially successful, it will greatly expand the market for that tech.
- drcross 9y agoDidn't Tesla open all of their patents?
- yessql 9y agoAll patents are open. Tesla offered to share them with other auto OEMs, if they sign up to agree to Tesla's terms.
- kuschku 9y agoTesla opened some of their patents, and only if you in return give all of your patents to Tesla. This is also why no carmaker except for Mercedes has used Tesla patents at all, and Mercedes simply bought 5% of Tesla to get the patents.
- wonder_bread 9y agoIf Tesla 'merged' with SpaceX and Boring Co. on the public market you're talking about a company that could have a $100B mkt cap as soon as next year, the slight and continuing unofficial convergence of all of his companies is a bit odd
- foota 9y agoI wonder if he's thinking of building a space gun.
- stcredzero 9y agoNot odd at all for someone bent on retiring on Mars. Airtight underground dwellings are the current best bet for Mars habitation.
- baron816 9y agoI don't think we should pay much attention to this stuff until they actually start building TBMs or have some technological breakthroughs.
- stephengillie 9y agoAgreed - they're a pretty boring company until they get some real tech going.
- 1024core 9y ago> They aim to have no impact at the surface by digging just about 20 feet (6 meters) in the ground. Is 20 feet enough? I would imagine that a lot more depth would be required to support the above-ground structures.
- SimbaOnSteroids 9y agoNope, modern subway stations aren't necessarily deeper than that. Plus TBM's bores are much smaller diameter than traditional holes. Plus they don't need the peripheral infrastructures needed with subways systems just elevators and I'm assuming emergency stairs.
- TrickyRick 9y agoMusk said something at TED about it being related to tunnel diameter and I imagine this test track having a pretty small tunnel compared to say a subway.
- Animats 9y agoA TBM doesn't just dig a hole. It installs tunnel ring segments to support the ground above. 6 meters down is no big deal. That's mostly to get below other buried infrastructure. Here's a good explanation of how TBMs work from Crossrail.[1] They use two types of TBM. There are also hard-rock TBMs, used in deep jobs like the Gotthart Base Tunnel. For some hard-rock jobs, a tunnel lining isn't necessary. Most of the problems in tunneling involve water. Mud, leaks, underground rivers, etc. The Boring Company doesn't mention water much. So far, the Boring Company just seems to have bought a small TBM and is learning to use it. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z38JIqGDZVU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z38JIqGDZVU
- erikpukinskis 9y agoThey've mentioned water when asked about Hyperloop, to point out that standard tunnels are waterproof to a specification that they could also support the level of vacuum necessary for Hyperloop, without modification. The SpaceX rep mentioned this in the recent Hawthorne city council meeting, and I believe Elon said the same thing in one of his presentations.
- pbreit 9y agoDoes anyone know the ownership structure of The Boring Company? Is it a spin-off of Tesla or SpaceX or a brand new standalone entity?
- rockinghigh 9y agoStandalone entity founded by Musk.
- agumonkey 9y agoIt's funny how must cross breeds his ventures. Solar energy, electric vehicles.. probably some high end engineering talent from SpaceX too. It's a bit like Apple maybe ? he bootstraps it's own vibe.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- paulsutter 9y agoBoring Company has a bigger potential impact on transportation than Uber or Google even dream about. At 200kph, with no traffic, all that empty land near San Rafael or beyond the Berkeley tunnel can be minutes away from downtown San Francisco. This could be a huge impact on housing and our everyday life. The transcontinental railroad was paid in part through land grants to the railroad[1], for parcels along the route. That land was instantly valuable once the railroad was completed. Real estate could be a bigger part of Boring Company profits than user fees. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_Transcontinental_Railroad#Land_grants https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_Transcontinental_Railroa...
- kobeya 9y agoWhat real estate? The railway companies got land grants because nobody (well, except the Native Americans...) owned the land they built on. The Boring Company is going to be drilling under already owned land no matter where it goes...
- paulsutter 9y agoThey could option or purchase land, and decide the route of the tunnel based on what they're able to obtain. That puts them in a position to capture value. It could also increase regulatory competition among localities.
- nibstwo 9y agoI thought they didn't even need to own the land to build tunnels as long as they do it at the right depth?
- torinmr 9y agoI think the parent was saying that they would buy parcels of land where they planned to build stations, and then profit when that land appreciated due to the presence of the station.
- atarian 9y agoPretty cool how Musk's companies reuse technologies amongst themselves. Back in 2015, SpaceX shared welding techniques and machinery with Tesla: https://electrek.co/2015/05/24/spacex-transferred-novel-welding-techniques-and-equipment-to-tesla-motors/ https://electrek.co/2015/05/24/spacex-transferred-novel-weld...
- Boothroid 9y agoPerhaps strap a rocket to the back of the boring machine?
- dx034 9y agoDon't all companies do that? GE will also share basic techniques between departments. And if you don't have another department to get the knowledge you contract other companies. There's no need to invent everything yourself. To me the whole thing sounds more like a marketing stunt. Tunneling is extremely expensive. Musk knows how to make products more efficient but the improvement needed in this case is probably far more than what he achieved with Tesla.
- capkutay 9y agoIt's still unclear to me how their technology is different. Did they just slap the Elon Musk brand/allure on regular boring machines for SpaceX/Tesla's own use? edit: Well I guess they have a pretty clear FAQ on their site, but I'm wondering if the small tunnel diameter can be used for anything other than cars. Would subway cars fit? https://www.boringcompany.com/faq/ https://www.boringcompany.com/faq/
- rocqua 9y agoAs I recall, they go for 2x smaller diameter tunnels. This gives 4x less dirt to move. Beyond that, they aim to get something like a 2x or 3x improvement by switching to electric and being better about strutting walls and boring at the same time. The 4x less work done 2x faster should be about an order of magnitude better. The reason they can go for smaller tunnels is using 'skates' as opposed to letting people drive. 'Skates' are kinda like a bus for your car. As the environment is controlled, the skates can be controlled by self-driving technology a lot easier. The added precision and control allows for smaller 'roads'. That is the argument from Musk as I understood it.
- tigershark 9y agoIt's a concept completely wrong in a lot of details starting from the premises. Their primary objective is to build a tunnel for 100M$ a mile saying that currently a tunnel costs 1B$ a mile. And as I linked in a previous thread London crossrail is already on that price range while boring full-size tunnels for underground trains. So I'm not really sure what they are trying to accomplish here given that the crossrail is already cheaper for tunnels with double the size of the ones than their are trying to build.
- jessaustin 9y agoThe costs quoted are USA costs. Massive infrastructure projects cost more here.
- wbl 9y ago
- Punisher 9y agoI keep thinking, if this is really just for research and development, why are they doing it under LA? It seems like there would be some place more remote and a little safer for drilling giant tunnels. Also, I'm surprised to hear it's only going to be 6m deep.
- baq 9y agoThey have property that they can dig on in LA.
- Bromskloss 9y agoOh, "Tesla" the company, not the man, as I expected. :-/
- andai 9y agoYeah, for the past five years I've been like, "Oh look, Tesla! Aww. Oh look, Tesla! Aww."
- blacksqr 9y agoThat doesn't sound boring at all.
- erikpukinskis 9y ago/r/thatsthejoke
- vm 9y ago"Boring" is the process of excavating a tunnel. Play on words :) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tunnel_boring_machine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tunnel_boring_machine
- kristianc 9y agoWhat I'm not clear about is how BC plan to overcome American cities tendency to sprawl. It seems there's a huge risk of building tunnels at enormous expense which travel between places where people, at some indefinite point in the not too distant future, no longer really travel to. Either that, or you build tunnels in highly concentrated places like Manhattan that just act as a supplement to existing metro networks. What am I missing here?
- erikpukinskis 9y agoIsn't that true of any capital expenditure? You make a model, cross your fingers, sometimes it works, sometimes it doesn't, but you make it up on the margin.
- kristianc 9y agoI guess but I'm making the presupposition that Elon Musk is smarter than me, therefore he wouldn't have overlooked this, and am curious to know what I'm missing or what my mental model of how American cities grow and sprawl is failing to take account of.
- erikpukinskis 9y agoIt takes decades for a population center to empty. Plenty of time to recoup an investment. If he starts with low hanging fruit, like transit between deadlocked parts of LA he'll be making money. Maybe eventually he gets down into boondoggle territory, but I don't see why that should be a concern. As part of a larger fund, a few boondoggles are no problem—learning experiences.
- samstave 9y agoWhat happens to all the material tunneled out? What happens when TBC wants to tunnel where secret government tunnels already exist?
- k_sh 9y ago...secret government tunnels?
- samstave 9y agoIt's long been rumored that there are tunnels cross crossing the us, connecting deep underground military bases. We know for a fact there are numerous tunnels in DC, some that go to places to support / maintain continuity of government in the event of nuclear war. I think it's erroneous to think that they are no longer in use, but nobody really knows their true extent. The point was simply that if the amount of tunnels needed for this type of transport were dug, through the US, they would reveal, somehow, if such tunnels did really exist.
- dx034 9y agoThe government will probably release information about areas and depths were no one is allowed to dig. This can be vague enough to not disclose information about where tunnels actually are while still ensuring their safety.
- andai 9y agoThe secret tunnels are much deeper.
- jeffreygoesto 9y agoThey must be careful. In Germany, tunnel construction just caused major train track damage: http://m.spiegel.de/reise/deutschland/a-1162727.html http://m.spiegel.de/reise/deutschland/a-1162727.html